Arrowverse: Every Pilot Ranked From Worst To Best

How does Batwoman stack up against the others?

arrowverse batwoman flash supergirl
DC

The CW's Arrowverse has been a part of our lives for nearly a decade now, and it's still very much a juggernaut.

Following the end of Smallville, few knew what the future would hold for superheroes on television, but the fact of the matter is that we didn't have to wait long to find out, as Arrow arrived on our screens the following year.

Its impressive level of success kickstarted a renaissance of superhero TV, as a ton of comic book-related shows were born - none more popular than its own spin-offs.

An era will officially end for the Arrowverse when the show that started it all bows out at the beginning of 2020, but in spite of that, the shared universe doesn't show any signs of slowing down, as The Flash, Supergirl, DC's Legends of Tomorrow and Batwoman will remain on our screens.

However, none of these shows would have succeeded without their pilot episodes, endearing millions of us to their worlds and characters, and allowing them to remain on the air to this day.

With that in mind, let's take a look back at all of the Arrowverse pilots so far (including the recently-aired Batwoman) and, while we're at it, rank them from worst to best.

5. Legends Of Tomorrow

Legends of Tomorrow Pilot
The CW

Legends of Tomorrow may be the Arrowverse's strongest show these days, but that wasn't always the case.

Now, it never quite reached the lows that some of its longer-running counterparts did, but it did struggle with a few issues of its own throughout its first season.

Legends' current strength lies in the fact that it knows exactly what kind of show it is and it embraces that. Season 1, however, was never quite sure of what it wanted to be, as it followed in the same dramatic footsteps as the likes of Arrow and The Flash - and it didn't really manage to find its footing. And some of that showed as early on as the two-part pilot.

Aside from that though, Legends' first offering was a solid way to kick the show off, as Rip Hunter gathered his crew of outcasts and misfits together for the very first time and it carefully explored some of the potential ways that these large personalities could clash over the course of the show.

Sure, its best days were still ahead of it, but this one was still, like the first season, an enjoyable offering.


4. Batwoman

Batwoman CW
The CW

The latest of the Arrowverse's shows, Batwoman made quite the impression on viewers with its first episode - mainly because it was a lot better than the controversial trailer suggested it was going to be. And it's easy to see why there was such appreciation for it.

Kate Kane's return to Gotham City proved to be a strong central narrative, as we quickly became attached to Kate herself, her journey towards herosim, and the supporting characters that surrounded her.

Furthermore, she looked the part (though it would have been nice to see her wear the red wig right away) and her battle with Alice felt like something off the big screen.

That's the problem with this pilot, however, as the fact that it exhibited film-like elements reminded us of the drawbacks of it being a TV episode.

There was more than enough story to fill out an hour or two of programming, which ultimately resulted in the episode feeling quite rushed. That aside, it told a solid story and turned the tide for Batwoman, showing that unlike the trailer, the show has real promise.


3. Arrow

Arrow Season 1
The CW

The pilot that started it all, Arrow's premiere offering was a gritty retelling of the Green Arrow's origins that let us know exactly what we should expect from the first season.

It was undoubtedly a bold move taking such a light-hearted character and dousing him in post-Dark Knight realism, but it really worked as Stephen Amell's broody Oliver Queen instantly made an impression on viewers.

More than that, the character's arc made for an incredibly compelling focal point of the show, as viewers were equally eager to see if he'd work things out with his family and Laurel as they were to see him put on the green hood.

Anchored by strong performances from leading actors Stephen Amell and Katie Cassidy, the pilot was a love letter of sorts to the 2005 film Batman Begins as it saw The Hood tick the first of his targets off his list and, in the process, set an incredibly high standard for the series - a standard that it rarely ever matched again after Season 2.

Though the show unfortunately would multiple times throughout its third and fourth seasons, the Arrow pilot did not fail its fans.


2. The Flash

The flash
DC

Being the first Arrowverse spin-off series and following in the footsteps of Arrow, which at the time had just finished its second near-perfect season in a row, there was a lot of pressure on The Flash to succeed - especially when you factor in the unnecessary criticism from those who didn't think Grant Gustin was the right choice for the titular role.

However, The Flash's pilot didn't just exceed expectations, silence critics and bring the Scarlet Speedster back to TV, it excelled in its own right - proving that every risk the producers had taken to make this show happen had indeed paid off.

What made the episode work was that it was nothing like Arrow. Sure, it borrowed a few structural cues here and there, but it had its own unique light-hearted tone that really set it apart. That tone allowed the family-centric storyline to thrive, as an ever-hopeful and kind Barry Allen became the impossible and, in doing so, decided to use his gifts to help those around him.

The writing was strong, the emotions were high and special tornado effects were movie-worthy. But the one thing that made this work more than any of that, was Grant Gustin's infectious performance - as the young actor portrayed Barry like the always-fighting underdog that we could root for. And root for him we did - something we're still doing five seasons later.

The Flash's first season set a new standard for the Arrowverse - one that has never been remotely equaled since - and it all started with this phenomenal pilot.


1. Supergirl

Supergirl TV Show
CBS

Supergirl's pilot episode had two added advantages in the fact that it was filmed for a bigger network (CBS) and that its titular character was directly related to one of DC's two most popular superheroes (Superman).

Those two advantages ended up paying off a great deal, because the show made a debut so triumphant, so larger-than-life and so inspiring that it felt often felt like we were watching one of the classic Superman films unfold before our eyes.

Focusing on Kara Zor-El's attempts to follow in her cousin's footsteps and embrace her Kryptonian legacy, the pilot told the story of how one woman quickly put it all on the line to become the hero that National City (and, by extension, the world) desperately craved. And it managed to do so without falling under the shadow of Superman or the issues surrounding his lack of appearances - as the network clearly wasn't allowed to use him.

With an exceptional leading performance from Melissa Benoist, an incredibly strong supporting cast - not-to-mention an exhilarating turn from the incomparable Calista Flockhart as Cat Grant - plus a heavy focus on family.

Supergirl's uplifting pilot made wise use of its limited time to tell the story it set out to and in the process, managed to make a 40-minute TV episode feel like a full-length movie.

--

Which Arrowverse pilot was your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below!


You'll Never Get 100% On This Arrowverse Quiz

Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

1. According To The Reverse-Flash, What Age Does Oliver Queen Live To Be?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.