7 Things Supergirl Needs To Do Next

The show is getting better, but there's more that it can do.

The pilot of Supergirl was rollicking, right out of the gate. Its momentum sputtered a few episodes lagged. Recently, however, Supergirl is starting to find its legs. The characters are beginning to get fleshed out, the actors are coming into their own, the action is getting better, and the well-meaning but hamfisted feminist messages have become a lot more subtle and well presented. Despite all that though, I still think there's a lot more the show could be doing to make itself into the high flying superhero show it has the potential to be. The Superman mythology is one of the richest in all of comics, with some of the best characters, villains, and concepts imaginable. And though the big screen version of Superman has jettisoned much of the more whimsical, lighthearted trappings in favor of Nolan style realism, Supergirl has retained the cartoony earnestness needed to pull off some of the wackier stuff the Golden Age era of comics brought to the table. (good-) And, well, Supergirl comics are chock full of the craziest, coolest stuff you'll ever seen in a comic book. So far, much of the show has consisted of monster-of-the-week stories interspersed with a running story line involving Kara, her aunt General Astra, and the memory of Kara's mother. And while that's worked out pretty well, there are a lot of really interesting pieces that could be brought to the board in order to make the show an even richer and more entertaining experience.

7. Develop The Villains

Most of the villains Kara has fought so far have been one-off alien threats that attack the city, are defeated, and then never show up again. That's standard for a monster-of-the-week style format, but these villains don't tend to have a lot of depth or impact. There have been two exceptions however. Astra, Kara's aunt and a Kryptonian general and eco-terrorist who believes that human beings are incapable of keeping their own planet in check, and Maxwell Lord, a business tycoon and mad scientist who the show seems to be setting up as Supergirl's own Lex Luthor style nemesis. They're both interesting characters, but the show hasn't quite used them to their potential yet. For example, Astra was killed off long before she really should've been. It was a well shot, dramatic moment, but it came about a season and a character arc too early. In that same light, Maxwell Lord is slowly being built up to be Kara's true nemesis, being responsible for many of the mishaps in the show with more villainous plans obviously in the works. It's a good start, but the show really needs to establish a firm big bad if the overarching story is going to have any weight or stakes.

6. Kara€™s Alien Nature

The biggest difference between Supergirl and her male counterpart is their relationship to their home planet Krypton. While Clark was sent to earth as a baby, raised by humans and only learned more about his home world much later in life. Kara didn€™t come to earth until she was twelve, after spending her childhood beneath Krypton€™s red sun. Though we€™ve heard bits and pieces about Krypton so far, none of it has been all that in-depth. It tells us nothing about Krypton as a society in this continuity, or how Kara feels about it in relation to her adopted home on Earth. How did she take to earth and its culture (and yellow sun) when she was younger? Was it strange to her? Did she have difficulty adapting? The pilot condensed Kara€™s origin to about ten minutes, before immediately jumping into her twenties, long after she€™d become accustomed to Earth and had a basic control of her powers. In fact, a good portion of the time the show seems to forget Kara is an alien at all, apart from her powers. It could make for an interesting bit of world building if Kara were to off-offhandedly mention Kryptonian customs and conventions. Does Kara retain the Kryptonian religion, the worship of the god Rao, or did she take on a human religion as well? There€™s no end to what you could do with a tapestry of alien culture, and it would do a lot for Kara and her place in the world to reinforce her nature as an alien being every now and then.

5. Mention/Introduce Brainiac

So far, Supergirl has established that Krypton was destroyed thanks to the planet€™s climate change, which ultimately caused it to implode from within. We don€™t know what caused these changes; it could easily be that Kryptonians were just as harmful to their environment as we are to ours, but maybe, just maybe, it was Braniac. In many versions of the canon the god-like, Skynet-esque thought-entity has been responsible for the destruction of Krypton, usually for reasons of either finding the world inferior or just simple curiosity. Well, simple curiosity on a ludicrous scale. If Supergirl wants to build up to a really big villain, there's no better choice than Brainiac. Just imagine what Kara would do when the being responsible for her home-world's destruction came to Earth, threatening her adopted home. Losing Krypton was a trauma that's defined much of her life. Unlike Clark, Kara has a far more personal stake in this. She saw Krypton get destroyed, remembers it, longs for it. Remember when Kara went in a grief fueled rage and fried Red Tornado? Take that and crank it up to eleven. Imagine the endgame showdown: Brainiac has come to earth and is preparing to assimilate it for documentation, all the while speaking in a haunting, robotic tone about being the most perfect being in the cosmos. Then the two have an epic final duel, Kara fueled by all the rage of a dead world, fighting at her most powerful.

4. Introduce Powergirl

This one may be a tricky, seeing as, technically speaking, Supergirl and Powergirl are different versions of the same character. But, since it€™s been confirmed that the show is connected to the Arrowverse€™s multiverse, meaning that alternate Earths are now fair game, and Powergirl can join the show. In the comics, what differentiates Supergirl and Powergirl is age. Powergirl is the Supergirl who grew up and shed the iconic S in order to establish herself as completely independent from her cousin. This idea could make for a great episode, or even a great mini arc. For example, what if on Powergirl's Earth, the pod that brought her to Earth was never knocked off course, and thus Kara was found by the Kent€™s alongside Clark? This would mean that in this universe, Kara would become a superhero first, and not have to crawl her way out from under her legendary cousin's shadow. It would be interesting change of dynamic, seeing as Kara was originally meant to be Kal-El€™s guardian and protector, not the other way around. In this world, Kara Danvers would be Kara Kent, and would have far different relationships with the entirety of the cast. She and Alex wouldn't be sisters, and may not even know each other. She'd have grown up in the Kansas countryside, raised by farm folk instead of by scientists, resulting perhaps in an accent change or even a different personality. The entire dynamic of the story would be different, and it would be cool to see Kara react to how her life may have ended up. On top of that, it would be amazing to see Melissa Benoist take a shot at playing a Kara tempered by a dozen years more experience.

3. Bring In Ms Martian

Something Supergirl has gotten a lot of praise for is its portrayal of relationships between women, which it does very well. However, while Kara has great relationships with her adoptive sister Alex and mentor Cat Grant, something she lacks in comparison is female friends. There€™s Lucy Lane, but so far her function has largely been to keep Kara from getting together with Jimmy Olsen so early in the show. I can think of no better candidate for Kara€™s superpal than M€™gann M€™orzz, Miss Martian. Largely known for her role in the tragically short lived Young Justice cartoon, Megan is the niece of the Martian Manhunter, who, depending on the continuity, came into her uncle's care after leaving Mars. She and Kara actually have a lot in common. Firstly, they€™re both the female relative of a DC comics legend. Secondly, they both usually have a bubbly kind demeanor that turns to frighteningly destructive rage when angered. And thirdly, they€™re both young alien women trying to find their way on earth, and reconciling their place in the universe. They€™d have quite a bit to talk about, and Kara could always use another alien ally to help when any Darkseid(sp?) sized threats come knocking. It would also provide great story lines for J€™ohn J€™onzz, as it would mean that he€™d no longer be the last of his kind. And that guy could always use reasons to be less mopey.

2. Get A Hand On Relationships

A trap that Supergirl seems on the verge of falling into is the dreaded love triangle. Kara has had semi romantic interactions with both of her males best friends, James Olsen and Winn Schott (though she did reject the latter), and the writers seem to be doing everything they can to drag these entanglements out. This is probably part of the reason Lucy Lane is even on the show, she's there so that Kara can't hook up with Jimmy until much later on. There's nothing wrong with romance of course, but it can become insufferable for the audience to slog through seasons of insipid romantic back and forth that they know won't amount to anything. Arrow suffered greatly to this effect. Oliver's romantic life could've been concise and believable, but instead it was stretched into a soap opera subplot very few fans liked. If the writers want Kara to have a romantic partner, then they need to pick one and stick to it, whether it be Jimmy or Winn. (Or if they want a third route they could pair her with Cat. Many of the fans would love it, and the two undeniably have the best chemistry of the whole cast.) Supergirl has too much on her plate to spend so much of it dwelling on dating. She may be an attractive twenty-something, but she's also a nigh invincible demigod of Krypton, and that second one should be the focus.

1. Establish Superman€™s Role

It completely understandable why the creative team would be hesitant to have the Big Blue Boy-scout appear fully on screen. This is Kara€™s story, and bringing in Superman may run the risk of overshadowing her. That, and having a Superhero as powerful as Superman, with well over a decade of experience, would probably end up undercutting all the drama. He would solve way too many problems way too fast for the story to be interesting. Here€™s the thing though, while it€™s understandable to not show Superman, him not being there kind of makes him look like an enormous jerk. They don€™t even need to really make him appear fully on screen, just clarify what role the Man of Steel has played in the life of his only living blood relative. Thankfully a lot of this stuff can be explained through a series of throw away lines. Why didn€™t Clark bring Kara to live with Ma and Pa Kent? Maybe they€™d already passed away, or were too old to raise another super powered child by the time Kara landed. Did Clark help her come to terms with her powers? Do they visit each other on holidays? Family has always been an important part of the Superman books, and it would be good to see what kind of family relationship Kara has with her closest living family member. What do you want to see from Supergirl in future? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread below.

Contributor

A creative writing student from Indianapolis, Joe loves games, fantasy novels and comics.