Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Ranking The Big Bads

From heavily made-up denizens to Alyson Hannigan in a black wardrobe, Buffy tangoed with many weird and wonderful antagonists during her time on TV.

Joss Whedon's seminal supernatural TV series Buffy the Vampire Slayer is surely one of the most influential genre shows ever produced, if not the definitive article. Everything from its format - primarily a mixing of high school drama and horror with a fair amount of comedy - to its slang-heavy, unique dialogue - Buffy characters are penchant-y for putting y's on the end of words that don't usually have them - have inspired a range of television shows ever since it first aired as a midseason replacement in 1997. However, the greatest cultural impact Buffy has made on TV is surely coining the phrase 'Big Bad.' A play on the Big Bad Wolf from fairy tales, the term was used both by fans and within the series itself to describe the main villain of an individual season of the show - and has since been adopted by TV fans worldwide. As the progenitor of the phrase, Buffy naturally has a bumper pack of brilliant Big Bads. So join us as we wield the strength and skill to look at a list of vampires, demons and the forces of darkness, from the littlest Bad to the best and Biggest Bad of them all.

7. Adam - Season Four

The story arc of Season Four largely revolved around Buffy and her friends discovering the Initiative, a super-secret off-shoot of the army who deal with the incarceration and experimentation of demons. Though the Initiative and Buffy seem to share a common cause, an experiment of theirs actually became the season's Big Bad; a Frankenstein's Monster made of bits of human being, demon and cybernetics known as Adam. Once created, the vengeful Adam felt isolated for being the only one of his kind and so rounded up a demon and vampire army to wage war on humanity, with the eventual aim to create more like himself. While a villain who's part Frankenstein, part-Terminator seems perfect material for Buffy (though oddly enough the show's previous foray into Frankenstein in Season Two's Some Assembly Required was also a dud) the combats and khakis of the Initiative just don't sit well in Buffy's supernatural, gothic-tinged world. In fact, Whedon himself realised the problems with Adam and had Buffy and company kill him in the penultimate episode of the series, rather than the finale - would you Adam and Eve it! Well, we've never heard of that happening elsewhere so at least he's number one in that category.

6. The Master - Season One

The very first Big Bad in the series was ancient vampire the Master (and nope, this wasn't a crossover with Doctor Who), the leader of the vampire Order of Aurelius who was entrapped in the Hellmouth below Sunnydale. The only way he could escape from his prison was to open the Hellmouth and bring about the apocalypse. Thankfully, as he was such an easy-going guy, he had no qualms about this, sending him into conflict with the Slayer many times. While Mark Metcalf gives a fun, at times creepy, performance, and the character suitably evokes Count Orlok from classic vampire film Nosferatu, the Master is a somewhat disappointing villain. With a similar problem to Adam, the Master doesn't get a great deal to do, forever waiting in the wings until the Hellmouth opens so he can wriggle up to the surface world. Having said that, the Master does get his time to shine in Season One's finale, Prophecy Girl, where he finally escapes his bounds and faces off against Buffy - even killing her, temporarily. You kill the show's lead character and you're still second-from-bottom - sorry Master, you had some tough competition.

5. Dark Willow - Season Six

Buffy the Vampire Slayer loves to play with audience expectations, from the premise of the show itself - a blonde teen is actually the saviour of the world? - to sudden character deaths - well, do I have to remind you? One of the show's most deliberated pieces of misdirection came in the identity of Season Six's Big Bad. Throughout the series, it is set up that the Trio, a collection of Sunnydale's geekiest inhabitants, namely Warren, Andrew and Jonathan, have teamed up to be the town's latest supervillains. However, when Willow the witch's girlfriend Tara is accidentally killed by Warren (ah, sorry for reminding you about that), she turns to dark magic to exact her revenge on those that wronged her. The result is Dark Willow, the true Big Bad of the season. Willow is one of the best characters on the show and a strong point of her turn to the dark side is that her addiction to her powers is built up for several seasons before hand, in an impressive bit of pre-planning from the showmakers. If she has a problem its that because Willow is so easy to love as a hero, Dark Willow makes for a slightly unconvincing villain. Although she does attempt to cause the end of the world - something ten-a-penny in Buffy - it's doesn't feel like that much of a threat. Perhaps because it's loveable Willow behind the wheel and we knows she's too much of a Big Good to be a proper Big Bad.

4. The First Evil - Season Seven

The final season of Buffy aimed to up the stakes higher than ever before by placing the ageless entity known as the First Evil firmly in the Big Bad position. Said to be the personification of all evil on Earth, the First was a non-corporeal being that could assume the shape of any dead person to influence others into doing its bidding. This bidding, by the way, was to eliminate the Slayer line, leaving the world without a hero to protect it from, well, evil. While the First is an original reinvention of the Devil and a villain of suitable magnitude for last season of the show, it just misses out on being one of the top three due to, as a shapeless creature, there being no single face or a persona to latch on to. Though this was somewhat rectified in the introduction of Firefly's Nathan Fillion at the tail-end of the season as Caleb, a crooked preacher and accolade of the First. Nevertheless, while the First may be the origin of humanity's sins, in the context of this article, we shall have to rename it the Fourth Evil.

3. Glorificus - Season Five

In a typical Buffy subversion, Season Five's Big Bad, the all-powerful Goddess Glorificus, as played by Clare Kramer, is portrayed as a spoilt high school cheerleader - but one with the power to end the world if she doesn't get her own way. Trapped in human form, Glorificus, more commonly known as Glory, spends the season in search of the Key, a mystical device which will free her from her Earthbound bonds so she can return to her own hell dimension. Unfortunately for her, the Key has been placed in the care of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, in the form of her younger sister Dawn, and she won't let Glory take her without a fight. Compared to the other Big Bads, Glory has one of the most complex stories of Buffy villains; as well as her quest for the Key, it is revealed that Glory feeds off the minds of others, leaving them mentally-handicapped, she shares a body with seemingly-ordinary human Ben Wilkinson and she is near-invincible - apart from having a weakness for a handy macguffin called the Dagon Sphere. Phew! Even if things do get a little complicated, though, Glory is certainly one of the conceptually-strongest and most powerful villains Buffy and the Scoobies ever faced. Glory to Glory!

2. Mayor Wilkins And Faith - Season Three

At work throughout Season Three is Richard Wilkins, the Mayor of Sunnydale, an immortal sorcerer who made a pact with the demon world to rule over the town for all time. Always peppy and charming despite his diabolical leanings, the Mayor planned to ascend to a higher form, that of a pure-breed, snake-like demon. Naturally, not being a fan of the demon crowd, Buffy and her gang pitted themselves against him. However, while Wilkins is certainly an entertaining villain all by himself his high ranking on this list is confirmed by his partner in crime and surrogate daughter, Faith, the rogue Vampire Slayer. Troubled teen Faith starts off merely a little wayward according to Buffy's methods but over the course of the season becomes a murderer and falls prey to the allure of the bad. Unstable and irresponsible, Faith is the exact antithesis of Buffy. But what really makes the Mayor and Faith so successful as the season's Big Bads is the relationship they share. Loner Faith finally finds someone who cares for her - in the form of a mad despotic politician. Even demon mayors realise you've got to have a little faith...

1. Angelus, Spike And Drusilla - Season Two

It could be argued that Buffy's first season is really just a taster for what is to come and the show really gets off the ground (or should that be rises from the grave?) in Season Two - or more precisely in episode three of Season Two, School Hard, when vampire couple Spike and Drusilla first turned up to cause havoc for the Slayer. As any Buffy fan will tell you, Spike is perhaps the best Buffy character of them all, with James Marsters' effortless cool more than making up for his wavering British accent. Also, not to be forgotten is his eternal love Drusilla (well, eternal until she ditches him for a demon with antlers but we won't go into that now), an ethereal, rather insane individual, Dru shared Spike's lust for chaos, carnage and generally having a 'bloody' good time. However, as if Spike and Drusilla weren't enough to carry the season, the plot thickens when tormented vampire and Buffy's lover Angel loses his soul and becomes the wise-cracking, evil-doing Angelus. The three best vampire characters on the show teamed up to be seriously sinister in Sunnydale! What could be better? Much like the Mayor and Faith, the best thing about having Angelus, Spike and Dru as Big Bads is the interaction between the three, particularly Spike and Angelus as they fight for Dru's affections. Also, more so than any other Big Bad, fighting Angel hits Buffy hard as she has to stop a twisted, evil version of the man she loves from destroying the world; emphasizing the tragedy at the show's centre that Buffy's Slayer responsibilities mean she has to make difficult choices. With this dramatic conceit at the heart of having Angelus as an enemy, plus the endless fun of Spike and Dru, Season Two's line-up of villainous vampires are certainly the best of Buffy the Vampire Slayer's Big Bads. Is this list as super-strong as the Slayer herself? Or do you think this article needs to be slain with a wooden stake and sent to a hell dimension for getting it wrong? Leave your comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.