5 TV Cliffhangers That Had Terrible Resolutions

Viewers waited too long for these resolutions to be screwed over like this...

The subject of the best television cliffhangers of all time is a frequent topic of online discussion. Fans and critics alike remember episodes that have become television touchstones because of their dramatic final scenes, followed by the chilling promise, "To Be Continued..." The advertising slogan used to promote the cliffhanger of Dallas' third season, "A House Divided," is probably more entrenched in the public consciousness than any of the episode's actual story (the tagline, of course, being, "Who Shot JR?"). Likewise, the subject of television shows which were cancelled on a cliffhanger ending rather than a conclusive finale has also been a frequent topic of online discussion. Farscape fans still smart from the blow of "Bad Timings," which promised a continuation in the face of cancellation, even though the series ultimately received a miniseries wrapping things up. Less discussed, however, has been the subject of cliffhangers that ultimately had terrible resolutions. Anyone who watches television €“ unless they are supremely discriminating €“ has probably seen an example of this. Viewers wait for an entire summer (or longer) only to find out that the writers of their show of choice couldn't care less over the cliffhanger they used to string you along over the hiatus. Take a look as we examine five of the worst cliffhanger resolutions in television history.

5. Star Trek: Voyager, "Equinox"

Plot Summary: The U.S.S. Voyager answers a distress call and makes contact with the U.S.S. Equinox, another Federation starship stranded in the Delta Quadrant. Commanded by Rudolph Ransom, the Equinox crew is eager to receive Voyager's aid, but soon it becomes clear that they are hiding a dark secret. Eventually, it is revealed that the Equinox has been committing genocide in order to harvest the energy from the corpses of a race of "nucleogenic" aliens. With every alien they kill, the Equinox is able to get home a little faster. Captain Janeway is horrified by this revelation and orders the Equinox crew arrested, but they quickly escape, leaving Voyager behind as it is assaulted by hordes of the nucleogenic aliens. The Cliffhanger: In the episode's final shot is a point-of-view from one of the nucleogenic aliens. We watch as it barrels directly towards Captain Janeway, who barely has time to turn around and face the creature before the screen goes black. The Resolution: Captain Janeway is knocked to the deck, but is able to dodge the lifeform's deadly thermionic radiation. Every other character who is attacked by these aliens, it should be pointed out, is killed immediately. Janeway appears immune to this fate, however, for no other reason than the fact that Kate Mulgrew is in the opening credits. The Backstory: Rumor has it that Kate Mulgrew was dissatisfied by the role of Captain Janeway during season five of Star Trek: Voyager. Unsure if she would be back for season six, the producers wrote this cliffhanger ending, which put Janeway in mortal peril. Eventually, Mulgrew's concerns were resolved and she stayed with the series until the end, but the producers were never able to come up with a satisfying way of resolving the fifth season cliffhanger.

4. The West Wing, "Twenty Five"

Plot summary: After learning that his youngest daughter, Zoey, has been kidnapped, President Bartlet is distraught. It's unclear if her abduction is an act of terrorism or a simple kidnapping; a faxed ransom note discovered by Donna suggests both possibilities. In private, he confesses to Leo McGarry, his chief of staff, that he's having trouble focusing on his essential duties. Bartlet decides to temporarily step down, invoking the twenty-fifth amendment. Since there is no vice president currently in office, the Speaker of the House is brought in to take his place. The Cliffhanger: As the season ends, Zoey's whereabouts remain unknown, as do the identity and motives of her abductors. President Bartlet steps down from office, and the Speaker of the House €“ now the acting President €“ tells him, "You are relieved, Mr. President." The Resolution: Zoey's abduction is almost an afterthought in the two-part premier of season five. Most of the episodes deal with the conflict between the new (Republican) President and Bartlet's staff (Democrats). Finally, at the end of the second episode, an FBI agent says, "I think we may have found something." It turns out the FBI has found Zoey. Who abducted her? Unidentified "terrorists," all of whom were killed during her rescue, and whose motivations and identities are never explained. The Backstory: Series creator Aaron Sorkin and series director Thomas Schlamme both departed the program after the fourth season, due to conflicts with NBC President Jeff Zucker over script deadlines and budget overruns, amongst other issues. Sorkin had his own ideas about resolving the cliffhanger €“ he wanted it to be the work of a group of Rapturists "at the back of a muffler shop" €“ but ultimately left the show's new writing staff to handle the resolution. They did so by quickly dispensing with the cliffhanger, as well as many of the characters and storylines which had been central to the fourth season, and moving on in their own direction. The series would struggle to find its voice until the sixth season, when it began to tackle the next presidential campaign.

3. Rescue Me, "Drink"

Plot Summary: In the previous episode, Teddy's wife, Ellie, was killed by a drunk driver. Now at her funeral, Teddy makes it clear that he blames Tommy for her death. Tommy started Teddy drinking again, which led Ellie to drive the car the night she was killed. Later, most of the guys are at the bar. Teddy barges in with a gun, points it at Tommy, and orders him to do shot after shot. Teddy says he knows a guy who drank himself to death, but that he prefers the certainty of a bullet. There's only one in his gun. He asks Tommy if he would like to do the honors. Tommy, lightheaded, declines, and Teddy knocks him down to the ground and points his gun at Tommy. The Cliffhanger: Teddy shoots Tommy in the shoulder, twice, and we watch him slowly bleed out on the floor of the bar. Teddy holds a gun to all the guys and tells them not to go anywhere €“ he wants them to stay here for a few hours, while Tommy slowly dies. Blood everywhere, Tommy sees the ghost of his dead brother, Jimmy, who tells him it will all make sense on the other side. The Resolution: The next season opens with Tommy in the ambulance with his family and Lou. While on his way to the hospital, Tommy flatlines, but his "death" doesn't last long, and after a few visions, he's resuscitated. The guys use their police connections to keep Teddy from getting arrested. In other words, the consequences of the fifth season cliffhanger were completely dispensed with, and the series once again returned to the status quo. The Backstory: The fifth season finale wasn't the first time the series ended an episode with Tommy at death's door, but it's arguably the closest the character ever came to his own demise and in that respect, it might be the most disappointing season finale Rescue Me ever had. It has been rumored that writers and executive producers Denis Leary and Peter Tolan wanted Tommy to die and be a ghost in the final season €“ a logical conclusion to the end of season five €“ but the series ultimately chose to keep Tommy among the living.

2. 24, "Day 2: 7:00 a.m. €“ 8:00 a.m."

Plot Summary: In the season two finale, the United States is on the brink of war with several Middle Eastern countries. Bombers are already on their way; once their payloads are released, the world will be in the middle of a global conflict. President Palmer wants to cancel the attack, but he has been removed from office, and the Vice President will only agree to turn the planes around if the evidence implicating the three Middle Eastern countries in question can be disproven. Jack Bauer €“ with the help of Sherry Palmer, the President's ex-wife €“ successfully record a confession from one of the conspirators, and the planes are called off at the last minute. President Palmer is reinstated, and he attends a news conference in downtown Los Angeles. The Cliffhanger: Max, one of the conspirators, makes a phone call to Mandy, an assassin last seen in season one. He tells her, "It's me. Go Ahead." At the press conference, Palmer makes a short speech, and then begins shaking the hands of the crowd. One of the people in the crowd is Mandy, who shakes his hand. Afterwards, she calls Max and tells him, "It's done." After a few moments, Palmer feels dizzy, and looks down at his hand. It's...bubbling. The president collapses and the people go into a panic. The only sounds heard over the episode's final clock are Palmer's heartbeat and his voice, gasping for air. The Resolution: Season three jumps ahead three years after the assassination attempt on Palmer's life. Wayne Palmer, the President's brother and now his chief of staff, briefly mentions that the men who tried to assassinate him were brought to justice. Palmer now has a scar on his hand and arm, but the assassination attempt on his life and the connected plot to launch the United States into a global war is never mentioned again. The Backstory: Critics and especially fans complained loudly about the producer's decision to ignore the season two cliffhanger. Eventually, the plot of the 24 videogame was written to take place between seasons two and three and resolve these loose ends, but this was too little, too late. 24 had already set a precedent for abandoning plot threads €“ even major ones €“ whenever the producers felt like it. As a result, the series was never as good as it was during seasons one and two.

1. Millennium, "The Time Is Now"

Plot Summary: Millennium Group members are seen in bio-hazard suits, cleaning out a house full of bodies. Outside, dead birds litter the ground. Later, Frank Black (Lance Henriksen) is contacted by a man named Gilbert, who warns him that their lives may be threatened by the Group's activities. When Gilbert is later killed in a car accident, Frank suspects the Group. Subsequently, Frank learns that a Soviet-engineered virus has been reappearing in the United States. The Millennium Group has developed a vaccine €“ but only manufactured enough doses for its members. The Cliffhanger: Frank flees with his family from the city to his father's woodland cabin. He was only able to get one dose of the vaccine, and he and his wife decide to give it to their daughter, Jordan. Later that night, Catherine wakes up sick, and realizes she has the disease. Rather than wake up Frank, she quietly leaves the cabin and goes out into the forest to die. Frank wakes up in the morning, finds blood on her pillow, and realizes that she is dead. His hair turns white, and as he cradles his daughter images of the collapse of civilization flash on screen, interspersed with chilling video noise. The Resolution: The third season picks up eight months later. It turns out the virus didn't bring the end of civilization as depicted at the close of season two €“ it was just a scare that claimed a few thousand lives. The Backstory: Executive Producers Glen Morgan and James Wong, along with series creator Chris Carter, believed that the second season of Millennium would be the program's last. In an interview, Morgan said the season finale was inspired by his research into possible end-of-the-world scenarios. Then, almost at the last minute €“ and too late to change the final episode of the season €“ Fox decided to renew the show for a third season. Rather than continue the world-ending scenario suggested by "The Time Is Now," however, the producers elected to write off most of the second season finale and continue the show from there. These attempts to re-tool the series weren't entirely unsuccessful, but they failed to attract new viewers, leading to the show's final cancellation at the end of the year.

Contributor
Contributor

Michael is one of the founders of FACT TREK (www.facttrek.com), a project dedicated to untangling 50+ years of mythology about the original Star Trek and its place in TV history. He currently is the Director of Sales and Digital Commerce at Shout! Factory, where he has worked since 2014. From 2013-2018, he ran the popular Star Trek Fact Check blog (www.startrekfactcheck.blogspot.com).