Buffy The Vampire Slayer: 10 Worst Things Spike Ever Did

Sunnydale's favourite blond vampire's most wicked misdeeds.

Buffy the vampire slayer
Mutant Enemy

One of the Buffy universe’s most beloved and complex characters, Spike grows and evolves more than perhaps any other Joss Whedon creation over his time on TV. Starting off as a snotty, upstart vampire with delusions of grandeur, over six seasons of Buffy (and one of Angel) he develops into something far more rounded and interesting.

From killing for sport to losing his edge due to a behaviour-modulating chip in his head, to falling in love with Buffy and ultimately regaining his soul, it’s a rollercoaster for Spike, and one which sees him transition from big bad to genuine hero.

But while he spends much of the series in non-antagonistic roles, he still has a CV replete with deplorable acts. Some of these took place while he was a soulless killing machine, and can be explained, if not excused, accordingly. Others, however, took place when he was ostensibly a force for good, a changed man.

For all Spike’s noble intentions, his terrible past (and present) was never skirted around, which only added depth to his character. Here are William the Bloody’s true lowlights.

10. Killed His Mother (twice)

Spike and his mother Buffy
The WB

A major part in the mythology of Spike is his somewhat Freudian relationship with his mother, Anne. As the young William Pratt, the human Spike enjoyed a comfortable if frustrating life in Victorian London, struggling to permeate high society but coddled by a loving mother.

After one romantic frustration too many he was lured to the dark side by Drusilla, and one of his first acts as a vampire was to visit his consumptive mother and “cure” her of her tuberculosis by turning her into a bloodsucker.

Unfortunately but predictably, the change caused an abrupt personality shift in Anne. Spike’s vampiric mother made allusions to a latent incestuous desire in the young man; when he couldn’t take the taunting, he tearfully staked her, turning her to dust.

While both events were understandable and arguably noble-minded, the fact is that Spike killed his own mother twice. That’s a heavy weight to carry around, even for a member of the undead.


9. The Anya Incident

Buffy Entropy
The WB

Of all the members of the Scooby Gang, Anya and Spike are the perpetual outsiders. Both have lived lives as demons only to find their powers in some way revoked, and while both can pass for human for the most part, their links to the dark side mean they’ll never truly fit in.

This seems to lead to a healthy friendship for the most part, two sarcastic onlookers with a sideways view on the heroic tendencies of their companions. That is until season six episode “Entropy”, in which a combination of booze, spite, and heartbreak sees them take their relationship to another level, with disastrous consequences.

After Anya’s jilting by Xander and Buffy’s final rejection of Spike (with whom she’s been carrying on a secret, shame-inducing fling), the two find themselves alone and drunk in the Magic Box, and the inevitable happens.

This dalliance causes misery for all involved. Xander finds out and flies into a rage; Spike and Buffy’s fling is revealed. BTVS often preaches the ultimately disastrous nature of revenge - this is a small scale, but no less meaningful, example of that.


8. Massacred The Kalderash

Fool For Love
Mutant Enemy Productions

As a notorious vampire with a century or so of intercontinental mayhem to his name, you can take your pick when it comes to Spike’s worst acts as a vampire. He was a keen torturer, caused chaos in Sunnydale for the majority of season two, and was mentioned in passing to have eaten the population of an orphanage, which is pretty heavy.

Of all the heinous acts alluded to in Buffy and Angel, though, the massacre of the Kalderash people has to rank highly. The Romany tribe that cursed Angel with his soul in the late 19th century play a major offscreen part in the show’s mythology, and a season two episode of his titular show covers their ultimate downfall.

Orchestrated by Darla as an act of revenge, this is a particularly savage scene, with Spike at the centre. The besouled Angel effectively surrenders his crown as the most vicious vampire at this point.

This isn’t a plan of Spike’s devising, but he’s the attack dog set upon his poor victims by a vengeful Drusilla, and it’s a frightening side of Spike we’ve not seen for a while at this point.


7. Led Harmony On

Spike Harmony
Mutant Enemy

Spike’s brief, tumultuous relationship with the recently vampirised Harmony Kendall is played almost exclusively for laughs. Indeed of all the prominent characters on Buffy and Angel, Harmony is given less depth than most - she’s Cordelia without the character development, and as such is ripe for a laugh at her expense, be it based on her ditziness or her one sided romance with Spike.

They get together in season four, and from the off it’s clear Harmony’s desire for a genuine relationship is not reciprocated. Spike is flighty and unreliable, and infuriatingly bent on murdering the slayer. Things only get worse when he becomes infatuated with Buffy beyond a desire to murder her. He imagines he’s with his former nemesis while sleeping with Harmony, and strings the genuinely lovelorn vampire along to indulge his fantasy.

Harmony’s a fun character and Mercedes McNab one of the show’s more gifted comedic actors, but Harmony deserves better (this would have been a hashtag had the show been made 10 years later). Then there’s the whole age gap thing, but in the Buffy world that’s not a thread you want to pull.


6. All Round Poseur Tendencies

Spike Buffy
WB

While it can hardly compare to some of the more vicious acts in Spike’s locker, one particularly objectionable part of the character is his poseur tendencies. While one can hardly begrudge Spike for changing things up once he became a vampire, the speed with which he reinvented himself simply outs him as a tryhard and a faker.

William Pratt the human wasn’t far off a Victorian Niles Crane, penning poems and dreaming of bettering himself socially. He was fey and soft spoken, lacking in confidence. He was vampirised in 1880. Later that same year, we see him speaking in an affected working class London accent, with a put on swagger to match.

Spike is a trend hopper - he boasts of being present at Woodstock, then later jumps on the punk bandwagon in the late ‘70s. He claims Billy Idol stole his look, though it could easily be the other way around. (In fairness he maintains this aesthetic for the remainder of the show, settling into vampiric middle age.)

He’s a Londoner who supports Manchester United - that says it all, really.


5. Spike X Buffy

Buffy Spike Handcuffs
Mutant Enemy

Continuing Spike’s history of problematic romance is exhibit B: the whole Buffy saga. Through seasons five and six we see Spike experience an unwelcome crush, turned obsession, turned destructive fling.

Initially, Spike is pitched as a creepy but pathetic stalker. He lurks outside Buffy’s house. Steals trinkets, and is eventually caught pawing through her clothing. Things get worse when he begins to actively pursue her, offering charmingly to murder his ex-girlfriend to impress Buffy, and ultimately destroying her relationship with Riley.

Then, in season six, Buffy is brought back from the dead, alive but inexorably changed. In this fragile state, she begins a clandestine physical relationship with Spike. Neither party comes out great here, but Spike’s manipulative tendencies (telling Buffy she’s not right in a gaslighting manner) belie his assertion that he loves the slayer.

This reaches a peak which we’ll discuss later, but Spike’s infatuation with Buffy takes him down some seriously sketchy paths. Talking of which...


4. The Buffybot

Buffybot Buffy
Mutant Enemy

With his rock star aesthetic and penchant for cutting one liners, Spike is probably the single coolest character in Buffy history - but every now and then he goes and does something that very much punctures his aura. Perhaps the most extreme example: commissioning an incredibly lifelike animatronic sex robot version of Buffy to tend to his every whim.

The Buffyboy is a creation of resident science creep Warren Mears, who parlayed his own history of building robots based on women he was obsessed with into a cottage industry. We’re then treated to a fairly graphic idea of how the lovesick Spike would like to be spending his days: he play fights with the robotic slayer, before transitioning into another physical activity.

Needless to say, when he’s eventually caught in the act by the gang, Spike’s latest act of deviancy doesn’t go down at all well. Buffy in particular is revolted by the whole set up, though a sequence of events leads to the slayer seeing just how devoted Spike really is to her. Luckily, Buffybot only has a prominent role in one episode - it’s pretty gross.


3. Spike X Drusilla

Spike Drusilla
Mutant Enemy

The headline act in Spike’s troublesome relationship resume is his century-long off and on partnership with Drusilla. The mentally unstable Drusilla was Spike’s sire and lover for 100 years (with all the quasi-insestuous vibes this comes with), and while Spike likes to suggest that their romance is the stuff of legend, really it’s the stuff of nightmares.

For much of season two, Drusilla finds herself in a weakened state following an attack in Prague, and Spike uses this as an opportunity to assert his control over her, keeping her on a tight leash and making all the decisions for the couple as they attempt to take over Sunnydale.

Later, when she recovers, she seems to lose interest in the now-wheelchair bound Spike, but he won’t take no for an answer. At season two’s conclusion, he knocks her unconscious before spiriting her out of town. He returns to Sunnydale to force Willow to brew him a love potion following Drusilla’s latest rejection; he then abandons this idea in favour of torturing her until he gets his way.

To cap it all off, once he gets sick of her, he offers her up as a sacrifice to impress Buffy. Sure, things work a little differently with the undead, but this certainly doesn’t sound like a healthy relationship.


2. Murdered Two Slayers

Buffy Fool for LOVE SPIKE
Mutant Enemy

Season five’s “Fool For Love”, one of the series’ very best episodes, is a great showcase for Spike and James Marsters. While more often than not a comedic character to this point, here Marsters is pure cool, recounting to Buffy his adventures through the 20th century in her attempt to better understand how to survive as a slayer.

For all his visually enticing swagger, though, this is an episode built around Spike’s murder of two young women, the slayers of their day, as he rampaged around Europe and later North America as a young and vicious vampire.

The first, Xin Rong, he killed during the Boxer Rebellion. The second, Nikki Wood (whose son later emerges to settle a score) he took down on the New York subway in the ‘70s, before stealing from her his distinctive coat.

These are expertly choreographed and brutal fights that hammer home the sheer destructive power Spike possesses. He may have been effectively neutered by The Initiative at this point, but beneath his chip lies a killing machine - and this is just the highlight reel.


1. Seeing Red

Buffy Seeing Red
Mutant Enemy

For all Spike’s vampiric savagery, some of this can be written off as the nature of a vampire. But Spike is the rare bloodsucker who tries to change for the better even without a soul forcing him to do so, which his why his sexual assault on Buffy in season six’s “Seeing Red” is so difficult to watch.

Indeed it’s one of the most harrowing scenes in a show that, while generally bouncy in tone, never strayed away from the darkness in life. Spike visits Buffy’s house to attempt to regain her affections. She responds with an unequivocal no, but Spike won’t hear it. He attempts to force himself on her before she kicks him off.

He’s instantly ashamed of himself, and the incident directly leads to him fleeing Sunnydale and eventually regaining his soul. It’s a a harrowing scene, courageous in its way for its unflinching look at the horror that can exist within a relationship, but slightly mishandled in that the ramifications of this unforgivable act are never fully explored when Spike returns with his soul (James Marsters for his part felt it didn’t quite work).

For all his supernatural evil, it’s the mundanity of this assault that looms largest in Spike’s catelogue of misdeeds.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)