6 Times Supergirl Improved DC Mythology (& 4 Times It Failed)
Exploring the impact of Melissa Benoist's Maid of Might on the greater landscape of DC Comics.
With Supergirl currently in the middle of its fifth season, the Melissa Benoist-starrer has gone from strength to strength after an admittedly rocky start.
If you remember, that start ended up with CBS opting against renewing the series for a second season. But in hindsight, that move proved to the best thing to happen to the show – for CBS’ loss was The CW’s gain.
Once housed on the same network as Arrow, The Flash, and DC’s Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl began to flourish. And not just in an over-the-top superheroes and supervillains sort of way, as the show spent just as much time exploring real-world issues and themes as it did superpowered aliens.
At a time when casual audience's memories of anything Super are of Henry Cavill’s cinematic Man of Steel, it was a bold move to take a punt on brining the Maid of Might to live-action life. That move, though, has paid off in fantastic fashion, with Supergirl becoming a go-to favourite of many a genre fan.
Like any show that’s loosely based on an existing property – in this case the larger world of DC Comics – there are always going to be changes both good and bad made to the established lore, and so here are the ways in which Supergirl has improved (and failed to improve) the long-standing mythology of DC Comics.
Improved DC Mythology...
6. Alex Danvers
Away from the titular Maid of Might, one of Supergirl’s key characters is Chyler Leigh’s Alex Danvers. The thing is, Alex doesn’t actually exist within the pages of DC Comics.
Whereas a show like Arrow took a barely used DC character like Felicity Smoak and developed her into a major player, Supergirl went one better with Alex Danvers and completely created the character from scratch. And to be fair to the minds behind the series, they’ve done a great job with Kara’s foster sister.
Not only does Alex so often have a vital role to play in Supergirl’s ongoing battle to fight the good fight and protect National City and beyond, but Danvers has been fantastically fleshed out as a brilliant character who can more than stand on her own two feet.
In the Alex Danvers character, Supergirl has been able to highlight not only a sibling relationship, not only a work/family dynamic, but the series has also been able to put the spotlight on the LGBT community as Supergirl’s second season saw Alex struggling with the fact that she was gay.
With how she’s been written and developed over Supergirl’s five seasons, Alex Danvers is most definitely a welcome addition to the larger mythology of Supergirl.
5. Has Shown Just How Vicious Lex Luthor Can Be
Before Supergirl, the last live-action incarnation of Lex Luthor seen by audiences was Jesse Eisenberg’s so-so take on the villain in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. And to label the reaction to Eisenberg’s Lex as so-so would be a massive understatement.
When Jon Cryer was cast as Supergirl’s Lex Luthor, a few eyebrows were raised at the prospect of the Two and a Half Men star playing Superman’s iconic nemesis. But when Cryer’s Lex got to go full Lex towards the end of Supergirl’s fourth season, the end result was gloriously sinister.
Audiences had been quietly waiting for Lena Luthor to embrace the dark side – something that has been fully flirted with during Supergirl’s ongoing fifth season – yet it was the appearance of Cryer’s scenery-devouring Lex that showed exactly why the Luthor name is one to be feared.
Michael Rosenbaum famously gave a fantastic, multi-layered Lex Luthor in Smallville, but that version of Lex was more about his journey to villaindom. In Supergirl, we have been spoiled with a Lex who is loud ‘n’ proud of his spot as one of the most deceptive and evil beings on the planet – to the extent that Jon Cryer’s Luthor made himself terminally ill, just so that he could toy with his sister.
4. Has Shone A Spotlight On C-Listers
Mon-El. Agent Liberty. Manchester Black. Reign. Maxwell Lord. Indigo. Eve Teschmacher. Mr. Mxyzptlk. Would anybody but comic book die-hards have ever even heard of these characters if it were not for the Supergirl TV series? Likely not.
Those seven characters are just a small sample of C-list – or even D-list – characters who have been afforded a spotlight thanks to Supergirl. And not just a brief, one-off appearance opposite Melissa Benoist’s Maid of Might, for those characters were all given at least a multiple-episode arc – with most of those villainous sorts getting a full season to let their own personal stories be fleshed out. Well, apart from Mon-El, for he's not a villain and actually had a couple of seasons as the on-off love interest of Kara.
In that regard, Supergirl has vastly improved the mythology of DC Comics in how it has made people aware – and, for the most part, care – about characters who they otherwise wouldn’t know even existed.
Sure, everybody knows the Lex Luthors, the Jokers, the Reverse-Flashes, the Ra’s al Ghuls, and the General Zods of DC Comics. But for Supergirl, it decided to allow other lesser-known villains to stand front-and-centre in a way that brought new awareness to the world of DC Comics.
3. The Inclusivity Of Comic Books
Once Supergirl really began to get its wings as a show – as in, once it switched to The CW with its second season – the series started to not just rely on the familiar tropes of capes ‘n’ tights. Instead, Supergirl has used its platform to highlight a whole host of real-life issues.
Comic books are for everybody. Whatever race, gender, sexual orientation, or religious belief, the world of comics does not discriminate. And neither does Supergirl.
To date, Supergirl has tackled so many issues in a way that’s respectful yet never afraid to be hard hitting when needed.
The series has seen Alex Danvers face the problems of coming out as gay, has seen racism tackled in the shape of aliens being attacked just for being aliens, has delivered TV’s first transgender superhero in the shape of Dreamer, and has even looked at political corruption and power plays.
Few shows in the history of television have been as all-inclusive as Supergirl, and it’s remarkable how well so many sensitive issues have been handled by the series so far during its five-year run.
2. The Show’s Superman Is Super, Man
While Superman is the most iconic superhero of them all, the larger scale mythology of the Big Blue Boy Scout has taken a hit in recent years.
Since Henry Cavill’s Superman hit the silver screen in Zack Snyder’s 2013 Man of Steel, the general popularity of Superman has been on the wane. Cavill himself was a great fit to play the character, and the actor did the best with what he was given, yet both Man of Steel and Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice portrayed Supes in a darker, dourer way that was more akin to a Bat-tale.
In Justice League, there was at least a glimpse at the attributes and characteristics that make Superman great, but the public had already soured on the hero by that point.
Thankfully, Supergirl managed to succeed where the DCEU failed – in that it has delivered a pitch-perfect Superman, as played by Teen Wolf’s Tyler Hoechlin.
In this Superman, we’ve been reminded just why the Man of Tomorrow is such a fantastic character. Hoechlin’s Kal-El is a symbol of hope, is dripping in humanity, and is an inspirational figure who manages to have a god-like aura without bringing the derision that can at times go with that status. Similarly, the Last Son of Krypton has only been used sparingly – meaning he doesn’t take away the spotlight from Melissa Benoist’s Kara, while also making his own appearances more impactful when they do happen.
Supergirl is doing Superman right. So much so, that this incarnation of the hero and Elizabeth Tulloch’s Lois Lane are to headline a Superman & Lois spin-off series later this year.
1. Has Made Kara Just As Important As Her Cousin
Regardless of how big of a comic book Supergirl fan you are, there’s no getting away from the fact that she’s so often been in the shadow of her more famous cousin. After all, the Man of Steel is the greatest hero in the history of comics – meaning it’s always going to be a tough ask for any Super-sort to live up to the legacy and legend of Superman.
Arguably the greatest thing that The CW’s Supergirl has done for its titular heroine, is that the show has made Kara Zor-El feel just as big a deal as Kal-El.
While audiences saw an unsure Supergirl in the series’ first season – with Kara still a rookie who was learning on the superhero job at that point in time – the Girl of Steel soon began to step up to the plate and become as important a hero as her more illustrious cousin. To the point that, not only has Kara saved the entire world on numerous occasions, but Supergirl has even toppled Superman when the two have butted heads.
Across its five seasons, Supergirl has made its star feel just as powerful and heroic, if not more so, than the famed Big Blue Boy Scout. And for that, the series should be commended for just how much it has gotten viewers to care about Supergirl on all fronts – whether that’s as Kara Danvers or as Kara Zor-El.
Failed To Improve DC Mythology...
4. The Changes To Jimmy Olsen
On face value, as a character on its own, Mehcad Brooks’ James Olsen is a great character and an important part of the Supergirl TV series. In the context of the greater mythology of DC Comics, however, Supergirl’s spin on Jimmy Olsen is just a little confusing.
In the comic book world, Jimmy is the long-time BFF of Clark Kent who works at The Daily Planet as a photographer. A scrawny nerd, Olsen finds himself having to rely on CK to get him out of all kinds of scrapes over the decades, but Jimmy also provides a very human grounding for Superman to rely on and be influenced by.
When you hang around with an array of god-like figures, it helps to have a regular everyman at your side to keep you in check and maintain that your focus isn’t just on otherworldly action up in the stars. And that’s why Jimmy Olsen is such a fascinating character to be positioned alongside the all-powerful Kal-El.
For Supergirl, the show decided to reimage Jimmy Olsen as James Olsen – a handsome, muscled-up, suave photographer-turned-news mogul who has his own heroic alter-ego as Guardian.
As mentioned, this depiction of the character works well within the confines of Supergirl, and James is a brilliant character. Yet in the scheme of DC mythology, it just goes against the established history of the Jimmy Olsen character.
3. Copies A Little Too Much From Superman
As a show, Supergirl has made the Girl of Steel feel just as important, if not more so, than Superman. Of that, there is absolutely no doubt. The problem is, the show has at times fallen back on Superman mythology a little too much as it looks to showcase the Girl of Steel.
For instance, Superman has Lex Luthor, so Supergirl now has Lena Luthor. Clark Kent is a journalist, so Kara Danvers is a journalist. Superman famously had Mark Millar’s Red Son arc, so Supergirl adapts this for its fourth season. Superman has an uneasy alliance with Batman, so Supergirl follows suit with Ruby Rose’s Batwoman. And those elements are just the tip of the iceberg.
To be fair to the minds behind the Supergirl TV show, they have handled all of the aforementioned points in a fantastic way that has felt fitting of Supergirl. In the mythology of the greater world of DC Comics, however, it just feels as if the Supergirl series has ripped off what’s already been seen and experienced by the comic book Big Blue Boy Scout.
So regardless of how well done this has all been done in Supergirl, it only takes away from the existing mythology of these DC characters.
2. It’s A Bird… It’s A Plane… It’s A Superchild!
Across various continuities, various alternative worlds, and various different mediums, Superman has at times had a child. And each and every time, the Man of Steel having a child by his side just never really works.
In its depiction of Superman, Supergirl has undoubtedly hit a home run – Tyler Hoechlin’s Supes perfectly encapsulating the traits that make the Last Son of Krypton such a beloved figure – but lumbering the Big Blue Boy Scout with a son is something that doesn’t sit well.
Supergirl has put Kal-El’s constant absence down to the fact that he and Lois Lane had decided to stay on Argo City after Lois became pregnant. Of course, the ongoing Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover has drawn Superman out of this exile, with him now being the father of a young boy named Jonathan.
Moving forward, the Superman & Lois spin-off series that’s to premiere later this year will focus on this new family dynamic for the Man of Tomorrow. How that works out remains to be seen, but the history of DC Comics proves that it’s a tricky task to make Superman a father – just ask Bryan Singer’s Superman Returns!
1. The D.E.O.

If somebody was watching Supergirl without any experience of reading the antics of the Supergirl character in the pages of DC Comics, you’d 100% think that every adventure and battle of Kara Zor-El’s is somehow tied to the Department of Extranormal Operations.
To clarify, the Maid of Might’s place in the larger mythology of DC has pretty much zero connection to the D.E.O.
The comics do indeed have a D.E.O., with the organisation debuting in Batman #550 back in 1998, yet the comic book version of Supergirl has barely given even a fleeting mention to the agency.
Not only does it feel far too contrived that the majority of Kara’s weekly missions in Supergirl revolve around the D.E.O., it’s also starting to get to the point where the constant ties to the D.E.O. are starting to hinder Melissa Benoist’s Girl of Steel. To the point that the sooner the show puts some genuine distance between Kara and the D.E.O., the better.
Having the D.E.O. exist in Supergirl is absolutely fine, but it cannot be the be-all and end-all of so much of the titular heroine’s very existence.