Castlevania Season 2 Review: 7 Ups And 2 Downs

Netflix's 'animated Game of Thrones' returns, but is it better than Season 1? 

Netflix Castlevania
Netflix

Castlevania Season 2 dropped this week with eight new episodes, and the quality of both writing and animation have not waned - in fact, they have improved, in many ways, even when Season 1 was already a masterwork in its own right.

While not the perfect season, despite currently being ranked at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, it certainly delivers on both action and slick, smart writing, somehow doubling down on the "animated Game of Thrones" comparison with thickening plots, intrigue, and a complex cast of characters, both old and new.

Fortunately not the end of a short but fantastic era, with Season 3 on the way and plans being discussed on how to expand the originally planned feature film script, this season has wrapped up its major story while setting up the future in a way that has audiences excited for more.

With that in mind, here are the best, and a couple of the not so great, features of a season that we now know is the beginning of a hopefully long and successful stint on Netflix, for what is still considered the best onscreen adaptation of a video game so far.

Some spoilers for the events of Season 2 ahead!

9. Down: Exposition And Talking Heads

Castlevania Carmilla Isaac Hector Godbrand
Netflix

As enjoyable as Warren Ellis's writing is, there is a point at which the characters exposit, argue, converse, scheme and plot more than actually doing anything. And while that gave space for some wonderful character moments, it isn't long before audiences realise it's taken certain characters 3 episodes to read books and make plans, and another 3 to enact said plans.

Much of the series and its backstory is told in flashbacks, which, while intriguing and fun to watch, doesn't do much to move the plot forward. This season seemed more focused on character building before jumping back into plot, which, while not in itself a bad thing, certainly didn't move things along until the final act.

And when the final act comes, and the desires and intentions of the other characters, which were so prominent in the season, aren't met, the central, dramatic "oomph" of Dracula's battle seems diminished, if not the emotional core of it.

Though the decision to put as much focus on characters can be seen as a positive, it makes the main plot feel rushed in parts, like the promise of another season made the creators shuffle their story around in a hurry.


8. Down: The Pacing

Castlevania Season 2 Fight
Netflix

Though the overall story was told masterfully, and was never boring, the series often felt as though it ramped up the action too quickly, then transitioned back to slow, thoughtful conversations just as abruptly. One might argue it's realistic in war to have long periods of planning and waiting before a short but brutal battle, but the telling of a narrative requires just a little more transition in-between either.

Though it served to build up fantastic characters along the way, the way the story gave more time to characters such as Hector, Isaac, Carmilla and Godbrand made Dracula's own story almost a sideline plot for much of the season, before bringing it back to Drac' in the climax.

The episode divisions were equally jarring. When binged, the season flows just fine as a full narrative, but the credits hit in seemingly random places, cutting off at scenes that did not feel like the conclusion of an episode, but more like a commercial break.

As a whole, the story works and flows well, but having it divided into eight 23-minute episodes instead of, perhaps, four 46-minute ones, or just one whole long film, felt superfluous in the long run.


7. Up: The Performances

Castlevania Godbrand Carmilla
Netflix

The voice acting, including that of the new cast, is superb, with both humour and deeply emotional moments being delivered effectively. Warren Ellis's script was able to mix deeply hilarious, if adult humour in without undercutting the drama and action, and the voice actors were able to bring the complex emotions of affection, love, uncertainty, anger, and such to the fore.

Some standouts in this season were Godbrand, played by the unconquerable Peter Stormare, whose loud and brash and bombastic presence was felt all the way through, as well as Jaime Murray's graceful, powerful, and scheming Carmilla, Adetokumboh M'Cormack as the reserved yet deeply violent (and deeply passionate) Isaac, and the powerful yet sweet and meek Hector played by Theo James.

This isn't even mentioning the powerful and painfully emotional performances of Graham McTavish and James Callis as Dracula and Alucard respectively, and the truly heartwarming and sometimes heartbreaking performances by Richard Armitage and Alejandra Reynoso's Trevor and Sypha.

The talents behind the voice cast and the fantastic script come together beautifully, bringing out some of the greatest acting and emotional depth seen in a fantasy cartoon in a good long while.


6. Up: The Action

Castlevania Trevor Sypha Fight
Netflix

As seen in Season 1, the action scenes in the series are like centerpieces for the show's visuals, with animation so fluid, graceful, and beautifully paced, they maximise the medium in a way that would have been impossible to replicate in live action.

This season doubles the action seen in Season 1, with fantastic fight choreography and frame-by-frame beauty that came together in what was almost a dance, but with weapons and more gore. Each character works well together and individually, comfortable in their own styles and ingenious in how they're able to take on their foes.

Much like the best of anime, the style clearly inspiring this series's own, each fight scene is treated like its own show, keeping viewers at the edge of their seat, waiting for their heroes to succeed even when the odds seem against them, with a conclusion meant to be satisfying based on how the fight started.

Though the animation is, very rarely, clunky in some places where dialogue and simple actions take place, every fight scene is masterful, and a treat to watch, and more or less the reason this show is perfect for the animated medium.


5. Up: Dracula's Demise

Castlevania Dracula Season 2
Netflix

Where most other shows would try to milk as much of the leadup to the battle against Dracula as possible, season 2 went a different route, showing the effects of Dracula's rage on him as a person and giving him a conclusion worthy of the deep and complex character he was introduced as in season 1.

Instead of the rage-filled, beast-like man hellbent on revenge for his wife, we find someone empty, wanting silence, as a portent for what's to come.

It's a more nuanced portrayal of rage and loss than has been seen in the fantasy genre in a while, with Dracula following patterns of grief instead of stoking the flame of his vengeance almost endlessly, like other villains seem to.

He even comes to himself when he sees Alucard's childhood room, a father seeing his son for the first time since he was consumed by wrath, and realising what he's become.

The heartbreaking fight between Dracula and Alucard reveals to all what Alucard seemed to understand early on—that he was only fighting now for the sake of fighting, even if he'd died the day his wife did, and had been writing "the world's longest suicide note" ever since.


4. Up: The Intrigue

Castlevania Hector Carmilla
Netflix

The fact that Season 2 didn't jump into the most straightforward "vampires help Dracula kill everything, trio has to fight vampires" formula, and instead doubled down on the "animated Game of Thrones" comparison, showed off Warren Ellis's writing chops, allowing the complex power structures of a war council to devolve in the most dramatic of ways.

While talking heads can bog a plot down sometimes, the underhanded natures of the council's members, especially that of Carmilla, kept things interesting and on edge, with internal conflict just as prominent as the external.

Though Dracula himself seemed not to care about the proceedings, watching Isaac—who is wholly loyal to Dracula in a love he's not likely to acknowledge—react to Godbrand and Carmilla's betrayal with merciless retribution, and watching Hector try to do what he thinks is right and get screwed over in the process, makes audiences excited for what's to come for all these newcomers in season 3.

It was fantastic insight into the wants and desires of each character, and was much less simplistic than most fantasy tales, allowing for destruction and death to come from the most unexpected places, and allowing for audiences to have multiple characters to root for.


3. Up: The Trio

Castlevania Trio Trevor Sypha Alucard
Netflix

The relationship between Alucard, Sypha and Trevor builds up wonderfully this season, with the animosity between Trevor and Alucard bringing them to laughter instead of fabricating false drama, and Sypha's empathy sidestepping the relationship tropes often used by lazier writers.

The way Trevor and Alucard rib each other, with teeth but no more real malice, and even affection, encourages future encounters of a friendlier kind.

Sypha seems to be the most put together, understanding her own feelings and the feelings of her two dear friends and being more or less what keeps the team together, with both her powerful magic allowing them to succeed and her emotional intelligence cutting down any stupidity or emotional constipation early on.

Each member of the team shows off even more prowess in this season, fighting beautifully together as a team and individually, with Trevor flexing his skill with both the Morningstar whip and a stick he picked up from the enemy, Sypha showing off insane amounts of will and magical power, and Alucard using his other abilities, including his wolf transformation, during battle.

The trio has only grown more likeable, and makes audiences vie for more of their adventures together in later seasons.


2. Up: The New Villains

Castlevania Isaac
Netflix

Many of the new characters in Season 2 got to shine and got their stories fleshed out well, with some getting some absolutely intriguing setups for the already announced season 3, and most of whom got interesting backstory communicated effectively in short but memorable flashbacks.

Carmilla's ambition is encapsulated beautifully when she's shown to have murdered her last master. Hector's softheartedness in youth mirrors that of his older self and his affinity for animals, whereas Isaac's youth shows his loving nature warped into a violent one, when his love was abused by a father figure.

The reveal that the last battle the story had been leading up to wasn't even the last episode was surprising to many, but the last episode did well to set up what was to come, with Carmilla and Isaac both looking to amass an army, and with Hector unwillingly made a pawn to future plans of domination.

With two major villains, both powerful and vicious in their own rights, rising to power at the end of this season to fill the power vacuum left by Dracula, there's sure to be much more to be excited for seasons to come.


1. Up: Emotional Depth

Castlevania Alucard Tears
Netflix

Though the tight, fast-moving setup action of Season 1 did well to get audiences excited for more, Season 2 has a surprising amount of emotional complexity almost outshining the main plot and action, taking time out of flash fights and gory kills to emphasise relationships and expressions of deep feeling and pain.

Instead of a mission to kill a monster, the story becomes a son's mission to put his father out of his misery and to make sure he doesn't hurt anyone else, for the sake of a mother he loved and lost and misses. Instead of a merry band of heroes, viewers get some broken and sad people helping each other through hardship and showing friendship, love, and loyalty.

Instead of an overlord hellbent on culling the Earth, audiences get a sad, tired man who just wants peace after all the anger drained out of him, leaving only grief.

It's beautiful and painful in equal measure, and all comes together in the last scene, where instead of triumph and victory, viewers get a young man in his childhood home, tired after long days of fighting, finally able to rest, weeping for all those he loved, that he's lost.

What did you think of Castlevania Season 2? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, artist, professional animator. Indie comics and Hi Nay podcast creator. Queer Filipino storyteller || @MotzieD on Twitter || Originally from Quezon City, The Philippines. Currently based in Toronto, Canada || motziedapul.com || hinaypod.com