Brooklyn Nine-Nine: The Best Halloween Heist Episodes, According To IMDb
5. Halloween II (IMDb Rating 8.7)
Season 2's Halloween Heist is where the games really begin.
The bet is back on, and Jake is offering Captain Holt even more overtime. Instead of stealing his Medal of Valor, Peralta wants to take the watch from Holt's wrist.
Here we see Jake seemingly manage to succeed, but only to have the watch stolen by the pickpocket he recruited to take said item. Things go from bad to worse for Jake, as his car is impounded, he finds himself on a party bus, and he's eventually arrested. Luckily for the winner, things actually go according to plan.
Halloween II is where we see Brooklyn's Halloween Heist episodes really come to life and it's clear that they were only going to get better and better from here on out.