7 Actors Who Should've Won An Emmy But Never Did

Award-givers don't always get it right, but they can get it drastically wrong...

It happens year in and year out at the Emmys; some of the best shows and indeed, stars on television lose out to weaker, safer bets. Or worse still, they get completely ignored and don't even secure so much as a nomination. The amount of years Jim Parsons has won Best Lead Actors in a Comedy Series makes me sick to my stomach, because although I think he's quite good (certainly the only standout on the show), it's a shame that his performances get recognized over performances with more depth and more range like Steve Carell on The Office. Too many actors like Carell have worked so hard to give the best performances they could possibly give and they get completely robbed when it comes to televisions most prestigious awards. For once I'd like to be pleasantly surprised by who wins the award and see some terrific actors and actresses get properly acknowledged for their incredible work. Another thing that happens so often is that an actors work will go unnoticed because of the show they are in; as is the case with Fringe, a show which never seems like it could be properly recognised by something like the Emmys, and so John Noble's incredible performance on that show is another shocking omission from the awards. Here are 7 terrific actors and actresses deserving of an Emmy they have never, and possibly will never receive.

7. Will Arnett

Emmy He Should Have Won: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series For His Role: GOB on Arrested Development Arrested Development is one of the most original and hilarious sitcoms ever made and sometimes, behind all the jokes, it can be difficult to see just how hard the cast are working. Will Arnett is no exception, and from the first episode where he rides up on his segway and cons his own nephew into buying a game of monopoly with missing pieces, he completely becomes GOB. For three seasons Arnett's GOB was consistently hilarious in his overly-dramatic, overly-emotional performances, knocking every joke given to him completely out of the park. And better still, coming back six years later to do season 4, it felt as if he had never even been gone as he once again transforms perfectly into the GOB we all know and love. Since Jason Bateman nabbed a Best Actor nomination this year, surely Arnett deserved one for Best Supporting Actor, right?

6. David Duchovny

Emmy He Should Have Won: Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series & Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series For His Roles: Agent Fox Mulder on The X-Files & Hank Moody on Californication David Duchovny been been nominated four times for three different categories in the Emmys and has even won two Golden Globes for The X-Files and Californication, respectively. He's established himself as a legitimately terrific actor as well as a cult hero, and has proven that he is incredibly dynamic, excelling in drama and comedy, often in the same performances. In his work in the X-Files as Fox Mulder he embodied a character that so many people could relate to and brought him completely to life in a believable way. The chemistry between he and Gillian Anderson's Scully is one of the most enticing aspects of the show and certainly one of the best romances television has ever seen, as unconventional as it may be. His Emmy nods were well deserved, but the guy deserved the award and it's a pity it never happened. Californication is much more heavily a comedy and the Emmys have yet to recognize Duchovny's stellar work on the show as recovering drug addict and on-going sex addict, Hank Moody. It's a performance that goes deeper than it might appear in the first season, and shows the range he's capable of, being incredibly witty while also being emotionally unstable and damaged. Those who thought he could never get cooler than Fox Mulder were wrong when this show came along, and it's equally as deserving of the Emmy.

5. Michael C Hall

Emmy He Should Have Won: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series & Outstanding Lead Actor In A Drama Series For His Roles: David Fischer on Six Feet Under & Dexter Morgan on Dexter Television lost out on one of its most consistent and brilliant actors these year with the end of Dexter. It's likely enough that Michael C Hall will come back to star in another television show in the near future, but what are the chances that it will be in a role as brilliant as that of Dexter Morgan? Then again, he did also portray another fascinating character in the early 2000's; David Fisher in HBO's Six Feet Under. So maybe there's hope after all that another role will come along that is worthy of his immense talent. In Six Feet Under, Hall played David Fisher, an openly gay character who is also a co-owner of family-run funeral home. It's one of the best television shows ever made and the cast is absolutely pitch perfect. David Fisher is particularly interesting because of his juggling of professionalism in the job and the emotions that come with it. At the beginning of the show his character feels professional, yes, but also somewhat robotic and emotionally detached. He becomes a much warmer character as the show progresses, and like every other character on the show experiences emotional ups and downs on the more extreme ends of the spectrum. Hall is a pro and makes you believe and feel the highs and lows as he does. Hall's performance is even more impressive because of his fearless performance as a gay character, in one of the truest and perhaps even most explicit portrayals of a gay character on television. In case you didn't know, Hall is indeed straight. Much better known as the titular character in Showtime's Dexter, Hall is given much more sinister material to work with, and he completely engulfs the character in another brave and brilliant performance. The quality of Dexter is highly debated towards the end of the show's eight season run, but there's no denying that Dexter Morgan is a consitently compelling character brought to life by Hall's complex performance as a serial killer with fascinating morals who tries to juggle work, family life and well, being a serial killer. He's been nominated for both roles and has even won a Golden Globe and Screen Actors Guild Award for Dexter, but no Emmy win, which is a real shame.

4. Connie Britton

Emmy She Should Have Won: Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series For Her Role: Tami Taylor on Friday Night Lights Friday Night Lights is an astoundingly impressive show in its warmth, excitement, humour and drama. The show is brilliantly written and has an incredible indie feel about it that differentiates it from a lot of other television. At the front of such a great production is the stellar cast led by Kyle Chandler and, of course, Connie Britton. Chandler has already picked up the Emmy for his performance as Coach Eric Taylor €“ and it's well deserved €“ but Connie Britton as his wife Tami Taylor gives a complimentary performance that's equally deserving of the award. Although nominated four times for an Emmy (twice for Friday Night Lights, once each for American Horror Story and Nashville respectively), she never won it, and it's a real shame because she really gave it her all on the show and made the character her own, giving off warm and sincere vibes in a role she was born to play. For five seasons Britton portrayed one of televisions most likeable and believable Mothers, and her relationship with her daughter and indeed the children at the school where she counselled and became principal was truly remarkable and fascinating. Not to to mention, her portrayal of one half of television's most durable married couples is nothing to sneer at either. Give this woman an Emmy!

3. Laura Dern

Emmy She Should Have Won: Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series For Her Role: Amy Jellicoe on Enlightened Laura Dern is a highly accomplished actress with dozens of nominations for television and film under her belt, including four Golden Globe wins. Like many of the other entries on this list, she has also been nominated for an Emmy but never won one. With an astounding five nominations, each for a different category, it's a small wonder and a real shame that she's never picked up the win. For me, the work she deserved to be most recognised for was her role of Amy Jellicoe on Enlightened. Enlightened was a gem of a show that ran of HBO for only two short seasons, and Dern served as both star and co-creator. And star she did, giving one of the most excellent performances of her life in a show that is categorized as "comedy" by the award shows but is really much more than that. The show may start out feeling like more of a comedy than a drama, but it's not long before things get real, and you'll know this if you've ever seen it. Holding it together firmly is Dern in an incredibly vulnerable role about a woman's emotional struggle against the world and her fight for what she believes is right. Her character is extremely likeable because of Dern's sheer enthusiasm for the role, which is so obviously apparent it's impossible not to enjoy. She strives to be the best, and like her performance in David Lynch's criminally under-appreciated 2006 film Inland Empire, she goes above and beyond the call of duty to completely encompass the character and make her feel real. The most commendable aspect of her performance is the bi-polarity of Jellicoe's character, a woman who was once a ragaholic (she can't live without Ragahol!) but now back in the real world after rehabilitation. The effort she makes to always be so cringe-worthily positive and quirky is brilliant to watch, especially when you just know she's holding back all the anger she has. She's funny and touching in a show that probably wouldn't have worked without her. One Emmy, please.

2. John Noble

Emmy He Should Have Won: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series For His Role: Walter Bishop on Fringe Fringe is a show that was understandably overlooked by the Emmys. It is, after all, borderline hard science fiction; something which the Emmys rarely seem to take much notice of. Looking past the sci-fi there are solid performances throughout the show's 5 year run by the main cast, but none coming close to John Noble's efforts as Dr. Walter Bishop. The man is head and shoulders above the rest of the cast and he demonstrated the professionalism of a truly experienced actor, completely embodying everything that the character stands for. Although Fringe had a solid enough run for five years, it undoubtedly had its rocky moments and at times the fate of the show felt uncertain. It is Noble's performance as estranged scientist Walter Bishop who kept the show together and gave it much needed heart. Bishop's relationship with his son Peter is one of the shows strongest aspects and it's so wonderful to see it develop and flourish. Although it seems Walter is nothing more than a mentally challenged scientist at the start of the show, we soon come to realise just how much of a genius he is, and just how much love he has in his heart for Peter and indeed for the FBI team he becomes a part of. Walter's relationship with his new lab partner Astrid is equally as excellent and touching to watch as he becomes more of a father figure, and the love between them is clearly apparent. Noble is a pro and he knocks the emotional scenes out of the park every time. We also see another side to Walter at several points in the show; a darker side that feels equally as vulnerable but gives Noble a chance to show off his versatility, showing that he indeed can be the bad guy too. Or more complex still, a good guy capable of committing evil acts. He's a terrific character and the obvious standout of the show, and Noble is well deserving of the Emmy.

1. Steve Carell

Emmy He Should Have Won: Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series For His Role: Michael Scott on The Office (US) There was never any doubt in my mind who would top a list like this. If there's one crime that the Emmys are most guilty of, it's not giving this man the award that he deserved not only once, but on several occasions. With his performance on The Office, Steve Carell quickly became one of my favourite actors on television. Although he originally started out as an American reincarnation of Ricky Gervais' David Brent on the UK Office, Carell soon brought something else to the character of Michael Scott and showed that he's so much more than just an ignorant and offensive boss. That being said, some of Carell's best work on the show is when he gets to be an ignorant and offensive boss. In the very first episode where he calls in Pam and pretends to fire her just for laughs, we get the first indicator of what kind of character this man is. He's terribly awkward, naive and his idea of humour is so skewed that he is often offensive without even realising. And that's what makes him such a complex character. He's not actually a bad guy, and it becomes clearer and clearer that this is the case as we get to know him better. He doesn't mean to offend or hurt feelings; it's just the way he is. We all know someone like Michael in real life. Someone so terribly socially awkward but you can't help but love them because their intentions are never malicious. Carell taps into this and goes deep, showcasing on so many occasions in his seven season stretch that he is a loving, caring man with nothing but pure intentions. Scott is the funniest show on the character and so much of that is down to Carell's pitch-perfect timing and most likely improvisation. He bounces off his co-cast so well and it's clear to see that his professionalism rubs off on them. In the midst of all the laughs, he also proves to be the most lovable character, and when it's his time to finally leave, it's overwhelming emotional to see him go. To see him get the happy ending he deserves and finally meet someone that understands him, that "gets" him, is beautiful. He made us laugh and made us cry, and he gave us one of televisions all-time great characters. If that's not worthy enough for an Emmy then the whole awards lose credibility.

Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a television junkie. A film fanatic. A pop culture know-it-all. An interactive media masters student, and a bass player. 22 years old and Irish. Thinks Netflix is a Godsend.