Doom Patrol Season 1 Premiere Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs
The best superhero TV debut in years.
DC Universe looks to bolster its fast-growing platter of streaming content with Doom Patrol, adapted of course from the legendary cult DC comic of the same name.
And though the streaming service got off to a shaky start with the mixed response to Titans last year, it's safe to say that Doom Patrol is a far more exciting proposition from the jump.
Smartly delineated from any mainline DC properties and characters - despite the team being introduced in Titans' fourth episode - the show's season premiere is full of shrewd creative choices, namely focusing on character-driven drama above all else.
But make no mistake, Doom Patrol also brings the glossy wonder you'd hope for from a superhero show, while skirting clear of many of the pitfalls that harangue so many similar series.
Fingers crossed that the show can maintain this level of consistency across its 15-episode first season, because this is a very encouraging start indeed...
Downs...
2. Not Enough Negative Man
Though the first episode does a pretty bang-up job of giving the titular superhero outfit their fair due, the one character who feels the most under-served in the season premiere is undeniably Larry Trainor aka Negative Man (Matt Bomer).
Aside from his obligatory backstory being rushed through, he takes more of a backseat compared to his comrades and often just fades into the periphery.
It's especially odd as Matt Bomer is such a magnanimous presence, yet he's given peculiarly little to do and ends up feeling like a bit of an afterthought.
Hopefully he'll come into his own throughout the season, because let's be honest, what's the point in hiring an infuriatingly handsome actor like Bomer and then keeping his gorgeous mug off-screen for the entire run?
Expect flashbacks-a-plenty, but on the basis of Doom Patrol's opening hour, he desperately needs more to do.
1. The CGI Is A Mixed Bag
One of the most consistent issues with superhero TV shows is the tendency not to spend enough money on the visual effects, and the result is that the overwhelming majority of these CGI-heavy shows end up looking embarrassingly cheap and tacky.
And though Doom Patrol is one of the better-produced recent superhero series, it does also feature some gaudy VFX work that drags the entire production down.
From Cliff Steele's (Brendan Fraser) wonky opening NASCAR accident to Larry Trainor's fateful plane crash, Rita Farr's (April Bowlby) blob effects and Mr. Nobody's (Alan Tudyk) surreal, shadowy composition, the CGI mostly ends up looking a bit chintzy and rushed.
It's telling that the show didn't start shooting until late last August, which is an extremely fast turnaround for such an ambitious project.
The visual effects certainly aren't on the lower end of the spectrum for the genre, but given the polish present elsewhere, it's a shame it's so frustratingly inconsistent throughout.
But with those bugbears out of the way, here's everything Doom Patrol gets right...
Ups...
7. The INCREDIBLE Cast
Above everything else, the main reason this show works is the fantastic cast. A fine cabal of under-appreciated character actors and rising stars have been teamed together, and their off-the-charts chemistry makes the show crackle with energy and enthusiasm in almost every moment.
The easy highlight is Brendan Fraser as Robotman, whose career has been on a very welcome upswing recently.
And though the majority of his role is simply a voiceover - bar a few flashbacks - he gets a rare opportunity to re-shape his rubber-faced goofball persona into something more dark and tragic.
Timothy Dalton doesn't have a huge role in the premiere as Niles Caulder aka The Chief, but true to form, he classes the production up something fierce and doesn't remotely seem like he's here for a simple paycheck (as you might suspect from an actor of his sure calibre).
Orange Is the New Black star Diane Guerrero is also terrifically spunky as Kay Challis aka Crazy Jane, selling the multi-faceted, distinct nature of her dozens of personalities but also ensuring to bring plenty of heart to the table.
Alan Tudyk also doesn't have a big role in the first episode as Mr. Nobody, but his snarky narration is hysterical, and he's a credit to pretty much anything he touches, so he should fare well once his role grows in future episodes.
6. It's "Mature" Without Trying Too Hard
By comparison, the season premiere of Titans was an exercise in how not to establish an adult-skewing tone.
It was "mature" without being mature: the brutal violence and foul language felt incredibly forced, and got the series off to a rough start from the outset.
However, Doom Patrol does a far better job of managing its tone from episode one. The first five minutes alone feature a decent amount of nudity, and the entire episode is rife with vulgar language, yet none of it feels self-conscious or like it's trying too hard.
It all feels organic to this world and the tortured characters within it, and better still, it doesn't clash with the more sweet and human moments as the heroes expose their vulnerabilities later.
Oddly the season premiere is actually surprisingly low on brutality, though one can imagine that this'll change in the coming episodes. Because why give us boobs and F-bombs if you're not gonna give us fountains of gore, right?
5. The (Mostly) Strong Production Values
From the show's glossy opening titles onwards, it's clear that a decent chunk 'o change has been poured into it, and aside from the sometimes rough visual effects, its production quality is a major credit to superhero TV shows.
For starters, the cinematography is slickly cinematic at all times and lacks the flat TV aesthetic that's so prevalent in these series (especially Marvel's Netflix shows). It feels like every image has been carefully composed rather than rushed through to meet a schedule.
The general production design is also terrific, with the various sets helping make the world feel truly alive, vibrant and distinct from our own. That it can weave all this together with heroes who, frankly, should look ridiculous is mightily impressive.
4. It Makes Clever Changes To The Source Material
We'll keep spoilers to an absolute minimum here, but Jeremy Carver's script makes some smart alterations to the source material which heighten the character drama while also updating things for the modern age.
For starters, Robotman's origin story is fleshed out further with an added revelation that only layers more tragedy and shade on top of his already horrific genesis.
Grabbing a lot of headlines already is the decision to make Negative Man a closeted gay man, which only further emphasises the identity issues he suffers from after being horrifically disfigured in his opening plane crash.
There are other changes elsewhere also, all of which successfully add complexity to the heroes in a way that's more relatable for a contemporary audience.
3. The Hilarious, Self-Aware Tone
There wasn't ever much worry that Doom Patrol would end up taking itself too seriously, but the very first moments of the episode make this abundantly clear, as Tudyk's Mr. Nobody complains about the over-abundance of superhero stories in the world and asks the audience, "Have you hung yourself yet?"
Though the majority of the episode doesn't stay quite this meta, there is still a tenor of self-awareness running through the first hour, appearing to appreciate the tropes associated with the Quirky Superhero Team and cleverly side-stepping a lot of them.
If it can maintain this level of playfulness while still doing right by its characters, then Doom Patrol could basically end up being what Suicide Squad wanted to be: DC's answer to the Guardians of the Galaxy.
2. It's A Charming Introduction To The Characters
Though the Doom Patrol was officially introduced in Titans, this is their real coming-out party, and whether you saw the Titans episode or not, it's a terrifically endearing welcome for the heroes (aside from Cyborg, who will show up soon).
Despite the undeniably formulaic structure of the season premiere - the first half of the episode is basically one expository backstory after another - the show doesn't feel in a rush to establish their bond or layer on the lazy, forced sentiment.
Instead, the character dynamics are rough around the edges but still charming in their scuzziness, and by focusing less on plot and more on the heroes, it feels decidedly less formulaic than similar recent superhero shows.
1. It's The Best Superhero TV Debut In Years
In total fairness, there haven't been a ton of truly startling, unique superhero TV series in recent years that just came storming out of the gate, so it may sound like damning Doom Patrol with faint praise to call it the best superhero TV debut in a long time.
But this is a vibrant, confident season premiere which avoids so many of the pitfalls that other shows have fallen into, skirting clear of contrived writing, forced character dynamics and cheap production values to deliver an enormously encouraging statement of intent.
Now it just remains to be seen whether or not the rest of the season can maintain this level of charm and forward-momentum, but you can rest assured that most will be returning to see how episode two turns out.
What did you think of Doom Patrol's season premiere? Will you be tuning in next week? Shout it out in the comments!