Batwoman Season 1 Premiere: 7 Ups & 3 Downs From 'Pilot'

Batwoman makes her presence felt with a surprisingly strong debut offering.

Batwoman CW
The CW

Contains spoilers for Batwoman Season 1, Episode 1.

The latest entry in The CW's ever-growing Arrowverse, Batwoman is a show that has had everyone talking long before it even came into existence.

From the character's introduction in last year's Elseworlds crossover to the hype surrounding her own spin-off series, anticipation was high to see Kate Kane come to life. And then one misguided trailer turned much of that positivity on its head and resulted in the show generating a different kind of buzz. Nonetheless, people were talking about Batwoman.

That brings us all the way to the series premiere, and the moment in which we get to see Kate Kane tell us her story in the way that the writers initially intended for her to, unfiltered and without the use of questionable marketing. And believe it or not, the result might surprise you.

Batwoman is an effectively dark entry in the Arrowverse franchise that takes cues from its predecessors and yet sets itself apart from them completely. It's a unique offering that has so much more to say than its trailers suggested and, with a little room to grow, all that potential could carry it to greatness.

First, the negatives...


Downs...

3. Dodgy CGI

Batwoman CGI
The CW

While most of the pilot episode utilises special effects rather well, there are a few occasionally spotty moments that just, well, take you out of those very moments - such as Batwoman's triumphant pose over Gotham (which was filmed from an angle that just didn't match the angle of the CGI background) or that time Kate stood in front of a heavy CGI cityscape.

Look, we all know that network TV shows just don't have the budget that blockbuster films do, so to expect state-of-the-art CGI from them would be ridiculous. That said, previous Arrowverse shows have all started off with pretty effective film-like pilot episodes.

Remember the tornado in The Flash's first episode? What about the way Supergirl saved that plane? The quality of special effects in the series premieres were on a different level than even the best of what these shows have to offer nowadays - and that is why fans expected the same consistently high quality from Batwoman.


2. Wig Snatched

Batwoman Arrowverse
The CW

As entertaining as it was watching Kate grow into her role as a hero, it was hard not to notice the absence of one of Batwoman’s most recognisable features: The iconic red wig.

During the character’s first ever live-action appearance in last year’s Elseworlds crossover (and all the subsequent promotional material for the show), she did indeed sport the wig – and it is undoubtedly a look that should be marvelled at – so you can see why some viewers were left feeling a little short-changed not to see the completed costume show up in the first episode.

Given that the writers were attempting to tell Batwoman’s origin story in a 40-minute window, you might think it wrong to criticise them for not rushing this aspect of her origins, but as the pilots of Arrow, The Flash and Supergirl all successfully gave their respective heroes their final (at the time) looks, why couldn’t Batwoman? After all, the costume was ready.

The timing, however, did present other, more important issues...


1. It Felt A Little Rushed

Batwoman Trailer
The CW

Due to all the negativity going into Batwoman, expectations were unfairly low for the pilot episode. But you know what? The writers really pulled it off and delivered a compelling origin story for Gotham's new saviour. The only problem was that Kate's story was so compelling that we, as viewers, wanted to see more of it.

Unfortunately, the episode was trying to fit an origin worthy of a film into a 40-minute TV episode, and there were times that it really showed. Characters reached conclusions far too quickly, arguments hit their boiling points too soon and anything that couldn't be shown had to be dealt with through Kate's narration.

In addition, the editing in parts was somewhat choppy and never fully gave the audience a chance to digest anything, as the whole thing moved along far too fast. And as a result, much of the great story remained below the surface, because that surface was brushing over things at an alarmingly quick rate.

It's not exactly fair to blame Batwoman itself on this as they had to stick to the conventions of network TV, but the pilot episode really could have done with another 10 minutes, as it would have allowed the story to breathe a little more.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

7. It's SO Much Better Than The Trailer

Batwoman Trailer
The CW

Once upon a time, all was going well for Batwoman. Ruby Rose's appearance in Elseworlds had gone down incredibly well and, as everything from the feel to the overall costume was so perfect, it had all of us excited to see the character on a weekly basis. And then the show's debut trailer changed everything.

With a focus on the less theatrical elements, a terrible choice of song and its utilization of those corny and nonsensical lines of dialogue as closing punchlines, it understandably rubbed a lot of people up the wrong way simply because this was not the comic-accurate Batwoman that was promised to us in the crossover.

Thankfully, the whole product was so much better than the trailer suggested it was going to be. With a strong story, proper music and just enough theatrics to leave us wanting more, the show is already beginning to feel like the Batwoman we hoped for.

The fact that one trailer can sour anticipation for one of the year's most anticipated shows really goes to show you how important marketing really is. Thankfully, the strength of the Pilot has allowed Batwoman to break free from its shadow once and for all and, in doing so, leave it in the rear view mirror.


6. It's Dark

Batwoman Batman suit
The CW

As each of the Arrowverse shows have their own unique tones, it was important that Batwoman establish its identity rather early on. It did just that as, in a single episode, it made it clear that The CW's shared universe was in for a new darker era.

Owing quite a lot to Arrow, the show's tone is somewhat of a mix between dark and fantastical, employing elements of the Emerald Archer's show (broody protagonist with a penchant for voiceover) while also plunging itself into its own brand of Bat-related darkness.

This makes for a compelling watch and, if nothing else, solidifies the show as both a visual marvel and a worthy successor to Arrow.

Batwoman was always destined to be dark and, for the most part, the pilot episode successfully made it happen.


5. The Music

Batwoman CW
The CW

Music is synonymous with superheroes. It's hard to think of Superman without hearing John Williams' classic score or Batman without one of Danny Elfman or Hans Zimmer's iconic themes playing in your head. Yep, every great hero needs great music.

Within the first few seconds of the Batwoman premiere, it was clear that she too had her theme. In fact, she had retained it from her appearance in Elseworlds, as a slight variation of the powerful and triumphant Blake Neely-composed theme played over the opening titles and then recurred throughout the episode.

There was a great majesty about that music that gave Batwoman an epic larger-than-life and almost mythical feel - which is why it was so infuriating to hear that generic pop track in the trailer. Thus, it goes without saying that it was a wise choice to bring it back for the series.

Every hero has a theme, and Batwoman has found hers. And what a goosebump-inducing theme it is.


4. Gotham City Looks Like Gotham City

Batwoman Gotham City
The CW

As unique as all of the Arrowverse shows are, the fact that all of them are filmed in Vancouver results in Star City, Central City and National City bearing more than a few similarities. There isn't anything that really sets them apart from each other - and that is something that robs them of a unique visual aesthetic.

Now, as unique visual aesthetics are what Gotham City is all about, it was imperative that Batwoman didn't fall into the same trap. And thankfully, the first few moments of the show highlighted that it had no intention of doing that.

The exterior shots are filmed on the streets of Chicago which instantly allows it to stand out from all the rest - presenting Gotham as a more unique city in a multiverse full of similar settings. Moreover, it utilises the same Wayne Enterprises building that Christopher Nolan used in his acclaimed Dark Knight trilogy - which was also filmed in Chicago.

Undoubtedly a nice way of setting Batwoman apart as a visually larger-than-life production, Gotham City has never looked better.


3. A Great Villain

Batwoman Alice
The CW

Even with the brilliant Rachel Skarsten in the role, there were initially concerns that Alice wouldn't be, well, crazy enough. The character is downright unhinged in the comics and has absolutely no qualms about sinking to the lowest of depths to achieve her goals - a bit like the Clown Prince Of Crime himself.

However, the trailer presented her as a more relaxed and less dangerous crime boss. While she is indeed all of those things in the show, she's also a lot more than the preview gave her credit for.

A highly active antagonist, she was fully involved in the pilot's narrative and, through her confusing Alice In Wonderland-themed dialogue, successfully managed to use her apparent brand of 'crazy' in a very intimidating fashion.

Every Bat-Family member needs a Joker to overcome, and Kate Kane has found her's in Alice. That said, the most interesting part of their relationship is the fact that the two may be more involved than the hero ever thought.


2. Ruby Rose's Performance

Batwoman Ruby Rose Kate Kane
The CW

The casting of Ruby Rose as Kate Kane was rather divisive, as some were thrilled at the idea of her taking on the mantle of Batwoman while others were dead set against it - claiming that her previous acting suggested she wasn't capable of bringing the character to life. Well, the Pilot certainly gave fans plenty of chances to see her in action and it's clear that those naysayers underestimated her potential.

We all knew that she looked badass, so that was the part she was always going to nail. And she did - whether walking down an eerie hallway in street clothes or spreading her wings on a skyscraper as Batwoman, Rose was committed to everything that she did and produced the perfect broody performance.

But the most striking of her offerings came in the flashback sequences (in which Kate lost Sophie to the Academy), as Rose's subtle performance was both perfectly in-line with her character and yet more emotional than we ever expected to see Kate so early on. And it worked in solidifying Sophie as a major part of the character's life.

Rose looks set to follow in the footsteps of the likes of Michael Keaton, Heath Ledger and even the Arrowverse's own Grant Gustin, as an unlikely performer who manages to silence the outraged critics with her strong performances.

Bravo Ruby, bravo.


1. Off To A Strong Start

Batwoman CW
The CW

In spite of the fact that the episode felt like a rushed film with a strong conclusion, the writers made it very clear that we are only just getting started - and after that episode, that is most definitely a good thing.

What made Batwoman's pilot episode work so well is how, despite the limited time, it managed to juggle a number of engaging family-driven storylines alongside the theatrics of it all. But more than that, it was so intricately plotted that every major story move seemed to impact the next.

Kate always wanted to be a Crow until Batwoman came along and now she's been given that opportunity and doesn't know what to do with it. She returned to save the love of her life, only to find out that she was married to someone else. And she always blamed Batman for her family's death, only to discover that he did all he could to save them - a discovery that eventually led her to take up his mantle... and even discover that Alice could be her long thought-to-be-dead sister Beth.

Even though some scenes felt a little truncated, the pilot was, for the most part, like a well-oiled machine that accomplished what it set out to do and, in the process, set the stage for what looks to be an incredibly interesting debut season.

-

What did you make of Batwoman's pilot episode? Tell us in the comment section below.


You'll Never Get 100% On This Arrowverse Quiz

Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

1. According To The Reverse-Flash, What Age Does Oliver Queen Live To Be?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.