8 Utterly Ridiculous TV Castings That Totally Rocked Anyway

Because if you thought Hal Wilkerson would make a good amoral drug lord, you're totally a liar.

The process of launching a television show is a very risky and expensive venture. Once things like lighting, sound, editing and everything in between are taken into account, it's not unheard of for the cost to exceed a million dollars per episode with no guarantee you'll ever see that investment again. And even with the best script or the flashiest CGI money can buy, the show's success is still heavily dependent on the strength of its characters and the actors who play them. This is the power of casting.

Producers and casting directors are responsible for finding someone who can embody a certain persona for what could be several years whilst consistently appealing to their intended audience, and once they've made their final decision there's no going back. As for the viewer, there are three typical behaviours the average person displays when browsing the cast list for a new show.The first is the nod of approval, usually for an actor they've seen or heard of before and have confidence in their ability to pull the role off. The second is the look of anticipation for someone they've never seen act but have probably heard good things about. This article focuses on the last one, the type of casting that leaves a face of intrigue or bewilderment on the reader because they, for whatever reason, cannot fathom the idea of them playing this sort of role on that type of show. Most of the actors in this list were unlikely to be first choice for casting, some may even have been expected to fail in their role, but every single one of them by luck or design have turned out to be an awesome choice and have had more than a positive impact on their respective shows. As per every discussion about television, this article is on red alert for SPOILERS and the list is in no particular order.

8. Lucy Liu As Joan Watson €“ Elementary

Whether in books, feature films or television shows, Dr. Watson €“ the sharpshooting, ex-military side-kick to Sherlock Holmes has existed for well over a hundred years and generally speaking, most adaptations have stuck pretty faithfully to the character blueprints laid down in novels like 'A Study In Scarlet' penned in the late 19th century. So when CBS announced they were casting Lucy Liu to fill the doctor's shoes for their brand new sleuth show Elementary, one can only imagine how that revelation played with Holmes traditionalists the world over. Naturally, the process of transforming a character from a white British male to an Asian American female demanded significant changes in their back story to accommodate the new circumstances. From where we left the honourable, upstanding soldier, in steps Joan Watson, the disgraced surgeon turned live-in sober companion to the irascible Sherlock while he solves crime and recovers from drug addiction in their Manhattan Brownstone apartment. I didn't know what to make of the decision to cast Lucy Liu as Watson at first. Historically I had always been against the idea of adaptations deviating from their predecessors in terms of characterisation or thematic content, but watching Elementary for a season and a half has completely changed my opinion on the matter. In this case the differences in style, tone and setting help distinguish it from the other versions, including its BBC counterpart and despite the physical differences between John and Joan, they are both competent, extremely patient and exhibit the warm personality traits essential to Watson's character, which is way more important than say, the colour of their skin. When two similar TV shows come out within a relatively short space of time it's only natural to compare them, and in this instance it's fair to say that 'Sherlock' has probably been the more successful venture so far. When all's said and done however, Lucy Liu's Watson added a dimension to the relationship between doctor and detective audiences have rarely seen before and breathed new life into an age old character.

7. Kate Mulgrew As Galina 'Red' Reznikov €“ Orange Is The New Black

Orange is The New Black was one of the most talked about new shows of 2013, and whenever a TV series receives so much hype I always make an effort to manage my expectations instead of bowing to the mass hysteria and being disappointed with the actual product. That said, if I had to make a list of all the things I expected of the first episode, witnessing Captain Janeway dish out cafeteria-style meals in a prison jumpsuit would certainly have been right at the bottom.

For the shamefully unaware among us Kate Mulgrew is famed for playing Captain Kathryn Janeway, the commanding officer of Starship USS Voyager in the fourth instalment of the Star Trek television franchise from 1995-2001. She will always be remembered for being one of the rare female leads in the sausage-fest that was 90's television, but playing such an influential role for so long makes the actress and character inextricably linked. We watched Janeway battle the Borg and guide her crew back to Federation space for seven seasons, so to see her go from that to getting shaken down by creepy prison guards twelve years later is mind-boggling to say the least.

When I first saw Mulgrew on Orange Is the New Black, I (perhaps erroneously) took it as a fall from grace after the height of her Star Trek years, which is exactly how Red, the once-respected business owner must've felt when she was forced to trade her freedom for communal showers. Like Janeway though, Red is fiercely intelligent, leads her prison faction with an iron fist and demands respect from all members of Lichfield Correctional Facility, including the staff.

When it comes to casting, employing a transgender actress and a Broadway veteran only for her to play mute for virtually the entire series shows that the team behind Orange is The New Black aren't averse to making some pretty ballsy decisions, and including Kate Mulgrew in that mix has been one of the many triumphs in a near faultless first season. There's a lot more to see from Red in series two, and I for one cannot wait to come along for the ride.


6. Ice T As Odafin 'Fin' Tutuola €“ Law & Order SVU

In the world of showbiz, it's not ridiculous or even wholly remarkable for a rapper to appear in a film or TV show. In fact, you'd probably find it more difficult to name one who hasn't tried acting at some stage in their career. Unfortunately (and more often than not) said rapper will go for roles that fit their public image, playing criminals or exaggerated versions of that constructed image that perpetuate negative stereotypes instead of challenging them. With all this in mind, if we consider the fact that Ice T, ex-member of the rap heavy metal group Bodycount and the brains behind the highly controversial song 'Cop Killer' has played Detective Odafin Tutuola of the New York Police Department's Special Victims Unit for close to fourteen years, the irony is too delicious to ignore. Law & Order Special Victims Unit is not my favourite show in the Dick Wolf police drama canon. Each episode contains way too much intensity and emotional fallout to fit into a very rigid forty minute schedule for my liking, which in turn causes many scenes to come across very stunted and undeveloped. Amidst the chaos of investigating sexually-based crimes though, Tutuola is the silent strength of the 16th precinct and goes about his business with a calm level-headedness. He doesn't let his personal feelings cloud his judgement and his partnership with Detective Munch adds a refreshing respite from the fractious, pressured relationship we frequently endured with Stabler and Benson. Ice T deserves praise for his work on Law & Order. He doesn't fall into the trap of playing the arrogant, aggressive cop who treats his suspects and the world around him with an air of brutality as one might expect, he adds maturity and a strong sense of justice to the cast. I'll never understand how the ability to speak words to a beat lends itself to playing deep and complicated characters, but if other rappers fancy trying their hand at this acting lark they'd do well to take notes.

5. Mike Henry As Cleveland Brown- Family Guy/The Cleveland Show

Cleveland was the best character on Family Guy. He was the good natured voice of reason in his four-man band of alcoholics, paraplegics and sex offenders and probably suffered the most repercussions from Peter's hair-brained schemes compared to the rest of his friends. Seth MacFarlane must've thought he was onto a winner when he gave Cleveland his own spin-off, as did the rest of us when it finally aired back in 2009. It's recent cancellation however would suggest otherwise. I never really put much thought into what the real face behind Cleveland looked like. His deep, elongated speech pattern and that infectious laugh suits his character so well that I just assumed the actor would pretty much look like a carbon copy of the animation. It wasn't until I randomly watched a promotional video for The Cleveland Show during one of my aimless voyages around YouTube that I heard his voice attached to a white man from Richmond, Virginia. What's more, Mike Henry also provides the raspy sounds of Rallo Tubbs and various other bit parts like Consuela the housemaid in Family Guy. I like to think of myself as having a good ear for voices, but I can't hear any of Cleveland in Consuela or anything that sounds remotely like Rallo in Herbert the paedophile (another one of Henry's characters) which is a testament to the skills of the actor himself. Unfortunately, Mike Henry's vocal artistry still didn't stop The Cleveland Show from being an unoriginal 'Family Guy in blackface', to quote John Whorter of The New Republic. How it lasted four seasons is beyond me, but it's inevitable axing means that Cleveland and his family will be returning back to Quahog where they belong.

4. Patrick Stewart As Avery Bullock €“ American Dad

Patrick Stewart (OBE) is a legend of stage and screen. He's one of the greatest actors of his generation, has given stunning performances on every acting platform going and has been highly decorated for his services to drama over the course of his long career. So when we see the great Jean-Luc Picard and Charles Xavier in positions like this below in American Dad, the word mindf**k doesn't begin to cover it. The man in that clip is Avery Bullock, the slightly unhinged deputy director of the CIA's Langley Falls branch and Stan Smith's immediate superior. Unlike Cleveland Brown, Bullock was created to assume the likeness of his vocal artist for the sole purpose of making a respected Shakespearean actor the voice of the most surreal situations imaginable. From where we heard that voice recite some of the most dramatic moments ever written, we're now treated hearing it describe a fetish for overweight Asian women and sing cheesy 80s pop tunes on a regular basis. Bullock is arguably the most extreme character in the whole American Dad universe (second only to Roger of course); he treats his task force like children and comes up with the most insane plans to solve the simplest problems. One could easily be forgiven for finding personalities like Bullock's more over the top than humorous. Then again, it takes a special kind of person to hear the voice of Hamlet and Prospero send grown men to the 'quiet area' without milk and not find it the least bit funny. Taking a recurring role in a sitcom like American Dad shows that Patrick Stewart isn't too stuffy to add a bit of frivolity to his acting resume. And with a show littered with the highest number odd-balls you're likely to find in Western animation, Bullock is just the right amount of crazy to make it work.

3. Amanda Abbington As Mary Morstan €“ Sherlock

I don't think anyone was particularly surprised to see Mary Morstan in the main cast of Sherlock this year. She appears in several of the Conan Doyle mysteries as the doting wife to Watson, and Holmes' staged suicide in The Reichenbach Fall provided the perfect opportunity to work her into the BBC adaptation as a comforter to the grief-stricken doctor. Even with all the indications of her arrival, I was still interested to see how she would win over the quintessentially imprudent Sherlock Holmes where so many other potential Mrs Watsons failed. By the time 'A Sign of Three' ended however, it was abundantly clear she'd succeeded. Mary Morstan is perfect for Watson. She's intelligent, forward thinking and is one of the few people who could be in this 'You Me and Dupree' style three-way relationship without encroaching on the doctor-detective bromance. Of course, you didn't need a mind palace to see there was more to Mary than met the eye but I challenge anyone to claim they knew she'd turn out to be a reformed assassin before it came out in the series finale with a straight face. In hindsight, I'm not sure whether the biggest shock was learning some of the grizzly details in Mary's past or discovering that her actress Amanda Abbington is actually the real-life partner to Martin Freeman and they have two children together. Compared to the other castings on this list, using a real life couple to portray a romantic relationship on-screen makes sense on-paper. It explained why Freeman and Abbington looked so natural together and meant the production team could spend more time concentrating on weaving gritty, elaborate stories rather than having to waste time building the foundations of their courtship and subsequent marriage. And whilst it is understandable to find the idea of nepotism distasteful in those casting decisions, taking one look at Abbington's acting reel shows that she's paid her dues playing bit parts on the detective show circuit and is more than qualified to take on a role such as this. Overall, Mary Morstan was one of the highlights in a slower than usual season of Sherlock, and if she can get the approval of the great Holmes even after she put a bullet in his chest then she's most definitely a keeper.

2. Radiohead As Radiohead €“ South Park

Scott Tenorman is not a nice character. He conned a boy several years younger than him out of ten dollars by making him believe buying pubic hair would cause puberty, and then subjected the same defenceless child to multiple rounds of public humiliation for his attempts to reclaim his stolen possessions. If Eric Cartman were on trial I imagine the defence's opening statement would look something like this. However, despite all his of flaws, no jury in their right minds would ever agree that the punishment of making Tenorman unwittingly eat the remains of his dead parents quite matched his crimes. 'Scott Tenorman Must Die' is a landmark episode in the history of South Park. Not only did it set a new, dark precedent for the animated series, it also gave Radiohead the rare honour of playing themselves in a guest role on the show. Radiohead aren't known for being the most media-friendly band in existence, so to see them on them make an appearance in something that isn't an incredibly awkward news interview is one thing, but to then watch them mock a ninth grader as he mourns his dead parents in a twisted Titus Andronicus-esque turn of events is quite another. When you think about it, Radiohead's appearance on South Park isn't completely ridiculous €“ both the band and show often make a commentary on society and popular culture through their work. Furthermore, the group played their part in one of the most critically acclaimed episodes on South Park ever made. If we take nothing else from the experience, we at least know to never, ever p*ss Cartman off again.

1. Bryan Cranston As Walter White €“ Breaking Bad

I have a theory about Vince Gilligan's decision to cast Bryan Cranston as Walter White in Breaking Bad. According to the trivia page at IMDB, the bosses at AMC were reluctant to cast a well-known comic actor in a serious and at times incredibly brutal drama. Looking at it from their point of view, employing a man who was known as Hal the incompetent patriarch in Malcolm in The Middle for six years as a drug lord would seem to undermine the show's credibility before it even began. In this case though, I think Cranston's time on the sitcom actually helped to shape Walter White's characterisation in astounding ways. At the beginning of Breaking Bad there were many parallels between Hal Wilkerson and Walter White. Both were bread-winners to steadily growing families, stuck in relatively low level jobs and emitted a palpable sense of dissatisfaction with their lot in life. I'd even go so far to say that Walt is merely a future version of Hal, and while we never see the chemistry teacher make such a gormless expression, the photo to the right of the images above is practically interchangeable with both characters €“ save a pair of glasses and a moustache. So when we watch Walt approach Jesse for the first time or break into a warehouse to steal methylamine in season one, you can't help but picture Hal in the same situation. Similarly, the scene where he strangles Crazy 8 in episode three is so disturbing because we for all intents and purposes see a familiar character perform a very unfamiliar act. On top of this, Walt's gradual change in appearance is a fantastic marker for the moral decline and destruction of Hal, the ordinary well-meaning man to the selfish and manipulative Heisenberg. The man on the right of the screen would rather keep an extremely dangerous drug distributor hostage and feed him regularly to avoid taking his life. Conversely the man on the left would watch a woman choke to death, sign off on multiple murders and poison children just to fulfil his own self-serving agenda. It's difficult to judge whether or not Vince Gilligan had intended any of this when he made the case for Bryan Cranston to undertake the huge endeavour that was Breaking Bad. Knowingly or not, casting him in such a role undoubtedly had a hand in constructing what is one of, if not the greatest TV character of all time. Come on, who really thought Hal from Malcolm In The Middle would ransack the Emmys as the psychotic lead in a gritty, drug-focused drama? If you said you did, you're most certainly a liar.

Contributor
Contributor

A self-confessed Buffy fanatic with a penchant for sleuth shows, superheroes and anything with an infectious groove. I'm a Music and English Literature graduate with zany opinions on music, TV and film to unleash on anyone who will read them. Follow me on Twitter: swingking007