Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best

Which season slays the competition?

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is one of TV's most iconic and beloved shows, and being finished and off air for sixteen years hasn't lessened its appeal or wounded its impact. Buffy Summers is one of the world's greatest and most recognisable fictional characters, and villains such as Angelus, Glory and the Gentlemen remain as scary and nightmare inducing as they were when they first hit our screens.

All the seasons have their weak spots, be it poor graphics, questionable character additions (sorry, not sorry, Kennedy) or appalling bad guys, but they are all monumental and incredibly good fun. Each season is full of wit and wisdom, and messages of friendships and strength.

Sure, Season One may look slightly old and tacky now, but that doesn't mean it's any less effective as it was in the 90s. And Season Six may be bleak and dark, but that doesn't mean it's all doom and gloom. From characters to great dialogue, from relationships to teen melodrama, all seven seasons have something important to give.

In the following list, enjoy as we rank the seasons of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Some major spoilers follow.

7. Season Four

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Hush
Mutant Enemy

The weakest season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is still pretty strong. "Hush" and "Restless" are two of the series' most daring and beautifully executed episodes, and the introduction of Spike as a main character turns out to be a great gamble. The return of Faith Lehane is also something special, and a return many fans were excited to see. Her two-part arc is one of the best of the season.

All of this aside, Season Four doesn't have enough Faith or Gentlemen to keep it afloat, as it finds itself weighed down by many things. Riley Finn and the Initiative, for example, start off strong but get tedious quick, and the loss of Cordelia Chase, Angel and eventually Oz as main cast members hits the show hard.

Episodes like "Superstar" and "Beer Bad" are hilarious but unnecessary, and Oz leaving Willow is devastating and cruel given the potential of his character. The less said about Adam the better, though we'll concede he sounds promising on paper.

Tara Maclay is a fantastic addition to the show, though, and Spike and Anya bring a level of sarcasm and pessimism to the show that left with Cordelia. This is still Buffy, after all, so there is a lot to love. It's just a shame there wasn't more of it.


6. Season Seven

Spike Buffy
Mutant Enemy

Season Seven is a bit of a mess despite its epic scope. Episodes like "Him" and "First Date" may be fun, but given the threat of the First Evil they don't fit with the dark, apocalyptic tones of the season. Also, supporting characters like Kennedy, Rona, Amy, and nearly all the Potential Slayers are massive let downs.

But this is still Buffy. Spike's arc is phenomenal to watch and James Marsters' performance makes him the star of the show. His episode with Robin Wood - "Lies My Parents Told Me" - is one of the show's more underrated gems, and episodes like "Help", "Dirty Girls" and "Chosen" are all expertly crafted to raise the stakes (sorry) of the coming war. Andrew Wells, another former antagonist, also gets the chance to shine and adds some much needed humour to the proceedings.

Still, a more consistent tone and pace would have been nice, and fans would agree that Anya deserved both a better death and a more emotional goodbye.


5. Season One

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

The season where it all began. The film is forgotten and the show that starts it all gives audiences a fresh and much more confident look at Buffy Summers and her world.

Buffy, Xander, Willow, Cordelia and Giles are all well written and often brilliantly acted, and each of them manage to be likeable despite some of their more annoying habits. I.e, Cordelia being a mean girl and Xander being the show's most brash personality from the get-go.

Sure, "I, Robot...You, Jane" isn't the show's best effort, and parts of the season haven't aged very well, but The Master is a perfect debut Big Bad encapsulating the evil and mythology of Buffy's secret life. Also, Buffy's willingness to sacrifice her life for her duties (and not for the last time) instantly makes her a hell of a protagonist to watch.

And "Nightmares", as a side note, is a true series high-point well worth re-visiting.


4. Season Six

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Dark Willow
Mutant Enemy

In many ways, it's easy to understand why Season Six is such a divisive season of the show for many fans. But once you look past the bleak tones and the devastation that comes with "Seeing Red" (seriously, that episode HURTS), what you're left with is a clever and more mature season that delves into themes of depression, sex, addiction and friendship with ease and some well executed scripts.

Even the Trio, who are at first silly and a touch too slapstick, become more dangerous as the season goes on, giving us the dark and crushing episodes "Dead Things" and "Entropy". Also, Adam Busch's role as the despicable Warren Mears cannot be dismissed, and Alyson Hannigan's turn as a Big Bad is deeply affecting.

This is the season which also brought fans "Once More with Feeling", a musical episode which hits all the right notes (sorry again). Unfortunately, we don't get enough of Dark Willow and watching Xander leave Anya at the altar is a bit too much to bear. But at least we get the yellow crayon speech...


3. Season Five

Buffy The Gift
Mutant Enemy

Season Five is truly fantastic, and a lot of it comes down to Glory. Narcissistic, cruel and unabashed by her evil intentions, Glory is Buffy's most formidable and fun to watch opponent. However, the true strength of the season comes in the form of Buffy's fabricated sister, Dawn, who is placed within the narrative without much of an explanation why.

When her purpose is revealed, however, the threat of the Big Bad becomes more personal than ever. Though some fans dismiss her as annoying or shrill, which she can be, Dawn's relationship with Buffy give our protagonist a relationship outside of boyfriends, and it's great to see.

"The Body" is the best episode of the season and maybe the entire show, and characters like Spike, Giles and Willow get some brilliant moments to shine. Buffy's second sacrifice of the show is even more powerful than Season One, and her speech to Dawn as her friends react to her death is nothing short of heart breaking. In fact, Season Five would be number one if not for Riley Finn's ham-fisted exit and the far too weird Knights of Byzantium.


2. Season Two

Angelus Buffy
Mutant Enemy

Season Two is a very personal season for everyone involved. Watching Angel lose his soul and become king tormentor and Big Bad to the Scooby Gang is often tough to watch, but thanks to David Boreanaz and Sarah Michelle Gellar's obvious chemistry, it's also the show at its most compelling.

The addition of Spike and Drusilla takes the show to more fun and threatening places, and episodes such as "School Hard", "Surprise" and the epic two-part finale "Becoming" makes this season Buffy at its most shocking and emotional. "I Only Have Eyes for You" is an underappreciated gem, too, but "Passion", in which Angelus kills Jenny Calendar and leaves her to be found by Giles, is Joss Whedon at his most cruel and ingenious.

In fact, the only thing keeping Season Two from the top spot is "Go Fish", which is a classic fun monster-of-the-week romp, but one which ruins the momentum of the coming finale.


1. Season Three

Season Three edges out the competition for two big reasons: consistency, and the addition of Faith Lehane. This is Buffy at its most well organised and tightly written. Everyone gets a moment to shine, be in Xander in the wonderfully fun meta episode "The Zeppo", Willow in the alternate timeline-based "Dopplegangland", or Oz in "Beauty and the Beasts."

The alternate reality episode "The Wish" is one of Buffy's most daring episodes, and "Earshot" and "Lover's Walk" make for two more of the show's more underrated. Mayor Richard Wilkins is also a devillishly fun Big Bad whose jovial and polite manner perfectly contrasts Angelus in the last season.

But it is Eliza Dushku's rogue Slayer, Faith Lehane, who steals the show from everyone, providing a darkness to the show and shifting the idea of good versus evil to the idea of good people gone bad. Watching the two Slayers go head to head is without question the show's most exciting fight, and the emotional pay-off still hits home all these years later.

Tie it all up with a bow made from wonderful supporting characters like Oz, Cordelia, and guests Wesley Wyndam-Prcye and Spike, and what you've got is a great show at the very height of its powers.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/