Arrow Season 4: 20 Most Shocking Moments (So Far)

Looking back at some of the massive shockers from Season 4 so far.

Arrow's fourth season debuted in the second half of 2015 and left fans eagerly awaiting more as the show took off for its mid-season break. Fear not, though, for the show is set to return to screens imminently. Despite being promised a lighter, happier tone for Arrow, supposedly much more like the feel of The Flash, the Emerald Archer-centric series has continued to skulk in the shadows for the most part, even though the season opened with a happy-go-lucky Oliver Queen shacked up with Felicity Smoak as they spent their days jogging and perfecting omelettes. In amongst the first half of the season, we saw Oliver mourning at a mystery gravesite, there was the engagement of Ollie and Felicity, we saw appearances from Hawkgirl, Hawkman and Vandal Savage, characters returned from the dead, Thea Queen is massively unhinged, and there was a whole host of other traumas for the Master Bowman and his supporting cast of characters. So with anticipation high ahead of Season 4's return, it's time to take a look back and and refresh on the moments that have made us yell with excitement and gasp in sheer horror.

20. Oliver Queen, Shark Wrangler

It was a moment that lasted merely a few seconds, but it was a huge shocker to see Oliver Queen chased by a giant shark as he swam back to the shore of Lian Yu after a deep sea dive to the sunken Amazo during the Dark Waters episode. Sadly, we never actually got to see Ollie tackle the shark directly, but we saw one of the world€™s greatest predators creeping up on the underwater Queen before we then saw him back on land after what seemed to be a bit of a tussle. Oliver Queen is a man of many talents, and it seems that shark wrestling is just one of the Emerald Archer's many skills.

19. Bar Room Brawl

The lesson learnt here is simply don€™t offer to buy Thea Queen a drink. During Brotherhood, a creepy older guy hits on Thea whilst her other half takes a phone call. Not taking too kindly to his offer, the youngest of the Queen clan promptly proceeds to smash the guy€™s face on her table before dispatching him through a drinks fridge and then pummelling his face, until Alex manages to snap her out of her rage. Of course, this was largely down to Thea€™s unhinged post-Lazarus Pit state, but it was still a shocking moment nonetheless, firmly showing that this Thea Queen is very much a different one to what we€™d seen before.

18. Damien Darhk Makes His Mark

For a lot of shows with debuting villains, they take their time to introduce their new €˜big bads€™, having them lurking in the shadows and manipulating proceedings before eventually stepping forward and showing the world what an utter b*stard they are. Not Arrow (this year, at least). Only 7 minutes into this latest season we saw the arrival of this year€™s uber-rogue, Damien Darhk. Not only that, it wouldn€™t take long before we€™d get a showcase of just what Darhk could do. Not happy with merely killing his own men on a whim, he€™d even go on to tangle with the rebranded Green Arrow. And not happy with just tangling with the Master Bowman, Darhk would actually start to suck the very energy out of the body of his foe. It was an eye-opening arrival for Damien Darhk and one that marked him out as a major player in The CW€™s DC realm.

17. Return Of The Vigilante

Sure, it may not make for a great hero, but seeing Oliver Queen brutally beating the tar out of people makes for some awesome TV. We hadn€™t seen that side of the Emerald Archer for a little whole now, but it made an appearance during Dark Waters. During his initial venture into becoming Star(ling) City€™s protector, the man initially known as The Hood used uncompromising methods, often killing those who had failed his city. As Oliver has grown as a hero, he€™s also taken a back step when it comes to the whole killing thing. But when Felicity, Thea and Diggle are kidnapped by Damien Darhk, the gloves well and truly come off as the Master Bowman mercilessly destroys any and all thugs and Ghosts that he comes across in his attempt to get information on where his kidnapped Team Arrow cohorts are. Given how Season 4 of Arrow was supposedly going to be lighter in tone and more akin to The Flash in its feel, it was a shocker to see Oliver Queen return to his old ways.

16. Kill The Sex Offenders!

There had been murmurings of how much a Lazarus Pit dip takes out of someone, but Thea Queen€™s resurrection only served to further back up those claims. Having been killed by Ra€™s al Ghul in Season 3 and then brought back from the dead courtesy of a quick soak, Thea has what€™s classed as a €˜blood lust€™. Whilst that€™s messed up enough on its own €“ after all, it basically means Thea is cursed with having to kill somebody, anybody, in order to maintain her sanity €“ things take an even more shocking turn when Malcolm Merlyn turns up to offer Thea the names of countless paedophiles and sex offenders. Merlyn€™s logic is that these people won€™t be missed and deserved to die, and Thea would do well to off these sick puppies in order quench her thirst. To many, Merlyn certainly has a valid point, but Thea is still supposed to be doing the whole hero thing, meaning death to anyone is generally frowned upon. Either way, it was a major surprise to see Merlyn offer up a list of people for the youngest of the Queen clan to kill.

15. Oliver Queen Calls Out Damien Darhk

Of course, Oliver Queen knows who Damien Darhk is courtesy of having met the no-good Darhk whilst Ollie was under his Green Arrow guise, but in Darhk's mind Oliver and the Emerald Archer are two different people still at this stage of the game. As such, Darhk thinks nothing of threatening Oliver as he makes his run for Mayor of Star City. It€™s fair to say that Ollie doesn€™t let Darhk€™s intimidation get to him, instead focussing his attention on doing what is best for Star City. Then Darhk strikes. Hard. Sending a drone to unleash rounds of fire on a shoreline of kids. Not cool, Damien. Not cool at all. The big surprise here, though, is that rather than go after Darhk as the Green Arrow, Oliver takes to the local news station and publicly reveals what Damien is really up to and calls him out. It€™s a ballsy, some would say stupid, move and one that certainly came as a bit of a shock to many, including some of Team Arrow who maybe thought publicly naming and lambasting this super-powerful bad guy isn€™t necessarily the greatest of ideas.

14. Constantine€™s Appearance

Given Arrow€™s ever-expanding roster of characters and guest stars, you never know who€™s going to turn up next. As such, it was a pleasant surprise to many to see John Constantine appear in Season 4€™s fifth episode, Haunted. Matt Ryan did wonders as the titular lead in NBC€™s Constantine series, yet the show was cancelled after one season despite positive reactions from critics and fans alike. And with that cancellation, it was believed that was the last we€™d see of Ryan€™s Hellblazer. During the island flashbacks, we see Baron Reiter torturing an unknown man, but it€™s only when we hear the familiar Constantine score and the roguish faux scouse accent that we realise that it€™s John Constantine who is the latest person to take a trip to Lian Yu. Over the course of the episode, both in flashback form and in present day Star City, we€™d see Constantine and Oliver Queen become BFFs as Hellblazer plays a key role in helping to stabilise the mind of the resurrected Sara Lance.

13. Malcolm Merlyn, Green Arrow

Throughout the history of comic book characters, many a different person has taken on certain comic book mantles. For instance, Bruce Wayne, Dick Grayson, Azrael, and even Tim Drake have all taken on the moniker of Batman, whilst Steve Rogers, Bucky Barnes, Sam Wilson, and John Walker, amongst others, have all been Captain America at times. One of the biggest surprises of the first half of Arrow€™s fourth season was seeing uber-b*stard Malcolm Merlyn saving the day whilst dressed as the Green Arrow. Oliver Queen is powerless as Damien Darhk looks to gas Felicity, Thea and Diggle, and it€™s down to Merlyn and (finally proving herself useful) Laurel Lance to come to the rescue. Added to this, Malcolm made for a pretty badass Green Arrow and even held his own against Damien Darhk.

12. He€™s Aliiiiiiiiiiive!

When Season 3 came to a close, we saw Ray Palmer apparently blown up in his own office. As such, when this current season opened, we saw that Starling City had been renamed Star City in his honour and that Felicity Smoak had been given full control of Palmer Technologies. For all intents and purposes, Ray was most definitely as dead as dead can be€ only this is a show that specialises in bringing its characters back from the grave. With Ray, though, the shocker here wasn€™t even him coming back from the grave: it was that he hadn€™t actually died in the first place. He€™d finally managed to perfect the ability to shrink, a power he€™d been working on during the second half of Season 3, but had been captured and held hostage in miniature form by the nefarious Damien Darhk. Of course, Ray would manage to escape courtesy of Team Arrow before he disappeared off to find himself (also known as DC€™s Legends of Tomorrow). Regardless, him still being alive came as a big surprise to many, even if the promo work for Legends of Tomorrow had done its best to ruin that surprise.

11. Thea Queen Vs. Andy Diggle

Whereas some shocks are hard-hitting, emotional or upsetting, the Thea vs Andy fight was shocking in the way that nobody was expecting to see such a kick-ass fight scene in Brotherhood. With the apparently long-dead Andy Diggle alive and well, Team Arrow set out to capture John Diggle€™s older brother. It comes down to Thea being the one to take him down, but an almighty, super-cool fight takes place between Speedy and Andy. Arrow has delivered its fair share of memorable fight sequences over the years, but this one, directed by long-time stunt coordinator James Bamford, was perhaps its very best as Thea and Andy took part in a multi-floor battle that felt like Daredevil€™s famed hallway sequence or something from The Raid. https://youtu.be/mIRU13vdqhE

10. Thea€™s Immunity

From the moment Damien Darhk appeared mere minutes into the opening episode of Season 4, we quickly learned that this was a ridiculously powerful villain who had a penchant for the dramatic and thought nothing of offing his own men, cohorts or enemies at a moment€™s notice. Even Oliver Queen - the Green Arrow, the Emerald Archer, the Master Bowman, a man who has been around the block, been through hell, overcome near-impossible odds €“ finds himself within an inch of taking his final breath at the hands of Darhk. Simply put, Season 4€™s big bad had been positioned as a rogue that could not be beaten. Then Thea Queen happened. Brotherhood saw Thea involved in one of the greatest fight sequences of the show to date, bringing down Andy Diggle after a multi-storey battle. She then gets confronted by Damien Darhk, who unleashes his apparent €˜death grip€™ on her only to see it backfire. Due to Thea€™s dip in the Lazarus Pit, it appears that she is immune to Darhk€™s powers, causing the rogue€™s killer touch to backfire.

9. Savage Canary

Sure, Sara Lance was killed off during the opening episode of Season 3, but for anybody who€™d seen any of the promo work for DC€™s Legends of Tomorrow, we all knew that she was going to be brought back from the dead again. That resurrection would happen in Season 4€™s Restoration. If seeing Laurel Lance dig up the corpse of her sister or the subsequent Lazarus Pit dip weren€™t shocking enough, it was even more shocking and creepy to see what sort of Sara Lance was brought back from the dead. What we were given was an almost-feral Sara who Laurel ended up keeping in her basement, presumably feeding her fish heads, stale bread and curdled milk. It wouldn€™t take long before we€™d realise that this resurrected master assassin only had one intention in mind: to kill the person who had killed her, meaning Thea Queen was in her sights. Of course, all would be resolved courtesy of a timely John Constantine intervention, and Sara would head off into the sunset to clear her head before turning up in Legends of Tomorrow.

8. Laurel Pulls A Gun

Urgh, the horrible characterisation of Laurel Lance continues. Throughout Arrow€™s run to date, Laurel has been the most poorly written character on the show. Considering how vital Dinah Laurel Lance is in the comic book world, it€™s such a huge shame to see the character bastardised in this largely-excellent series. During Season 4, Laurel has done little of note, and what she has done has largely been clumsy, selfish or flat-out d*ckish. But in terms of the most shocking thing that she€™s done this season, if bringing her dead-and-buried sister back from the dead wasn€™t bad enough, if keeping her feral sister chained up her basement wasn€™t bad enough, she then proceeded to pull a gun on her when things maybe weren€™t working out all that great! Not only was this a shocking move on Laurel€™s part, it was also a ridiculous one that capped off a resurrection that came across as purely self-serving and plain stupid.

7. Working With The Devil

Arrow loves to start its seasons off with a bang, and Season 4 was no different. Not content with showcasing how powerful and merciless Damien Darhk can be, an even bigger shock was ahead at the end of the season€™s first episode when it was revealed that Quentin Lance was working alongside Darhk. We€™ve seen over the past four years how much disdain Lance has had towards Oliver Queen at times, but seeing him working with the man who wanted to destroy Star City was a massive twist. Of course, all would be smoothed out on that front after Ollie got wind of Lance€™s working relationship and wasted no time in confronting him about it in the way that only Oliver Queen could.

6. Hawkgirl Fluffs Her Lines

Most fans already knew for a fair while that Hawkman and Hawkgirl were to be a part of The CW€™s shared DC universe as they get set to make a big splash in Legends of Tomorrow, but we didn€™t know whether they would just debut in that show or make an appearance in either The Flash or Arrow first. As it happens, Kendra Saunders popped up earlier in The Flash€™s Season 2, but it was when she was trying to find her inner Hawkgirl that things got a little more complicated. During the Arrow half of the Arrow/Flash crossover event, Kendra is now finally on board with who she really is. Setting up a master plan involving Green Arrow, The Flash, Hawkman, Black Canary, Speedy, Diggle et al, all Kendra has to do is become Hawkgirl. Only she fluffs her lines at the most vital of moments, giving fans (and her fellow heroes) a major surprise. With Kendra bottling her big moment, her and Hawkman are quickly killed before the whole plans falls apart and the other heroes, not to mention Central City, are vaporised. Well, apart from Barry Allen, because he can run really, really, really fast.

5. Andy Diggle Is Still Alive

Ever since we first met John Diggle way back at the start of Arrow€™s run, one of the few constants in his life has been that his brother Andy was dead, killed by Deadshot at the request of H.I.V.E. So, when we found out in Brotherhood that Andy was still alive, it was a huge shock to both John and to the show€™s viewers. Whereas other characters have died and come back from the grave, it was revealed that Andy never actually died at all. In fact, he was essentially a crime lord of sorts rather than the war hero that we were all led to believe. The present-day Andy Diggle is a man with no remorse, no care, and not even any affection towards his wife, son, or his heartbroken brother. How things play out for the Diggle brothers going forward remains to be seen, but Andy€™s return was a huge curveball and one of the biggest shocks of the series to date when he was unmasked by John.

4. Oliver Queen, Father

Long-standing fans of Arrow have been waiting for more to come of the young pregnant girl who Moira Queen paid off a few years ago, and Season 4 has certainly seen that plot point flesh out significantly. Poor Samantha was given a cheque for $1 million from Moira to vanish from Star(ling) City and get rid of her baby. So, when we glimpsed her with a small child in Central City during an Oliver appearance in an earlier episode of The Flash, alarm bells were starting to ring. Just before Season 4 came to a mid-season close, though, we were given confirmation that Oliver Queen was indeed the father of young William and that Samantha never cashed that mega-bucks cheque. It was slightly creepy confirmation, mind, given how Ollie stole a strand of hair from William€™s hat and got Barry to analyse it€ but yay for fatherhood, right?! Of course, we€™ve seen how Oliver keeping his son a secret played out, with Felicity leaving him. Luckily for the Emerald Archer, Barry conveniently ended up going back in time and caused that error of judgement to be erased. Phew! It€™s just a shame that Ollie is seemingly letting the exact thing play out again now, though.

3. Grave Consequences

So, who exactly is it in the grave? That€™s the question we€™ve all been asking since the closing moments of Season 4€™s very first episode. The scene itself was a shocking one €“ a solitary, emotional Oliver Queen set 6 months in the future and stood over the grave of a loved one, only to be joined by a sorrowful speedster €“ and it was a moment that brought the season€™s debut episode to a crashing close. With this shocker, we€™re still yet to get the pay-off, and speculation is still rampant on just who it could be in the grave. Felicity, Thea, Diggle, Captain Lance, Samantha, William, and even Nyssa al Ghul have been suggested as biting the bullet in the future. The one that€™s missing from that list of potential corpses? Laurel Lance, which in itself is a downer given how poorly that character is written week to week.

2. Felicity€™s Mid-Season Fate

As soon as the first episode of Season 4 transitioned from a shot of an engagement ring to a gravesite, many quickly jumped ahead and predicted that fan-favourite Felicity Smoak would be the one who Oliver is seen mourning for. That could still very well prove to be the case, but the mid-season finale saw an even more shocking happening in regards to Miss Smoak. Whilst the first episode threw up Felicity as a possibility to bite the bullet, the mid-season finale saw Oliver€™s newly-crowned fiancé literally riddled with bullets after the limo escorting her and Ollie came under attack. Given that the two got engaged during the last 5 minutes of the mid-season finale, long-time fans of the show knew that it couldn€™t end on such a happy note, but it was still a jaw-dropper to see Felicity full of bullets and seemingly dying in Oliver€™s arms. Promo work suggests that Felicity may well survive this attack, but even then she€™s not totally ruled out of being the one housed in the grave that Oliver will be visiting in a few months€™ time.

1. Oliver Queen, Rest In Peace

They don€™t get much more shocking than killing off the titular character of a show€ well, forgetting the fact that the series killed off Oliver during last season€™s mid-season finale only to see him miraculously brought back from the brink after his first battle with Ra€™s al Ghul. But yeah, killing off a show€™s main character is serious business, and it was a huge shock to see Ollie bite the bullet during Season 4€™s Arrow portion of the crossover with The Flash. With the Emerald Archer and the Scarlet Speedster doing their best to put a stop to immortal, time-travelling rogue Vandal Savage, their efforts are futile and Oliver knows it. Sensing the end is near, he orders Barry to save himself. It was a mark of a wily veteran knowing that this was the end, and thus it was as we saw Oliver Queen essentially vaporised along with Felicity, Thea, Diggle, Laurel, Cisco, Caitlin and anybody else that happened to be in or around Central City. Of course, the fact that all of this was retconned thanks to Barry travelling back in time softened the blow a little, but at the time this happened it was a huge, huge shocker that nobody saw coming. Agree with this most shocking moments? Have some shockers of your own to look back on? Let us know in the comments.

Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.