DC Vs Marvel: Who Is Winning The Superhero TV War?

Arrow Vs Daredevil, The Flash Vs Agent Carter: Who is coming out on top?

Marvel and DC have been churning out huge cinematic superheroes for the big screen for decades now. While DC certainly had the edge with Richard Donner's Superman and Tim Burton's Batman, Marvel finally got the budget, vision and effects to bring huge franchises like Spider-Man and X-Men onto film. With the release of Iron Man and the shared universe that culminated in The Avengers, Marvel finally got the edge over DC, who - aside from the critical success of The Dark Knight trilogy - is now scrambling to replicate the shared universe template, using Man Of Steel as a platform for finally bringing The Justice League to the big screen. On TV, the superhero genre has been a rather different affair. In many ways it has been around longer - just look at the 60's Batman TV show for example - but it is in the last couple of years that it has really started to take off in the fashion of its big screen counterparts. The CW now have the interconnected Arrow and The Flash, with Legends Of Tomorrow on its way, while ABC is tapping into the shared Marvel Cinematic Universe with Agents Of SHIELD and Agent Carter. But which is better? It is a little less clear cut than the big screen Marvel and DC movies. With less budget, less effects, TV superheroes can feel a little less flashy than Superman or Captain America. But done right, they can make for great entertainment. This article looks at what led up to the likes of The Flash and Agent Carter, what Marvel and DC TV shows are currently airing and ask, on the small screen, who is winning the TV superhero war?


10. DC's Early Superhero TV Shows: From Batman To Smallville

DC characters have been on the small screen for decades. As far back as the 1950's George Reeves featured as the man of steel in the popular Adventures Of Superman. But DC's most famous live-action TV series is the wildly camp but loveable Batman that saw Adam West and Burt Ward take on Batman and Robin for 120 episodes over three seasons. With memorable performances from Frank Gorshin as The Riddler, Julie Newmar and Eartha Kitt as Catwoman and Cesar Romero as the Joker, the Batman series was a major part of superhero TV history, even if was closer to the awful Batman And Robin movie in tone then Christopher Nolan's dark and dramatic Dark Knight trilogy. The 1970's followed with Linda Carter as Wonder Woman, another iconic DC character that ran on television for three years. While the 1980's was a bit of a wilderness for comic-based superheroes on TV, it came back in force in the 1990's with the first major attempt at a TV adaptation of The Flash, starring John Wesley Shipp as the speedster and Mark Hamill as the villainous Trickster. Both actors found roles in the new series of The Flash, Shipp as Barry's father and Hamill as the same character. But while this series ran for a single season, it was Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman that proved massively popular. It's villains were absolutely rubbish, but it was the chemistry between Dean Cain's Clark Kent and Teri Hatcher's Lois Lane that everyone tuned in for. Superman proved the inspiration again for another popular DC TV adaptation: Smallville. Focusing on early years of Clark Kent, it brought in many iconic heroes, from Hawkman to Green Arrow into its mythos as it ran for a full decade, one of the longest runs for a cult TV show at the time. Before the current phase of superhero TV shows, if you were to ask anyone what the biggest or most popular superhero TV shows of all time were, the chances are the 60's Batman, 70's Wonder Woman, 90's Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman and the 2000's Smallville would be high on that list.

9. Marvel's Attempt At Live Action: The Incredible Hulk

Can Marvel say the same? Well there is one major contender to the mighty DC throne: The Incredible Hulk starring Bill Bixby as David Banner and Lou Ferrigno as the Hulk. As popular as Batman and Wonder Woman but darker and more thought-provoking too, it centred on the mental as well as the physical struggle between Banner and the Hulk and ran for a massive five seasons. The Incredible Hulk even returned for three TV movies, the first two of which were notable for the guest-starring superheroes; Thor in The Incredible Hulk Returns and Daredevil in The Trial of the Incredible Hulk. Both were set up as back-door pilots for TV shows featuring these heroes but they never materialised. The only other notable Marvel superhero TV show that ran at the same time was The Amazing Spider-Man which also ran on CBS, though this was never as popular as The Incredible Hulk. The Marvel live-action pickings are slim after this point. Mutant X was a rather pathetic attempt to do something with the X Men mythos while the arguably better Blade: The Series ran for just a single season. In the precursor to the Arrow-verse and Marvel Cinematic Universe TV shows, DC definitely wins on the live action front.

8. The Animated Years: X-Men Or Batman: The Animated Series?

Of could it would be remiss not to look at the many animated shows that adapted Marvel and DC superheroes for TV. The beauty of a good superhero cartoon is that budget is no issue and indeed audiences have witnessed some pretty epic storylines translated to the TV screen. The 90's were perhaps the golden age for animated superhero television with X Men, Batman: The Animated Series and Spider-Man proving to be definite Saturday morning viewing for kids - young and old. If DC has proven to be the most consistent with live action TV shows over the years, then perhaps Marvel have had the edge on the animated front. Spider-Man, Spider Woman, Iron Man, Fantastic Four and various incarnations of the X Men have appeared in animated form over the years, leading up to modern classics like Marvel's Ultimate Spider-Man, Avengers and Hulk and the Agents Of Smash. Add in dramatic retellings of storylines like the Phoenix saga and Marvel has served animated television well. On the DC front, it isn't quite as spectacular. Batman: The Animated Series might be one of the finest superhero TV shows of all time - live action included - but other attempts haven't gained quite the appeal of the Marvel counterparts. Teen Titans and Batman Beyond tried something new, while some of the attempts at the Justice League were a bit bland and the less said about Krypto the Superdog the better. If DC ruled live action superhero TV shows then Marvel have consistently won the battle when it comes to their animated counterparts.

7. Arrow And The Start Of Modern Superhero Television

Three years ago marked a turning point in superhero television, though few would have guessed it at the time. Arrow was another new standalone superhero show, riding the wave of big superhero movies, but many assumed it would be just the latest successor to Smallville, which finished on The CW network a year earlier. But it was different. It fully embraced a full-fledged superhero on the small screen and its mix of Lost-style flashbacks and increasingly engaging cast made it a hit, finishing of its debut year with a shocking and unexpected finale. With seasons two and three it has continued to mine the DC universe, bringing in new characters like Black Canary, Atom and memorable villains like Deathstroke. It has even drawn on the Dark Knight trilogy for inspiration, bringing in the League of Shadows and the big bad himself, Ra's AL Ghul. Arrow had a thrilling second season and a mixed if still epic third and hasn't been afraid to draw on its comic-book roots, proving that superheroes can work on the small screen as much as the big.

6. The Marvel Cinematic Universe On The Small Screen: The Birth, Fall And Resurrection Of SHIELD

DC might have ruled ruled the silver screen with Superman and Batman, but then Iron Man and the birth of The Avengers changed all that. Suddenly superheroes lived in the same movie universe, even crossing over and teaming up just as they did in the comics from where they came. As phase 1 can to a triumphant end, Marvel naturally wanted to get in on the TV front as well. Agents Of SHIELD struggled in its early days; the expectation of following The Avengers and Joss Whedon on a executive producer meant it could never possibly live up to expectations. More than that, the show failed to get the balance right between humour and drama and by failing to utilise existing characters from the comics, the cast felt a little...bland. The events of Captain America: The Winter Soldier changed all that as the war with HYDRA changed the dynamic of the show and season two finally became the confident, dramatic show audiences had been expecting from day one. The arrival of comic-based characters like Mockingbird certainly helped and leading the Marvel Cinematic Universe's introduction into The Inhumans, rather than relying on the movies for inspiration, was another step towards it success. With Secret Warriors looking to be adapted for the small screen in season three, the best might be yet to come. There is also another show that found its footing from day one and has arguably been more critically successful in its first eight episode run than all of Agents Of SHIELD's two seasons. Agent Carter did something special with the Marvel Cinematic Universe and created an origin show for SHIELD while utilizing the successful character of Peggy Carter to create a slick, fun, female-led show in a way that the movies have yet to do. Captain Marvel might be the first Marvel female superhero-centric film, but Agent Carter got their first, proving that you don't need a Norse god or a man in an iron suit to succeed. Thankfully UK audiences will finally get to experience Agent Carter for themselves when it debuts on Fox this month.

5. The Arrow-Verse Gets Bigger: Enter The Flash

Proving that there are some occasions where a spin-off show can be more popular than the original, The Flash has demonstrated in just one year how to do a superhero TV show right. The viewing figures for its pilot episode were huge and it only went on to become more of a success each week. Fully embracing its comic roots in a way even Arrow never did, audiences watched as the Flash faced off against villains like The Weather Wizard, Trickster, a telepathic Gorilla called Grodd and of course the Reverse Flash itself. It had confidence, loveable characters, brilliant action sequences and ventured further in its first season where other shows might not get to in three. It is a testament to is success that it is already jumping into the Flash multi-verses in the eagerly anticipated season two. But part of the success of The Flash and Arrow this year are their willingness to embrace the wider universe both shows share. The main heroes have already popped up in each others series while supporting characters like Felicity, Cisco, Joe and Ray regularly visit each other cities and team up to provide essential support and aid the characters from the visiting show in working on their own mysteries. Despite a little bit of confusion over Arrow's involvement at the end of the first season of The Flash, it has always felt like these shows exist harmoniously, while neither have sacrificed the tone of their own show. Arrow remains dark and broody while The Flash stays fun and knowingly hokey even when things are at their worst. With the producers confirming more crossovers in the future, the universe of Arrow and The Flash remains as big and bright as ever.

4. Gotham To Constantine: DC's Further Attempts At Standalone Series

Of course, just because the Arrow-verse has expanded and Agents Of SHIELD and Agent Carter all tie neatly until the Marvel Cinematic Universe, that doesn't mean every superhero TV show is connected. DC continue to lead the way on the small screen with more and more of their characters finding their way onto TV. Whether these are as successful remains to be seen; certainly none of the other DC-based shows share the same success as Arrow or The Flash. Constantine is an interesting show. Presumably not dark enough for a network and yet failing to gain wider audiences, it failed after its first year. Gotham on the other hand feels a little Smallville in concept with its focus on the early days of Detective Gordon and every villain Batman ever faced. The only thing missing in this Batman TV show is Batman, making audiences wonder why the show is bothering in the first place. It has gained enough viewers to get a second season but will it really ever get to where it needs to; i,e, the introduction of the Caped Crusader? DC are certainly winning in quantity but against larger connected superhero TV universes, can individual shows survive in isolation?

3. The Birth Of The Defenders: Daredevil On Netflix

With the Arrow / The Flash juggernaut - and another spin-off to follow - it has been looking like a one-side battle with DC succeeding over Marvel on the superhero TV front. But this year things have started to change. Agent Carter became a critical success, Agents Of SHIELD got a lot better and now the deal between Marvel and Netflix has started to pay dividends. The arrival of Daredevil has been modern-Marvel's first true superhero TV show and a magnificent one at that. Darker, grittier and more violent that what the MCU has done before, Daredevil has been a breathe of fresh air, a show that has the confidence - and platform - to differ from its big-screen counterparts. It is also worth noting that Vincent D'Onofrio's Daredevil produced the finest villain in the MCU since Loki. The success of Daredevil has spurned a second season in 2016, which will introduce another major Marvel character; The Punisher. Not only that, Netflix will have Jessica Jones by the end of the year, Luke Cage and Iron Fist after that before they all team up with Daredevil for The Defenders. If Agent Carter and Agents Of SHIELD have delivered something fresh to the superhero genre, then Daredevil and its Netflix companions will bring a whole host of new superheroes to the small screen in the next couple of years. With that schedule, Marvel can finally complete with the many heroes of the Arrow-verse.

2. The Future for DC: Legends Of Tomorrow And Supergirl

Greg Berlanti, one of the masterminds behind Arrow and The Flash, is certainly not resting on his laurels. Not only is a second spin-off in development, but he is also working on another DC TV show for CBS. It shows a confidence and passion to bring these characters to screen in a way that DC is only just struggling to put together on film. Legends Of Tomorrow in one of the most exciting superhero shows in development; a time travel action show, spinning off from Arrow and The Flash - and featuring both lead heroes in what looks set to be the pilot episode - all while utilising one of the big bads of the DC universe, Vandal Savage. Using an established mix heroes and villains from the original two shows, Atom, White Canary, Captain, Cold, Heat Wave, Firestorm and bringing in fresh heroes Hawkgirl, Jay Jackson and Rip Hunter this could be more epic and dare we saw it more fun than The Flash. Supergirl meanwhile while exist on another network and apparently have some reference to the man of steel itself, though Kara will be the central figure. It continues the brand of fun, almost kooky lead superheroes and demonstrates DC's determination to go bigger and bolder in its TV and film products. There is no word yet whether it will tie into the world of Arrow, but that might happen, making DC's TV superheroes a juggernaut on television as well as film.

1. DC Or Marvel ?

So who comes out on top? Pre-Arrow and Daredevil, DC would have been the clear frontrunner with a number of successful TV adaptations going back to the 1950s. Only The Incredible Hulk had any big star power. Perhaps the trick with Marvel was their focus on animated superheroes; in that arena they certainly excelled. 2015 has certainly seen a turning point for Marvel, and with Daredevil and Agent Carter that is only going to grow and add another layer to the wider Marvel Cinematic Universe. But DC - and The CW network in particular - is still showing how it is done with Arrow, The Flash, Legends Of Tomorrow and Supergirl dominating superhero television. While it maybe isn't as clear cut as it used to be, DC probably still have the edge, if only because the Marvel Netflix shows are still getting going. It might be a different world on the big screen, unless Batman Vs Superman: Dawn Of Justice is a critical success, but the joy of modern superhero adaptations is that you can pick whatever suits you best. And the good thing now is that there is as much on television as there is on film. Great if you love comics and superheroes, not so much if you're finding yourself oversaturated with them. What do you think? Is DC still the clear winner? Or have shows like Daredevil tipped the balance? Please let us know in the comments below...

Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter