8 Reasons The Seinfeld Superbowl Reunion Just Didn't Work

Seinfeld is nothing short of legend. It's the quintessential show about nothing. The Yada Yada, and it sadly ended its run in 1998 despite co-creator, head writer and star Jerry Seinfeld being offered $1 million an episode to continue for a tenth season. However, during this year's Superbowl halftime show, Seinfeld returned, sort of. The Superbowl halftime show is famous for all sorts of great advertisements and shorts, and with the charge of $1 million for 30 seconds of airtime during the special, they really need to put special effort in to make it worth our time. Does anyone remember the Ferris Bueller Honda commercial not too long ago? How about all those new trailers for the movie's that we'll be collectively spending a billion dollars on in the summer? It really is as much an event as the actual Superbowl, and something as big as a Seinfeld reunion really should have been something beyond superb. Sadly, it just wasn't, and here's a few reasons why. Although if you don't believe me, see the six minute commercial for yourself: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FhmpTxLhqzU

8. It Was Built Up Too Much

Not too long ago, we heard the news of "Top Secret Seinfeld Reunion In The Works." How exciting did that sound?! Our minds were spinning with questions; was it a fully realised version of the reunion episode we saw during season 7 of Curb Your Enthusiasm? Was it a movie? If so, how would that work? Nope. Sorry. It's just a not-so-funny six minute Superbowl commercial. We'd heard that Larry David and Jerry Seinfeld were writing, David was directing, and Seinfeld was most certainly starring. What we ended up with wasn't what we would have wanted, and it certainly wasn't especially good. Quite clearly, we had expected too much.

7. It's Just A Comedians In Cars Getting Coffee Advertisement

What were you expecting when you heard about another Seinfeld? A couple references to old school Seinfeld? I hoped that George would get upset, and that there wouldn't be anything wrong with that. Instead, it was some strange, meta-physical version that acted as a trailer for Seinfeld's new web series Comedians In Cars Getting Coffee trailer. So does that mean the fictional Jerry has a web series now too? I wouldn't imagine it to be very popular, especially if he's interviewing the creator of the iToilet. The advertisement was just that, an advertisement. It brought some attention to Acura, and to Seinfeld's web series, but it didn't do anything for the show it was supposed to be homaging.

6. Hello, Newman...Goodbye, Newman...

Is two people acting together as shadows of the original characters really a reunion? When we heard "reunion", we wanted a fully fledged reunion with the entirety of the main cast. What we needed was for Jerry to be accompanied by the holy trifecta of supporting leads; George Costanza, Elaine Benes and Cosmo Kramer. In the episodes where for whatever reason a main cast member was missing, it didn't matter how good the episode was, we always noticed and missed the hell out of the absent character. The Chinese Restaurant is one of the best episodes of Seinfeld, if not the best, but it didn't have Kramer, and we most definitely noticed. Just ask Jason Alexander about The Pen and he'll tell you how much he noticed. If the Superbowl reunion were good, I wouldn't have minded the absences of Elaine and Kramer as much, but given the quality of the special, it just added to the disappointment. Additionally, and just to add insult to injury, Newman appears for all of ten seconds. At least when he appeared for ten seconds in the Curb reunion, it was damn funny. This time he talks about food, does some weird laugh and scuttles off, which is a pretty shameful waste of the show's most popular recurring character.

5. It's Just Not Seinfeld

Seinfeld Happy Gif Sure it might be Seinfeld and David at the helm, and sure it might feature the characters of Newman and George, but it just wasn't Seinfeld. Maybe the problem was merging it with CCC that made it seem surreal, but the thing is that it wasn't just that. It wasn't funny. There's no other way to describe it. There was some seeds of observational humour, sure, such as "The Over-Cheer" and the availing oneself in the master bathroom when you're a guest at a popular couple's household, but it never really paid off. They just mentioned that George did it. Not even the mumbling bit worked. Maybe the problem is that they're both out of touch. After all, it seems rather evident that they are when you watch this short. It seems surprising to hear "Hello...Newman" acted out so poorly by Seinfeld. Did he hiccup halfway through the line? Did he not want to do another take? You're not Calculon, Mr. Seinfeld, it's okay if you have another go.

4. It's Just Not Comedians In Cars Getting Coffee

Yes, they're in a car, and yes, they get coffee, but the subjects of the episode in question are not two Comedians, which is what made CCC so funy. In the Seinfeld universe, it's one stand-up comedian who went to jail with his best friend who is a failed sit-com writer and app inventor who lost his money...in a car getting coffee (during the Superbowl halftime show). The point of CCC (and what made it so good) was that the two comedians exchanged pleasantries, drove around and had a good time while deeply analysing what makes comedy comedic as well as sharing stories of how they made it and what they had done as favours for other comedians and such, and they did it for about three times the length that they did in this six-minute long reunion.

3. We Already HAD A Reunion (A Good One, Too)

The whole of season seven of Larry David's sister show, Curb Your Enthusiasm, was dedicated to reuniting Seinfeld and the others. Estelle Costanza, Newman and Kenny Bania even briefly appeared to join the fun. The plot of the reunion (within the reunion) was George trying to get back on his feet after being scammed out of the millions he made from inventing the iToilet (based on an idea skill he claims to have acquired during the show), and now wants to marry his ex-girlfriend who had shares in the iToilet and kept them for himself before Bernie Madoff could take it away from her. Unfortunately, the girlfriend wants a pre-nup, so George is marrying a woman who has half of his money so he can keep half of his money that wouldn't be his if he didn't get married. Does that make sense to you? Regardless, it wasn't just a reunion, it was a chance to see the warped Curb-versions of the cast, which made it even more funny, and it seemed like the perfect way to see the Seinfeld universe off. You want more of the cast together? Get them on Curb Your Enthusiasm again and let it be.

2. You Couldn't Just Interview Jason Alexander?

In series one of CCC Seinfeld interviewed Michael Richards, and that went pretty well. Same goes for his interview with Larry David. Why couldn't he just spend an episode interviewing Jason Alexander? Apparently he's nothing like his Curb Your Enthusiasm personality so he must be not only entertaining, but a great person to have a conversation with and very insightful to boot. Now, not only have you wasted your opportunity to interview Jason Alexander, but Wayne Knight also. Maybe it's because he's only had 22 episodes so far (23 if you count this), but it seems as though Seinfeld won't be re-interviewing comedians on his show, with there being a wide variety of them to choose from in future, so the thought might not go through Seinfeld's head that he hasn't actually interviewed Alexander or Knight as themselves. Come on, don't you want to see Seinfeld and Knight have coffee as regular people?

1. "We Already Screwed Up One Finale..."

...And now you've screwed up another one. I didn't have much of a problem with the finale, I was fine with the irony that the main cast of the show about nothing were arrested for doing just that, but sadly I was more than a little underwhelmed. Then Curb came along and salvaged it with a genuine scripted episode (we just didn't see every second of it), and we got the chance to finish on a good note again. Now, unless drastic measures are taken, this is our final Seinfeld reunion. What a shame it is, too. With Curb, it wasn't just one episode, it was a whole 10 episode season (if you want to be technical about it, Jerry appeared in 5 episodes during that season, Louis-Dreyfus in 4, and Alexander and Richards in 3 episodes each). All the more importantly, it was brilliantly executed and wonderfully performed. Now we have this bland, short commercial for Acura, and to a lesser extent, Comedians In Cars Getting Coffee. But the worst part is, I don't care that it's a commercial for those things. If it were just a 30-second spot featuring the cast (in character) ordering at Burger King, it would be okay as long as it were funny. Now, if you try and educate anyone under the age of 25 as to what Seinfeld is, their reaction will be "Oh. The one from that Superbowl special? Nah, that sucked, not my taste". Then they'll probably switch their attention back to their TV screens and continue to watch their endless Friends reruns. Any other reasons the reunion didn't work? How would you like to have seen it go? Leave your answer in the comments and thanks for reading!

In this post: 
Seinfeld
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Nerd. Not much else to say on that front. Television, film, comic book and general useless trivia enthusiast. Maybe you'll find me funny.