Doctor Who: 8 Reasons It Will Be Better After Matt Smith

matt-smith_doctor_who11 After much gnashing of teeth it was recently revealed that Peter Capaldi has been cast to replace Matt Smith as everyone's favorite time and space travelling Doctor. This of course has led to a lot of online hand-wringing over the future of the show. This is a common occurrence any time The Doctor regenerates. We typically spend several years getting to know The Doctor and when it comes time to replace him everyone is quick to declare " The show can't possibly be as good as it was with (insert your favorite Doctor here)". The new Doctor is typically greeted with trepidation. This is shortly followed by acceptance and a statement along the lines of "Oh, I see. they totally got that choice right. Yeah, this show's still pretty awesome." Well now we are back to step one. Everyone is up in arms, ready to write the show off before Matt even says his goodbyes. I for one am not ready to do this. In fact, I believe now is a time to get excited about the future of the show. Sure, it has a few issues but there is much more going for this show than many want to give it credit. So lets explore some of those reasons and maybe you'll find yourself a little more excited for what's in store.

8. Steven Moffat Has To Leave Sooner or Later

Moffat If you ever want to get lost down a fairly disturbing rabbit hole just Google Mr. Moffat. Everyone has an opinion about the show runner, the vast majority of them negative. He's a lazy writer, he relies too heavily on complex story arcs, he leaves too many of those arcs unexplained, he's sexist. There are no shortage of calls to Fire Steven Moffat, or that Steven Moffat Sucks. If you think the man is bad for the show you have plenty of avenues to share your feelings. Well I have good news for you - Steven Moffat can't run the show forever. That's right, sooner or later the man will step aside and cede control of good Doctor to someone else. After all, he's been involved with the show since its return to the airwaves in 2005. He's got to be getting tired of the grind and the naysayers, right? Before you know it he'll be a fading memory and all of our problems will be solved.

7. Clara Should Be Better

600300clara5 Here's another hot button topic for many fans right now. The Doctor's current companion started her show run with a pretty cool debut in Asylum of the Daleks and a good turn in The Snowmen. Yet following her first two episodes she hit a pretty big dry spell. The stories were average, her acting was a little cheesy at times (Ghostbusters!), and for some reason she just didn't seem to connect. My biggest problem with Clara is there was no reason to care about her for several episodes. Sure, the Doctor clearly was interested in her but her character was pretty bland and we didn't know exactly what the big deal was until towards the end of Season 7. Well, now we know. Clara sacrificed herself to save the Doctor (and the universe) and the Doctor got to solve his riddle. Now the two are free to explore the palpable romantic tension that has developed between them. Except Clara's Doctor isn't going to make it to season 8. The man she came to know (and love?) is being replaced by a much older Doctor. As we saw with Rose and the Tenth, there will be some adjusting after the regeneration. Even more exciting is the Doctor's character change that appears to be on the horizon. Clara will have to deal with a totally new personality, one that I think (hope) is going to be a major departure from the last two Doctors. Where Eleven was a goofy, fun loving, yet hauntingly damaged, big kid, the signs point towards the Doctor's past coming back to haunt him for the 50th Anniversary and beyond. Which brings us to.....

6. A Dark Turn For The Show

Who exactly is John Hurt? Christoper Eccleston's Doctor had a dark edge to him. Many attribute this to what happened during the years we did not see the Doctor (the end of the Time War, whatever is up with John Hurt). David Tennant's tenth Doctor and Matt Smith's Eleventh Doctor were much more lighthearted and fun. Sure they both had their share of darker moments but the enduring images of the tenth and eleventh Doctors are much lighter than those that came before them. Well now we are about to find out about a very dark secret the Doctor has harbored. He's also dealing with the final goodbye to River and still likely reeling from the loss of Amy and Rory. All signs point towards towards a much darker version of the Doctor this time around. Some of the best moments for Doctor Who are the ones that show him releasing the raw, damaged man that dwells under the surface. He's spent over 900 years fighting and dying, watching his friends fight and die. Those dark corners of his soul have to hide some juicy stories and it looks like some of those are beginning to bubble to the surface.

5. The Characters

Strax

A large part of our love for Doctor Who comes from the role of the supporting characters. We get to see his world through the eyes of his companions. We've seen him marry a woman who he encountered out of order in time. We've experienced his devastation when he's lost these friends over and over again. We've also gotten to see some amazing villains: The Master, The Silence, The Great Intelligence and of course the Daleks and Cybermen. Right now we're sitting at a crossroads for the show's supporting cast. River Song is gone (at least for now), The Great Intelligence has been defeated and Clara is still pretty new to equation. Over the next couple of seasons we will get to know a brand new Doctor, finally (hopefully) get to know Clara and will likely be introduced to several new friends and villains. The show has always been great at introducing and developing strong characters and there is no reason to believe that will stop now. Plus, more Vastra, Jenny and Strax is a really, REALLY good thing.

4. The Stories

John HurtAlong with the introduction and development of new characters we will get to explore new story lines. We'll have an entirely new Doctor to get to know in season 8. On top of that we get to find out about the whole "What's Up With John Hurt" thing. There is a reason Doctor Who has been so successful. The show has always done a great job of making you care about the characters. Once you care about them the show puts them in harms way. Once they are in danger the Doctor swoops in to save the day. Lather, Rinse, Repeat. The great thing about Doctor Who is that it REALLY puts its characters in harms way. Companions die, or get marooned in parallel dimensions, or trapped in 1930's New York. Heck, even the Doctor dies every few years. The storytelling magic of this show isn't leaving with Matt Smith. Which leads us to.....

3. Steven Moffatt

936full-steven-moffat Hey wait a minute, how can Steven Moffat be a reason for a better Doctor Who after I already said he should leave the show? Well, because it's my article, that's why. Look, I get it, many (most?) of you hate the guy. You can't wait for the day where he is sent packing. You will rejoice and your world will be whole once more. Just one thing: The guy knows how to tell a damn good story. Yes, I'll agree he relies too heavily on convoluted plots and story arcs that drag out over entire seasons. Yes, he has left some plot threads dangling. Consider though, those story arcs have everyone tuning in from week to week. We wanted to know why Amy Pond had a crack in her wall. We all lost our minds when the Doctor eliminated Ganger Amy. We gasped when we found out River was the Gamma Forrest translation of Melody. And those dangling plot threads; who cares, he ties up the important ones. Get over it. Yes, he kills off everyone we love but that just adds to the emotion. We never feel safe with Moffat. Anyone can go at any time. That builds tension and keeps us tuning in. Bottom line, in an era where more and more fans are getting their entertainment from alternate sources (read, not TV), Moffat has increased viewership for Doctor Who while at the helm. People are tuning in to see the man tell his stories. I for one am looking forward to see where he goes next.

2. Peter Capaldi

Doctor Who Peter Capaldi We can debate how the next Doctor was chosen until the cows come home. That's a subject for a different time. The simple fact here and now though is: Peter Capaldi can act. Full Stop. While most people seem to be fixated on his foul mouthed turn on The Thick of It, I think we really need to be keying in on his performance as John Frobisher in Torchwood: Children of Earth. If you haven't seen it I highly recommend a viewing in the very near future. His haunting portrayal of a middle management civil service officer stuck in an impossibly horrible scenario is one of my favorite roles on any film or TV show. His performance brought amazing weight to a show known for campyness. This is doubly important if the series does indeed take a darker turn as I posited earlier. Mr. Capaldi should prove quite adept at exploring the more disturbing aspects of the Doctor's character. I am so confident in the future for Mr. Capaldi that this would have been my #1 reason if it weren't for the fact........

1. It's Doctor Who

0000-560-50th-montage-1-50f485b9 Fifty years folks! This wonderful, amazing, thrilling, spellbinding, heartbreaking, redemptive show has been on the air for fifty years! There's just something about this show, a magic that's hard to explain. Sure, it's had some down times. Some early seasons were largely ignored by viewers. It was dropped and left for dead for several years. Yet the show continues to pick itself up, dust itself off and come back stronger every time. Yes, there is a strong possibility that the show will struggle in Season 8. Heck, Season 7 didn't exactly fire on all cylinders from week to week. Even if it does struggle though the show will find its way. With strong characters, story lines, actors and management, not to mention a rabid fanbase that will hold everyone accountable, the show has all the tools to continue its run of success. We will all miss Matt Smith but the show will be just fine without him. Geronimo!

Contributor
Contributor

A longtime fan of all things Science Fiction, gamer, cinefile, voracious reader and triathlete (one of these things is not like the other). You can find examples of my science fiction writings as well as updates on a hopefully upcoming novel at dwightdwade.blogspot.com