8 TV Love Triangles That Worked (And 3 That Didn't)

To be or not to be... that is the question.

Buffy Angel Spike Featured
Mutant Enemy Productions

Till death do us part. That is how long we like to believe relationships in the real world will last. In television, however, it's a very different story. It's rare for a TV couple to remain together forever, and in order to ruffle a few feathers some showrunners like to insert a third party into a seemingly perfect relationship, just to cause a bit of a stir and keep their viewers interested.

These so-called love triangles can be controversial, but when they're good, they're really good. How many television series have we sat through, hoping and praying that our protagonist will tell their one true love how they feel, but when they finally muster up the courage to do so, they realise that this person is showing affection for another instead? Yes, we've witnessed some absolutely cracking love triangles over the years, and will likely to continue to for many years to come.

However, they're not all to die for, unfortunately. In certain cases, bad writing and implausible affairs have resulted in some shows jumping the shark entirely. These are some of TV's finest love triangles, and the ones that never should have happened.


The Good...

8. Ivy, Derek & Karen - Smash

NBC

The first episode of Smash appeared to hint at the possibility of a relationship between potential Marilyn Monroe star Karen Cartwright and stage director Derek Wills - something that became a reality further down the line. But things grew complicated when the other woman vying for the role of Marilyn, Ivy Lynn became romantically involved with Derek.

The on-stage tension between the two actresses was magnificent enough on its own, but throwing in a love triangle only proved to intensify the drama further, which made Karen and Ivy's musical numbers all the more powerful. Moreover, on a subtextual level, it gave both Ivy and Karen more to work with on stage, due to the fact that their own love lives were becoming as colourful as the real-life Marilyn Monroe.

A change in direction for the show's second season put an end to the triangle, as Derek chose to do the right thing and stand by Ivy, who was now carrying his child, which was the perfect conclusion to not only the show, but to this three-way rivalry.


7. Liz, Max & Tess - Roswell

Roswell Love Triangle
The WB

Waitress Liz Parker and Roswell's resident alien Max Evans were one of TV's first golden teen couples, and viewers couldn't get enough of their chemistry. Much of the Roswell's first season teased the audience with said chemistry, refusing to put Max and Liz together until rather late on. When the two characters finally did embrace their feelings, however, Max discovered himself being drawn to fellow alien Tess in a way that was more than sexual.

In an excellent twist, it was revealed that Tess was actually Max's alien soulmate, and he was destined to be with her, leaving Liz with no choice but to let him go. Of course, it wasn't that simple, as Max refused to let a little something like destiny stop him from being with his real one true love. Again, this storyline was expertly executed and led to what would become one of the greatest love triangles in television history.

The idea that destiny was stopping the two characters from being together was genius, and it added a whole other level to their romance - something akin to Romeo and Juliet. They became star-crossed lovers, fighting to hold onto their forbidden romance.


6. Quinn, Finn & Rachel - Glee

Glee Rachel Finn Quinn
Fox

Glee saw many love triangles over the course of its six-season run, but none were able to live up to the original trio of Rachel, Finn and Quinn. Perhaps what made this storyline stick in our minds was the fact that Finn and Quinn were, on the outside, the perfect high school couple, but on the inside, they were both just pretending. He was the jock that every girl wanted to be with, and she was the cheerleader that every girl wanted to be. But when Rachel came into Finn's life, it unlocked a part of him that he'd kept hidden - she saw the real Finn, not the socially popular persona that he put on in front of his friends.

Finn had to make a choice: to stay with Quinn and maintain his social reputation, or give in to his true feelings and be with Rachel. Every great TV series needs a bit of conflict (when it's internal it's even better) and this love triangle was full of it. Having said that, it was also one of those rare occasions where we all knew which girl Finn should choose. It was always going to be Rachel.

For some odd reason though, the musical dramedy revisited this storyline in the second season of the show - after it had already been wrapped up -and this time around it wasn't handled as well, and felt repetitive.


5. Luke, June & Nick - The Handmaid's Tale

Hulu

June Osbourne has lived two completely different lives, which is perhaps the reason why this love triangle works so well. The first life was full of love and happiness, where she was cherished by her husband Luke, and their daughter Hannah. The second life is full of terror, as she is enslaved in a totalitarian society, and raped repeatedly for the purpose of giving her commander a child. In this second life, she is trapped and alone, but soon develops feelings for Commander Waterford's driver, Nick.

At first, we're rooting for June and Nick, but when June discovers that Luke is alive and well, things grow complicated. In spite of her dystopian circumstances, the handmaid refuses to give up hope, praying that one day she'll be able to return to her former life. But if this ever becomes a reality, will her love for Nick be strong enough to endure a post-Gilead society, or will she be drawn back Luke?

This love triangle has been expertly executed, giving us a reason to root for both men, and June's internal conflict is absolutely glorious.


4. Dean, Rory & Jess - Gilmore Girls

Gilmore Girls Rory Jess Dean
The WB

The Rory/Dean/Jess storyline caused a stir during Gilmore Girls' initial run, and it became such a thing that people still debate on which of the guys Rory should be with to this day. Much like the earlier Roswell entry on this list, what made this love triangle stand out was the fact that Rory's two potential suitors couldn't have been more different from one another.

While both Jess and Dean were insanely attractive, Dean was the good-hearted guy that every resident of Stars Hollow adored, while Jess was the one-syllable-uttering bad boy, who rebelled against every adult in town.

Rory couldn't have found a more perfect first boyfriend in Dean, but as she continued to grow, she was experiencing other feelings, and found herself drawn to the resident bad boy. Again, the conflict here was excellently depicted, and we still feel sorry for Rory for having to make such a choice.


3. Stefan, Elena & Damon - The Vampire Diaries

Vampire Diaries
Warner Bros.

With Twilight still a popular film franchise at the time, vampire-centric love triangles were all the rage when The Vampire Diaries came along. However, the hit CW series had a much stronger love triangle at its core than Twilight ever did, which was only intensified by the fact that it was executed exceptionally.

Ask anyone who has watched The Vampire Diaries from the beginning. At the start, we were all team Stefan. Stefan was the kind, unassuming, non-blood-drinking vampire who stole Elena's heart, but when Stefan's attractive bad boy brother Damon turned up, our heads were turned. The clever writing on the show made it seem like Damon was never really an option for Elena, but eventually she succumbed to the darkness.

Perhaps the best thing about this particular love triangle is the fact that neither choice is really 'the right one'. Both men were perfect for Elena. Each satisfied a different part of her personality, and this is the type of internal conflict that makes love triangles all the more enjoyable - regardless of who we want our protagonist to end up with.


2. Meredith, Derek & Addison - Grey's Anatomy

Grey's Anatomy
ABC

The relationship between Meredith Grey and Derek Shepard was one of television's finest, and by the time the young intern had fallen madly in love with the neurosurgeon, the writers injected a little bit of competition into the mix when Derek's wife Addison turned up at their place of work. It was a perfect shock - especially because we had no idea Derek was still married. What made it even worse was the fact that he had never mentioned this fact to Meredith either, which created a whole other problem in itself. He'd lied to her.

The execution was superb, and Addison came along at just the right time to create trouble for the young lovers. But as Addison became a mainstay of the long-running hospital drama, viewers began to warm to her, realising that she wasn't the cold-hearted witch they'd all presumed her to be. As a result, viewers weren't sure who they wanted Derek to be with. But no matter how hard Derek tried to make things work with his wife, his love for Meredith just wouldn't go away. And, in typical Grey's fashion, things became even more complicated when Meredith started falling for her vet, Finn Dandridge.

Grey's Anatomy has seen many love triangles during its lengthy run, but none have been as memorable as the one that started it all. As TV love triangles go, Derek, Meredith and Addison was one of the greatest we've ever seen


1. Angel, Buffy & Spike - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy Angel Spike
Mutant Enemy

There was never really a question on which love triangle would receive top billing, was there? This one is the old dilemma that faithful TV viewers have long struggled with: who should Buffy Summers be with? Angel or Spike.

What's interesting about this love triangle is that it wasn't really a love triangle at all. It was simply two separate relationships that our protagonist had during two very different eras of her respective show. Angel was the broody vampire who stole Buffy's heart, while Spike was the rough vampire with no rules, who awoke something dark within her. But, in spite of the time that had passed between the two relationships, viewers were divided on who Buffy's soulmate truly was.

It was arguably the first love triangle that caused such a stir with television viewers, and it no doubt influenced the Twilight franchise and The Vampire Diaries - as well as many of television's other stories of forbidden love. She may have made several tough decisions over the years, but Buffy never had to choose between her two lovers. Just as well, because it would've been a tough choice. However, in the final episode of the hit series, Buffy did call Spike her champion, so perhaps this could be implying that Spike was her one true love?

Interestingly, Buffy actress Sarah Michelle Gellar doesn't seem to think so, as she recently confirmed in an interview with Entertainment Weekly that she was Team Angel, saying:

“There was something so beautiful to me about the Buffy and Angel story. I think that Spike understood a different part of who Buffy was and I think she needed to understand that and discover. But for me as Buffy, I think Angel.”

And now for the love triangles that should be forgotten...


The Bad...

3. Mickey, Ian & Trevor - Shameless (U.S.)

Shameless US
Showtime

The love triangle between Shameless regulars Ian, Mickey and newcomer Trevor didn't last long, and with good reason. The seventh season of the hit Showtime comedy-drama focused on Ian's budding relationship with Trevor, but things became complicated when Mickey escaped from prison.

The problem with this triangle is that it should've never happened. Sure, Ian and Trevor may make a nice couple, but they're isn't really any chemistry between the two characters. Mickey, on the other hand, was the love of Ian's life, and sparks would fly every time they were in the same room. It's also important to remember that the only reason the fan-favourite relationship was ended was because actor Noel Fisher departed the show.

Bringing Mickey back for a few episodes revitalised one of the show's less than stellar seasons, but Ian's relationship with Trevor relationship shouldn't have figured into the equation because, again, there is no passion between the two. As soon as Mickey came back, Trevor should've been dumped. It wasn't really a case of 'who will Ian choose?', it was more 'when will Ian break up with Trevor?'


2. Lana, Clark & Lois - Smallville

Smallville Clark Lois
The CW

Clark Kent may be destined to end up with Lois Lane in the Superman comic books, but it certainly didn't feel like this was the case in TV series Smallville. The WB show had all the components necessary to nail this, with both Tom Welling and Eric Durance proving to be the perfect actors to provide us with real-life iterations of the comic characters, but the execution of their relationship wasn't great, and the whole thing was overshadowed by Clark's first love, Lana Lang.

For years, the young farm boy was madly in love with Lana, and the feeling was mutual. But the writers made us wait many seasons before the pair would address their obvious chemistry. And when they did, their happiness was short-lived. The big problem was that the showrunners were obligated to make Clark fall in love with Lois, which proved difficult after they'd practically friend-zoned Lois in the fourth season.

But with the show nearing its conclusion, the creators had no other choice but to end Clark and Lana, in favour of Clark and Lois. However, the way in which the relationship was ended also proved problematic, as it was written into the narrative that Clark physically couldn't be near Lana because she had ingested Kryptonite. Therefore, it made it look like the future Superman was simply settling for Lois because he couldn't be with the woman he truly loved. Moreover, by this stage in the game, viewers had been championing Clark and Lana for years, so some were left disappointed when they couldn't be together.


1. Laurel, Oliver & Felicity - Arrow

The CW

While there are arguably more offending love triangles on this list, the thing that made this particular one was deplorable was its execution (or lack of). Before Arrow had even begun, avid comic readers were expecting to see lovers Green Arrow and Black Canary come to life on-screen. This iconic relationship was briefly explored in the first season of the show, but it was sidelined when Oliver Queen began to have feelings for Felicity Smoak.

Instead of building up what could've naturally been a wonderful love triangle with Oliver struggling to choose between Laurel (the woman he is destined to be with) and Felicity, Arrow's showrunner Marc Guggenheim decided that the show's protagonist would fall in love with Felicity and only Felicity - regardless of what the fans wanted or expected from the show. As a result, Laurel was left out in the cold.

Following the inception of 'Olicity', Arrow's standard started to rapidly decline, and before long it was more reminiscent of a daytime soap opera than a gritty superhero show. Laurel became a background character, and Katie Cassidy was horrifyingly under-utilised, before unfairly being written out of the show for no apartment reason - which again impacted the viewing figures.

Perhaps the main reason why this love triangle is at the top of this list is because it never really had the chance to become a love triangle. Poor execution ruined what could've been a wonderful storyline - and in many ways, ended up ruining the show.

What was your favourite TV love triangle? Tell us in the comment section below.


Contributor
Contributor

Stephen Patterson is an experienced writer and reviewer. He's also a TV addict.