Arrowverse: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
29 seasons of unforgettable action, but how do they stack up to each other?
The CW's Arrowverse has experienced quite the success over the years. Originally just one show in 2012, the popularity of Arrow saw it expand into a multiverse of possibilities.
The Flash joined the ranks in 2014, before Supergirl arrived on CBS the following year. After that, a direct spin-off joined the party in DC's Legends of Tomorrow, paving the way for the first major crossover between the four. And, following that, Black Lighting - another offshoot - showed up on our screens in 2018 before official spin-off Batwoman made its presence felt in 2019.
Crisis On Infinite Earths officially brought them all together on Earth-Prime, while also welcoming new arrival Stargirl into the new multiverse.
Yes, the Arrowverse has dominated TV for almost a decade now, and with a new arrival (hopefully two) on the way next year, it shows no signs of stopping.
It may not return in its usual Fall slots this year, but that means we have time to reflect on the journey so far. With that in mind, let's revisit all of the Arrowverse's seasons and, while we're at it, rank them.
29. Arrow Season 4
The season that many believed killed Arrow isn't any better upon reflection. Though it starts strong, it zig-zags its way through a gimmicky grave mystery before plummeting into unwatchable territory.
We'd never realise the brilliance that Damien Darhk would later be capable of because here the character is so corny and one-dimensional that it's hard to take him seriously. He was also too overpowered for a show like Arrow and his mysticism undermined everything it was.
You know what else undermined the show's identity? Oliver and Felicity's melodrama as the latter became an intolerable caricature of what she used to be. And killing off Black Canary was an unforgivable decision that rightfully turned comic book fans against it.
28. The Flash Season 4
The Flash also struggled in its fourth year. Though still miles ahead of the previous entry, it just couldn't find its footing because a host of conveniences hindered what was nearly a great storyline.
All the potential in the world and a fantastic performance from Neil Sandilands wasn't able to get things in gear as The Thinker's master plan was one big plot device that produced multiple villain-of-the-week episodes - none of which had the magic of the previous standalone adventures.
The sidelining of Kid Flash was also very disappointing and the new corny tone made everything feel that much cheesier.
27. The Flash Season 5
Things certainly improved in The Flash's fifth season but that couldn't prevent it from falling victim to similar pitfalls. Nora West-Allen's introduction livened things up, but it wasn't long before her arc started going round in circles as she proceeded to make the same mistakes over and over again.
Moreover, Cicada was an underwhelming villain. The writers tried humanising him and it worked to an extent, but whenever he showed up in costume, he'd mumble a few "this ends nooooowww"s before popping off everytime something went wrong. And Team Flash kept allowing it to happen.
That said, it thrived whenever it leaned on Reverse-Flash and, because of this, it offered up one of its very best finales.
26. Arrow Season 3
The season in which the cracks began to show, Arrow's third offering was a mixed bag as it devolved into a diluted Batman story that got too caught up in the melodrama along the way.
Ra's Al Ghul had promise as a villain, but the Batman similarities and the execution of his 'be-my-successor-or-else' tantrums undercut the story they were attempting to tell. Yes, it made for some fantastic episodes but there were simply too many of them to play with and not enough story to spread out. And to top it all off, this is where Felicity's evolution into the self-centred monster she became in Season 4 really began.
In spite of all that, the Starling City trilogy that follows the midseason premiere is bloody fantastic.
25. Supergirl Season 5
A new suit, new storyline and dramatic change to the status quo all presented the Supergirl writers with a solid foundation to follow in Season 4's strong footsteps. Unfortunately, Season 5 ran out of steam pretty quickly.
Leviathan were such vanilla antagonists that the show needed to rely on Lex Luthor once more but even then it wasn't long before things fell into the same old cycle. And speaking of the same-old-cycle, Lena Luthor's mind-numbing I'm-not-the-villain-but-hey-let's-act-like-the-villain shtick was long past its sell-by date.
It's by no means the worst the Arrowverse has to offer, but it is a flat offering that abandons subplots because Crisis, struggles to juggle all of its characters and relies on the tired old Kara/Lena conflict that the show would be much better off without.
24. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow Season 1
Legends of Tomorrow may be one of the Arrowverse's most beloved offerings, but it didn't start off that way. The show that gave fan-favourite supporting characters something to do initially felt like little else than just that.
There was a central narrative there and it was well-executed as Rip Hunter's eclectic mix of time-traveling heroes and villains sought to stop Vandal Savage's reign of dominance over the timeline, but as a whole, the show did struggle to stand out in a crowded landscape of fantasy shows.
It's not as bad as some would have you believe and there are plenty flashes of brilliance throughout - flashes that the writers thankfully capitalised on in the subsequent season.
23. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow Season 4
Legends is usually at its best when it tackles crazy sh*t with reckless abandon, but it ventured too far into outlandishness in Season 4.
Perhaps it was the murderous unicorn, the battles with Fairy Godmothers, or maybe it was just that nobody took anything seriously, but Legends' fourth excursion round the time-stream veered too far into hilarity at the expense of the drama.
But it was far from all bad. The subplot involving Nate and his father was full of wonderful moments that did their very best to ground a ridiculously off-the-wall season, John Constantine's full-time arrival was worth the wait and the brilliant 'Legends of To-Meow-Meow' is among the show's best episodes.
22. Supergirl Season 3
Had Supergirl Season 3 continued in the direction the first half was going, it may have been the show's best. The way Reign was introduced was so 'End of Days' that it instilled a genuine sense of dread and her apocalyptic arrival in the midseason finale was goosebump-inducing.
Everything that came after this was fine, but the execution felt off and that might be because it felt like the show was starting to rush through things without giving the developments time to sink in.
Kara's mother's alive? Sure. The love of her life just returns to the future with no goodbye moment? Yup.
None of what happened carried the emotional weight it was supposed to because it was executed in such a going-through-the-motions manner, undercutting the impact entirely.
21. The Flash Season 3
Some took issue with the fact that The Flash was too reliant on speedster villains in the early-going, but it's easy to see why when you look at some of what came next. That's not really the problem with Season 3 though. The problem was that Savitar was so powerful, so all-knowing and so unstoppable that it was impossible for him to be anybody but Barry - rendering the multiple 'Future Flash' teases redundant.
Furthermore, the time travel logic was patchy and inconsistent, Julian Albert felt like he lacked purpose after the first half and the relegation of Iris to damsel-in-distress was problematic.
In all fairness, there were some admittedly great episodes (the musical crossover with Supergirl is a classic), the birth of Killer Frost was well-executed and seeing The Flash team up with Kid-Flash, Jesse Quick and Jay Garrick was always a thrill.
20. Arrow Season 6
Despite starting off well, Arrow Season 6 got stuck on an contrived civil war between the original and new members of Team Arrow. To make matters worse, it implied the hypocritical originals were right and attempted to villainize the newbies by making them behave out-of-character.
It turned things around in the final third as the shift from Cayden James to Ricardo Diaz moved the series back to the gritty material it does best. Diaz's hostile takeover imbued it with a fire it lost early on in the season, providing the show with some of its darkest episodes.
There were issues, but this saved what would have been a lacklustre offering and handed the show one of its most consistent run of episodes. And the performances of Katie Cassidy and Kirk Acevedo elevated everything.