Arrow: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best

25. Ben Turner

Arrow Bronze Tiger Ben Turner
The CW

Like the best kind of villains in the Arrowverse, Ben Turner a.k.a. Bronze Tiger also saw himself having quite the change of heart over the years. Originally little more than a heavy for hire, he formed alliances with China White before his incarceration led to him becoming an involuntary member of the Suicide Squad.

Perhaps the most integral moment of his journey came when he saved Lyla from death, as that single-handedly prepared him for a redemption storyline - one that we didn't see until the show's seventh season, when he helped Oliver defeat Ricardo Diaz in Slabside Penitentiary and subsequently helped him stop Emiko's attack on the city.

While a lot of his arc felt underdeveloped because it took place off-screen, it was still compelling at the best of times, and Michael Jai White is always incredibly convincing as the character.


24. Ricardo Diaz

Arrow Ricardo Diaz
The CW

Taking over from Cayden James as Big Bad halfway through the sixth season, Ricardo Diaz was revealed to have been the mastermind behind all of the manipulating that sent his predecessor on his revenge-driven scheme in the first place. While that would have been a lot more plausible if the character was portrayed as more than just one-dimensional thug in the first half, it didn't stop actor Kirk Acevedo from stealing the show in the second.

Orchestrating a city-wide takeover, Diaz grounded Arrow in the city-orientated realism that we hadn't seen from it in far too long and, when he was given time to breathe, he turned out to have a surprisingly deep (and compelling) backstory. His reign of terror would also result in one of the strongest back half of episodes the show had ever produced.

It's a darn shame that he was once again wasted in the seventh season.


23. Walter Steele

arrow walter steele
The CW

A solid addition to the first two seasons of Arrow that just gradually faded from existence, Walter Steele was a close friend of Robert Queen who essentially inherited his empire upon his disappearance.

Married to Moira and in charge of Queen Consolidated, there were a lot of reasons for Oliver (and the viewers) to dislike him, but in a rather surprising twist, there was no underlying motive here - Walter was an admirable man through and through and, although his temper came out from time-to-time, there wasn't a bad bone in his body.

Like much of the original line-up of supporting characters, Walter was a well fleshed-out asset to the show who unfortunately became less relevant as it grew more far-fetched - so much so that it's hard to imagine a place for him in the show that it has become.


22. William Clayton

Arrow William Clayton Then Now
The CW

After a long-teased introduction, William played a recurring role in the middle of Arrow's run, occasionally popping up whenever he was in danger. However, following the death of his mother on Lian Yu, he went on to play a much bigger role in Seasons 6 and 7.

The problem with the young version of William was that, for the most part, the writers struggled to treat him like a real character, which is a shame because Jack Moore delivered some great performances throughout his all-too brief run on the show. As a result, his presence was a plot device to cause and fuel conflict and, when it finally seemed like they had given him something stronger (presumably his struggles with his sexuality), he was written off the show altogether.

The adult version fared much better. Now played by Ben Lewis, William's role in the flash-forwards has provided the character with a long overdue meatier role - but the fact that the majority of his rich character journey took place off-screen still feels like a major missed opportunity.


21. Isabel Rochev

Summer Glau Arrow
Warner Bros.

Isabel Rochev's introduction in the second season of Arrow positioned the character as a rather intriguing one and, for the most part, that's exactly what she turned out to be. She was intentionally illusive and that made her all the more interesting, as Oliver (and us) wondered whether she could be trusted or not - the answer was, of course: No.

From staging an attempted hostile takeover of Queen Consolidated to shockingly aligning herself with Deathstroke, she managed to make every moment count during her 9-episode stint on the show and, in doing so, proved to be a rather formidable foe.

Though the writers could maybe have used her a little more, Summer Glau was nothing short of magnificent in the role and, together, they achieved everything they set out to do with the character.


20. Tatsu Yamashiro

arrow tatsu katana
The CW

One of Arrow's best limited uses of an iconic comic book character, Tatsu Yamashiro had a relatively major role in the show's third season. Reluctantly aiding Oliver as her husband Maseo worked alongside him in the flashback narrative, she grew rather fond of him and ended up becoming one of his closest allies throughout his battle with Ra's Al Ghul in the present.

A masked sword-wielding assassin by the name of Katana, her character journey met a tragic end when she had to use her sword to kill her League of Assassins-trained husband.

Of course she could have been used more here and there, but then again, had the writers taken a few missteps with her at some point down the line, she may not have remained the badass that we remember her as.


19. Amanda Waller

Amanda Waller Arrow
The CW

Ruthless, determined and damn near cold-blooded at times, Arrow's iteration of Amanda Waller shared a lot of similarities with her comic book counterpart in that she was always willing to do whatever it took to get the job done - irrespective of the cost.

The corrupt head of A.R.G.U.S., she had a part to play in the show from the very beginning - despite the fact that she wasn't officially introduced until the second season - and, also like the comic version, had a hand to play in assembling the Suicide Squad.

It goes without saying that, had she been given the chance, Cynthia Addai-Robinson could have been an even greater asset to the show than she already was. Unfortunately that was not the case. Another victim of Arrow's lacklustre fourth season, Waller (like Laurel Lance) deserved so much better than what she was given.


18. Dinah Drake

Arrow Dinah Drake
The CW

Introduced as a replacement Black Canary, Dinah Drake's arrival didn't go down all that well with fans, but that didn't stop her from winning many of them over. She was headstrong and stubborn, which made her unafraid to stand up to Oliver when she felt that she had to and, in a short space of time, she found her place on Team Arrow, bringing a whole new level of badassery to it as she did so.

However, in spite of the fact she would continue to be an asset through her affiliation with the SCPD, she has never quite received the full development that she needs - something that led to her becoming lost throughout Seasons 6 and 7, while the forced Team Arrow conflict in the former completely destroyed the majority of fans' interest in her.

A valuable member of Team Arrow, no doubt, but one that simply hasn't gotten the necessary attention to be the big time player she's portrayed as, and thus, she's always felt relatively underdeveloped. That, however, doesn't take anything away from Juliana Harkavy and her impressive acting chops.


17. Rene Ramirez

Arrow Rene Ramirez Wild Dog
The CW

Oliver's most outspoken Season 5 recruit, Rene Ramirez's journey on Arrow has been a bit like the character himself in that there has a been a lot of ups and downs.

A unique and original spin on the Wild Dog character from the comics, Rene boasts one of the most comic-accurate costumes in all of the Arrowverse (excluding that hideous short-lived armour) and, for the most part, he's been rather engaging.

Grounded by a strong performance from Rick Gonzalez, we have watched the character make a ton of mistakes only to learn from them and develop for the better. Though he's a little too confrontational at times (remember the "this doesn't change anything, hoss" debacle?), he has become a fixture of the modern iteration of Arrow and, quite frankly, it's hard to imagine what the show would look like without him.

His relationship with daughter Zoe is also incredibly touching.


16. Lyla Michaels

arrow lyla michaels
The CW

Lyla first made her presence felt on the show through her association with A.R.G.U.S. and, more importantly John Diggle. The ex-wife of Oliver Queen's best friend, she wasted no time making an impact on the show, enticing viewers with her badass attitutde and Team Arrow with her competence in the field. In doing so, she became one of Arrow's strongest (if not best) recurring characters.

Lyla may never have been a regular, but she's one of the few supporting characters who feels like they've been fully fleshed out. Now remarried to Diggle and the mother of baby John, she is one half of what is undoubtedly the show's healthiest relationship and has ascended through the ranks in her profession to become the Director of A.R.G.U.S.

When she appears on-screen, you know that all hell is about to break loose and, even after all these years, its still a pleasure to watch Audrey Marie Anderson do her thing.


In this post: 
Arrow
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.