7 Tearjerking TV Sitcom Tributes To Cast Members Who Died

Get the tissues, it's time to say goodbye to your favorite characters--and the actors playing them.

Lea Michele Glee
tumblr

When a television show has been on the air for a few years, it's easy to become attached to the characters, and for regular viewers to consider them something of an extended family. Because you can't choose your family, as they say, but you can choose who sit down in front of the tube and watch for 30-60 minutes each week.

So it tends to be a little troubling when one of your favorite characters is killed off. (With the exception, perhaps, of fans of The Walking Dead, who should be used to it by now.) Substantially more heartbreaking, though, is when you learn that the character you've grown to love was killed off because the actor portraying that character died in real life.

Some series choose not to dwell on this, briskly removing the character for ludicrous-but-emotionally efficient reasons, such as having the character take that long (LONG) trip to Bangkok they've always wanted, or if the show takes place within a specific realm of employ, by having the character suddenly transferred elsewhere. 

But the best showrunners know that it's often more appropriate to address these real-life deaths head-on, rather than trying to gloss it over. After the reports have come out about the nature of the actor's death and the proper statements have been made by those who work on the show, a tribute episode will follow. This onscreen grieving and eulogizing is often heartbreaking for audiences, but befitting of actors who spend so much time working in the medium.

7. Scrubs (John Ritter - Sam Dorian)

John Ritter Zach Braff
NBC

Though the sitcom 8 Simple Rules was John Ritter's primary job when he passed away, and that show delved headlong into an emotional eulogy for his character, there's something about the Scrubs tribute episode that was more consistent with the real-life comic actor's essence.

Only appearing in one episode as J.D.'s dad (Season 1, "My Old Man"), Ritter played the character with the perfect amount of charm and aloofness. His interactions with Zach Braff didn't feature the subtlest of humor, featuring such gems as a father asking his son to pull his finger so he could fart in the classiest way possible. 

But his comic style fit the often manic and loony nature of Scrubs, and he would have made a fine recurring cast member. It was a wise move by series creator Bill Lawrence not to recast the part following Ritter's death. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJ2G0bIhOHw

Instead they wrote his passing into the show, with J.D. struggling to deal with his dad's sudden departure. As the best Scrubs episodes do, Season 4's "My Cake" aptly balances heart and hijinks. There's not a better dedication possible to someone like Ritter, who perfected that balance decades prior.


6. NewsRadio (Phil Hartman - Bill McNeal)

Phil Hartman NewsRadio
NBC

Tackling the real-life death of a beloved cast member is especially hard when the show is known for its constant comedy. NewsRadio was not a series known for its heartfelt moments. It was comedy through and through.

So when Phil Hartman horrifically murdered by his wife, it was more than a little uneasy to consider how the sitcom might handle this touchy situation. Perhaps they'd have the cast break character completely to reminisce about their coworker during a clip-show retrospective? Or maybe this was a situation where it was perfectly reasonable to send his character, Bill McNeal, on an Arctic expedition for an undetermined amount of time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wPHqZLVeqk

In the end, NewsRadio opted to open Season 5 with a scene informing us that Bill died of a heart attack. The entirety of his onscreen coworkers return to work commenting on how beautiful the funeral service was, bringing along with it a brief moment of silence. Then Andy Dick's character wonders aloud whether the display of flowers next to the casket, in the shape of a broken heart, was meant to represent the manner of Bill's passing, prompting Stephen Root's character to respond thusly:

"No, that was me. I sat on it in the limo."

This was a dedication to Phil Hartman, after all, a man who was comedy through and through.


5. Cosby (Madeline Kahn - Pauline Fox)

Madeline Kahn on Cosby
CBS

For Cosby to land Madeline Kahn in one of the show's primary roles was no small coup. Kahn is one of the funniest women to ever grace the big and small screens, gaining notoriety as a go-to actress from Mel Brooks' bag of tricks. Unfortunately, Kahn had begun chemotherapy for ovarian cancer a couple of years into the show, and the disease would take her soon after.

Rather than recast the character (which would have been impossible...it's Madeline Kahn) or have her die offscreen, the principal cast gathered onto the set to fondly reminisce about their experiences working with the legendary actress. 

Their conversations are spliced into one of the finest clip shows ever put on television. The kind of retrospective that made viewers unsure if they were crying because Kahn was just that funny, or because they were so saddened that they would never see her perform in another series or film.


4. Suddenly Susan (David Strickland - Todd Stities)

Suddenly Susan Cast Photo
NBC

Finding the balance between maudlin tribute and whimsical homage is difficult when memorializing an actor most famous for playing a goofy, unfathomably moronic character on a sitcom. To make the ordeal too sentimental would betray the essence of the character, while playing the laughs too heavily might make it feel insincere.

When Suddenly Susan supporting actor David Strickland committed suicide, it was important for the episode that incorporated his death, the Season 3 finale "A Day in the Life," to toe the line. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpLVPmNm7ac

The episode centered around his character Todd, who suddenly went missing, and the requisite search for their lost coworker. Along the way, they all find out some special things about Todd that they never knew, about his generosity and overall good-hearted nature. The episode is spliced together with small scenes of the actors breaking character and talking directly to the camera about their recently deceased costar, often having trouble holding back tears.


3. Glee (Cory Monteith - Finn Hudson)

Cory Monteith as Finn Hudson
Fox

Though Cory Monteith was 31-years-old when he died of a drug overdose, he was much younger in the eyes of his fans, who watched him most frequently as teenager Finn Hudson in the musical television series Glee. That aspect, considering him as ten years younger than he was in actuality, made his untimely death a little harder for viewers to take.

Because the manner in which Monteith died had already taken over headlines, the creators of Glee opted to leave Finn's death ambiguous, even admonishing such interest in the opening scene where one of the characters says, "Everyone wants to talk about how he died. But who cares?" The show clearly didn't want any of the messy real-life controversy bleeding into the show's tribute.

The rest of the episode, "The Quarterback," was an hour-long tribute to both the actor and his character through song medleys. Each song seems a little less polished than usual for the show, which typically puts so much emphasis on the songs being iTunes ready. Here, it's like the actors are singing, not their characters. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kAIiL9gGqE

When Monteith's real-life girlfriend, Lea Michele (who also plays his girlfriend in the show), gets through her speech about the losing the love of her life and sings Adele's "Make You Feel My Love," it leaves a weepy path of destruction.


2. The West Wing (John Spencer - Leo McGarry)

Leo McGarry West Wing
NBC

For much of the duration of The West Wing, the character of Leo McGarry was one of the main focal points, acting as White House Chief of Staff. He was Martin Sheen's right-hand man, considered by some to be the one really in charge of the country. McGarry was ol' reliable. McGarry was the voice of reason.

When John Spencer passed away from a heart attack, a major plot line involving his character's run for vice presidency as part of the Democratic ticket was hastily rewritten. His character died of a heart attack on election night. He and Jimmy Smit's presidential nominee were supposed to lose the race, but the show's writers decided it would be appropriate to posthumously award his character the title of Vice President.

There is no fluff or pomp involved with the tribute to McGarry. In fact, there aren't many words spoken of him by any of the main characters. The funeral scene which opens up the episode is a simple sermon given by a pastor, with each of his friends and colleagues looking statuesquely somber. When the pall bearers (including Sheen) carry his casket, draped in the American flag, out of the church, it's unpretentious and truly affecting.


1. Sesame Street (Will Lee - Mr. Hooper)

Mr Hooper with Burt and Ernie
PBS

Oh boy. Having a character die on Sesame Street is comparable to lining up a hundred or so children under the age of 10 and having Harry Potter tell them that Santa Claus doesn't exist. And that he murdered their parents. It's...terrible, basically.

But when Will Lee, the actor who played one of the original (and rare for that time) human characters on Sesame Street, passed on, the show's writers decided it would be a good time to teach its young viewers one of the most unfortunate life lessons of all: That sometimes, even though it doesn't seem fair, people die. Parents were encouraged to watch the episode with their children, to guide them through and answer any questions they had.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxlj4Tk83xQ

There really no words that can adequately describe the scene in which Big Bird tries to comprehend how his friend, Mr. Hooper, will no longer be around to tell him stories. It is one of the most heartrending things ever filmed, and there's a good reason it was never rebroadcast. 


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.