Doctor Who: Every Doctor's First Episode Ranked Worst To Best
Establishing yourself as the next Doctor is a tough job that can have wildly varying results...
The longer that Doctor Who goes on, the harder it has to be for a new Doctor to make an instant impression. Not only do they have to assert their presence as a lead, they're the latest torchbearer of a 60-year legacy, desperately trying not to drop it and set the TARDIS ablaze.
Fan wisdom suggests that the first episode of any Doctor will never go down in history as their best. There's certainly some truth in this, as it can take actors a few episodes before they settle into the role.
That's presumably why the trope of 'post-regenerative trauma' was created, to allow for the new Doctor to work out what they want to do with the character.
The best Doctor Who debuts are the ones that hit the ground running. Look at Matt Smith popping his head out of a crashed TARDIS in The Eleventh Hour, or Tom Baker karate chopping bricks in Robot. You immediately buy them as the Doctor, and are quickly swept into their next adventure.
So, with that in mind, which of our 15 main Doctors hit the ground running, and which flop out of the TARDIS with a whimper?
15. The Twin Dilemma
The Twin Dilemma is notorious for its companion-throttling scene, so let's not dwell on it. It's there, it's not good, but it's not the only issue with the Sixth Doctor's debut story.
In fact, Colin Baker's brash and bombastic Doctor isn't even the problem with The Twin Dilemma. After the unpleasantness of the opening episodes, he makes an immediate impression, a righteous crusader who is in sharp contrast to Peter Davison's meek moralising.
Rather, the biggest problem with The Twin Dilemma is its placing at the very end of Doctor Who Season 21. The money has clearly run out, and the script could've benefitted from some more attention during the gap before Season 22.
There was a good reason for putting it at the end of a season however, rather than at the beginning. Producer John Nathan-Turner was worried that strike action may have seriously impacted production on Season 22, so brought Colin Baker's debut forward to avoid it being derailed.
Unfortunately, that debut was already derailed by having to follow the dark and gritty The Caves of Androzani, with a story about some twins that were really good at maths.
14. Castrovalva
Castrovalva has some amazing moments, from the TARDIS being lured to the Big Bang, to Castrovalva folding in on itself. However, as a debut for the Fifth Doctor, there's not much of him in it for the first two episodes.
The main dramatic thrust of Episode One is his need to have a good nap. And then in Episode Two, the sleeping Doctor gets carted around in a little TARDIS wardrobe by Tegan and Nyssa. After all that rest, he's still not up to full strength by Episode Three.
Castrovalva relies on the companions to lead the story in the Doctor's absence, which works when the companion is an established character like Clara or Rose. Tegan and Nyssa have only been around for a few episodes prior to Castrovalva, making them almost as much of a mystery as this new amnesiac Doctor.
Adric is the longest-serving character at this point in Doctor Who, but he's trussed up in the Master's climbing frame for the majority of the story.
With so many characters unable to establish their presence, the Fifth Doctor's debut feels quite wishy-washy, setting the tone for the whole era.
13. The Star Beast
The Star Beast is a hard one to judge, because its central premise relies on viewers seeing the Fourteenth Doctor as an aged version of the Tenth.
But Fourteen never establishes himself as a new incarnation with an old face. Instead, he's just the Tenth Doctor but with stubble and bags under his eyes.
On the plus side, that means any tedious post-regeneration amnesia is quickly dispensed with, as the Doctor's crisis becomes a core part of the story. Why has the Doctor chosen that face? What will it do to Donna Noble?
On the downside, The Star Beast just feels like a throwback to 2008, and doesn't signal some bold new era for Doctor Who. While that's very obviously the point (this was the big 60th anniversary party, after all), that makes it a strange entry in the long history of Doctor debuts.
12. Time And The Rani
Like The Twin Dilemma, Sylvester McCoy's debut story Time and the Rani was hampered by behind-the-scenes drama. This time, it was the dramatic exit of script editor Eric Saward, and the firing of Colin Baker.
Saward's departure meant that John Nathan-Turner had to find a replacement quickly, and also meant that there was a dearth of workable scripts. Colin Baker's refusal to film a regeneration scene meant that the Seventh Doctor's debut came out of a fairly unremarkable end for his predecessor.
It's a minor miracle that Time and the Rani even got made, and it's a lot better than many would have you believe. It marks a significant upgrade to Doctor Who's VFX, and Sylvester McCoy is great fun as the Seventh Doctor.
However, the tedious aliens and the Rani's giant brain can feel like an embarrassing hangover from the worst sci-fi tropes of 1980s Doctor Who.
Time and the Rani doesn't resemble what the McCoy era would quickly become, meaning that many see the superior Paradise Towers as the true start of the Seventh Doctor's era.
11. The Church On Ruby Road
There are moments in The Church on Ruby Road that announce Ncuti Gatwa as a brand-new type of Time Lord. The scene of the kilt-wearing, gin and tonic-saving Doctor dancing in a nightclub affirms that this is an incarnation who wants to savour every moment and experience.
The Doctor's rooftop dash to hang with Ruby on the Goblin Ship is joyous, while Gatwa excels at delivering hand-wavey dialogue about the language of rope. In this respect, The Church on Ruby Road does its job at establishing who this new incarnation is.
So it's incredibly disappointing that the majority of the episode takes place in Ruby's flat. It's hard to see the Doctor truly fly when they're moving from cramped room to cramped room.
Things pick up again when the Doctor travels back to save baby Ruby, but there's a constricting atmosphere to much of 2023's Christmas special, that feels like it's keeping Ncuti back from properly letting loose as the Doctor.
Thankfully though, the policeman scene was added to give the Doctor more screentime early on. It's a moment that allows Gatwa to flex his Doctor muscles, and he nails the kindness and confidence of the character in the span of a few lines.
10. Deep Breath
Peter Capaldi's debut as the Twelfth Doctor was an atmospheric Victorian horror movie with dinosaurs, but it dials down the fun of that premise way too much.
Deep Breath is emblematic of the mistakes that were made during Capaldi's first series. It's a strong run of episodes, but the Twelfth Doctor is rarely afforded the chance to lighten up a little.
Still, there are some great set-pieces in Deep Breath, from the Doctor and Clara's tense meeting in the restaurant, to the unveiling of his new costume and TARDIS colour scheme. The scene where the Doctor reveals that he didn't abandon Clara after all is a proper punch-the-air moment that confirms this more abrasive incarnation is still the same character underneath.
By the end of Deep Breath, Capaldi has arrived as an older, more serious Doctor, but still the same hero that we've followed for 50 years.
Which is why it's utterly insane for Steven Moffat to write in that scene where Matt Smith tells Clara, and the audience, not to worry about the grumpy old man not being boyfriend material.
9. The Christmas Invasion
The Christmas Invasion runs the risk of making the same mistakes that Castrovalva did way back in 1982. However, it's thanks to Billie Piper's brilliant performance as Rose Tyler that the modern era's first post-regeneration story works as well as it does.
Ultimately, it's the story of the Doctor just needing a good lie down all over again, but with a bit of Christmas tinsel. However, the absence of the Doctor adds to the drama of the worsening situation with the Sycorax. If he doesn't wake up quickly and be the Doctor again, Earth is going to fall to an alien invasion.
Rose is the audience identification figure throughout, gradually coming around to the new Doctor, and reassuring the viewers at home that the new guy is going to be pretty great.
David Tennant then gets his big hero moment by ripping off The Lion King, defeating the Sycorax leader in a sword fight, and flinging a tangerine at a handily-placed button. It doesn't get more Doctorish than that.
8. The TV Movie
Say what you like about the 1996 TV Movie, there's no doubting Paul McGann's magnetic performance as the Eighth Doctor.
While it's a bit too mired in decades of Doctor Who continuity to be an effective introduction for a brand-new audience, it's still a pretty great introduction to a brand-new Doctor.
Grace Holloway is the Dana Scully to the Doctor's Fox Mulder, struggling to believe the impossible things she's seeing unfold before her very eyes. Paul McGann's breathless delivery and vibrant energy shows that he completely understands how to reinvent the character of the Doctor for a '90s audience.
While it leans heavily into the post-regenerative amnesia trope, Matthew Jacobs' script never forgets to make the Doctor our hero, giving him big romantic and heroic moments as he begins to remember who he is.
Sadly, the TV Movie never led to more live-action adventures for the Eighth Doctor, but its failure to take off in America was nothing to do with Paul McGann.
7. The Woman Who Fell To Earth
From the minute that Jodie Whittaker's Thirteenth Doctor crashes through the roof of that train, she hits the ground running. Chris Chibnall's script for The Woman Who Fell to Earth wastes no time in letting the first female Doctor take charge of the situation.
As a debut story for both a new Doctor and a new showrunner, The Woman Who Fell to Earth establishes a more grounded and realistic urban setting than some of Russell T Davies' best work. The images of Sheffield at night as an alien trophy hunter rampages through the streets felt like a very modern take on Doctor Who.
And not only was The Woman Who Fell to Earth a great debut for Jodie Whittaker, it felt like a reinvention of the show that marked a clear departure from the Moffat era.
That doesn't quite carry over into the rest of the Chibnall and Whittaker era, but what does is Whittaker's infectiously enthusiastic portrayal of the Doctor. She does it all in this episode: she faces down weird cable monsters, investigates a space mushroom, builds a new sonic, and even finds time for a nap.
Take that, Fifth Doctor!
6. Robot
No actor has ever grasped the Doctor with as much enthusiasm as Tom Baker. That's clear from his very first story, Robot, in which he commands your attention from the moment he sits up in the UNIT laboratory.
Placing Tom Baker's Doctor in a UNIT story is a perfect way to show how this fourth incarnation is different from his immediate predecessor. The Fourth Doctor is far shabbier and rough around the edges than the sharply-dressed Third Doctor, and this difference in style carries over into the science.
For example, it's hard to imagine the Third Doctor lobbing a bucket of a metal-eating virus over the enormous K-1 robot – that would've been more of a Sergeant Benton job. But here, the Fourth Doctor gamely leans out of the side of Bessie and flings a pail of the solution all over the giant rampaging android.
Overall, Robot is a hugely enjoyable story that does a great job setting up the tone of the Tom Baker era.
5. Rose
The first episode of Doctor Who's 2005 revival had a big job to do, and the fact that we're all sitting here in 2024 proves that it surpassed all expectations.
Rose is a Doctor Who episode that fizzes with chaotic energy. From burping wheelie bins to plastic Mickeys, there's a cartoonish aesthetic to Russell T Davies' 2005 relaunch, but it's grounded by Christopher Eccleston's excellent performance.
Where other actors in the role may have leaned into the chaos, Eccleston's matter-of-fact performance makes you believe in some of Rose's more outlandish moments. Which is exactly what you want from your Doctor.
Both a brand-new character and the Doctor that older fans knew and loved, Eccleston truly is phenomenal in Rose. He's a 21st century upgrade of the chilly outsider we first met in a junkyard, and despite being battered and bruised, he retains the charisma of his previous incarnations.
4. The Eleventh Hour
The Eleventh Hour had to make sure that Doctor Who could survive the loss of David Tennant and Russell T Davies. By the time the episode finished, the show's future was assured, thanks to an exceptional performance by Matt Smith as the Eleventh Doctor.
Steven Moffat writes a deceptively simple story of an alien prisoner loose on Earth, which allows Smith the chance to demonstrate every facet of the modern Doctor. We get the chaotic energy of the fish fingers and custard scene, the poetry of the apple, and the big confrontational speech on a rooftop.
Smith pulls all of this off beautifully, and gives the most fully-formed Doctor performance since Tom Baker in Robot. His awkward physicality is brilliant for the new Doctor, like a baby gazelle learning to run.
On top of this, there's Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill bringing sitcom couple energy to Doctor Who, Olivia flippin' Colman, the Doctor literally eyeballing one of the monsters-of-the-week, and a long-overdue cameo by Sir Patrick Moore.
It's one of Doctor Who's most confident and thrilling debuts. The Eleventh Hour? More like The Finest Hour!
3. The Power Of The Daleks
The Power of the Daleks introduces the concept that the Doctor can change their face by "renewal", but doesn't get bogged down in the minutiae of how the process works.
Instead, it kicks into gear with one of the greatest Dalek stories of all time. David Whitaker's Dalek scripts are always a joy, because he writes them not as unthinking robots, but as sneaky, manipulative aliens. Here, they position themselves as compliant servants, but they're secretly plotting against everyone on Vulcan.
It was a genius move to pit a brand-new Doctor against the Daleks. After all, between 1963 and 1965 they were arguably the biggest stars that Doctor Who had produced. Bringing them back for Patrick Troughton's first story means that the pressure is taken off him as he finds his feet.
Not that Troughton wastes any time – he's instantly charming as the Second Doctor, retaining the impishness of Hartnell's incarnation, but dialling it all the way up.
Many Doctor Who actors say they don't feel like they've "arrived" until they face the Daleks. Troughton does that on day one, and the rest is history.
2. An Unearthly Child
Okay, yes, An Unearthly Child introduces us to a lead character who is a kidnapper and potential murderer. That's not the Doctor Who we would come to know and love.
However, Doctor Who's first 25 minutes should be taught in schools. The way that it builds up the mystery of Susan Foreman and her enigmatic grandfather is masterful.
The atmospheric foggy streets and the creepy old junkyard add to the sense of foreboding around what lies behind the gates of I.M. Foreman. And then, finally, the Doctor arrives, emerging out of the fog, coughing and spluttering, and deeply suspicious of these trespassing teachers.
This isn't quite the Doctor that we'll grow to love, but the way that he tries to teach a disbelieving Ian and Barbara about the TARDIS is great. This won't be the last time that he has to try and explain insanely complicated scientific theories to pudding-brained Earthlings.
An Unearthly Child more than lives up to the name Doctor Who, and though the rest of the story devolves into dull caveman and aimless wandering, that first episode still holds up today as a solid 25 minutes of drama.
1. Spearhead From Space
We wouldn't be here today without Spearhead From Space. Doctor Who was facing cancellation at the end of the 1960s, inspiring a radical, budget-saving rethink. And then, a technicians strike meant that Jon Pertwee's debut story also had to be radically rethought in terms of production.
As a result, we get the most gloriously cinematic bit of Doctor Who until The Eleventh Hour (which is heavily inspired by this). Like Matt Smith's debut, Spearhead From Space is all about an alien who falls from the sky and is then immediately thrown into saving the Earth.
The Third Doctor is also immediately charming, introducing himself to Liz with his endearing eyebrow acrobatics, and generally running rings around the Brigadier. It must've been a major culture shock to viewers at the time to have the Doctor exiled to Earth and given a car instead of a TARDIS!
However, Jon Pertwee's performance as the Doctor is so great that it reassures viewers that this is still the same show. So successful was Pertwee as the Doctor that it led to a brand-new golden age for Doctor Who, the influence of which can still be felt today.