Arrow: 10 Best Episodes So Far
You have failed this city.
Over the course of three seasons, Arrow has defied expectations. Thanks largely in part to its stunning action and likeable characters, the story of Oliver Queen’s vigilante quest to clean up his city has raised the bar for superhero TV shows as a whole.
Action-wise, Arrow has few equals. The show’s fight choreography is often incredible and more often then not, Oliver throwing down against a villain is the best part of the episode. What ultimately makes all of his arrow-shooting exciting, though, is that we care about the people doing the fighting. From Oliver to Team Arrow to his villains, so many of the characters have relatable, fleshed-out personalities that force us as viewers to be invested in their fates.
And while Arrow can scale down and nail the character moments, it’s also proven to have a massive scope. The fights have gotten bigger, the comic book references have gotten more plentiful and it’s even spawned an entire superhero TV universe.
Whether focused on a comic book antagonist, Oliver’s crowded personal life or his past on the island, Arrow is a routinely enjoyable show. With the new season premiering on October 7th, we look back at the episodes that made Arrow what it is today, and got us to come back every week for more.
10. Public Enemy (Season 3, Episode 18)
Written By: Marc Guggenheim & Wendy Mericle
Directed By: Dwight Little
In contrast to the excellent second half of Season 2, the latter part of Season 3 was perhaps the weakest Arrow has ever been, yet Public Enemy nearly pulled the show out of its rut. Perhaps that's because it was the first episode in a while where there was a palpable feeling of danger for Oliver.
With Ra’s al Ghul telling Detective Lance that Oliver is the Arrow, he quickly becomes hunted on every front. Lance is often the heart of the show so seeing him lead a manhunt against Oliver really speaks to how betrayed he felt.
But even though Paul Blackthorne killed every scene he was in, the episode really belongs to Roy. After spending a huge amount of time on the sidelines, it’s ultimately Roy who steps up to rescue Oliver, surrendering himself in the Arrow costume. Even before that climactic moment he grabbed the spotlight as he took charge of Team Arrow, escaped the cops with his patented parkour and even took out a League member.
On top of all that, the soap opera-like flashback involving Shado’s twin sister Mei was just poignant enough to make us look past how ridiculous it was. At least it was a nice change of pace from Oliver running back and forth through a market.
9. Unthinkable (Season 2, Episode 23)
Written By: Marc Guggenheim & Andrew Kreisberg
Directed By: John Behring
After so much incredible build-up to the Oliver vs. Slade fight, it culminated in Unthinkable with an all-out war for Starling City. Even the League of Assassins showed up, and the show has never felt more epic.
Amidst all of the action, there were still some great character moments. We got our first taste of Olicity and it felt great. Even if it was a fake-out it was still a moving scene between the two characters. Then there’s Oliver’s no-killing rule put into effect. It was a small thing throughout the fighting, but it marked the culmination of a year-long character arc.
But holy crap, that fight. Many of the episodes included in the list belong partly because of the strength of their action sequences, but nowhere is that more true than here. It’s hard to definitively call one fight scene the best of the series, but Oliver vs. Slade has the best claim to that title. Watching them seamlessly shift between past and present offered something thrilling, but this was only elevated by the way we see Oliver’s growth in handling the beaten Slade each time.
Following the Season 1 finale, this episode had huge shoes to fill. It delivered, and capped off the strongest run in Arrow’s history with an immensely satisfying conclusion.
8. The Climb (Season 3, Episode 9)
Written By: Jake Coburn & Keto Shimizu
Directed By: Thor Freudenthal
Season 3 was largely a jumble of ideas that didn’t really land but The Climb marked a high point in which there still looked to be a lot of promise left. All of the build-up paid off with a thrilling fight sequence atop a mountain and a resolution to Sara's murder.
Before Sara’s murder was resolved, the suspects dwindled to the point where Thea seemed the most likely choice. It would have been more interesting had she done it of her own volition instead of being hypnotized, but it still created a welcome dilemma for Oliver to solve.
One of the other highlights of the episode was Maseo’s reveal in the present. Though not as moving as when Slade did it in Season 2, it was still a surprise to see Maseo again, especially aligned with the League of Assassins.
Ultimately, though, this episode owes its success to that final fight scene. Before he became bogged down by bad writing and poor motivations, Ra’s al Ghul was a nearly mythic figure in the Arrow universe. His power was that he was so mysterious and his subtle confirmation of his immortality only furthered that intrigue. More than that, he proved to severely overmatch Oliver in their fight, leading to a completely shocking conclusion with Oliver ‘dying.’
7. Deathstroke (Season 2, Episode 18)
Written By: Marc Guggenheim & Drew Z. Greenberg
Directed By: Guy Bee
Slade Wilson got plenty of spotlight during Season 2 but Deathstroke absolutely belongs to Manu Bennett. We’ve seen the mirakuru-addled Slade act like a madman in the past, but this marked the reveal of Slade as a cool and collected strategist. As a villain with infinite resources, a hugely-detailed master plan, and a series of surgical strikes, this episode proved that Slade was without a doubt the most formidable foe Oliver had ever faced.
Though the central conflict of the episode centres around Slade kidnapping Thea, it’s his smaller actions throughout that cement his status in Arrow lore. He ultimately lets Thea go, but not before revealing to her that her real father is Malcolm Merlyn. He then follows that up with informing Laurel that Oliver is the Arrow. With just a couple of words, Slade turned two of Oliver’s most trusted allies bitter towards him. He finishes this sequence off by freeing a bus full of convicts for his army.
Beyond Slade’s machinations, there’s other small moments of greatness peppered throughout. Isabel Rochev, now in control of Queen Consolidated, reveals herself as a villain, and the always entertaining Anatoly makes a fun inclusion in the past. Arrow doesn’t often devote this much time to its villains but in this instance, it’s good that it did.
6. The Brave And The Bold (Season 3, Episode 8)
Written By: Marc Guggenheim & Grainne Godfree
Directed By: Jesse Warn
A lot of the best episodes of Arrow often succeed because they further the larger plot of the season. That said, there’s still room for Oliver and company to have enjoyable filler episodes that don’t carry any long-term significance. The Brave And The Bold is perhaps the show’s finest one-off outing.
Acting as the second part of a crossover with The Flash, this was a much more fun and lighter hour for the show. Thanks in large part to the visiting cast members, we got to see the Arrow operate in a welcome new light, if only for an hour. The show's typical darkness still found a way to creep in, however, with all of Oliver’s sidekicks becoming keenly aware of what they’re risking by working with him.
At the core of the episode was Captain Boomerang, a ridiculous villain, even for the comics, but somehow the show made him awesome and threatening, all the while clinging to his theme of boomerangs. That fight scene alone inside of ARGUS is one of the series’ best.
With the crossover episodes looking to become a regular feature for the show, this bodes well for the series future since it offered a new take on the traditionally darker show and gave us an amazing one-time villain.
5. City of Blood (Season 2, Episode 21)
Written By: Holly Harold
Directed By: Michael Shultz
Though there were still two more episodes left, City Of Blood undoubtably marks the beginning of the end for Season 2. Ramping up towards Oliver’s final confrontation with Slade, this episode took the time to set the stage for their battle and remind us of the emotional stakes involved.
Following his mother’s gut-wrenching murder in the previous episode, Oliver is at his lowest, hiding out in a secondary facility and ready to turn himself over to Slade. The bad guys are winning and each of the antagonists looks like they are going to get what they want. Of course, with a little motivation, Oliver returns and the real fight begins as the episode ends, leading into the bombastic final two episodes of the season.
Before the conclusion, the episode still succeeds, with moments like Oliver talking to Sebastian Blood, telling him how crazy Slade is and watching Blood legitimately consider whether he should bail or not. Then there’s Felicity’s hilarious interrogation of one of Blood’s guards that completely subverts expectations. And finally, Laurel’s admission that she knows Oliver is the Arrow. Despite the thrills of the final two episodes, it's the more quiet moments here that cement City Of Blood as the best of the three.
4. Sacrifice (Season 1, Episode 23)
Written By: Marc Guggenheim & Andrew Kresiberg
Directed By: David Barrett
Arrow is at its best when it finds that sweet spot of being simultaneously silly and poignant. Since it’s a CW show, there’s often overwrought moments of drama, but when it reigns those in and provides an emotional payoff, the series is never better. Case in point, the season 1 finale, Sacrifice.
Every character had something important to do. Lance finally caved and joined up with Felicity to stop the earthquake device, Moira publicly exposed the Undertaking, and Malcolm revealed himself as a seriously terrifying megalomaniac.
Action-wise, the series had never been better. The final battle on the island cemented the scope of the series on a technical level. And in the present, the rooftop fight sequence between the two archers was visceral and proved that Oliver didn't need to be the best fighter to win.
For all his hard work though, Oliver couldn’t stop Malcolm, because his second, secret device goes off. This was a wonderfully surprising reveal that few assumed Arrow could pull off. This would lead to the best moment in an episode full of them, when Tommy sacrifices himself to save Laurel, and dies in Oliver’s arms.
Like any good finale, Sacrifice brought all of the season’s pertinent storylines to a satisfying close and set a bar that none of the show’s subsequent finales have matched.
3. The Promise (Season 2, Episode 15)
Written By: Jake Coburn & Ben Sokolowski
Directed By: Glen Winter
Acting as a spiritual successor to a Season 1 episode set fully in flashback, The Promise marked Slade’s return to Oliver’s life. In the present day, after fully revealing himself to Oliver in the cliffhanger ending of the previous episode, Slade used the hour to taunt Oliver in his own home. He framed the past narrative as he charmed Moira and Thea at the Queen Mansion, slowly ramping up the tension as Oliver’s allies file into the house over the episode.
Despite Slade’s jovial attitude, the flashbacks themselves mark the end of a year-long friendship between himself and Oliver. But before it all fell apart, we’re first treated to the real birth of the Arrow. We see just how far Oliver has come, and how disciplined he’s become during his time on the island. Then there’s the action-packed assault on the Amazo freighter, the reveal to Slade of how Shado really died, and a dream sequence inside of a flashback.
The episode was pure Arrow gold and just greatness all around. It delivered emotionally, kept us enthralled and built up the characters just as they were all about to go at it. Even with all of the episode’s successes, however, it could never match the original...
2. The Odyssey (Season 1, Episode 14)
Written By: Andrew Kreisberg & Marc Guggenheim
Directed By: John Behring
The first half of Season 1 had a lot of promise. It was ramping up the season-long mystery of the Undertaking while Oliver continued to find his footing as a vigilante. That said, it was often bogged down by familiar criminal-of-the-week scenarios. That all changed with The Odyssey.
Whereas the flashback scenes sometimes felt forced and unnecessary, The Odyssey embraced them and set nearly the entire episode on the island, five years earlier. Chronicling Oliver and Slade’s failed attempt to sneak aboard a supply plane, the episode managed to show the bond forged between the two characters. Not only did their pairing provide a healthy amount of action and entertainment, particularly the Slade vs Wintergreen fight, it would set the stage for a much larger emotional payoff in Season 2.
The episode also offered some memorable present day implications as Felicity proved her worth to Team Arrow. Additionally, her juxtaposition with the ultra-serious Diggle made for a lot of fun that would lead to a much larger role going forward.
This was the first really strong episode of the series. It made people take notice of a show they wanted to dismiss simply because of its network and source material, and was a sign of the quality to come down the road.
1. Three Ghosts (Season 2, Episode 9)
Written By: Geoff Johns & Ben Sokolowski
Directed By: John Behring
If you’ve been paying attention to this list, it’s fairly apparent that Season 2 was the high point of the series. Specifically, the back half of Season 2, which chronicled Oliver’s ongoing fight with Slade in past and present, was almost inarguably the best stretch of episode the series has yet to put together. And it was the midseason finale, Three Ghosts, which marked the beginning of that run.
Told in the vein of A Christmas Carol, Oliver experiences visits from Shado, Slade, and Tommy. The latter of those apparitions offered one of the most moving moments in the show’s history as Tommy urged Oliver to get up and fight as the hero he knew him to be. It was an emotional high for the series, one made all the more memorable by the insane reveal that followed it. Slade’s speech on vengeance as he revealed himself in the present day as the architect of Oliver’s misfortune may have been the single best scene in the entire series.
This episode showed what Arrow can be at its peak, offering emotional impact, thrilling action and a shocking twist to cap it all off. Oh and we see The Flash get his powers. What more could you want?
What are your favourite episodes of Arrow? Let us know in the comments.