7 Star Trek Actors Who Were Fired
Boldly gone.
There are nearly 600 hours of Star Trek. That might feel like a very random fact to open an article with but 600 hours, for one intellectual property, is an absolutely astronomical figure and puts the hours that must have gone into writing, producing, filming, and editing it comfortably into the hundreds of thousands.
And yet, despite all of that time, spanning all of those decades, only a handful of stars have ever been fired from the show. Understandably, as it's such a career-making gig with such an emphasis on recurring characters, that nobody would want to lose a character if they could help it.
Thus unlike other shows that feel like they've practically got a revolving door policy (looking at you ER), Star Trek will only fire someone as an absolute last resort. Meaning the stories behind said incidents tend to be as bizarre and strange as anything in the actual episodes themselves. Let's take a look at all the names who were forced to boldly go to the unemployment line.
Honorable Mentions
Just a quick pitstop here to clear up a few names who feel like they maybe should be on this list but don't quite fit the fired remit.
Terry Farell, who of course played Jadzia Dax in Deep Space Nine, left during Season Six. After approaching the show's producers and asking for a lighter schedule to allow her to pursue some other acting opportunities she was told that wouldn't be possible so instead just decided to leave.
Denise Cosby's time as Tasha Yar came to an abrupt end on The Next Generation when she was killed off after only 22 appearances, but this was her choice as well. Frustrated with her lack of character development and sick of having her ideas shot down, she elected to quit the show.
Finally, her Next Generation colleague Marina Sirtis was nearly fired ahead of Star Trek Nemesis when she had the temerity to ask the studio for parity of pay with some of her male colleagues. Shocked by such an alien concept, she was told if she wouldn't sign on they'd simply replace her with Seven of Nine. Sirtis called their bluff, Jeri Ryan turned it down, and a compromise was eventually reached.
7. Grace Lee Whitney
When Gene Roddenberry first devised the crew for Star Trek (well, technically this was the second time he did it, but more about that later...) he created the character of Yeoman Janice Rand, a personal assistant of sorts to Captain James T. Kirk. However, despite Grace Lee Whitney playing the part in the majority of the opening episodes, she was fired from the show before it concluded its first season.
The network and the producers claimed, at the time, that this decision was purely budgetary and they simply needed to streamline the cast to keep costs down but, years later, Whitney would reveal that she had been sexually assaulted by one of the show's executives and, in an effort to avoid any negative press, she was quietly let go from the show.
There's a happy ending of sorts though, as a sustained letter-writing campaign from fans and the support of her former cast members led to her being brought back in for the movies. She returned to the Enterprise for Star Trek: The Motion Picture, The Search for Spock and The Voyage Home, and even made the transfer to the Excelsior with Sulu in the Undiscovered Country.
She's never named the executive responsible because, in her words, this is her story, not his, but it remains a black mark in Star Trek's otherwise celebrated history.
6. Jennifer Lien
It's virtually impossible to talk about Jennifer Lien's exit from Star Trek: Voyager without using some arrangement of the words Nine, Seven, and Of given that Kes departed the very episode after the Scorpion two-parter that introduced her Borg colleague. Despite how obvious a straight-swap seems, everyone involved has always maintained there was more to it than that.
In a version of events that's backed up by writers, producers, and even Lien herself, Kes' time on the ship had just naturally come to an end and there was no other way to really explore her arc. Brannon Braga specifically regards her exit as a fault on the part of himself, saying; "it was a creative decision and it was a failure of imagination on the writers' part. We were running out of things to do with Kes. We had to make room in the budget for a new character in the cast so there was a pragmatic reason but it was primarily a creative decision."
By letting Kes go the show removed the headache of how to write more material for her while, at the same time, avoiding any pressure from the network to streamline a show that they already felt had "too many characters" in it. She would, of course, briefly return for the episode Fury but once Seven arrived on the scene she was pretty much straight out of the airlock.
5. Biff Yeager
I just want to take a moment to reflect on what an amazing name Biff Yaeger is...
...
Ok, that's enough.
It's a testament to LeVar Burton's performance as Cheif Engineer Geordi LaForge that a lot of people forget that he was originally the ship's helmsman. While he was manning the conn, all the way down on Deck 36 (yes, I'm that big of a nerd) the Enterprise had a revolving door of "Chief Engineers" who worked together to maintain the ship's systems and fix its technical problems.
Most of these figures didn't stick long in the memory, but one who did was Lieutenant Commander Argyle. In fact, he was so good in the role that the show's producers planned on making him a permanent member of the cast and giving him a much bigger role in future episodes until one day they just suddenly changed their minds.
The story - at least according to Will Wheaton - is that Paramount received a deluge of letters from fans advocating for a bigger part in the show for Argyle. They were impressed by the impact he'd made on the audience until, one day, they noticed that some of the letters were referencing his role in episodes that hadn't aired yet. Becoming suspicious they found out that Yaeger himself was behind this.
He'd written to fans personally to pressure them into sending letters to Paramount. Thus, they quickly binned him from the show, added some new engineers, before finally making LaForge the full-time Cheif of Engineering later in the show. Oops.
Still though, he was a big hit on Gilmore Girls so every cloud.
4. Geneviève Bujold
It's a common misconception that Kate Mulgrew played the first-ever female captain in Star Trek. While she was certainly the first full-time one, a handful of other women did beat her to that honour across the various series that preceded Voyager. What's even less well known than that though, is that Kate Mulgrew wasn't even the first Captain Janeway.
When Paramount signed off on a female captain, near-legendary Canadian actress Geneviève Bujold was the producer's first choice for the role. She was approached, accepted the offer, and the character of Nicole Janeway (as she was known then) was born. The only problem, Bujold's extensive movie and theatre experience hadn't even remotely prepared her for the rigors of shooting episodic television.
The long (often 18 hour) days on set, the constant adjustments from makeup and wardrobe, and simply having to take orders from directors she didn't know, took an immediate toll on the actress and she left the show after just a day and a half. Rick Berman commenting at the time that "it was immediately obvious it was not a good fit".
On the second day of filming, after heading to her trailer in tears followed quickly by Berman and the director. After a short conversation, it was decided that things would be better for both parties if she didn't return the next day and they recast the part. Strictly speaking, she walked, but only because a push was coming otherwise.
3. Gates McFadden
Yep, they actually fired Beverly Crusher. She didn't really just take that job as Head of Starfleet Medical.
Interestingly, only in the last few years has the true story behind McFadden's departure from the show really come to light. At the time, an official announcement from the network said that she "had left the series to pursue other career options". In reality, McFadden had just received a call from her agent saying that the producers wanted to go "in another direction" and wouldn't need her back.
But the plot thickened substantially though when Rick Berman revealed that she was actually fired because writer Maurice Hurley "had a real bone to pick" with her as an actress. In short, he didn't like the way she acted and so used his considerable sway to have her removed from the show. Adding further fuel to this account of events, the moment Hurley himself left the show, McFadden was brought back.
That return was seemingly inevitable though, as the frosty reception that had greeted Diana Muldaur replacing her as Doctor Katherine Pulaski, plus the pressure from both fans and Patrick Stewart, had made the decisions seem idiotic.
2. Kirstie Alley
At the time, the inclusion of Kirstie Alley into the cast of Star Trek II looked like a costly and transparent attempt to add some much-needed mainstream star-power to a franchise film. However, Alley was legitimately a lifelong Star Trek fan, who spent her youth watching the Orignal Series and running around pretending to be Spock's daughter, so when the part came up so jumped at the chance to audition.
Despite being a hit with fans and nailing the part, by the time Star Trek III rolled around she'd been recast with Robin Curtis. Precisely why this happened though differs depending on whose version of events you're more inclined to believe but the incredibly short answer is, of course, "money".
According to the official line from Paramount at the time, Alley and her representatives had asked for 10x the fee she was paid for Star Trek II, putting her ahead of long-standing series regulars like DeForest Kelley, and after considering it decided that she didn't justify those sorts of sums.
Alley's version, which she has told herself on a number of occasions, was that when the studio approached for about reprising the role they offered her less than she was originally paid for her first outing, so she concluded that they mustn't be that interested in having her involved.
As for where the truth lies, it's probably a bit of both.
1. The Entire Cast Of The Original Pilot (Minus Spock)
In 1964, with America still firmly gripping its throbbing erection over the space race, NBC decided to cash-in on this fascination with the stars and commission a show that would see man exploring the wonders of outer space. By February of the next year that show had been pitched, produced, and piloted, and Star Trek's The Cage was screened to the network. They absolutely hated it.
It was too slow, too intellectual, too boring, and nothing at all like what millions of Americans would be imagining the final frontier to be. But, in a move that virtually never happens, they were still sold on both the idea and the man behind it, so allowed Gene Roddenberry to try it again and produce a second pilot. He went back to the drawing board, created the characters of Kirk, Scotty and Sulu, and Where No Man Has Gone Before saw the show commissioned.
However, right next to that drawing board was the trash can, and in that he'd put Jeffrey Hunter as Captain Pike, Majel Barrett as Number One, John Hoyt as Dr. Boyce, and virtually every other member of the ship's crew. In fact, from the original pilot, only Leonard Nimoy's Mr Spock remained, albeit with a new approach to the emotion-suppressed Vulcan species.
Pike stayed part of the canon with Hunter reprising the role and Barrett would admittedly return as Nurse Chapel, Lwaxana Troi, and the Ship's Computer, but that was it. Star Trek's most famous and brutal swing of the axe came before it had even started.