Dexter: Ranking His Foes From Worst To Best
After eight years of serial killer drama, Dexter is finally coming to a close. At the time that I'm writing this article, we're three episodes from the end, and though there have certainly been ups and downs throughout the years, there's no denying that Dexter is one of the most electrifying and enjoyable shows on television. This season, Dexter is up against a killer known as the Brain Surgeon, who removes a piece of brain matter from his victims, wraps it in butcher paper, and places it on the doorstep of an expert neuropsychiatrist, Dr. Evelyn Vogel. Vogel's past is intricately intertwined with Dexter's, and he soon finds himself helping her catch the killer. Since we haven't yet reached the end the season, I've decided to leave the Brain Surgeon off of this list. Perhaps when all is said and done, it will be worth revisiting. For now, I've compiled a list of the Big Bads and antagonists from the past seasons of the show and ranked them from worst to best, depending on how interesting their characters were, and what sort of effect they had on Dexter. WARNING: MAJOR SPOILERS WILL FOLLOW! This list compiles villains from each season of the show, so be warned if you aren't caught up!
Honorable Mention: Dexter Morgan
Dexter is, first and foremost, his own worst enemy. He has placed himself in more terrible situations, and made more bad choices, than anyone else in the show. Yes, this is mostly due to his Dark Passenger, but he constantly puts his need to kill before any of his other responsibilities. When he has the chance for a clean getaway, he waits until he can kill the man he's been hunting. And when he encounters a monster, like the Trinity Killer, he idolizes him and pays the ultimate price for his hesitation. Though he's certainly made it this far in the series, one has to question some of Dexter's actions throughout the show. And three episodes from the end, one has to wonder what fatal mistakes he'll make before the final curtain falls.
14. Louis Greene - Seasons 6 & 7
Louis might very well be the show's biggest missed opportunity. We first see him in season 6, as a lab intern under Vince Masuka. He had an intriguing creepiness of his own and appeared to have a special interest in Dexter that bordered on obsession. He and Dex played an interesting game of cat and mouse as audiences tried to decipher what his true motivations were, and what secrets of Dexter's he may have known. At the end of season 6 we're led to believe that he may be the "Big Bad" of season 7, and early fan speculation suggested that perhaps he was Dexter's nephew, the son of Brian Moser, the Ice Truck Killer. Unfortunately Louis ended up being nothing more than a scorned video game developer, mad at Dexter for mocking him. I can't help but feel that the writers had big plans for him that fell short once they started developing season 7, and decided to ultimately kill him off rather early (and in a pretty unspectacular fashion) to focus on other characters. Memorable Moment: Showing up in Dexter's apartment after Dex threatened him to stay away. Ultimately not very smart, but a ballsy move nonetheless.
13. George Washington King - The Skinner - Season 3
Do you not remember The Skinner? I'm not surprised. He was a pretty useless antagonist, who had absolutely no ties to Dexter at all and was someone Dex ignored through most of the show's third season. He has also never been mentioned in the show again after his death in the season 3 finale. He gets his name because of his MO of removing the skin from his victims, either post-mortem or as a method of torture. He starts this as a way to find a man named Freebo, who owes him money for heroin. Freebo is killed by Dexter, but the Skinner doesn't know this and begins torturing people that may know of Freebo's whereabouts. He's eventually hired by Assistant District Attorney Miguel Prado to go after Dexter. Dexter kills Miguel, frames the Skinner for the murder, and then is abducted by him (on his wedding day, no less). The Skinner takes him to a tobacco warehouse in order to skin and torture him, but Dexter escapes and snaps his neck. Though The Skinner is a unique serial killer, he remains pretty low on this list due to the lack of impact he's had on the rest of the show and his pretty lame motives. Memorable Moment: He captures Dexter. Easier said than done!
12. Ray Speltzer - Season 7
Ray appears around the same time that Deb learns that Dexter is a serial killer. He is only present for a couple of episodes, but his impact on Deb and Dex's relationship was big enough to land him a spot on this list. Ray is a psychotic serial killer who lures female victims to his home, then murders them in a grotesque yet unique ritual while wearing a bull horned helmet. He is extremely violent, releases his victims into a handmade maze, then stalks and brutally beats them to death with his bare hands before ripping the earrings off of their corpses to keep as trophies. At this point in their relationship, Debra refuses to accept what Dexter does, even if Harry's code keeps him from killing innocent people. He offers Speltzer as a way to show Debra that he's doing society a favor. At one point, Speltzer catches Dexter and knocks him out before placing him in the maze. Dexter escapes, and Deb later confesses that she wanted to kill Speltzer and that he's a prime example of the flaws in the system. Dexter then tracks down and kills Speltzer, and when he confesses to Deb what he did, she tells him she's glad. It's the first time Deb is actively involved in one of Dexter's kills, and the way she grapples with feeling glad about Dexter killing him shows that she may not think of the world as strictly black and white anymore.
11. Stan Liddy and Joey Quinn - Season 5
Stan Liddy was a corrupt police officer in the narcotics division, before being fired after a failed sting operation. He's then hired by Joey Quinn to investigate Dexter, because Quinn believes Dexter may be involved in Rita's death. Though an interesting part of season 5, the Liddy/Quinn investigation felt a lot like 'Doakes 2.0,' and the fact that Quinn has never decided to follow-up on his original suspicions of Dexter is just ridiculous. Especially in season 7, when LaGuerta arrests Dexter for being the Bay Harbor Butcher (but more on that later). Memorable Moment: Liddy, to Quinn: "Dexter... the f**k kind of name is Dexter?"
10. Lila West - Season 2
Lila was the first character, besides his brother, to truly understand and embrace who he is, Dark Passenger and all. In fact, she likes that he's a serial killer, and kills James Doakes hoping that that will bring them closer. She's delusional, sociopathic, and an arsonist who will do anything to protect Dexter, who she believes is her soulmate. She also tries burning Dexter, Astor, and Cody alive in her apartment, which gives her a bit higher standing on this list than the previous entries. Their relationship, though flawed (and eventually quite dangerous) was one of the most interesting relationships Dexter has had in the series. Maybe if she hadn't have turned out to be such a lunatic, they could have had a future together. Dexter seems to regret killing her in the end, once again taking the life of someone who loved him for who he was. Memorable Moment: Blows up the cabin where James Doakes is locked-up after he reveals that Dexter is the Bay Harbor Butcher
9. Assistant District Attorney Miguel Prado - Season 3
Assistant District Attorney Miguel Prado was notorious for his harsh enforcement of the law, and shared Dexter's frustration at "cold-blooded killers" being set free. After Dexter accidentally kills Miguel's brother Oscar, Prado embarks on a personal mission of revenge against the man he thinks killed him: Fred "Freebo" Bowman. He catches Dexter killing Freebo, and sympathizes with him (not yet knowing the extent of Dexter's Dark Passenger). The two form a close bond, become best friends, and Dexter eventually trains Miguel as his first apprentice. Dexter and Miguel shared an interesting friendship. Though originally based on a lie, Dexter does feel genuine affection for Miguel, as evidenced by letting him witness the Dark Passenger at work. Unfortunately for Dexter, Miguel betrays this trust by unleashing his own darkness, fueled by a selfish ambition to deal his own personal justice. He kills his rival attorney, Ellen Wolf, and then plans to kill LaGuerta when she becomes suspicious of him. Miguel remains one of the few people that Dexter regrets killing (the other two being Lila and The Ice Truck Killer). Memorable Moment: To Dexter: "I am the last man that you want to f**k with. BECAUSE I WILL F**K YOU BACK! In ways you never even imagined!"
8. Travis Marshall - The Doomsday Killer - Season 6
Season 6 aimed to go back to the show's roots by focusing on a single "big bad," this time being the Doomsday Killer, Travis Marshall. We're led to believe for the majority of the season that Travis is aided by his mentor, Professor James Geller (played by the always awesome Edward James Olmos), though it's revealed that Geller is actually dead. Travis killed him before the season began, and we've only been seeing the hallucination of him that Travis sees. Geller is, ultimately, a physical manifestation of Travis' own Dark Passenger. The Doomsday Killings remain some of the most unique, and graphic, of the entire show. His ritualistic killings recreated images from apocalyptic stories in the Bible, including the Four Horses of the Apocalypse and the Whore of Babylon. He even tries sacrificing Dexter's son, Harrison, which he thinks will mark the beginning of a new world. Dexter stops Travis in time, and brings him back to his church to kill him. For some reason, Marshall doesn't get much love from fans of the show, and is often regarded as one of the worst antagonists. Personally, I thought he was quite interesting, and the reveal that Geller had been dead the whole time was one of the best handled twists in the show. He also has had one of the longest lasting effects on Dexter, since killing Travis led to Deb's discovery of his secret. Memorable Moment: Killing his own sister and displaying her as The Whore of Babylon at the school where she worked.
7. Jordan Chase - Season 5
Jordan Chase (born Eugene Greer) was overweight in his youth. He discovered that he had an ability to manipulate others, and used his gift to build himself a future. He's the author of "Take It Now," a motivational book and audio cassette that gained him fame across the world. He's also the founding member of "The Group," a five-man organization that kidnapped, tortured, raped, and murdered various women before placing them in barrels and dumping them into a swamp. The other members of The Group were childhood friends of Chase, who he manipulated and controlled, resulting in the death of twelve women. The case at Miami Homicide would become known as the Barrel Girl Case. Chase is one of the most ruthless, and downright evil, killers in the show. The sheer heinous nature of his crimes makes even the biggest fans of the show a bit queasy. He's an interesting character with a deep, psychological backstory that unfolds rather well on screen. His character also functioned as a way for Dexter to face his feelings about Rita's death and move on from it by taking on Lumen Pierce, Chase's latest victim, as an apprentice. Chase is, interestingly, the first major antagonist not to be killed by Dexter. Memorable Moment: Facing death without any remorse or regret about his crimes.
6. Captain Maria LaGuerta - Season 7
Though Maria LaGuerta was a recurring cast member since the pilot episode, she didn't become a foe of Dexter's until the show's seventh season. While investigating the crime scene left at Travis Marshall's church, she comes across a blood slide left at the scene. This prompts her to start re-investigating the Bay Harbor Butcher case, which everyone thinks is closed thanks to Dexter's framing of Sgt. Doakes. We never really got a glimpse of LaGuerta's detective side until season 7, and I believe it was handled quite well. In the past her character always seemed a bit annoying, and any story revolving around her wasn't very interesting or important to the larger themes at hand. The writers truly gave her some great moments in season 7, including how well she manages to figure out Dexter's secret, and Deb's involvement in it, before ultimately paying the price. Though writers have (at this point, at least) failed to truly capitalize on her death in the season 7 finale, her last few episodes delivered some of the most exciting, intense moments of the entire series. She definitely went out with a bang. Memorable Moment: Arresting Dexter for being the Bay Harbor Butcher.
5. Isaak Sirko - Season 7
Isaak Sirko is the head of the Koshka Brotherhood, who comes to Miami to avenge the death of his lover, Victor, who was killed by Dexter. Sirko is a cold, brutal, killing machine, leaving a trail of bodies in his wake, which Dexter quickly notices. Dexter tries to have Isaak killed by a rival Columbian gang, but underestimates Isaak's skills. Isaak kills the men with ease but is arrested, nonetheless. The two form an interesting relationship, after Isaak is let out of prison and attempts to kill Dexter, and the two men develop a mutual respect for one another. Isaak tells Dexter that, "under different circumstances, we could have been good friends." Isaak is eventually killed by assassins, and Dexter dumps his body at sea so that he may rest with Victor. Though he may not have left the show as a villain, he remains one of the most intriguing antagonists in the entire series. He shows no mercy when hunting Dexter, yet is able to overcome his need for revenge in order to conquer a common enemy. Aspects of his character are revealed slowly and interestingly throughout the season, and his final scene on the boat with Dexter remains one of the most memorable of season 7. Memorable Moment: Forcing a man to write a fake suicide note, confessing to a crime he didn't commit, to save one of Isaak's men.
4. Special Agent Frank Lundy - Season 2
Special Agent Frank Lundy is brought to Miami to investigate the Bay Harbor Butcher case, when the bodies Dexter has been dropping into the ocean are found by divers. He is famous for his ability to break seemingly impossible, high-profile cases, often coming in and discovering crucial evidence that the local police department overlooked. Lundy comes dangerously close to discovering that Dexter is the Butcher. So close, in fact, that Dexter has to frame Sgt. Doakes in order to keep from getting caught. Lundy has an interesting, unorthodox personality that makes him incredibly interesting to watch, such as his enjoyment of the "little things" in life, like his cucumber cream cheese sandwiches, every day at 1 o'clock. His romantic relationship with Deb has had tremendous lasting effects on her character throughout the show, and I would argue that Dexter learned more by trying to outsmart Lundy than he's learned from his various victims. Memorable Moment: Taking one look at a fake letter Dexter wrote hoping to throw them off his trail, and deciding that the Butcher must be someone who works in law enforcement. Excellent police work, Lundy!
3. Sgt. James Doakes - Seasons 1 & 2
It's a shame that Sergeant James Doakes was so good at his job, because it's what ultimately wound up killing him. He was arguably one of the most interesting, and likable characters in the entire series. We saw in season 1 that he got the creeps from Dexter, but he never acted on his suspicions about the blood spatter analyst until season 2. Unfortunately for Doakes, this leads him right into Dexter's hands, as he's captured and kept in a cage until his death. It's unfortunate that a man like Doakes will be remembered as the Bay Harbor Butcher, because he truly was the best cop at Miami Metro. What really makes his character so memorable isn't his memorable, badass use of expletives, but the honest conversations he has with Dexter towards the end of the season. Up until that point Dexter had no one to talk to about his inner demons, and if it weren't for Lila showing up to blow up the cabin, Dexter would have turned himself in. Memorable Moment: "Surprise, MothaF*cka!"
2. Arthur Mitchell - The Trinity Killer - Season 4
Though the Trinity Killer takes the top spot on most "Best Dexter Foes" lists, he's missing one key aspect that would have placed him as my number 1. However, more on that in a minute. Arthur Mitchell, played wonderfully by John Lithgow (who received a Golden Globe and Emmy for the role), is the main antagonist in season 4 and has had one of the biggest effects on Dexter as a character: he kills Dexter's wife, Rita. Mitchell had been killing people using the same pattern for over 30 years, going unnoticed to all except for Agent Lundy, now retired. His cycle contained three murders: He would cut a woman's leg in a bathtub, letting her bleed to death. Then, he would force a mother to jump from a parking garage to her death. Finally, he would lure a man down a dark alleyway and bludgeon him to death. He had a fourth murder in each cycle that Lundy didn't know about, which was to take an innocent child and bury him alive in cement (using his charitable house-building project as a cover). Dexter was amazed by Trinity, and looked up to him as an idol. He had lived a seemingly normal life for decades, had a loving family, and was able to carry out his murders without being caught. Dexter slowly forces his way into Trinity's life, trying to find ways to learn from him and live a similar lifestyle. Little did Dexter know that Trinity was actually an incredibly damaged man, whose family lived in constant fear of him. The Thanksgiving meal that Dexter shares with the family remains one of the most brilliant, intense scenes in the entire series. But, of course, Dexter's idolization of Trinity doesn't come without a cost. Dexter had, on several occasions, the chance to kill Trinity, but chose not to out of selfish reasons. Once Trinity discovered who Dexter was, he committed his final murder. After Dexter finally killed Trinity and dumped his body into the ocean, he came home to find his wife Rita dead in a bathtub full of blood, her leg cut open, the final victim of the Trinity killer. And Trinity left Dexter's son Harrison sitting in a pool of his mother's blood, an image that reflects Dexter's own beginning. Memorable Moment: Murdering Rita and leaving Harrison in a pool of her blood, while giving Dexter no hint of the deed when on his table.
1. Brian Moser - The Ice Truck Killer - Season 1
And last, but certainly not least, we come to the best foe Dexter has had to face: his own brother, The Ice Truck Killer. I mentioned that Trinity was missing one aspect that I believe puts ITK above him: the personal connection to Dexter that makes the first season of the show so magnificent to watch. Yes, Trinity commits the most shocking murder in the entire series, but the revelation that Brian Moser is Dexter's older brother changed Dexter's character forever. The two brothers were separated when Harry chose to save Dexter from the shipping container where their mother was murdered, and leave Brian behind. Harry believed that Brian was too damaged to be saved, which arguably led to him becoming the ITK. Both brothers ended up becoming serial killers, but Dexter had one thing Brian didn't: Harry's code. The dichotomy of the two characters is fascinating, especially considering that the final reveal happens in the season finale. Throughout the season, ITK has been toying with Dexter, leaving him clues and cryptic messages at crime scenes and on his own doorstep. I would argue that the show has failed to reach the same level of brilliance that is displayed in its first season, as Dexter's fascination with ITK makes him question his own methods as a killer. As the season drew to a close, Brian kidnapped Deb, hoping that he and Dexter could kill her together and be reunited as brothers. Instead, Dexter turns on his brother and kills him, staging it to make it look like a suicide. It's a heart-wrenching, emotional, and pivotal moment when Dexter sits in the corner of the room, crying, as he kills the one man on Earth who can truly, and fully, understand him. Memorable Moment: Proposes to Deb, then knocks her out and puts her in a kill room for Dexter.