7 Doctor Who Spin-Offs That Could Replace Class
More Torchwood, anyone?
This month brought the inevitable news that Doctor Who spin-off Class has been cancelled after just a single eight-episode season. First dropped on BBC IPlayer last October, the teen-oriented sci-fi show somehow never managed to earn a lot of viewers or even form much of a cult fanbase. Despite its connections to a globally-beloved franchise, Class ended up flunking big time.
Let's hope this doesn't put the BBC off attempting any more Doctor Who spin-offs in future, though. As was proven with Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures a few years ago, shows set within the Whoniverse that focus on a familiar character can achieve great success. Class' downfall was probably that it featured an entirely fresh cast, so there was no real reason for Who viewers to follow the show.
To save face about Class' failure, the BBC could make a different Doctor Who spin-off each year. Perhaps with the same eight-episode format and dropped on IPlayer. With the right ideas, this could really help to expand the Doctor Who universe, as we would get a different part of it highlighted each time. Thankfully, there are many characters who are ripe for being promoted into their own spin-off.
7. The Adventures Of The Ghost
Steven Moffat definitely had his finger on the pulse last Christmas when he wrote The Return of Doctor Mysterio, a fun romp that gave a Doctor Who twist on the classic superhero story. Comic book TV is everywhere right now, so it was a canny move from the show to get into the tights n' flights game for one episode.
But why not take it further? Given the success of the multitude of Marvel and DC series out there, it would surely be a sound investment for the BBC to produce their own superhero show. You might remember that the 2016 Christmas special left Grant Gordon AKA The Ghost with his vast array of superpowers in tact, so it would be very simple to continue his adventures. In fact, The Ghost is already the star of his own comic book, produced by Titan Comics, so there is already a thirst for more from the character. Plus, actor Justin Chatwin (War of the Worlds) is established enough to helm his own show.
Part of Class' problem was that it was aimed squarely at a teenage audience, which put lots of fans off. A show about The Ghost would not have this problem as, hey, everyone loves superheroes nowadays.
6. River Song
When looking at the recent supporting cast of Doctor Who for a character who could hold a spin-off, one in particular jumps out. Namely, the Doctor's kind of wife and fellow time traveller Professor River Song, as played by Alex Kingston opposite David Tennant, Matt Smith, and Peter Capaldi's Doctors.
River's adventures so far on screen have revolved around the Doctor, but it is clear that she still leads a very adventurous life when her hubby isn't around (as he glimpsed in The Husbands of River Song). A River Song spin-off could be just as flexible as Doctor Who, as she can hop around time and space as much as he can with her Vortex Manipulator.
The only trouble with a River Song spin-off is that she is 100% a Steven Moffat creation and, seeing as he is bowing out of the showrunner position after Christmas, Moffat looks to be washing his hands with Doctor Who completely. So it's unlikely he would be interested in helming a spin-off.
Still, Big Finish's series of River Song audio dramas has proven that other writers can grasp how to write for the flirty archaeologist with success, so maybe a Moffatless series could work.
5. UNIT
Here's another Big Finish series that would make for a great TV spin-off in its own right. The alien-busting military unit, er, UNIT have been a major part of the fabric of Doctor Who ever since their debut in the 1960s. If any characters from the show deserve to get their time in the spotlight it is these boys and girls.
Or, as it happens, just the latter. The modern incarnation of UNIT is a female-orientated organisation, as it is headed by Kate Stewart (the daughter of the classic character the Brigadier) and her scientific adviser Osgood (who may or may not be a Zygon). With the Doctor herself about to regenerate into a woman, a female-led UNIT spin-off would make for a nice companion to Doctor Who.
So what form would a UNIT spin-off take? A fun idea would be to use it as a kind of Doctor Who version of Agents of SHIELD, as it could deal with the fallout of incidents that occur in the main show. The Doctor is always swanning off straight after saving the planet, which must leave UNIT with the tough job of cleaning up his messes.
The Class route of distancing the spin-off from Doctor Who didn't work, so why not go in the complete opposite direction next time around?
4. Missy Who
Before Jodie Whittaker became the first female Doctor, the Master's latest incarnation Missy tested the waters for transforming a traditionally male Doctor Who character into a woman. And it ended up working a treat as fans took Michelle Gomez' barmy yet layered take on the Doctor's frenemy to heart. So why not give the beloved character her own show?
In particular, the season 10 finale left Missy in a hugely interesting place, as she was on the road to redemption for the first time ever. And, well, she also died. However, the Master is nothing but a survivor. There is no way we have seen the last of Missy.
A Missy solo series could see the former villain attempting to emulate the Doctor by going around saving planets. However, it could play with the classic Doctor Who format, thanks to Missy's far less strict moral code. She would obviously have more ruthless methods of getting things done and in some cases might even agree with the villain of the piece.
Though Michelle Gomez initially said she would bow out of Doctor Who along with her Doctor Peter Capaldi and showrunner Steven Moffat, the actress has since seemed more open to the idea of coming back as Missy in future. Are you listening, BBC?
3. The Sarah Jane Adventures: 10 Years On
To many, generally classic, fans, The Sarah Jane Adventures is still the best Doctor Who spin-off of the lot. SJA arguably captures the spirit of the parent series better than any of its fellow sister shows. A lot of that is to do with the wonderful Elisabeth Sladen, one of the true icons of the Whoniverse. That's why the fandom was left devastated when SJA was cancelled in 2011, after Sladen's untimely death.
Seeing as 2017 marks the tenth anniversary since SJA's debut, it would be a welcome treat for fans if the BBC brought the show back for a one-off season. Though Sarah Jane could not feature, for obvious reasons, we need to see what happened to her teenage friends and family. e.g. her adoptive son and daughter Luke and Sky and neighbours Rani and Clyde. And if they need a former companion in the mix, bring back Katy Manning's Jo Jones (who previously guest starred on the show).
Sarah Jane Adventures was always a massive success, so it's likely the BBC would be up for a return. Basically, this one is all in creator Russell T Davies's corner. He's not actively in the Doctor Who world right now, but he has commented that he regrets ending SJA when he did. How about finally putting that right, eh, Russ?
2. Torchwood: Season 5
When talking about Doctor Who spin-offs that need to come back, there is one that deserves a return even more than The Sarah Jane Adventures. No, not K-9 and Company. I am, of course, referring to Torchwood.
After a disappointing fourth season made in the US, Torchwood disappeared from our screens back in 2011. It wasn't for lack of appreciation from viewers though, as the adult-oriented spin-off arguably has an even more ardent fanbase than Doctor Who. What deceased TV character other than Ianto Jones has their very own shrine?
John Barrowman has routinely attempted to get the show back on the airwaves over the years, presumably with him writing as well as starring (Barrowman has written several Torchwood novels and comics with his sister Carole E. Barrowman). However, he has been very open with the fans that he has been unable to get the revival off the ground.
Once again, then, this one all depends on Russell T Davies' involvement. The writer has been helping out Big Finish with their Torchwood audio dramas, in an advisory rather than scripting capacity, so it is possible that this has reinvigorated his interest in making more Torchwood. If there ever is a season five, though, please - for the love of Jack - put the team back in Cardiff.
1. The Eighth Doctor
The idea of an Eighth Doctor spin-off series has become near-legendary in Doctor Who circles. Despite it never officially having been on the cards, fans have been calling for a return for Paul McGann for years. We have to hope that eventually the BBC will listen to the cries on the internet and make it happen.
Though he only appeared in a single TV movie back in 1996, fans fell for McGann's incarnation of the Time Lord and many were upset when he was snubbed for Christopher Eccleston come the 2005 revival. Thankfully, Eight was eventually brought back for a special mini-episode to tie in with the 50th anniversary in 2013. Unfortunately, despite this being the perfect backdoor pilot for a proper comeback, he has never returned to the screen since.
It's a real shame as the Eighth Doctor holds so much promise. Crucially, he never became directly involved with the Time War, meaning a series focusing on him wouldn't need to cough up a movie-sized budget every week to depict the intergalactic conflict. However, the Doctor's place on the periphery of the fighting would still allow the show to explore the fallout and effects of the War.
Ah, but wouldn't jumping around the Doctor's timeline confuse people? Well, a few years ago maybe, but contemporary movie franchises like Marvel, DC and Star Wars frequently hop around their own histories and casual viewers manage to keep up. You could even say Doctor Who needs a series like this to stay up to date with the high-concept cinematic universes littering pop culture at the moment.
What Doctor Who spin-off would you like to see materialise next? Let us know in the comments!