Community: Every Main Character Ranked Worst To Best
Which Greendale students were most worthy of six seasons and a movie?!
It seems wrong to call Community an underground hit, as the Dan Harmon show amassed an impressive six seasons - albeit without a movie - and garnered a huge fan following. With that being said, it's never considered to be a top contender in sitcom history. But, it certainly should be, as the series played with the clichés of the genre so well, delivered on barrels of laughs and had one of the best leading casts any ensemble sitcom has ever seen.
Part of what made the study group such great characters was how they played against sitcom archetypes. The set formula of characters was there, such as the motherly one, the hard worker and the egotist, but they only took the ingredients from these clichés and set out to bake a different cake entirely. This gave the show such a distinct identity and made each role memorable.
Sorting these characters based on their humour, position in the show, and development is an incredibly tough task, as they all brought something unique, and each character can be considered a fan-favourite in their own right. However, when looking closely, some do better than others.
9. Shirley Bennett
It's heart-breaking to see Shirley at the bottom of this list, but sadly, it makes sense. Yvette Nicole Brown did a fantastic job with the character, as she took a role that could have been very flat and turned her into a loving part of the series. Sadly there are a few drawbacks to her character that cause her to lag behind the others.
First, come the positives, and there's a fair few for her. As the surrogate mother of the group, she was always very loving and supportive, which made her such a loveable part of the show. However, there was a darker side to her that came from her passive aggression, anger issues and obsessive - arguably bigoted - religious values.
Despite these exciting character points, she was let down by the fact that she lacked personality or development outside of her archetype. Of all the characters in the show, she's easily the one who changed the least as she mainly remained as the caring motherly figure throughout the show.
Shirley gets points for being so wholesome, but her humour and character wasn't as strong as the others.
8. Pierce Hawthorne
Getting the legendary Chevy Chase for Community was like hitting a gold mine for the creators. His wealth of comedy experience made Pierce a constantly amusing character, and he undoubtedly brought a sense of validity to the show that was sorely needed. However, he fell short in a few areas, which is why he ranks lower on this list.
The heir to Hawthrone Wipes was a constantly funny character, thanks to his lack of filter and inappropriate comments. However, here lies one of his biggest problems. As a frequently offensive bigot, Pierce could be tough to root for, as most of his humour singled him out as unlikeable.
Additionally, he always felt like an outsider to the group, despite being one of the main cast members. His constant harassment and position as the "bad guy" was funny but painted him in a bad light, which brings him down here.
To add more smoke to this fire, his premature exit from the show and lack of acknowledgement meant that he left with zero fanfare. This was the straw that broke the camel's back regarding his feeling out of place with the main cast.
7. Ben Chang
Ken Jeong is, without a doubt, a comedy genius. The man has such a great way of bringing energy and over-the-top antics to his characters, and while it might not be for everyone, it was perfect for Community. He has such a skill with taking little things and making them way bigger than they should be, and that's something he brought to the forefront of Ben Chang. Still, the character did go off the rails, and not in a good way.
At first, Chang was the hilarious Spanish teacher who ruled over his class with an iron fist and constantly caused havoc for the leads. Jeong brought his typical obnoxious energy to this, and it worked. But, he was eventually outed as a fake and went through an identity crisis.
The devolution of Chang was hilarious at first, as his new position in the school grew to outlandish proportions. His period as dictator was a particular highlight. However, he felt very directionless after that ended and never managed to establish a key part in the leading group outside of being a minor annoyance.
For that, and his lack of subtlety, he falls near the lower end of this hierarchy.
6. Dean Pelton
When you think of Community, it's very likely that one of the first images you conjure up is the extravagant, overly eager and constantly costume changing Dean Pelton. This ludicrous character is synonymous with the show and you'd be hard pressed to forget about him. Jim Rash deserves a ton of praise for the part, but he doesn't entirely match the others.
It's tough to pinpoint when the Dean became a leading character, as he barely appeared in the initial episodes but slowly become a significant presence within season one. Soon, he became known for his delivery of news and episode plots and always sported a wild outfit to boot.
While Pelton was amazing, there were a few drawbacks to him, mainly stemming from two points. The first was that he never felt like a main character, as his position was always in support of the study group rather than the centre of the story.
The next was the fact that his flamboyant personality was very one-note. That one-note may have been very funny - as his love for Jeff and Dalmatian fetish proved - but it meant that he lacked nuance compared to the others.
5. Annie Edison
Every sitcom has a slightly neurotic overachiever; Brooklyn Nine-Nine has Amy Santiago, Friends has Monica Gellar, and Community has Annie Edison. It's rare to find an ensemble show that doesn't have this archetype, as it's such a great tactic to keep the plot moving forward and can be an excellent source of comedy. Annie is a clear example of the type but adds enough to make it feel special.
Alison Brie did a fantastic job with Annie, as she took what could have been considered the shows most cliched character - a young and attractive hard worker - and turned her into a nuanced person. Annie was confident in herself, but also shockingly shameless at times, as her dramatic outbursts were always cringe-worthy, and she didn't care what people thought of her, so long as she got her A.
Overall, Annie was a fantastic character, and seeing her grow from a shy/neurotic teen to a confident/outspoken young woman was amazing. She only falls a few points behind because her comedy moments weren't as vibrant as the coming roles, and she did fall into her archetype's clichés a little too much at times.
4. Troy Barnes
Plenty of people will be disappointed to see Troy fall just shy of the top three, as he's one of the show's biggest fan-favourite characters. It's easy to see why, as his dorky personality, high energy and flawless performance from Donald Glover make him such a vital part of the Community puzzle. However, there are just enough cracks to bring him down a little when looking at his character objectively.
Comparing Troy's humble beginnings in the show to what he'd become is like night and day. He started as a run of the mill dumb jock character, but through his friendship with Abed, he began to come out of his shell. His character became such a fun presence, as his naivety was always so innocent/sweet, and his tendency to freak out over surprising things - like meeting his hero LeVar Burton - was eye-catching.
However, the main letdown for Troy comes from that which made him better, I.e. his friendship with Abed. While it did bring out a new side to the character and gave us one of the best bromances ever put to screen, Troy always felt like a second fiddle to him, which brings him down a little as he had less agency in the show's narrative.
He was a great Constable to Inspector Spacetime, but a Constable nonetheless.
3. Jeff Winger
Jeff was the glue that held the group - and by extension, the show - together. His development from a shallow and selfish jerk to a shallow but not so selfish friend was one of the show's biggest selling points. He might have seemed like the typical leading man with a hidden heart of gold at first, but he proved to be so much more than that.
The former lawyer turned college student started as an entirely unlikeable guy. While he was effortlessly cool and suave, he was only concerned about himself. This is what made his development throughout the show so fascinating, as you genuinely saw him become a better person by learning from his mistakes and gaining the ability to let people in.
In addition to this, Joel McHale nailed the comedy aspects of the role, as Jeff's arrogance and ego led to some of the funniest moments in the series, such as his ego overload in "Contemporary Impressionists" and his conspiracy in "Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design".
Winger hit all the notes you'd expect from the lead guy but did enough to make the part nuanced and unique.
2. Britta Perry
Britta is the worst! Except, she's really not. The thing that's so great about this character is that she gave you the best of both worlds. On one side of the coin was her initial presentation as the cool and outspoken activist of the group. But, eventually, she devolved into a goofy and always embarrassing friend, and both of these sides of her were great.
Initially, Britta seemed destined to play the typical romantic interest foil for the main character. We'd seen it all before, as she'd be standoffish at first but would eventually succumb to the genre's clichés. But, this isn't what happened with her, as she went against the typical leading woman type and forged her own path full of goofy pizza dances and "Britta'ing" everything.
Seeing the rest of the study group constantly railing on her for her awkward quirks and lack of impulse control was always a treat, and she had some of the best development in the show. Just like a real friend, you felt like you were really getting to know her and her eccentricities as the series progressed.
She ended up being one of the funniest characters in the show, thanks to the excellent comedy work from Gillian Jacobs and her great development.
1. Abed Nadir
There are many things that Community is known for, such as touching emotional scenes, outlandish humour and goofy set-ups. But, one of the most critical aspects of the show was its meta humour. Abed wasn't just the character who played with this the most; he was the anchor that pulled the show past the fourth-wall.
Abed was constantly cracking some of the most entertaining jokes, as his way of seeing the world was so different from others, and he could almost tell he was in a sitcom. This gave the series a tongue-in-cheek self-awareness that helped it become popular, and it had Abed to thank for that.
Besides what he did for the show, Abed was such a likeable character, as his eccentricities were always a cause for entertainment, and he had some incredibly emotional moments. Plus, he always played a significant role in the development of narratives.
Finally, TV can often have trouble representing characters on the autistic spectrum, but Abed is one of the best. The show never sought to diagnose him or paint him like someone who was outside of the norm. Instead, it took the time to show how he operated on a different wavelength from others but could still be healthy, functioning and downright hilarious without leaning into stereotype.