Arrow: 6 Reasons Why Laurel's Death Was Actually A Good Thing
A little pruning never hurt the hedge.
From the very first episode of Season 4, Arrow began teasing an important death for the good guys. A flashforward in the premiere featured Oliver declaring vengeance against a mysterious "him" while shedding a few tears over a headstone.
It wasn't hard to figure out that the death had to be somebody major on the vigilante scene, and the only Flarrow-verse characters who would be ruled out were Oliver Queen, Barry Allen, and eventually Felicity Smoak. The person to die would have to be a big enough presence in Oliver's life to move him to tears and a quest for vengeance, but not so major a character that the show couldn't survive his or her death.
Well, it was seventeen episodes before we found out who was to die: the Black Canary herself. Laurel Lance was murdered by Damien Darhk, and the show will never be the same now that she is out of the picture. It's not entirely easy to imagine an Arrow without Laurel; now that Season 4 has come to an end and showed what Arrow will look like without her as a member of Team Arrow, however, it's safe to say that her death was objectively a good thing for Arrow as well as the other two shows in the Arrow universe on The CW.
Here are six reasons why her death - however sad it may have been - in Season 4 will work out for the greater good in Season 5 and beyond.
6. Too Many Death Fakeouts
Arrow developed the unfortunate habit over its first four seasons of not keeping dead characters dead. The Dark Archer - AKA Malcolm Merlyn - turned out not to be dead. Sara Lance comes back from the dead all the time. Slade was never dead. Ray and Roy only seemed dead. Oliver wasn't even dead after being skewered and kicked off a mountaintop. Thea was brought back from certain death thanks to a magical pool of resurrection juice. Andy Diggle hadn't actually been killed in action. The show had established a world in which "dying" doesn't necessarily mean being gone forever, and that was a status quo that completely ruined the stakes for a lot of the conflicts. The danger didn't feel as real if resurrection was a possibility.
Laurel's death was established right away as one that is sticking. Nyssa even confirmed to Quentin that there are no more known Lazarus Pits that could be used to bring her back, and magic was never seriously explored as an option for undoing her death. Arrow killed Laurel with no clear intention on bringing her back, and the stakes are nice and high for the good guys in Star City once more.
5. It Was A Bold Move
It was clear by Oliver's wrecked expression in the flashforward that the big death was going to be somebody reasonably close to him. Arrow ruled out Felicity as the possible death thanks to a second flashforward in the midseason premiere, so at least her name could be crossed off the candidate list before the six month mark.
One character that seemed likely to survive from the very beginning was Laurel Lance. As much as she hasn't been terribly instrumental to Oliver on Arrow over the years, she was the live action adaptation of legendary DC comic character Black Canary. Laurel seemed like she might be safe by virtue of her comic counterpart.
So, it was really a ballsy move for Arrow to ignore comic canon in order to kill off the woman who had taken on the mantle of the Black Canary. Arrow demonstrated that it's not afraid to move beyond the status quo of DC canon in order to tell its own version of the Green Arrow. Laurel's death was likely a big blow for comic Black Canary fans, but the show is after all called Arrow. Killing Laurel was a move that proved that the show is not afraid to be bold when the narrative calls for major change.
4. It Was A Payoff
After Season 4 spent seventeen episodes building up to the big death and dropping all kinds of foreshadowing, Arrow needed to follow through and kill off somebody who'd been around for a while.
The second half of Season 4 seemed to be leading up to a Lance ending up in the grave for Oliver to mourn, and Laurel really had to be the one to die if there was going to be a payoff on Damien Darhk's threats throughout the season. Darhk flat-out told Quentin that he'd kill Laurel if Quentin disobeyed. Quentin disobeyed, so Darhk killed Laurel. He just had the added benefit of killing off the Black Canary at the same time.
Laurel unfortunately didn't get the chance to go out in a blaze of glory, but part of the reason why her death worked for the overall narrative is that there was so little ceremony to it. Damien Darhk was a very bad guy, so he wasn't going to let her get out one last Canary Cry to free her friends. He murdered her in an ugly way that paid off on the build from the entire season to that point. It was a good beat of storytelling in a season that had gone off the rails with absurd baby mama drama, and it proved that Arrow could still follow through on big promises.
3. Team Arrow Was Too Big
Arrow started out in Season 1 as the story of one man hitting the streets to try and rid his city of crime. Oliver was a hero who occasionally required backup in the field from Diggle, while Felicity worked her techno magic from the Arrow Cave.
The three-person dynamic worked, and Arrow managed to incorporate Sara as a non-permanent member and Roy as a sidekick in Seasons 2 and 3 well enough. Season 4 featured a Team Arrow with five members, four of whom were masked fighters out in the field. The team was bloated with an overabundance of muscle that took the focus away from the Green Arrow on his own show, and turned too many of the formerly tight fight sequences into messy melees. Four field members was just too many. Somebody had to go.
Frankly, Laurel was the field member of Team Arrow that made the least sense. Oliver is a master of multiple disciplines after enduring half a decade of hell to be forged into a weapon, Digg has years and years of experience in addition to his sheer size, and Thea went through months of League of Assassins boot camp with Malcolm Merlyn that gave her some believable skills for her itty bitty frame. Laurel would have been useful more as a lawyer than a vigilante, but she could be spared in the field. Team Arrow needed to be pruned; Laurel made sense as the branch to be snipped.
2. Laurel Lifted Out
Team Arrow could have cut Laurel as a regular field member without Arrow necessarily killing her, but Arrow needed to kill somebody on Team Arrow for the sake of the payoff.
Laurel was the character whose death could have a large impact on the survivors in Season 4 but wouldn't cripple the team or the narrative in the long term. Arrow is the story of Oliver Queen's journey from poorly-coiffed pre-island Ollie to the fully-developed hero Green Arrow, and characters' importances must be determined by their relevance to Oliver. Of the five members of Team Arrow, Laurel had the least relevance to Oliver as of Season 4.
Felicity was the woman with whom Oliver had fallen madly in love. Thea was the little sister for whom Oliver had already proven he'd give up anything. Diggle was the big brother figure who served as an example to Oliver as a man who had learned to both be a hero and have a life. Laurel...was there. Her biggest connection to Oliver was via their relationship before the island and briefly after the island. Oliver has spent four seasons moving away from his past, and that has resulted in him moving away from Laurel as an essential figure in his life.
Team Arrow can function without her, and Laurel herself admitted that she isn't the love of Oliver's life. She lifts out, and her death won't destroy any necessary aspect of Oliver's life. Laurel was the right choice to die.
1. Death Needs To Matter In The Arrow-verse
Between Arrow, The Flash, and Legends of Tomorrow in The CW's DC universe, there are an awful lot of ways for characters to cross over from one show to the next. While a lot of those crossovers can be fun and overall harmless to all shows involved, it's essential that continuity is maintained between the series. Some of the crossovers that have happened ever since The Flash joined Arrow on The CW haven't made sense for one show or the other. Steps have needed to be taken in the name of continuity.
Laurel's death was established as a fixed point on all three series. Nyssa told Quentin on Arrow that there would be no Lazarus Pit shenanigans to bring her back. Rip Hunter told Sara on Legends that some tragedies happen in every timeline. Barry and Co. on The Flash met up with Laurel's Earth 2 doppelgänger and came to the clear realization that Earth 1 and Earth 2 counterparts are very much not interchangeable. All shows honored this major event to make the death matter in the entire Arrow-verse, and that bodes well for continuity in the future.
What did you think of the decision to kill off Laurel Lance? Share your thoughts down in the comments.