Black Mirror: 6 Best & 6 Worst Inventions
If you held a mirror up to society, what would you want to see reflected?
Black Mirror exists to hold... I dunno, something shiny that slips my mind at the moment. Anyway, the show exists to hold whatever that shiny thing is up to humanity and the way we use technology, and ask three simple questions:
1) Are you sure you want to be doing that?
2) No, really, are you sure?
3) Have you thought through what could happen?
Sometimes the technology shown in the episodes is wonderous, something to aspire to in this world. It's a game-changer, either on a small and more personal level or, oftentimes, in wide-ranging ways that solve many of the problems that face society at the moment.
But then there are the times when the tech itself is terrifying. That can be as simple as something getting into the wrong hands (regularly, what is good in one episode is portrayed as bad in another, simply due to who is using it and for what) or because the technology itself has terrifying implications for our future.
Let's take a look at the 6 best and 6 worst...
12. BEST - Dating Simulations
They say there's someone out there for everyone and, with seven billion people on the planet, chances are they're right. But that doesn't make dating any easier. How do you know if you've found the person for you or if it's just someone close enough? How well will this person who seems perfect cope with the bad times if they come? Will they be there for you even when someone seemingly better comes along? A quagmire of what if questions can hold back even the best relationships with uncertainty.
Which is why Hang The DJ has such a good piece of technology. Using the same sort of soul copying technology shown in San Junipero and U.S.S Callister, versions of the people are linked up and put through multiple scenarios in a virtual world where they can date and come apart. Thousands upon thousands of different scenarios play out in a millisecond, as the dating application finds these two in the local area.
When the virtual version of the characters fight against the odds to stay together, these results are turned into a percentage match that really shows whether it's worth giving your time to this person across the bar.
11. WORST - Eye Tracking Ads
Fifteen Million Merits features one of the most horrifying ideas out there, and yet it's one that is closest to becoming a reality: eye-tracking adverts.
For decades, as soon as ads came on, we'd all head to the kitchen and put the kettle on, and the advertisers knew we were doing that, but they also knew that we didn't want to miss what we were watching. Those of us who lived alone would be back and forth in the kitchen doorway, watching the ads anyway. Those who didn't always left someone watching the adverts, ready to call out the iconic "It's on!" or, in more recent years, pause the programme when it came back. Advertisers didn't care that we weren't all watching so long as someone was, as that was part of the contract between us.
Fifteen Million Merits sees that contract broken. All content is ad-supported, skipping ads costs real money, and eye-tracking means you are forced to watch every single second of the woman you've idolised in her new porn career.
And all without a cup of coffee to wash it down.
10. BEST - Dynamo Power System
In the episode Fifteen Million Merits, people spend work shifts cycling, using dynamos to create power for the city and being paid merits for their work. Seemingly an idea out of the dystopian futures handbook, this actually makes a lot of sense and solves several problems that are fast making themselves known in the supposedly non-dystopian world we live in.
Now, this is obviously as climate-friendly as you can get, so that's a major problem solved with power generation. People are going to stay fit in this job too, so perhaps requiring everyone to take a day a week performing it may be a good idea. It's also a way to guarantee jobs in an increasingly automated future, as the power required to automate this process would cost more than the power produced. So, nobody is going to be out of a job under this system, no matter how under-qualified they are, even if the work itself is so mind-numbing that they need to spend some of their earned credits on ways to brighten it up.
I say bring this into primary schools and work up, beginning to add it to workplaces as those kids graduate, until the whole country is covered.
9. WORST - The Credit System
While Fifteen Million Merits (last one from this goldmine, I swear) offers a solution several problems of the world as we know it, it brings in quite a few of its own, and those are very much based in reality too. The world itself is monetised like a free-to-play video game, and not the kind that rely on gameplay to keep people coming back. This is a world where everything is out to make a profit from the people.
Those guys riding their bikes to power the country are forced to pay even if they want to look at a new scene while riding or simply to change their avatar representation in their lives. As mentioned earlier, they're forced to pay to skip adverts, but related content ads are everywhere (even on fruit vending machines). Every squeeze of toothpaste costs money as you use it.
And those looking to climb out of that trap take part in a gameshow where they risk being forced into a porn career just to get back to where they were. What would you risk to get out of poverty?
8. BEST - Social Media Ghosts
Be Right Back features a zombie apocaly... wait, that's not right. That would be silly. Be Right Back actually features ghosts. That's social media ghosts: AI versions of people built from all of their social media profiles.
That time you got in touch with a company to let them know you love their products more than life itself could well be the defining feature of your ghost's personality. That book you took a photo of next to a martini alongside the caption "Another Friday night in" may be all your ghost talks about, even though you never actually read the book and just watched Walking Dead reruns out of order while eating pizza. Oh, and seeing as you never posted about that pizza, your ghost will never mention it.
It sounds dark because it's so imperfect, especially when so many of us portray an unrealistic version of ourselves online, but that's the genius of this idea. Grief is a lot easier to handle when you're confronted with an imperfect version of what you're missing; all the arrogance and pretence that is masked by love, is now at the forefront and lets you slowly move on from your loss before it overwhelms you.
7. WORST - Torture Game Shows
White Bear sees a woman waking up with no memory of who she is or how she got to where she is. She finds that a strange signal has turned most people in her world into passive viewers who will not even acknowledge the woman, while some are sadistic killers hunting her and others like her.
At the end of the episode we find out that the woman is a child murderer and that she was sentenced to have her mind wiped and go through psychological torture at this theme park, where paying customer play the uninterested voyeurs. Over and over the cycle continues, and it seems almost the perfect punishment for the worst members of society.
However, this often-quoted post-war confession from 1946 illustrates the problems with such an inhumane system.
First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak for me.
6. BEST - Immersive Video Games
Playtest introduces us to something that older video gamers across the world have been dreaming of ever since they watched Lawnmower Man then plugged their Virtual Boy headsets into their Gameboys and learned the hard way that virtual reality was not yet a viable way to play games.
Nowadays, that's all changed and VR is finally taking off. While not specifically part of its popularity, it certainly helps most players that nothing needs to be implanted into the brain stem in order to play whack-a-mole.
Having said that, if games the style of the survival horror game in Playtest were real, there would be queues miles long to get the "mushroom" pierced into the back of their necks. The game learns from the player, reading their brain activity to find what scares them, slowly ramping up the fear and keeping them just on the cusp of that experience without taking it too far or becoming boring.
While more augmented reality than virtual reality, games like these are the dream that players think of each time they pick up a VR headset and get ready to truly enter another world. Just, maybe not that particular game.
5. WORST - Social Rankings
How personable are you? Do you have a pleasant laugh or does it drill through the spines of all who hear it? Are your clothes always perfectly laundered and ironed, or do you occasionally leave the house with visible creases? Are you always polite to people, even when you've had a bad day or can you sometimes not be bothered?
How about how visibly you lead your perfect life? Do you take perfect shots of your food and upload them to social media? Are your kids always doing something so cute it almost seems manufactured? Are your pets cute enough and do they have the outfits that suit them?
Based on the social credit system that's actually in place in real-life China (and one that is worryingly being spoken about around Britain), Nosedive sees social media likes taken to the extreme. When the main character's social status starts plummetting, she finds herself in a spiral where she's continually rated down until she's fallen so low that she's denied access to services, the home she's looking to buy, and even her job.
And that's terrifying.
4. BEST - Full Immersion Care Homes
As health care gets better and life expectancy gets longer, many of the elderly are finding themselves living longer and more fulfilling lives, finding themselves just as strong at ages far beyond those their parents managed to survive past. Many, but not all. There are still those who suffer from chronic disease and infirmity, yet who cling on to a life that has become nothing but pain for them. That's right folks, it's going to be a happy entry here.
The honestly quite beautiful San Junipero offers an elegant solution to this problem with full-immersion old people's homes. Those who are too elderly or too infirm for real-life can opt to enter a virtual reality program that takes them back to an era best described as a mash-up of their youths (imagine the memory of about ten years culture all smooshed together as a single year) where they can meet other people in the same situation.
Reverted to their youthful selves once more, they can live out a life that they understand amongst people they understand. And, when their time finally comes, they can be permanently uploaded into the system and live with their loved ones forever.
No, you cried.
3. WORST - Soul Copying
The episode U.S.S. Callister is basically the garage bargain basement DVD rip-off of Star Trek when it starts off, but it soon shows its focus on a truly terrifying use of technology. Taking place within a video game system much like the ones from the episode Playtest, the NPCs of the game have actually been copied into the game using the same sort of technology as is found in San Junipero.
The Captain Kirk-style character who commands the starship is, in reality, a creeper who kidnaps people from his office and keeps them in the game to be his personal playthings. Those who play along get to live, while those who don't are basically red-shirts.
And he gets away with it, because he's not actually kidnapped the people themselves. He's taken their DNA and uploaded copies of them to the games, so the actual people go about their lives without knowing that they've been copied and are held prisoner. While this sounds like a plot from Law & Order: Future Crimes Unit, there are far too many monsters in this world for tech like this to become available.
2. BEST - Child Tracking
If you're a parent then you know two terrifyingly connected things;
1) Children seemingly have access to the speed force, and are able to move incredibly fast the moment you take your eyes off them. Seriously, kids are like Weeping Angels when you blink.
2) The fear of losing a child is one of the worst ever. Even the thought of it can leave you feeling sick to your stomach.
That's why Arkangel's opening sequence, in which three-year-old Sara goes missing, is so harrowing. And it's so understandable that her mother signs her up to trial the Arkangel system. This system is at the very basic level a GPS location system for children, showing where they are on a map. But this is just the basic level.
Parents can also monitor their child's vitals, seeing if they're getting the right kinds of nutrition from their food, and heading off any serious problems long before they become an issue.
The system also includes an optional filter that censors both the sound and visual representation of whatever stresses the child out. So, if your drunken neighbour is out on the lawn waving his bits around, you (and he) are covered.
What parent wouldn't want that?
1. WORST - Memory Reading
Have you ever witnessed a crime and been asked to give a statement? Notice how hard it is? Memory is faulty, already coloured by our prejudice and bias, easily betrayed by limited language. As soon as the words leave our lips, they become lies (of omission, of inaccuracy) because we cannot make them into the whole truth.
So it is that Crocodile presents the Recaller, a device used to access the recent memories of those who witness crimes and piece together a fully accurate picture of what happened. This is not such a good thing for the main character of the episode who witnesses a crime literally seconds after committing a murder (itself committed to help protect the covering up of an accidental death from fifteen years previous) and soon finds herself spiralling into a series of other murders.
While the tech seems like a good thing for society, it would be seconds before this was used to invade someone's privacy, whether by stealing their passwords or uploading revenge porn. The world simply isn't responsible enough for a device like the Recaller to be in the wild.