Daredevil: 10 Punisher Storylines For Season 2

Charlie Cox vs Jon Bernthal, in a battle for fandom's hearts.

Matt Murdock is about to get some help with his one-man war on crime. Or else what's masquerading as the cavalry is going to cause even more of a headache. With a second season of Netflix's hugely successful Daredevil show a given, attention is now being paid to which Marvel characters might pop up in it. First name confirmed? The Punisher. Frank Castle has already been cast as well, with The Walking Dead's Jon Bernthal pulling on the skull-emblazoned jersey and an infeasible amount of bandoliers fulls of bullets. He's perfect for the role, but just as crucial as getting the character of The Punisher right is getting his storylines right as well. To the comic books! The first season of Daredevil skimmed more the tone and themes of Brian Michael Bendis and Frank Miller's run on the source material, but some major plot points came from comic arcs as well. Chances are it'll be the same for The Punisher's introduction €“ and thankfully, he and the Man Without Fear have met on more than one occasion. In most cases, there was little love lost between either character. So expect fisticuffs when the next bunch of episodes drop. What form should those fisticuffs take, however? Should they look to the classics once more, or something more up to date? And should they fight on a rooftop or street? Here are ten Punisher comics to adapt for Daredevil season 2.

10. Daredevil Vs Punisher

Starting with the obvious: this 2005 crossover, subtitled €œMeans And Ends€, sees the two vigilantes duking it out over their respective philosophies. Which is to say, despite working outside of the courts Daredevil usually lets criminals get locked up when he's done with them. When The Punisher's done, there usually isn't anything to lock up. What could have been a really rote, phoned-in crossover actually wound up in the hands of David Lapham, award-winning writer/artist of indie crime series Stray Bullets. The plot fits right into the state of things in the Netflix Daredevil series, too, with Wilson Fix toppled from his throne as the Kingpin of crime in Hell's Kitchen. That attracts every Tom, Dick and Stabby to vie for a place at the top of the city's criminal underworld, which Daredevil and The Punisher struggle to contain €“ whilst simultaneously struggling to deal with each other's approaches to crime-fighting. The only way it falls down is it use of every silly Marvel villain in the chest, but that can be easily changed.

9. The Punisher Strikes Twice!

The other obvious place for Netflix and Marvel to draw on is The Punisher's very first appearance in the comics. If Jon Bernthal's Frank Castle is being introduced as a totally new player in Hell's Kitchen in Daredevil's second season, why not use his first appearance in New York on the page as a template? But the only thing is, The Punisher isn't classically a Daredevil villain. He was originally a foil for your friendly neighbourhood wall crawler, debuting in 1974's The Amazing Spider-Man #129, where he's been hired by The Jackal to kill the webhead. Thankfully, Castle reneges on his boss when it turns out he's setting him up for mass-murder. It's a classic story, and one that could make the leap to the small screen without much modification. Get rid of The Jackal, because he's a Spidey villain (and a terrible one at that, tied into the much-maligned €œClone Saga€), and have somebody else hiring The Punisher to do in Daredevil because he's bad for business. Job's a good'un.

8. The Omega Effect

Of course, times change, and Spider-Man is now a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Peter Parker is getting recast and rebooted once more, with no formal announcement about who will be playing him this time, and when he'll be making his first appearance (rumour has it he'll be part of the main cast of Captain America: Civil War). Depending on when the second season of Daredevil drops, then, Spider-Man may well have popped up in the MCU. Just in time to play a part in an adaptation of €œThe Omega Effect€, a crossover from Mark Waid's run on the Man Without Fear's book which saw Daredevil, Spidey and Punisher teaming up against Megacrime. Yes, MEGACRIME. That is the name given to a conglomerate of crime families with an international reach, whom Matt has accidentally ticked off. Waid's approach to Daredevil moved him more into the bright, superhero world of comics than the dark, crime-ridden alley he'd occupied for a while, as copied by the series €“ so this might be a bit out-there.

7. The Bully/The Creep

A little more down-to-Earth is this two-parter written by Ann Nocenti and Mike Baron, respectively, which saw two different sides to the same story through the eyes of first Daredevil and then The Punisher €“ it's superhero Rashomon! Introducing Frank Castle by having him star in an episode, and then getting the same events from Matt's POV? Neat idea, and would actually do well to highlight the similarities and differences between the two with a little more subtlety than just... making them fight. Surely everybody's bored of comic book characters fighting each other, after seventy-five-or-so years of it? Actually, to be fair, there is a bit of crapping in €œThe Bully€ and €œThe Creep€. It would also fit into the mould Daredevil has so far made, which gave almost equal screentime to Wilson Fisk as Matt Murdock, making viewers €œunderstand€ the motivations of the villain as much as the good guy. Expect a similar treatment being afforded to The Punisher whatever happens €“ but there's worse examples than this to follow.

6. The Angel Dust Murders

Frank Miller's run on Daredevil has been the main influence on Netflix's Daredevil so far, with the series adapting everything from the black ninja costume from Miller and John Romita's €œThe Man Without Fear€ miniseries to the themes of Catholic guilt, using torture to get your way and The Hand which have their roots in the writers/artist's work. With an off-handed reference to Miller's Elektra in Daredevil's first season and the grapevine reporting villain Bullseye will be a part of the second, it would make sense to again look to his work in terms of introducing The Punisher. 1982's Daredevil #181-184, written and drawn by Miller, has Murdock and Castle facing off. The pair's crossover comes right in the middle of Miller's most famous Daredevil arc (ie Bullseye killing Elektra, and Matt not dealing particularly well with it). He and The Punisher clash during an investigation of how Angel Dust is being dealt at schools, which leads to the death of some kids. The first season has some grim highs to live up to!

5. Shadowland

Despite not being an especially fan-favourite arc, it looks like the 2010 crossover event €œShadowland€ is going to be a big part of Marvel's plans going forward. In the comics, Daredevil is seen in recent teaser images to be wearing a black costume not unlike the one he chose when he proclaimed himself ninja ruler of Hell's Kitchen. Backing up just a fraction, €œShadowland€ was a series which saw a load of Marvel's street-level characters being drawn into a conflict against a Matt Murdock who's gone a bit funny after a trip to Japan €“ which itself followed a series of unfortunate events which saw his secret identity revealed to the world, a trip to prison and a nervous breakdown. Amongst those street-level characters is The Punisher, who gets into it with Daredevil in a major way (not being particularly friendly with Matt means he doesn't hold back the way, say, Spider-Man does). The smart money is on €œShadowland€ forming the backbone of the upcoming Netflix Defenders crossover series, but elements could be used in Daredevil.

4. Punisher MAX

For decades, the mainstream comic industry was constrained by something called the Comics Code Authority €“ to get the sort of widespread distribution that got comics on newsstands as well as in speciality stores, publishers had to adhere to a lot of strict rules that regulated the amount of swearing, violence and black people allowed in a comic. If you didn't meet those standards, the comics would be censored or else rejected. In the early noughties, Marvel realised they didn't need the CCA's approval any more, and started up the MAX publishing line which told stories that were strictly for adults. Which meant Nick Fury ordering scores of sex workers to his room and cursing a lot, mainly. But it also meant Frank Castle was no longer constrained to the strangely bloodless world of regular Marvel, and Garth Ennis wrote sixty-plus issues where The Punisher barely interacted with superheroes, instead dispensing ultra-violent vigilante justice. Hey, that sounds a lot like the first season of Netflix's Daredevil series!

3. Marvel Knights

Before they went all-out mature readers with the MAX line, Marvel dipped their collective toe into more experimental waters with their €œMarvel Knights€ imprint. It was there that, amongst other things, Mark Millar told an out-of-continuity Spider-Man story, Daredevil got his groove back under Brian Michael Bendis, and The Punisher shone once more, too. All the characters beneath the Marvel Knights umbrella were formally introduced in a crossover miniseries of the same name, in which Daredevil and The Punisher were key players alongside Black Widow, Luke Cage (also to be part of the MCU as of Netflix's Jessica Jones), Moon Knight, teen hero Dagger and Shang-Chi, Master Of Kung Fu! The unnamed Marvel Knights squad is a superhero team formed by Daredevil, but a spectacularly dysfunctional one which frequently fights amongst itself or just plain doesn't get on. Again, Defenders is on the horizon, which will be Netflix's big street-level hero team-up. Seeing Matt try (and fail) before that, with The Punisher at his side, could work.

2. The Devil, Inside And Out

Ed Brubaker and Michael Lark had some considerable shoes to fill, as they took over from Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev's marathon run on Daredevil that defined the character for a whole new generation. Undaunted, the new creative team took the ball and ran with it, picking up exactly where the incumbents left off. That, by the way, was with Matt Murdock's secret identity having been outed by Wilson Fisk, before being arrested by the FBI and jailed alongside the Kingpin of crime and a whole score of supervillains just itching to get some shiv-shaped revenge on the Man Without Fear who put them there in the fist place. How could Daredevil possibly survive in such a place? He gets some unexpected help. Turns out Frank Castle is also serving some jail time, so Matt reluctantly teams up with The Punisher during a prison riot-turned-jailbreak. It's an uneasy alliance, a really damn cool story, and Netflix can reuse their Orange Is The New Black sets.

1. Welcome Back, Frank

Really, what all the fans are gunning for with The Punisher's introduction to Daredevil is that Netflix and Marvel might finally give a proper adaptation to Frank Castle's finest hour. Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon are widely agreed upon to be the best creative team ever to work on the character €“ beginning with their first arc, €œWelcome Back, Frank€. The Punisher had been through the wilderness, and barely made it. Nobody could quite decide on whether he was a villain, hero, or anti-hero €“ whether Frank Castle should be admired, sympathised with, or admonished. Ennis and Dillon went with €œall of the above€, crafting a complex character readers could get on board with. Which isn't to say his more deplorable traits weren't in effect (he still kills a lot of people), but it was within the framework of a crime story that would very much fit into the type of show Daredevil has set itself up to be. It may be a touch familiar to audiences, thanks to being the source material to the 2004 Punisher film but... John Travolta was in that. It might be a bit left-field to adapt a Punisher storyline for Daredevil's show €“ Matt makes only a fleeting appearance in the comics €“ but it fits the themes and structure of the first season, and would let Bernthal shine as he deserves.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/