5 Reasons Carnivale Should Be Revived On Netflix

It's still not too late to bring back one of the most underrated shows ever produced for television.

Carnivale1 Daniel Knauf's groundbreaking show Carnivale premiered on HBO back in 2003 to a large audience of 5.3 million viewers. The parallel stories of Ben Hawkins, a travelling carnie with strange healing powers and Brother Justin, a Methodist preacher on a mission, captivated audiences initially, but the show struggled to maintain its high ratings. Despite the awards and critical acclaim, Carnivale's running cost of $2 million per episode was deemed too expensive and the show was eventually cancelled by HBO after only two seasons. Like many shows ended long before their time, Carnivale has since gained a huge cult following of devotees fascinated by the enigmatic themes and overarching story line that never came to fruition. A few years after the shows demise, some of these dedicated fans created CarnyCon 2006 Live!, an event attended by both cast and crew from Carnivale. The demand for the shows continued existence is clearly there, yet HBO refuse to allow Knauf to take Carnivale to another network or even be continued in book form, despite remaining unwilling to renew the show themselves... Last year, Netflix produced a new series of Arrested Development, a critically acclaimed sitcom that was inexplicably cancelled after three seasons and at the end of 2013, Amazon Prime renewed the British show Ripper Street for a third season after it was initially cancelled by the BBC. This got me thinking... If any show cancelled this millennium deserves another chance, it's Carnivale. Knauf himself has since said that returning to these characters is like "putting on the most comfortable pair of shoes I€™ve ever had in my life... The dialogue just spilled out, and they were alive and three-dimensional. The characters are still alive, and they have so much to say." Nine years may have passed since the last episode of Carnivale aired, but through an outlet like Netflix, fans of Carnivale could binge watch to their hearts content, allowing them more of a chance to unpick the mysteries threaded throughout each episode. The campaign starts here. Read this article, outlining 5 reasons why Carnivale should be revived on Netflix and then share it. Share it on facebook, twitter and any other social network you can think of. Post a link on Carnivale forums, on Netflix forums, on HBO forums, emailing anyone who could help. It's still not too late to bring back one of the most underrated shows ever produced for television. Hell, even Firefly got a movie at least. Make it happen people.

5. The Unique Tone

HBOHBORyan Murphy's anthology series American Horror Story is one of TV's biggest success stories in recent years, attracting consistently high ratings while winning Primetime Emmy's and Golden Globe Awards along the way. The influence of Carnivale on the show is undeniable, especially when you consider that the next season of American Horror Story is actually a period piece subtitled Freak Show which will follow a set of performers working in America. The success of Ryan Murphy's project proves that audiences are ready for unusual shows that take chances and few are stranger than Carnivale. Despite some similarities between Knauf's work and American Horror Story, there has never been a show quite like Carnivale before, with its bizarre characters, abstract imagery and otherworldly atmosphere. Where else would you see a clay mask bleed, an old woman vomit coins or a comatose fortune teller set fire to her own caravan and trap her daughter inside along with her? Everything that is weird and strange is now back in vogue on TV, making this the perfect time to revive Carnivale on Netflix. Why should we let American Horror Story attempt a story like this when Carnivale did the same thing first and better back in the day?

4. The Incredible Art Direction

CarnivalecardsHBOCarnivale's pilot episode drew 5.3 million viewers, becoming the best ever debut for an HBO original series at the time. While the numbers inevitably tailored off somewhat, ratings remained stable throughout the first season and the general response was positive. Although some critics had issues with the pace of the writing, many praised the acting, cinematography and art direction as hugely impressive, particularly considering that the entire show was ran on a TV budget. The Emmy Awards agreed too and nominated Carnivale in seven categories for its first season alone, five of which it won in creative art categories such as Outstanding Costumes for a Series and Outstanding Art Title design. In the following year, Carnivale was nominated for a further eight awards, but failed to win any. From the outset, Carnivale was recognized for its unique cinematography and art design which looked like nothing else seen on TV. Setting Carnivale in the Dust Bowl of 1930's USA was a masterstroke that ensured the show would stand apart from its peers and the production values hold up just as well today as they did ten years ago. Renewing Carnivale on Netflix would bring a huge amount of media attention to the show, which could kick start its revival and potentially bag the team a few Emmy Award nominations for art direction and more besides. Arrested Development and House of Cards were the first Netflix produced programs to be recognized by the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences and it looks likely that more nominations will follow later this year in the next ceremony. A Carnivale revival would have a strong chance of competing and even winning industry awards if it is revived soon by Netflix.

3. The Cast Of Underrated Performers

Carnivale Cast One of the key components that made Carnivale stand out from other shows broadcast at the time was its slow measured pace. Despite featuring epic overarching themes, the majority of episodes leisurely took their time working through the narrative, prioritizing characterization over spectacle. To pull this off, Knauf and his team chose a talented group of mostly unknown actors to portray the various characters featured in the two converging story lines. Ben Hawkins and Brother Justin Crowe were the two key figures who viewers identified with throughout the two seasons, but there were a host of other memorable characters who deserved more screen time, including the Carnivales dwarf co-manager Samson (Michael J. Anderson), middle-aged stripper Rita Sue (Cynthia Ettinger) and the blind mentalist Lodz (Patrick Bauchau). Some of the cast from Carnivale have since found success in more film and television roles, such as Clea DuVall and Tim DeKay, who appeared in Argo and the TV show White Collar respectively. However, others such as Amy Madigan (who played Iris) have only worked in smaller roles since Carnivale's demise. It's unfortunate that so many talented and underrated performers from the show have struggled to find significant work since. Knauf himself admits that some of the characters he originally wrote were never given the opportunity to take their turn in the spotlight, as many had their roles reduced or even cut in the second season. Renewing the series on Netflix would allow the writers to bring back characters like the conjoined twins and Gecko the Lizard Man, exploring their back stories and unique idiosyncrasies in more detail. Such a move would allow Knauf to finally do these characters justice, providing further work for some of the most underrated actors HBO have cast in the past decade.

2. Phenomenal Storytelling

Carnivale HawkinsHBOOn the one hand, Carnivale is thematically simplistic in its story telling, exploring the epic conflict between good and evil that has raged for centuries. However, this was rarely the focus in any explicit way and instead, the majority of episodes gave far more attention to smaller character moments within the two parallel story lines. The complexity of the interwoven plots and their unpredictable twists made Carnivale inaccessible for some viewers who complained that the show was difficult to understand, but Carnivale was never cryptic just for the sake of it. Knauf had outlined the overall plot trajectory from the beginning, so viewers who persevered were rewarded with a number of powerful and daring scenes which transcended the shows small screen origins. Some clues were unfortunately never explained in their entirety due to Carnivale's early cancellation, but the writers worked hard to create a satisfying payoff at the end of the second season while still staying true to the shows mysterious tone and feel. Since the cancellation of Carnivale, more and more shows have appeared which tease and mislead audiences, such as Heroes, Fringe and even American Horror Story, all of which enjoyed varying degrees of success. Today, mainstream audiences are more ready than ever to embrace an intelligent show like Carnivale and it's uniquely epic storytelling could help the show compete against other successful programs like Game of Thones and Boardwalk Empire.

1. It Was Supposed To Last Longer

HBOHBOThe most disheartening thing about Carnivale's premature cancellation was that it was originally intended to run for six years. After the shows demise, Knauf revealed that he had planned out every major plot detail so all of the seemingly disparate threads which were never resolved would all come together in the series finale. Hardcore fans compared the shows cancellation to finding the best book ever made, just to discover that the only copy which exists has two thirds of the pages ripped out. In 2007, Knauf released the original pitch document which outlined the direction Carnivale would have taken... and it sounds incredible. That's the real kicker. If it had been given more of a chance, it seems that Carnivale would have improved season by season, tying everything together towards one colossal showdown at the end. Season three would have been set five years later, following individual characters after everyone at the Carnivale has left and gone their separate ways. Brother Justin would have become an influential radio preacher while Iris and Sofie fight over the power he wields. A mystery throughout the season would have revolved around Sofie's child and whether the father was Hawkins or Brother Justin (her husband/father!). Season four would begin at the advent of World War II, where the Carnies begin to reassemble, moving into Europe in order to find talismans that would help them defeat the forces of evil. The final two seasons would have revolved around the invention of the atomic bomb and Hawkin's quest to stop it from being used. Ben believes the Manhattan Project will bring about the end of the world, but in reality, it would only result in the end of the Avatars, of himself and Brother Justin. Hawkins ultimately decides to let the bomb go off as he realizes that it needs to happen, that preventing the explosion would hold mankind back forever in a state of adolescence. As the Omega, Sofie must sacrifice her and Ben's child in the blast... for some reason that still eludes me.

While it is exciting for fans to know the direction Carnivale would have taken, a revival on Netflix would not have to necessarily follow this plan to the letter, still allowing for surprises along the way.

When HBO ended Carnivale, the fans were outraged and bombarded the network with complaints and petitions, all to no avail. Some extremely dedicated fans even sent old-fashioned 1000 character long telegrams begging for the show to be renewed. Since Carnivale went off the air, the fan base has actually grown and with the recent success of Netflix produced shows, now is the perfect time to renew the one of the most original and intelligent shows ever produced for television.

Does Carnivale still have a chance to be renewed on Netflix or is too late? Remember to let us know what you think in the comments section below and start sharing this article. Remember, the campaign starts here!


Contributor
Contributor

David is a primary school teacher who tries his best to turn every math lesson into a discussion on the latest Pixar film. Passions include superheroes, zombies and Studio Ghibli. In between going to the cinema, moving to South Korea and eating his body weight in KFC, David writes for a number of movie sites, http://becarefulyourhand.blogspot.co.uk/