Arrow Season 8 Review: 5 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Reset'
Arrow's final season gets even more trippy as another beloved character returns.
Contains spoilers from Arrow Season 8, Episode 6.
Oliver Queen may be attempting to save the multiverse from complete and utter devastation, but it would sure be a heck of a lot easier for him if he could trust the being he's supposed to be working with. But unfortunately, things on Arrow are never that simple, are they?
The Green Arrow has made it his mission to figure out if The Monitor (a.k.a. Mar Novu) is to be trusted and has now prepared a contingency plan by securing the means to produce some god-killing anti-matter just in case he should need it. The one drawback of that contingency plan, however, is the fact that being an all-powerful god, The Monitor was always aware of that plan. But thanks to Laurel Lance, Team Arrow is now aware that Novu has been working with Lyla Michaels - a revelation that subsequently led to unconsciousness for Team Arrow's core three.
But just when it looked like Arrow's final season couldn't get anymore jaw-dropping, its latest installment, 'Reset' has flipped the switch altogether - introducing a new status quo that was made all the more effective by the reintroduction of another familiar face from the past. The result was a thoroughly compelling character-driven narrative that brought closure to some of the show's most important storylines and steered this season in another unexpected direction.
First, the negatives...
Downs...
2. Rewriting The Reset
Much like we've seen with every episode of Arrow this season, 'Reset' was so strong that one of the only real drawbacks (if it can even be called that) was incredibly minor. Nonetheless, the repetitive nature of the episode made it rather obvious as it went on, so it's worth flagging up.
In a Groundhog Day-themed episode such as this, consistency is key and, for the most part, 'Reset' pulled it off really well. However, there were one or two moments that didn't fit with the logic we had come to know about this specific time-loop.
Take the replays of Oliver waking up on the couch for instance. This was a fixed moment that, unlike the rest in the alternate reality, couldn't be altered - simply because it was the beginning. It usually played out with Oliver waking up to the sound of the TV before William, Mia and Connor came barging in. It all happened rather abruptly as their dialogue inexplicably drowned out the sound of the TV in the background.
However, when Oliver woke up the final time, he did so incredibly slowly and actually took the time to turn off the TV with the remote and wait a couple of seconds before the kids stormed in. As he hadn't done anything to change the reality yet, this should have played out exactly as normal with the trio arriving immediately. And on that note, having him use the remote to turn the TV off actually drew attention to the fact that the device mysteriously silenced itself the first few times.
Again, not a big deal but an obvious one due to the repetition.
1. Taking Oliver By The Hand
"You've always been a man who needed to see things for himself." Lyla Michaels told Oliver at the end of his test and, in all honesty, she wasn't wrong. That said, Oliver has always been a man who needed to see things for himself... multiple times. Truth be told, the Emerald Archer has been written in such a way over the years that his own pig-headedness results in a failure to learn from his past or his mistakes - simply because he doesn't see things as they are. The worst part about it is that it wasn't always intentional and, in a way, this episode fed into that.
'Reset' was so well-orchestrated that we all found ourselves scratching our heads just as much as Oliver and Laurel, but as it went on, it grew a little frustrating. When Laurel was gifted with her chance to say goodbye to Quentin and also free herself of the burden of the guilt that has stayed with her since his death, it all became clear... to everyone except Oliver.
This resulted in some on-the-nose dialogue as Lyla literally told him that "the only way to win is to accept the inevitable" - dialogue that was immediately rendered ineffective when Oliver hilariously responded that he had no idea what that meant.
As a standalone test, 'Reset' was highly effective in making Oliver Queen see the truth about the inevitability of his death in the Crisis, but it almost encouraged some of the more frustrating elements of his character as it beat around the bush in its attempts to get him there.
Now, for the positives...
Ups...
5. Quentin Lance's Return
Before we delve into things, can we just talk for a moment about how great it was to have Paul Blackthorne back on the show? Yes, the Arrow vet returned in 'Reset' as Quentin Lance mysteriously returned from the dead and had us all - but none more so than Oliver and Laurel - questioning whether he was ever shot by Ricardo Diaz.
In a matter of seconds it was clear that Blackthorne - who hasn't been a regular part of the show since the Season 6 finale - hadn't lost a step. Slotting back in with ease, he shared some powerful scenes with both Katie Cassidy and Stephen Amell - which is hardly surprising given that he produced his best work when around those two.
Even if it was only for an episodic vision, having Quentin back just reminded us viewers of how much the show desperately missed him. A parental figure to Laurel, Oliver and just about everyone else, he had both a warmth and a well of wisdom that the show has lacked since - but those wonderful attributes were on full display in 'Reset'.
Welcome back Paul, we've missed you.
4. David Ramsey's Direction
Though John Diggle temporarily showed up throughout Oliver and Laurel's time-loop (playing rather conflicting roles), the character was off-screen for most of the episode - and for good reason, as actor David Ramsey spent this episode behind the camera instead.
As director, the Arrow veteran certainly did a remarkable job on all counts, utilising the 'out-there' concept of the time-loop to draw out some of the finest performances of the season from the actors involved - and then capturing it all with some beautifully-shot invasive close-ups.
This isn't Ramsey's first foray into directing - he previously directed episode 7.11 'Past Sins' which also happened to be an Oliver/Laurel centric offering - but it was a more vivid experience that also managed to maintain the character-driven elements from his first outing, highlighting that he is capable of bringing something new to an already-effective formula.
3. The Team We Always Needed
There was something cathartic about the fact that it was only Oliver Queen and Laurel Lance who found themselves trapped in a time-loop because it meant that we got an entire episode devoted to a team-up between Green Arrow and Black Canary. Though that shouldn't sound alien considering the duo are one of the most iconic couples in comic book history, Arrow's constant subversion of what the people actually wanted to see throughout its run prevented us from getting that.
Yes, Oliver and Laurel's mission in 'Reset' revolved around the pair learning something, but if we learned anything from the episode, it's that Arrow itself would have greatly benefitted from this pairing if it had stuck its course all those years ago. No team, no capers and no relationship drama, just two well-developed heroes attempting to get to the surprisingly grounded root of their problems.
Not only was it great to see the show's leading man Stephen Amell once again work with leading lady Katie Cassidy in such a one-on-one environment, the visual of Green Arrow and Black Canary working together on such an important mission was one that made the fans' comic book-loving hearts so happy.
This is what we should have had from the very beginning.
2. Laurel Says Goodbye
It seemed that no matter what Oliver and Laurel did, they were destined to watch their beloved Quentin Lance die over and over again. What they didn't know at the time was that this was exactly the point, as the pair had to endure it in order to free themselves from the burdens they were carrying around. A test from The Monitor, it was also a type of gift as it presented them with a form of closure - and for Laurel that closure came in the form of a tearful goodbye.
Ever since she took up the mantle of the Black Canary, Laurel has went out of her way to do the right thing - including fighting for an earth that isn't her's even when her own home was wiped out. But it wasn't always like that, as the former Black Siren once struggled to leave her villainous days in the past. The one person who always believed in her, however, was Quentin as he embraced the Earth-2 doppelganger of his daughter back in Season 6 and attempted to set her on the path of good.
Unfortunately, his death robbed him of the chance to see her for the hero she had become and it also left her without a chance to say goodbye. 'Reset' amended that, as the pair shared a heartfelt farewell before Quentin died (again) with Laurel tearfully thanking him for believing in her. "That's what dads do," he told her, forcing all of us to reach for the tissues.
We already touched upon how well Paul Blackthorne works with Katie Cassidy, but this was some of the pair's finest work yet, as their incredible performances made this closure we had been waiting on even more of a poignant moment.
1. Acceptance Of The Inevitable
Though Oliver's part of the narrative was occasionally frustrating, it was still an important development for the Emerald Archer. Upon realising that there was no possible way of saving Quentin in this alternate reality, he recognized the parallels between it and the fact that they couldn't save Quentin in the real world either. In essence, he was forced to accept the inevitability of death.
In that moment, everything became so much clearer for him. He had been attempting to subvert, outdo and even kill the idea of death itself, but the fact of the matter is that from the moment he signed up for the Crisis, there was no cheating death. And with that, he also realized that his attempts to dispose of The Monitor were also a subconscious form of denial for, mysterious as he is, Mar Novu's intention has always been to save the multiverse - not destroy it.
The pieces are starting to come together - and are making for very interesting character journeys while they're at it - but with Oliver and Laurel now experiencing the clarity the need, it seems that the multiverse stands a chance.
Whether or not the former can actually cheat death is irrelevant right now, because the narrative needs the gravity of his complete acceptance of it. In order for us to believe it, Oliver needed to - mission accomplished.
-
What did you make of 'Reset'? Tell us in the comment section below.
You'll Never Get 100% On This Arrowverse Quiz