Arrow: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best
15. Malcolm Merlyn
If this list were to rank Malcolm Merlyn based on his Season 1 contributions alone, he would have been an instant Top 5. With that, let's focus on the positive.
As the Dark Archer (and the master manipulator behind The Undertaking), Merlyn was, without a doubt, one of the greatest villains to ever grace the Arrowverse with his presence. He was the first 'Big Bad' Oliver encountered during his vigilante escapades and proved to be a formidable adversary, worthy of carrying the first season. And his emotional motivations for doing so made him one of the show's most engaging characters.
Unfortunately, he remained part of the show after he had been 'killed' in the Season 1 finale and, although his reduced role in Season 2 was promising, he quickly became a parody of himself - popping up to either help Team Arrow or stab them in the back for absolutely no reason. And anytime things got remotely physical, he was defeated with ease.
As a result, he quickly became a pale, corny imitation of the terrifying Dark Archer that he once was.
14. John Diggle
John Diggle began his journey on Arrow as Oliver Queen's faithful bodyguard who, upon learning his secret, quickly became an ally in the fight against the crime of Starling City. And to this day, their bond remains one of the show's strongest aspects.
Aside from Oliver, Diggle has also enjoyed a number of strong storylines as he's fallen for Lyla, teamed with A.R.G.U.S. and even became one of the show's most valuable heroes as Spartan.
Unfortunately, he hasn't done anything of significance in a very long time. Yes, it hurts to admit it, but (aside from being a not-so-subtle tool for exposition) all he does is make the exact same mistakes over and over again, as the writers recycle previous material in a bid to keep him relevant. But the painful truth is that Diggle just hasn't been relevant in years.
A loyal and treasured member of Team Arrow and one of the show's longest-standing characters, but unless the writers can offer up anything new and interesting for him in the final season, he's nothing more than a relic kept around out of respect.
13. Nyssa Al Ghul
Nyssa Al Ghul may just be the best Arrow character to have never been a series regular - the reason being that she has always felt like a natural part of the show.
Showing up in the second season to track down her beloved Sara Lance, Nyssa went on to become a surprisingly enjoyable recurring addition to the team. Her temper made her a loose canon at times, but her honor made her a reliable ally - and she was one that Oliver and Team Arrow could call upon for help time and again.
Katrina Law brought an elegance to the role that few other deadly assassins possess and, of all the League of Assassins characters to show up over the years - and yes, that includes both Ra's and Talia Al Ghul - Nyssa was undoubtedly the best.
Arrow really could benefit from using her more than it actually does.
12. Adrian Chase
The fact that viewers were unable to tell whether Adrian Chase was a friend or foe to Oliver Queen was a testament to both the strength of the writing and to Josh Segarra's incredible performance.
As the D.A., Chase was an efficient ally who successfully managed to help Oliver out of some genuinely troublesome situations, but as Prometheus, he was something else entirely.
A scorned child of one of Oliver's first post-island victims, he intricately plotted his downfall by hiding in plain sight - befriending him, learning about him and ultimately getting close enough to betray him when he least expected it. This revenge-driven scheme worked (almost to perfection), and it's no surprise, really, given that it was a masterclass in how to be the perfect archenemy.
One of the Arrowverse's greatest villains, Prometheus was one of the few characters that was even more interesting when he wasn't wearing his costume. That being said, when he put it on, he was nothing short of terrifying.
11. Tommy Merlyn
Oliver Queen's best friend and lifelong playboy, Tommy Merlyn had a zest for life that very few people in Starling City could replicate. After all, he was young, he was rich and he was single - so why wouldn't he be happy? Well, the answer to that question is simply because he fell in love with a woman who he feared would never see him for anything other than the playboy that he once was.
His desire to prove to Laurel (and Oliver) that he was ready to grow up set him up for quite the character journey - a journey that he successfully completed. Although he was only a significant part of the show for one season, he underwent more development in that short space of time than most characters have gone through over the seven-season run.
As heartbreaking as it was to see Tommy leave us in the Season 1 finale, this early exit made him a rare breed of character, as he was one of the few who didn't stick around long enough to get tainted by the lacklustre later seasons.
10. Felicity Smoak
It's hard to imagine what Arrow would look like without Felicity Smoak. Though some would have preferred that she didn't exist, it's hard to deny how effective she was as a part of Team Arrow and, if anything, she added some much-needed levity to some of the darkest material.
A character that thrives in the supporting role, she became intolerable during the third and fourth (and occasionally, the fifth) seasons when the showrunners forced her to the forefront and turned her into Oliver Queen's love interest. And, unfortunately, that greatly hindered her from ever reaching her full potential.
That being said, when she was at her best, Felicity was quirky, adorable and badass - not to mention and an integral part of the team - and Emily Bett Rickards was an always enjoyable addition to the show.
It is hard to imagine what Arrow would look like without her, but we're going to find out in Season 8.
9. Thea Queen
Thea Queen was easily one of the best characters on Arrow. Unfortunately, that didn't prevent her from being one of the least-appreciated characters.
Oliver Queen's delinquent and rebellious sister eventually grew out of her vices as she fell in love and, in doing so, she matured into an fully-grown adult (before she was fully-grown) as she ran her own nightclub out of The Glades before going on to train with the League of Assassins and even become a superhero.
Willa Holland had a way of making even the most simple of lines feel like they carried a ton of weight and that is a talent that the show failed to utilise too many times. A character that consistently deserved so much better, it's a real shame that Thea's full potential was never realised. That said, we'll always have those first few seasons to appreciate just how strong of a character she truly was.
8. Sara Lance
A character that once started off as nothing more than Laurel Lance's cheating sister who was washed away to her death when she boarded the Queen's Gambit with Laurel's boyfriend ended up evolving into the Arrowverse's most badass warrior. Now if that ain't character development, nothing is.
Sara Lance was, in many ways, a device brought in to help her sister achieve her ultimate destiny and, for the most part, that worked as expected. What unexpectedly worked, however, was how well both the character and actress Caity Lotz slotted into the show.
Returning from the dead (twice), Sara managed to effortlessly transition into the well-developed Lance family drama. But it was her work as the badass Canary that made her stand out from the pack and, in doing so, paved the way for the character to become one of the most important in the Arrowverse.
While Sara kicks ass as the Captain of the Waverider in the off-the-wall environment of Legends of Tomorrow, she will always be more at home in her gritty roots of Star City.
7. Roy Harper
A character who many Starling City residents initially wrote off as nothing more than a street thug, Roy Harper was just a struggling teenager in The Glades with a moody disposition and a heart that was undoubtedly in the right place. With Thea Queen's help, he would evolve into a loving boyfriend who was able to pull himself out of his situation through employment and, in doing so, acquired the means to help the city in the way that he always wanted to - and he did so by The Arrow's side.
Like most of the show's earliest characters, Roy was an emotionally-tortured soul who often found himself going through more emotions than he could handle; he was flawed and scarred by his experiences, but becoming Arsenal gave him an outlet in which he could channel that pain into something better. To quote Oliver Queen, it allowed him to become "someone else... something else".
It's a real shame that Colton Haynes had to depart the show on a number of occasions, because he was one of Arrow's best performers, and Roy's personal struggles often grounded the show, and real, meaningful storylines like this was something that the middle seasons lacked a great deal of.
6. Quentin Lance
Few characters on TV have ever been put through the emotional trauma that the writers shovelled upon dear old Quentin Lance during his six seasons on the show. While not all of that emotional trauma was necessary, it did make him that much stronger of a character.
Sure, he wavered at times, with the multiple deaths of his daughters causing him to turn to alcohol, but he continued to overcome adversity, struggling through the pain in order to come out the other end, and in doing so, he made both of them (and us) very proud.
An honourable, morally integral but flawed individual, Quentin was undoubtedly one of the show's most human characters and, even as the show (and the wider Arrowverse) became more and more far-fetched, he remained that way, grounding the show with realism at a time when it was in serious need of some.
Moreover, his relationships with daughters Laurel and Sara (especially the former) were emotional highpoints for the show, as was his unorthodox kinship with Earth-2 Laurel. And no matter what was going on with the character, or how good or bad his storylines were, everything about him was immediately elevated by the acting prowess of the incomparable Paul Blackthorne.