8 Reasons Why How I Met Your Dad Is A Terrible Idea

Speak Hear See With hit TV sitcom How I Met Your Mother coming in to its ninth and final season, CBS have officially announced that they have signed off on a spin-off series called How I Met Your Dad. The creators from HIMYM, Carter Bays and Craig Thomas, have both signed on to co-write it with Emily Spivey (Up All Night) and both seem pretty excited by the opportunity to prolong their HIMYM success. The idea is that it will trace the structure of the original series, but this time told from the perspective of a woman with a completely unrelated cast and story. Throughout its run, How I Met Your Mother managed to capture that magical combination of a great ensemble cast and some really entertaining comedic writing. It has won the heart of many a Friends mourner, something which seemed impossible when it first appeared on our screens back in 2005 but has since become one of CBS's major ratings contributors. So it's easy to see why the idea of a spin-off has even been suggested. But how is HIMYM's successor going to live up to the original? Whilst the fact that the creators of HIMYM have jumped on board should provide some continuity in quality, it can't be ignored that spin-off series are always met with a sense of trepidation and usually for some very good reasons. So without further ado, click next to reveal the reasons How I Met Your Father should stay on the ideas pile...

8. We Will Be On The Rebound

Himym

Let's face it, even though the show has lost some of what made it awesome in the latest seasons, we're all getting graduation goggles now it's coming to a close. Just like Marshall suddenly loves his job the minute he decides to quit working for Goliath National Bank in The Exploding Meatball Sub, we can suddenly overlook all How I Met Your Mother's imperfections, the poor writing, the cheap jokes, and tell ourselves we don't want it to end. And when it does finally finish this season, we're going to be looking for something to fill that big HIMYM shaped whole in our lives and the obvious choice would be the spin-off. In our fragile state, we may end up looking for companionship at any cost, even if they're not right for us. So How I Met Your Mother fans may end up jumping on the readily available How I Met Your Dad bandwagon not because it's a great show but because we miss HIMYM and How I Met Your Dad will be there to take advantage of our needy and vulnerable disposition. And what happens to most rebound relationships? They eventually fizzle out because they were never meant to be...

7. The Premise Is No Longer Big Or Clever

Kids

The premise of an older Ted sitting his kids down and telling them a story of how he met their mother was originally a fresh and creative way of setting up a TV show. It allowed for interesting narrative techniques within episodes (like how future Ted can't remember why Lily and Barney were arguing in The Mermaid Theory) as well as creating an addictive and compelling narrative arc that spans the entire series. Fans became hooked and genuinely invested in the journey, hoping to be rewarded with the eventual reveal of how he met his future wife. However, this premise lost its novelty in the latter half of the show's nine year run and it became evident the writers were scraping the bottom of the barrel for ideas to keep this concept interesting. Instead, loyal fans have just become impatient and the painstakingly protracted story has come to be more frustrating than intriguing these days. With this in mind, How I Met Your Dad will not have a shiny, new concept to hang its hat on. Viewers will know exactly what to expect from the narrative and there will be no shroud of intrigue to capture our imagination. The writers of How I Met Your Dad will have to overcome all of this if they have any hope of luring the fans of How I Met Your Mother because to be quite honest, we've been there and watched that!

6. It's All About the Money!

Himym 2 Is nothing sacred anymore? Can we NOT make everything about bleeding as much money as possible from success please? Well, with How I Met Your Mother being one of CBS's highest rated shows, I suppose it was only a matter of time before Franchise Freddy got his claws into it. In a media climate where everything is a remake or a reboot or a retelling, HIMYM was a breath of fresh air as an original concept. Whilst similarities were drawn to Friends, with it being set in Manhattan and based on the lives of a group of young professionals, it had its own narrative twist and its own brand of humour. So yes, it was similar but it was also different enough for it not to feel like a betrayal to Friends fanatics who were hesitant at first. This is what eventually led to the show winning the ratings war every Monday night. But HIMYM's financial success does not necessarily give artistic merit to the idea of a spin-off and actually has the opposite effect. It's hard NOT to see it as a financial decision above anything else, something which taints both the memory of the original HIMYM and the proposed spin-off before it's even been aired. Why do they have to put profit before creative entertainment? Sorry CBS, the sign off on a How I Met Your Dad pilot feels like nothing more than shameless breeding of the cash cow that is its predecessor.

5. It Calls Bays and Thomas's Artistic Integrity In To Question

Bays And Thomas Both Carter Bays and Craig Thomas, creators of HIMYM, are whole-heartedly backing this idea for a spin-off: they have taken to Twitter to express their hopes that '#HIMYD becomes its own magical wonderful thing, and the two shows stand on their own side by side.' How is that possible guys? Firstly, if they're stood side by side, they're not stood on their own. But more importantly, surely they are relying on all their fans from HIMYM to follow them to their new show BECAUSE of the similarities? It seems like they are hoping to mimic the success of HIMYM by mimicking the show itself whilst simultaneously trying to assert that the show will be completely different just so they don't look like they have 'sold out to the man'. As well as this, they have both been quoted as saying that they agreed to do the spin-off because they are still having so much fun on HIMYM. It sounds like we won't be the only ones on the rebound. Thomas says the spin-off 'will be very much its own beast, but there is something comforting in knowing if you have some great idea for another love story [...] there might be another place to tell a new version of that.' So rather than create something entirely new or doing the spin off because they believe in its artistic merit, they are determined to stay in their HIMYM bubble because they're not ready to let go of the original show.

4. HIMYM Is Already Passed Its Best €“ What Do the Writers Have Left?

Autumn Of Breakups Ted telling Robin he loves her AGAIN, Barney having a dog for a wingman, Marshall pretending to be a sassy, southern lady whilst trying to find his inner goddess... if we're honest, season eight saw some of the more questionable writing from the creative team behind HIMYM. Could they not think of anything better than a dog for a wingman? Seriously? There have been many episodes that have brought cringes and sighs from viewers and this was mostly through regurgitating the same storylines again and again. Whether that was the Robin/Ted/Barney roundabout or Barney falling head over heels for Nora and then Quinn (who was essentially Nora but more appropriate for Barney). Then there's the fact that Marshall and Lily have been demoted to the role of slapstick comic relief. 46 Minutes was a particular low point as Marshall, Lily and her dad Mickey take part in a terrible horror movie spoof that is dripping in cheese. So with Bays and Thomas claiming they are still having so much fun on HIMYM and this is the result, do we really want to see more of this? The truth is HIMYM have thought of a genius premise for a TV series that ensures even when fans are annoyed and losing interest in the show, they still feel compelled to watch to the end of it, if only to answer the series long question of how Ted meets the mother of his children. Does that mean the writers have to care less about holding our attention from episode to episode? It would appear so. When the writers seem tired and out of ideas, what more could they possibly have to offer from the same exhausted concept?

3. We're Too Tired CBS! Leave Us Alone

Couple

With this in mind, do we really want to commit potentially to another nine years? The HIMYM narrative premise demanded that once you become a fan of the show you HAD to watch it to the end in order to determine who the mother is. This eventually became a frustrating fact that meant even as the show became less funny and interesting, we still HAD to watch it for fear of wasting our seven or eight yearlong investment in answering the eponymous question. Whilst screaming 'Why?' at the television when being forced to watch repetitive and/or underdeveloped storylines, we would still tune in week after week in hope of discovering a new snippet of the overarching plot. In fact, one fatal flaw of the narrative frame is that we end up longing for the end of the series so we can find out the answer and instead of mourning the arrival of the final season, it's being met with more of a long sigh of relief. Do we really have the energy for another narrative marathon or should we save ourselves the attention-sapping frustration and not bother investing at all this time? It could mean many viewers make quicker judgements on whether to follow the series. If it's not amazing right from the start, the network may find audiences have little patience to wait and see if it gets any better. Who wants to end up committed to another potentially poor quality show in nine years' time praying for the light at the end of the tunnel?

2. It's The Very Definition Of Uncreative

Speak Hear See Whilst there could maybe be an argument made if they were basing it round the perspective and backstory of the actual mother from HIMYM (it could involve clever continuity skills and would demand an impressive attention to detail to make sure the plots lined up), the fact that it is not going to be her story essentially makes it entirely the same show just with a different cast and a slightly different title. Same writers, same story, same narrative frame. As we've already covered, the writers seem to have the contradictory notion that How I Met Your Dad will be stand on its own but that is just not possible without an original and creative concept. It's not even like CSI migrating to Miami and New York because not only is How I Met Your Dad going to be set in the same city as HIMYM, but the CSI shows rely mainly on their independent episodic format as opposed to a series-long story arc that requires progression through a predominant amount of the episodes.The very fact that HIMYM and its upcoming spin-off are going to share exactly the same premise in exactly the same way just screams unoriginal. Someone's hitting copy and paste and if it's successful, we could be looking at a new era of replicated sitcoms. Gossip Guy or Two And Half Women anyone?

1. Some Things Are Just Better Left Alone

Joey1 Writers and network execs have ruined many a memory of our beloved TV shows with failed attempts to create spin off series and what they apparently fail to learn is that sometimes it really isn't worth it. Whilst it is obviously possible to piggyback on the original show's success by creating spin-off with a supporting character or similar element (Frasier seems the most obvious example), more often than not, something is lost in the reinvention and we're just left with an ugly mess embarrassment. So when a show has been as successful as HIMYM, surely it's better to just let it end with dignity? Let's face it, if Friends can't do it with the abomination that was Joey, writers should perhaps take heed from shows that have gone before them and just leave it alone. It obviously remains to be seen whether How I Met Your Dad will mimic its predecessor's huge success or pale into insignificance but with HIMYM's writing in the state that it's in now, it feels almost impossible to see what more they can squeeze out of the HIMYM sponge. They're struggling to finish the current series. How are they going to extract an entire new spin-off? Let's hope they have some magic left and they're saving some big secret that will add a new twist to this already tired premise but at the moment it seems there is only one thing left to say. It's going to be ter... wait for it... rible! How are you feeling HIMYM fans? Will you be watching with party hats and balloons? Or hugging a picture of Neil Patrick Harris and the gang crying 'it's just not the same!' Share your thoughts below.

Contributor
Contributor

Born in Yorkshire, Katie is a freelance journalist currently based in Essex. As a keen sports writer, Katie has a diploma in Multimedia Journalism from the Press Association and has worked on the busy Newcastle Chronicle sports desk. She has also written for Gateshead FC and contributed to various websites including Give Me Sport. When she's not watching sports, films or playing music, she's gaming. 8 hours and eventually reaching wave 80 on Modern Warfare 3′s Resistance is a productive day!