Agents Of SHIELD: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
After five years of adventures, which season stands as the show's best?
It's amazing what the television side of the Marvel Cinematic Universe has become. Here at the end of the franchise's first decade, we've met characters like Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist, and the Punisher through their own ongoing shows over on Netflix, watched the Runaways come together on Hulu, seen Agent Peggy Carter move from supporting character in the films to center stage of her own series, and Cloak & Dagger are set to make their big debut next week, but all of it started with one show: Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Back in 2013, Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. arrived in the wake of the mega-success of The Avengers and Iron Man 3, serving as the MCU's first foray into the world of television. Armed with the hook of the mystery behind Agent Phil Coulson's miraculous return to the land of the living and the promise of weekly Marvel content, the show was met with some massive expectations, and despite some growing pains through its first year, it has managed to keep rolling along, praised by critics and the loyal fanbase that has stuck with it for its solid storytelling, fantastic characters, and slick ability to continually reinvent itself.
With its fifth season having concluded last month and its sixth not set to arrive until summer of next year, let's take this time for a spoiler-filled look back through the journey so far, one that's crossed space and time, taken us into an alternate reality and much, much more.
5. Season 1
As just mentioned, Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. arrived in the fall of 2013 in the wake of the incredible success of The Avengers and Iron Man 3. It was the Marvel Cinematic Universe dipping its toe into the world of TV, an experimental, weekly slice of Marvel content meant to expand the franchise beyond the big screen.
For much of its run, the season had to spin its wheels, its episodic, case-of-the-week-type storytelling turning off a large number of viewers who wanted something more grandiose or, unfortunately, couldn't find merit in investing in something unless Iron Man turned up every week. Fortunately, though, when Captain America: The Winter Soldier arrived, the show was finally free to evolve into something else, blowing up its own concept to move into serialized storytelling through to its finale as HYDRA revealed itself, the Clairvoyant was exposed, and the comfortable team dynamic was forever changed when Grant Ward's true allegiances came to light, rewarding those who stuck by the show with some amazing hours of television.
The end of season one is one of the series' finest stretches and allowed for the show to continue reshaping itself, and though the first two-thirds of the season may hold the season overall back from being the show's best, it still did a lot right that needs to be acknowledged, like introducing a roster of fantastic supporting characters like John Garrett, Raina, the Koenigs, Deathlok, and Glenn Talbot into the mix to treating the circumstances around Coulson's return - Project TAHITI, that is - with respect to having fun with film characters like Nick Fury, Maria Hill, and Lady Sif to laying groundwork for future seasons with threads like the Gravitonium to the simple fact it brought this lovable gang, from the dynamic duo of FitzSimmons to the destined-for-greatness "Skye" to the badass that is Melinda May, into the MCU.
4. Season 3
The show's second season ended with the promise that the world would forever be changed thanks to mass-produced fish oil pills laced with Jiaying's Terrigen crystals making their way across the globe. Season three got to run with that concept, introducing a new generation of Inhumans and exploring how society responded to that fact, with groups like the government-created ATCU and the hate-mongering Watchdogs making their debut.
Within that, the show managed to introduce its own version of the Secret Warriors, explored the origins of the Inhuman race, brought familiar faces like Yo-Yo and Holden Radcliffe into the mix, and dove further into the different branches and ideologies of HYDRA, cleverly bringing Powers Boothe's character from The Avengers into the fold - naming him Gideon Malick in the process - to do so. Even further, we got some of the show's best episodes, like the Simmons-centric "4,722 Hours," the farewell to Bobbi Morse and Lance Hunter that was "Parting Shots," and "Maveth," which saw Coulson finally put Grant Ward down once and for all only for Hive to take over his body and arrive on Earth.
Unfortunately, once Hive enters the picture, the season's pacing slows down a bit too much to be perfect, the character's threat slightly diminished because his endgame takes a while to get going, but the wait turned out to be worth it, as the finale gave us a great sendoff for Hive and Lincoln Campbell before changing the whole game up once again before all was said and done, skipping ahead in time to reveal Daisy's new life as Quake and setting the stage for the LMD arc while wrapping up a narratively cluttered but otherwise solid season in great fashion.
3. Season 2
Following the show's late-stage reinvention of itself in the final stretch of its first season, the second season arrived with pretty high expectations that the show could continue holding strong. And rather than just rest on its laurels, the second season kicked things up a notch, using the HYDRA storyline as a launchpad for the introduction of something even bigger: Inhumans.
Along the way, characters like Bobbi, Hunter, Mack, and Lincoln made their debut, villains like Daniel Whitehall, Sunil Bakshi, Jiaying, and the scene-stealing Cal reared their heads, we lost Triplett, and Grant Ward descended further into madness as the selfish Raina was taken down a path of redemption. The season managed to give film characters like Peggy Carter, Sif, and Maria Hill more time to shine, slickly tied in with Avengers: Age of Ultron, and further solidified the show's masterful ability to pull off amazing twists, whether it be Daisy's status as an Inhuman or the rug pull that Agent Gonzales had good intentions all along and Jiaying was the real threat.
As for the team themselves, it was an incredibly solid year for each of them, from FitzSimmons' struggle to overcome what Grant Ward did to them at the end of season one to the revelation of why Melinda May was called "The Cavalry" to Bobbi and Hunter's true love for one another paralleling nicely with the Ward/Agent 33 arc to Daisy finding both answers about her past and a true identity in the present, which all dovetailed into a fantastic season finale that changed the game yet again and demonstrated the series' devotion to pushing itself into new territory.
2. Season 5
Following the Agents of HYDRA storyline at the end of the fourth season, which saw the team stuck in the alternate reality of the Framework for much of the arc, where could the show possibly go next? Turns out, into the future! Season five's first half saw the team sent into a future where the Earth had long been destroyed and the last remnants of both humanity and Inhumanity were under the thumb of the Kree, and the second half saw them arrive back in the present, desperate to find a way to prevent that future from happening.
Along the way, they encountered the evil Kree duo of Kasius and Sinara, Fitz and Simmons met their grandson, Deke, and discovered that HYDRA wasn't completely dead, with General Hale working with an alien Confederacy to "save" the Earth from a threat we all know too well now: Thanos. Longtime characters like Daniel Whitehall, Carl Creel, Deathlok, and Lane Hunter all made returns in different ways, the impact the Framework had on Fitz surfaced in the most terrible manner, and the long-awaited arrival of Graviton finally happened, with Glenn Talbot falling victim to further tragedy to become the season's ultimate villain.
And with Coulson's life hanging in the balance the closer the season came to a close, season five felt like - and was constructed to be - an end for the series in case it was not renewed, the show pulling out all the stops as the team's love for one another was put to the test. And though the season ultimately side-stepped being affected by Infinity War, its bittersweet ending, which saw Coulson and May having left the team to spend his final days together and the team setting out to find the frozen Fitz, turned out to be just the finale the show deserved.
1. Season 4
Arguably no season reinvented the show as much as its fourth. From the outset, it felt darker and dangerous - helped by a shift back on the schedule to a later hour - and the show embraced its pod structure with three distinct but connected storytelling pods, with Ghost Rider taking center stage in the first, Aida coming to the forefront with the middle LMD arc, and the team's entrapment in the Framework serving as the core of the Agents of HYDRA story.
Aside from Robbie Reyes and the Spirit of Vengeance being brought to life spectacularly, Aida proved herself to be one of the series' greatest antagonists ever, Daisy finally took up the mantle of Quake, we got to see alternate reality versions of Trip and a good guy Grant Ward, Jeffrey "Patriot" Mace made his introduction (and heroic exit), and the group's time in the Framework challenged them in huge ways, from Mack's desire to stay behind just to be with his daughter causing friction between him and Yo-Yo to the unleashing of Fitz's darker nature leading to terrible, irreversible consequences to Holden Radcliffe coming to terms with his idea of "immortality."
In all ways, season four represents Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. at its best: Tight, surprising storytelling, a perpetual interest in continually challenging its characters, and the ability to redefine itself over and over again in ways that make sense, all of which is wrapped up in a package made of slick action and - most importantly - an abundance of heart, something that proves just why this show has continued to chug along without wearing out its welcome five years on.
Which season is your favourite? Let us know down in the comments.