5 Shows The Gotham TV Series Can Learn From To Not Suck

Gordon Here's what we know so far about Fox's upcoming Gotham TV series. The setting will be a pre-Batman Gotham City, back when costumed criminals were still just regularly clothed criminals, before things go so bad that they needed a vigilante in a cape to beat said criminals to a pulp without all that pesky due-process nonsense. The show's main character will be a young Detective James Gordon, way before he was Gotham's police commissioner. He'll be played by Ben McKenzie of the OC and Southland. The show will kick off with the murder of little boy Bruce Wayne's parents, a somewhat significant event in that character's life. The show recently added cast members to play Alfred Pennyworth, Harvey Bullock, Captain Sarah Essen, Gordon's fiancee Barbara and Oswald Cobblepot, better known as The Penguin. But we're not here to talk about casting. The show is being developed by Bruno Heller, who created HBO's Rome and network TV's The Mentalist. Now, these are two very different shows. While Rome was a dense, character driven series full of power struggles and double-crossing, The Mentalist is a show I've never seen that kind of sounds like Psych, minus the pineapples and pop-culture references. The way Gotham is executed could go in so many different directions, and there's already a ton of pressure on Mr. Heller to do these characters and the mythology justice. There's so many mistakes that can be made, and the internet is ready to pounce. Fortunately for Mr. Heller, he can just turn on his TV and learn from what a lot of shows like this are doing right and what even more shows like this are doing wrong.

5. Don't Knock Us Over The Head With Comic Book References And Cameos Like Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Sif Alright, Agent Coulson. You used to hang out with the Avengers. The Battle of New York happened. Asgard is a place. Aliens are a thing. Nobody watching Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. is in any danger of forgetting that it takes place in the Marvel cinematic universe because we are being constantly, relentlessly reminded. An abundance of Easter Eggs could be a big pitfall for Gotham as well, and I'm inclined to preemptively blame it on network executives. I'm imagining a meeting where some bosses are reviewing a script and they're like "Where's all the Batman-y stuff? Put some white make-up and lipstick on that one wisecracking henchman, he's the Joker now." I'm shuddering at the thought of Gordon walking into a flower shop and Poison Ivy is the florist, or into a pet store and Catwoman is working the register, or into a hat shop and the Mad Hatter is making hats. I'm not sure why he keeps ending up in all these specialty shops, but the people working in the specialty shops should definitely not be Batman villains.

4. Don't Make It A Procedural Like Almost Human

Almost I'm not saying police procedurals are bad, it's just that Fox already has a very genre-specific procedural with Almost Human, and that show is freaking aces. Seriously, if you aren't watching Almost Human, stop not watching it. As my girlfriend so aptly put it in her blog, "It's I, Robot starring Oscar and Felix!" But enough about how I have a girlfriend and back to Gotham. The show would inevitably suffer from a "case of the week" format. Batman has arguably the best rogues gallery in all of comics. The show is already promising that we'd learn how Gotham City descends into a cesspool of crime by giving backstory on all of these characters, but if this week is the Killer Croc episode and next week is the Mr. Zsasz episode, we won't get to know any of these characters. Each episode of Gotham should feel like a chapter in a book, as opposed to a series of short crime novels starring the same detective. We need a three minute-long "Previously On Gotham" montage before each episode to remind us everything that's going on because the plot should be that dense. Okay maybe no three minutes but you get the point.

3. Don't Make It Cheesy Like Arrow

ArrowArrow is great superhero show that's doing a lot of stuff right. Before the Gotham pilot was ordered, a lot of people called it the closest thing we'd ever have to a Batman TV show. But there's one thing holding it back from being an amazing show. Cheese. I want to grate Arrow over a plate of nachos. I want to grill it between two buttery slices of bread. I want to melt it into a fondue pot, dip skewered pieces of sourdough in it, and pair it with a dry Cabernet. Arrow is a very, very cheesy show. This is aided in part by the CW's ironclad rule that every single person on all of their shows must be unbelievably attractive. In the universe of the CW, ugly people simply do not exist. Gotham City on the other hand is a very ugly place, full of people with faces made of clay and stuff. But it's not just the casting. Arrow's entire production design is just really cheesy, from the leather-on-leather-on-leather costumes to the sets. If you've watched the show, you've been inside of Oliver Queen's nightclub Verdant. That nightclub. I... I can't. The problem here is that Starling City just doesn't seem like a real place. Everyone and everything in it just seems too polished and faked. Gotham City needs to feel real, lived in, full of people that are believable. So far none of the cast members look like Abercrombie employees, so we're on the right track.

2. DO Make It Like The Wire And Boardwalk Empire

Chalky These two shows hit the exact tonal bullseye Gotham should be shooting for. Boardwalk and The Wire both strike a balance putting an equal focus on law enforcement and the criminal underworld. But even more than that, they're both shows about cities and the people who live in them. We don't just get to know the characters, we learn about their families and their pasts and what causes them to do the things that are driving the plot. Fox's Gotham City, in my imagination, would be almost a perfect amalgamation between the shocking realism of The Wire's Baltimore and the stylish tapestry of Boardwalk's Atlantic City. That's right, I just used the word tapestry. After all, the show isn't called Gordon or The Boy Who Would Be Batman, it's called Gotham. We should be getting to know everyone in this city. For example, I know more about a minor character's daughter's fiancé on Boardwalk Empire better than I know about most of the main characters on Arrow. This level of character development is going to make Gotham City seem like a real place. Probably not a place we'd want to go to, but a real place nonetheless.

1. Make It Exactly In Every Way Like The 1966 Batman TV Show With Adam West

Penguin Just kidding, but just imagine it. The mayor of Gotham (Played by Adam West, because duh) has a red phone on his desk with a direct line to Detective Gordon's desk, all of the specialty shops in town actually are staffed by Batman villains in their actual costumes and the first season ends with the Penguin completing construction on his penguin-shaped submarine. I'd watch that show. Wouldn't you?

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

David Bailey is a creative advertising professional who moonlights as a Private Investigative Journalist. He currently resides in Los Angeles and enjoys receiving haircuts and eating sandwiches. You may find him on twitter @TheRingaDingKid.