Doom Patrol Season 1: 8 Ups And 1 Down

DC's latest live-action series is a triumph.

Doom Patrol Season 1 Poster
DC Universe

Out of all the properties expected to really take off, nobody could've guessed that the one involving farting inter-dimensional donkeys and a cockroach determined to bring about the apocalypse would be the one. Yet, it's in Doom Patrol's refusal to compromise on any of its artistic merits that it's found success. If it had been placed on any other network, there's no telling just how much lesser a product it'd be. Thankfully, showrunner Jeremy Carver and all of the superb writers got to get away with so many F-bombs and wackiness, allowing the excellent final product to come out as it has.

It'd be easy to compare DP to Guardians of the Galaxy as it's another rag-tag group of lesser-known comic characters, but don't misunderstand and think this show is anything like what you've seen before.

Doom Patrol really is something of a revelation. It's a show that always elects to avoid well-tread superhero stories and whenever it must hit those genre conventions, the show will mock itself for it. Everyone involved should be praised for what they achieved here. But before the gushing continues, here's the show's only major negative...

9. Down: Action Is Severely Downplayed (And Consistently Shoved Off-Screen)

Doom Patrol
DC Universe

Taking a quick glance at the residents of Doom manor, you may notice that there aren't exactly any Bruce Wayne prodigies among them. This is where the show subtly sets up how Doom Patrol's focus differs greatly from fellow DC Universe show Titans: the action will not be the focus. There aren't too many impressively choreographed fights or especially flashy CGI-heavy encounters. Instead, heavy action sequences are used sparingly and often have a comedic edge to avoid going full 'superhero blockbuster' on any given fight scene.

And that occurs with the sequences that remain on-screen until their conclusion. After a second watch of the season, you begin to notice how often a fight scene is set up, then is cut off by the focus being moved to something else. If this was only an occasional occurrence, it'd be no issue. However, there are several promising encounters that the show sets up, but you often don't get to see it play out.

This show excels in many areas that Titans struggled, but Titans has the overall edge when it comes to the action.

Now then, back to singing this show's praises.


8. Up: A Tragi-Comedic Tone Utilized To Perfection

Doom Patrol Brendan Fraser
Warner Bros.

Humor can be a strength, but it can also feel like a crutch when a show's afraid to be sincere/serious. This show is hilarious, but it'll break your heart in an instant and isn't afraid to do so. Better yet, it completely earns your tears. Since every episode serves as character development for one or several team members and each one has serious baggage and trauma to unpack, audiences are always in for an emotional ride.

Take Brendan Fraser's Cliff as an example of how the show exceeds at tonal balance. In many ways, he is DP's comedic relief. When there's a quip to be made, he's usually the first to take advantage. Yet, the show never lets him be just that. He's also someone who lost everything several decades ago with the only semblance of his humanity left being the brain that powers his rusty robot body. He may drop plenty of quips, but his suffering, as well as the suffering of the other members, is taken seriously.

The show doesn't shy away from humanizing its characters and making them feel real. Doesn't matter if it's a character like Flex Mentallo that feels like a silly comic creation from the 1940s, they're still treated with respect, and it does wonders for the audience's investment.


7. Up: Clint Mansell's Score

Doom Patrol Danny Patrol
DC Universe

Gamers know him from his excellent contributions to the Mass Effect 3 soundtrack, others know him for his Darren Aronofsky movie scores that somehow made Black Swan and Requiem for a Dream more stressful and unpleasant (in a good way). However you know (or don't know) Clint Mansell, his work on this show deserves serious recognition. Furthering the synthesizer movement in modern Hollywood, Mansell's score for Doom Patrol is capable of making you feel something within yourself. Dread, joy, pure sadness, all of it comes included!

Mansell provided the soundtrack for Titans as well, and his work there is surely notable. That said, his synth-powered score heightens every moment of Doom Patrol. Emotional scenes, goofy back-and-forths, and even the utterly insane moments, all complemented so well by Mansell.

Doom Patrol's score is one that you may not always pick up on, but during that second viewing, you begin to appreciate the swells and plunges that complement what's happening on screen perfectly. He never allows his music to overpower the scene. Instead, he lets his music add its power to each given scene.


6. Up: Every Episode Is Experimental And Unique

Puppet Patrol Doom Patrol
DC Comics

An absolute standout element of Doom Patrol is the way no episode is treated as an afterthought. You never know what you're in for when that 'Previously on' recap ends and it's so refreshing to see when other shows in this genre suffer due to forcibly-padded seasons.

Better yet, DP reinforces these imaginative storylines by connecting it effectively to the season's central conflicts. The writers get to utilize their sense of creativity while making the episodes feel like a natural means of progression. Since the search for the Chief involves visiting the endlessly interesting places he'd gone to, you get a great variety of locations and personalities to meet. In addition, thanks to Mr. Nobody's all-powerful ability to direct the story, the show allows itself the possibility to be seemingly rewritten as it's happening.

Perhaps most remarkable of all, not one of the fifteen episodes in season 1 dips below the show's high-quality standard set after its premiere. Usually, there'd be those episodes you can skip to accommodate binging a lengthy season, but just know that you won't want to miss a moment.


5. Up: Notable Production Value/Design

Doom Patrol TV
DCU

Fans have grown accustomed to most comic book shows having 'fine, not great' production values with the Arrowverse properties, so they expected about the same with Doom Patrol. However, outside of the occasionally-iffy blob effects with Rita, the show does a great job of masking any limited budget. Through the continued use of practical effects whenever possible, DP maintains a sharply-cinematic look that rarely drops below that.

All in all, the show just has a great overall aesthetic. Creative lighting, impressively-detailed sets, all of it works in service to making the show look far more professional than its counterparts. The thought and care put into the artistic side of the show are more akin to an indie passion project than a superhero network show.

Although it's unknown how expensive the show is, DP never allows itself to look cheap. Through the emphasized use of practical effects, Doom Patrol not only gives its world a sense of authenticity, but also bolsters its sense of timelessness. Whether you watch the show today or a decade from now, you can bet it'll age quite nicely.


4. Up: Alan Tudyk's Scene-Stealing Mr. Nobody

Mr  Nobody
DC Universe

You've undoubtedly seen Mr. Tudyk in one project or another, but Doom Patrol finally gives him the chance to showcase his talent. Serving as central narrator and the season's big bad, Tudyk instills so much charisma, scene-chewing narcissism, and pure villainy in this character that his performance is something of a revelation. Whether he's on-screen or off, his superb vocal work carries so much energy into every episode.

Alan Tudyk seems to be having an absolute blast with the role and it makes him so entertaining to watch. You've certainly known egotistical villains, as well as psychopathic ones, but you've never seen an arrogant, self-important, meta-as-all-hell psychopath like Mr. Nobody. All of the show's events are like his own personal soap opera that he's constantly manipulating. He could've beaten Niles Caulder's group of misfits in the premiere, but that wouldn't have been satisfying. The fact that he makes everyone go through redemptive character arcs just so they're worthy to be defeated by him is delightfully different and absurd.

It's difficult to think of anyone else playing this role with such theatricality and flair. He infuses Nobody with a childlike delight of the DP's suffering rivals the Joker and a sense of importance that rivals the Riddler. It's truly a lovely combination.


3. Up: Superb Sense Of Representation

Doom Patrol S1 Larry Trainor
Warner Bros.

With modern society adopting an increasingly diverse look, Hollywood has taken it upon itself to start mirroring this through movies and shows. Unfortunately, it often comes across as being rather forced and unnatural, like an executive was trying to check particular topics off of a checklist rather than tell an all-inclusive story. Doom Patrol could've easily fallen into the same camp if their choice to make Negative Man's struggles with his sexuality and identity lacked authenticity. Unsurprisingly, Doom Patrol pulls it off with gusto.

DP's superb representation isn't only limited to the LGBTQ community either. The show's excellent commentary on the disabled sets it apart from just about anything else in Hollywood. Doom Patrol never shies away from these topics either, putting them in the forefront of many characters' personal progression. Not only does the series, at its core, encapsulate a wide array of struggles that the handicapped face (further explored in this Polygon article), it also promotes the importance of self-identity acceptance.

There are a lot of issues and rarely-discussed topics brought up here and it's massively refreshing. While the Russo brothers may pat themselves on the back for their single LGBTQ character cameo, Doom Patrol shows all of Hollywood how representation should be done.


2. Up: Uncompromising Weirdness

Doom Patrol S1 Premiere
Warner Bros.

A consistent issue that pops up with most comic book properties is an unwillingness to delve into the more absurd, cheesy origins that the franchise was founded on. Unless it's something like LEGO Batman that thrives on its character's quirky history, the creatives behind these modern comic adaptations would rather stick to what they know audiences will accept.

But not Doom Patrol! DP wears the pride of its inception on its sleeve, firmly showcasing the crazy shenanigans and its many other-worldly personalities. Can you think of any show that would include someone like the Beard Hunter or Flex Mentallo AND do them justice? A key component of why this works so well is that DP may include characters that would fit right in with something more parody-like, but the show never treats them like they're just there to be laughed at. They're treated like people, so you can emphasize and laugh with them.

This gradual acceptance of the fantastical and crazy carries over from the characters themselves to you, making it feel like you're really part of the team's many misadventures. The showrunners could've easily played it safe and made something more standard, but it's this commitment to the weirdness that makes Doom Patrol really special.


1. Up: Pitch-Perfect Cast

Doom Patrol
Warner Bros.

All of the previous points aside, no matter all the creative ideas or ambitious concepts that were in place, Doom Patrol needed to nail the casting or else it just wouldn't be a hit. Thankfully, after fifteen episodes and one Titans cameo, it's truly impossible to picture this show without this incredible ensemble. From Brendan Fraser's crude, full-of-metaphorical heart, Robotman to April Bowlby's regal, maternal Rita, this cast is an absolute knock-out.

Everyone plays off each other superbly and brings so much to their respective roles. Matt Bomer puts in arguably his best performance yet with Larry Trainor, the former pilot struggling to accept himself after decades of hiding his true self from the world (both literally and figuratively). Diane Guerrero channels her inner James McAvoy and never allows you to doubt that there are 64 separate personalities within her, constantly battling for some screentime. Joivan Wade plays up the heroism of Cyborg quite well but never fails to bring the necessary vulnerability and rawness of Victor Stone. Lastly, there's Timothy Dalton's Niles who instills so much authenticity to the role, completely selling both the 'beloved father figure' side of his persona, as well as the underlying malevolent side that can come out when necessary.

Everyone behind the camera deserves their fair share of praise, but WB? Be sure to give the casting director a raise.

What did you think of Doom Patrol's first season? Let us know down in the comments.


In this post: 
Doom Patrol
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, movie lover, life-long supporter of Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man and Ben Affleck's Batman, you know the rest.