8 Main Character Deaths That Killed Great TV Shows
These shows never recovered from these untimely character deaths.
The death of any prominent TV character is a precarious business. Killing them off too soon or in the wrong way can alienate your fanbase, but if you get it right the stars align and the chances are high you're going to create heartbreaking TV gold.
Sadly, this is most definitely not the case with the following TV show deaths, each of which came about in such a tactless, unfair or unfortunate way that it derailed the entire series going forward; the writers unable to recapture whatever magic that series once had.
From beloved sci-fi classics that couldn't live without the big personalities at their centre, to moody dramas that went too far removing a promising figure from their story, each of the following shows killed characters at completely the wrong time, in completely the wrong way, rendering the series' future forever tainted by their loss.
Of course, there are plenty of behind-the-scenes issues at play here that have to be respected -- sometimes, an actor just wants to step away, and that's that -- but for the most part these character deaths were, with the power of hindsight, a pretty bad idea.
With that in mind, here are eight TV character deaths that effectively killed their shows. This article will contains heavy spoilers for each show discussed.
8. Lexa - The 100
During her painfully short stint on The 100, warrior Lexa was one of the show's most compelling characters, and due to her leadership, strength, and budding romance with series lead Clarke, she seemed destined to stick around.
But it wasn't meant to last. Just as she started to get comfortable with the show's ensemble and confess her love for Clarke, Lexa was anticlimactically killed off by a stray bullet, in what can only be described as a lazy way to hurt its lead and crush an endearing same-sex love story.
With Lexa gone, The 100 scrambled to fill the void she left, but nothing worked. Like Clarke, the audiences never recovered from her death, and her absence was the first nail in the coffin for a series that would fall inexorably downward with each passing season.
If only Lexa had been given the role she deserved, The 100 wouldn't have ended up becoming such a mess.
7. Tara Knowles - Sons Of Anarchy
Tara was part of Sons of Anarchy from the very beginning. The strong-willed love interest of Jax Teller, she was always on the outside of his shady lifestyle, but was always there to remind him of his humanity.
It was a shame, then, when the show cruelly killed her off in the penultimate season, stabbed repeatedly in the head by Jax's rage-fuelled mother, Gemma, and left lifeless for her heartbroken lover to find.
Going forward, Tara's death forced Jax into the darkest (and final) chapter of his own life, where he abandoned his humanity and eventually murdered his own mother. You can see why the writers killed her, but to do it so coldly and let the show become so hopeless after the fact is to date a bitter pill to swallow.
Like many characters on Sons of Anarchy, Tara deserved so much better. Or at the very least, a more meaningful, less cruel demise. The show was never the same.
6. Rita Morgan - Dexter
In a series about an emotionless serial killer, Dexter needed someone to anchor him to his humanity. Luckily for him, he had his future wife, Rita.
Whilst Dexter was off killing other serial killers and concealing his identity from his colleagues and loved ones, Rita was at home opening him up to the possibility of a real life. He was, by his own admission, incapable of real love, but with Rita their relationship showed he wasn't entirely dead inside.
It was a mighty shame, then, when Rita was brutally killed by the Trinity Killer in the show's fourth season, because whilst it was one of Dexter's finest moments, it also meant that future seasons would be lacking her hopeful presence.
And sure enough, both Dexter the show and Dexter the character were never the same without her; there was a human element and a challenge missing from Dexter's life. More free to delve into his bloody pasttime, the show became quite tired with her gone, and never recovered.
5. Rick Grimes - The Walking Dead
Yes, yes, Rick Grimes doesn't actually die in The Walking Dead, but everyone thought he did, and after his presumed demise he isn't seen again (until a cameo in the show's finale, that is).
Rick's "death" in the middle of the zombie drama's ninth season threw the show and its characters into disarray, since it no longer had a true protagonist guiding the drama, nor Rick's compelling desire to protect his family at its centre.
Try as he might, Daryl couldn't fill the void his best friend left, and the show itself failed to find an emotional centre after he was gone. It became more of an ensemble, despite the fact many of the characters still standing lacked the depth of Officer Friendly.
He may be coming back for his own spin-off, but that won't change the fact that The Walking Dead's final years were lost and unfocussed without him.
4. Tara Maclay - Buffy The Vampire Slayer
If ever there was a character who didn't deserve their fate, it would be Buffy the Vampire Slayer's Tara Maclay, the love interest of Willow who was unceremoniously shot dead by violent big bad Warren Mears.
Meeting her end in the supernatural drama's controversial season six episode Seeing Red, Tara is killed almost as an afterthought, shot through the heart by a stray bullet after reuniting with Willow for what seems like their happily ever after.
It was a callous and horrible end for such a lovely, innocent character, put in place only to push Willow into her long-teased villain arc. Worse than this ultimately lazy character manipulation, though, was the fact that Willow and Tara were the only same-sex couple on the show.
Buffy never overcame Tara's death or the horribly dark events that followed it (Willow tries to end the world and flays Warren alive), which linger over the show for the rest of its run. It's a death that you can't forget or forgive, and the show's final season fails to justify or move on from it.
3. Fox Mulder - The X-Files
The X-Files was always about Fox Mulder and Dana Scully, whose relationship and investigations into alien activity drove the show's drama, humour and heart.
It was colossally detrimental for the show, then, when Mulder was abducted and believed dead at the end of the show's seventh season, and then appeared only sparingly (typically through archive footage and brief cameos, because David Duchovny quit following issues with Fox Studios) on the following two seasons.
Now, Mulder doesn't actually die, but his MIA status leads many to believe he is, and his absence is deeply felt. Whilst Scully is a great character in her own right, without Mulder she's not quite the same, unable to carry The X-Files' mysteries alone.
It also didn't help that Mulder was replaced by Agent Doggett, who despite being played by Robert Patrick is given very little to work with. By the time he returned for the show's final seasons, The X-Files wasn't able to recover from his absence.
2. Nick Clark - Fear The Walking Dead
Before it became the utter shambles it is now, Fear the Walking Dead had a great three seasons at the start of its run, thanks in large part to the endearing nature of the Clark family at its centre.
The best of the family by a large margin was Nick Clark, a recovering addict whose survival instincts and mental struggles made him a compelling joy to watch. That is, until the fourth season, when he was randomly killed by newcomer Charlie to make way for some new protagonists.
Not only did Nick meet an unceremonious end after everything he'd been through, but his demise also came after he seemed poised to take on a bigger role, befriending Morgan Jones and leading his own group through the long-dead world.
Fear the Walking Dead never recovered from Nick's death or the cast overhaul that followed, and looking back, it's safe to say his last breath was also the show's. What could have been.
1. Zoe Barnes - House Of Cards
Zoe Barnes was only around in House of Card's first season, but she was far-and-away the best part of it, proving a brilliant foil to the vicious Frank Underwood and allowing Kate Mara to give one of her finest performances.
It wasn't meant to be, though. Just as Barnes starts to figure out Frank's secrets, he brutally kills her by throwing her into an oncoming train. It's an admittedly fantastic if implausible scene, but it does mean that House of Cards is missing a big piece going forward.
Though Frank faces many competitors in future seasons, he never has a more compelling relationship than the one he had with Barnes, a quick-witted and intelligent journalist who could have made the show's future drama that much juicer if she'd been allowed to stay.
With her gone, Frank never has a rival as dangerous or entertaining, and by extension House of Cards itself never feels so alive again.