Arrow Season 8 Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Present Tense'
The present and the future collide in one of Arrow's best ever episodes.
Contains spoilers for Arrow Season 8, Episode 4.
Arrow's final season has, much like the majority of the show's run, been a tale of two halves.
On one hand, we have Oliver Queen preparing for his final mission, as he sets out to save the multiverse with The Monitor's apparent guidance and assistance from John Diggle and Laurel Lance. However, the celestial being's behaviour has made the Green Arrow more vigilant than ever.
On the other hand, we have the flash-forward narrative which tells the story of Mia Smoak, William Clayton, Connor Hawke and the Canary Network set up by Laurel and Dinah Drake. Though it never carried the emotional weight that the primary narrative did, the cast elevated the material and proved themselves worthy of being the future's Team Arrow.
However, in a rather unexpected twist, last week's instalment somehow made both of those halves one, as an unknown force brought Oliver and Diggle's children to the present, leading to one of the most jaw-dropping cliffhangers in Arrow's seven-year history.
'Present Tense' picked up where that cliffhanger left off, successfully bringing the past and present together in what was yet another strong offering from what is shaping up to be one heck of a final season.
First, the negatives...
Downs...
2. Grant Wilson's Debut (Return)
It was a definite surprise to see Grant Wilson in charge of the Deathstroke gang. Having previously appeared in Star City's other dark future on Legends of Tomorrow - where he too led a Deathstroke army - it was undeniably nice to see Jamie Andrew Cutler back on the show. That being said, his official debut (given that this current timeline hasn't been wiped from existence) was somewhat underwhelming.
As he was nothing more than the ghoulish figurehead behind the birth of the Deathstrokes that would inevitably train JJ, he wasn't given a backstory, a goal or any kind of development whatsoever. And as he's Slade Wilson's son, this was rather disappointing.
Slade now knows of his other son's existence, so you would expect him to show up at some point (given that he was supposed to go off and look for him), right? If so, maybe we'll get more than what we got here.
1. Mia's Refusal To Share The Truth
When future Team Arrow showed up in the present, they were asked some questions by their fathers in a bid to understand where they came from and what actually happens in the future. However, ever the stubborn archer, Mia took it upon herself to hold the truth back (imploring William and Connor to do the same) and, instead, told them a somewhat fictionalized version of events that just so happened to omit Zoe's death and JJ's rise to villainy.
If this had stemmed from The Flash ideology of their fear of changing the future and erasing their own timeline from existence, then it would have been more than plausible, but Mia's refusal to allow her teammates to tell the truth - when someone as smart as William (who was also a major Flash fan) would have been able to figure out how it could change the future - resulted in it coming off as nothing more than an attempt to force some conflict.
The conflict was great, but heaping lies and deceit on top of it didn't really feel all that natural. Not telling Oliver, Diggle and Rene what happens was fair, but Mia's typically broody reasons (of lack thereof) felt just a little bit off.
Now, for the positives...
Ups...
7. Curtis' Return
Before we begin, let's just talk about how great it was to see Echo Kellum back as Curtis Holt.
The character was a mainstay on the show from Seasons 4 - 7 and, although he didn't always live up to his potential, it's hard to deny how great Kellum was in the role. Sure, Curtis may have stuck around for too long without really developing, but seeing him back in action in 'Present Tense' was a reminder of how great he could be when used sparingly.
Not only did his return add some much-needed comedy to the emotionally heavy episode (he's always been a gem in that department), it also made the episode feel even more important because we had such a large iteration of Team Arrow.
Hopefully we'll get to see him at least one more time before the show comes to an end.
6. Team Arrow: Next Gen Finally Feel Like A Part Of The Show
Ever since the flash-forward narrative began, William, Mia and Connor (and Zoe) have held their own and proven themselves as strong, effective characters. However, the narrative itself has often struggled with lack of screen-time and little plot progression - something that was really hindering this season's intriguing sibling rivalry between Connor and JJ.
Moving these characters into the present was a stroke of genius because now they have the focus they need to fully develop. No longer do they have to rush to reach a certain plot point before the show cuts back to someone (or something) else more important in the present.
We need to fully know these characters before the show comes to an end - especially if one of them is expected to co-lead a spin-off show - and now, they have to room to breathe which gives us a chance to do just that. And that, more than anything, may just be the best thing to come out of this move.
5. The New Dynamics
Watching 'Present Tense' was like watching a spin-off show in and of itself simply because of all the new dynamics that unfolded on our screens between characters who had never really interacted before.
Naturally, the most obvious of these new dynamics came when Oliver interacted with the adult versions of his children. The fact that he quickly bonded with William made for an interesting contrast to his relationship with his daughter, whom he struggled to connect with due to the fact that, in her timeline, she grew up without him. The same could be said for John and Connor, as the former struggled to comprehend the fact that he was destined to end up adopting a child he had just met a few days beforehand and the fact that this could lead to his biological son's descent into villainy.
But it wasn't just the parent/children interactions that stood out, as Mia ended up sharing quite a poignant scene with Laurel (with whom she had only interacted with once in the future scenes) as the latter used her own experience to inform her of how dark and lonely a path of revenge can be. And the Earth-2 Black Canary even shared her first scene with adult William too - as did Curtis.
You would think that, eight seasons in, Arrow would have exhausted all possibilities when it comes to its cast, but it was so refreshing to see so many new dynamics in an episode so late into its run. And it revitalized what is already shaping up to be a great season.
4. Dinah Comes Into Her Own
Juliana Harkavy may be a series regular this season, but we haven't really seen all that much of her yet. Now, that's obviously down to Oliver's intense travels (and we're only four episodes in!), but after a brief cameo in the conclusion of last week's instalment, she was back on our screens as the show's second Black Canary Dinah Drake.
Over the years, Dinah is a character that sometimes gets lost in the madness of the show's group storylines, but there is undeniably potential there. And in this week's episode, she was used incredibly well.
Being a peacekeeper and confidante, she was imperative in keeping Team Arrow together after they discovered the truth about Star City's dark future, and how it ultimately impacts their children. Speaking to Diggle, she inspired him to talk to his adopted son Connor, and chatting to best friend Rene, she inspired him to change the future.
This seems like it's building towards Dinah's crucial role in setting up the Canary Network and, by extension, Arrow spin-off (working title Green Arrow and the Canaries) - and if that ends up being anything like her role in this episode, it's safe to say we should expect better things for her going forward.
3. Setting Up The Future
"Why wait for a future we can start making now?"
That was the question that Rene Ramirez posed us with right before he launched his campaign to become mayor. Having learned that he was due to become a corrupt politician and that his daughter Zoe was destined to die, he vowed to change the future, refusing to let those events ever transpire.
'Present Tense' thrived on the arrival of the next generation of Team Arrow because they were able to warn their predecessors of what was to come simply by relaying what their world looked like. Were they meddling with time if they were transported there by a cosmic being? That remains to be seen, but it certainly looks like our characters are ready to start learning from their past to change their own future.
"Not all of the future was bad, right?" Laurel Lance reminded us. "Just do the good stuff." And with that, Rene kick-started his campaign, Diggle began training Connor and the Canaries began working towards their network - and the dark fate that awaits Star City in 2040 is wiped from existence (or so we hope).
2. William's Coming Out Scene
It goes without saying that 'Present Tense' was an episode that ran high on emotions. But the most striking of all its scenes was the one in which William reconnected with his father and, in the process, came out to him.
As he uttered those words ("I'm gay") and nervously waited for his father's reaction, Oliver's face gently formed into the warmest of smiles before confirming that he and Felicity had known all along.
One of the biggest complaints regarding young William's departure in Season 7 stemmed from the fact that we'd never get to see him open up to his father about who he was, but this scene corrected that. It was such a genuine moment between father and son - one that was both powerful and subtle - and both Ben Lewis and Stephen Amell captured the warmth of this scene beautifully.
1. The Monitor Continues To Confuse (Or Does He?)
This season has had quite an impressive track record when it comes to flooring us with cliffhangers, having successfully utilised its three first episodes to do just that. However, after destroying Earth-2, revealing that Lyla is in cahoots with The Monitor and even bringing the Star City 2040 kids to the present, how would Arrow manage to baffle and confound viewers in the closing moments of its fourth episode?
Well, they only went and had The Monitor confront Laurel and offer her a chance of resurrecting Earth-2. The catch? She had to betray Oliver Queen.
It's hard to know what Mar Novu's overall plan is here. He's been telling us all along that he wants to prevent the Crisis and yet is going out of his way to antagonise the one man that is supposed to be helping him. That being said, it's possible that this isn't The Monitor and that it's actually the Anti-Monitor (notice how his voice sounds vaguely different).
That's why this cliffhanger couldn't have come at a better time. Oliver is doubting The Monitor now, and as a result, so are we. What are his intentions when it comes to Laurel? Is he just testing her, or is this simply the Anti-Monitor attempting to destroy Team Arrow from the inside so that they can't prevent the Crisis? And it's clever to make us wonder if Laurel will betray the Green Arrow because, after all this time, the former Black Siren has finally found the redemption she's been looking for - will she risk it even if it's for all the right reasons?
Provided she doesn't, this is a genius story move. If she does, however, it risks pulling the show's storytelling apart. Nonetheless, it made for another great twist to close another great instalment.
-
What did you make of 'Present Tense'? Tell us in the comment section below.
Titans Quiz: How Well Do You Know Jason Todd?