Every HBO Miniseries Ranked Worst To Best
Chernobyl? Band of Brothers? Mare of Easttown? What's the best HBO miniseries?
Home Box Office (HBO) have been creating miniseries since the mid- to-late 80s, and really began to master the medium in the 90s. The original series they conjured up back when things were just getting off the ground were usually short, two-hour events, but have since grown into some of the most wildly innovative shows on TV.
Outside of such hit shows as Oz, The Wire, The Sopranos, and Game of Thrones, the miniseries is where HBO thrives. Today, the network is regarded as perhaps the best TV content creator in the world, and looking at the miniseries it has crafted over the years - whether alone or in partnership with other overseas companies - it's easy to see why.
HBO is all about pushing the boundaries. Their shows tackle daring social themes, and few are ever short on violence and adult content. Over the last four or five years, the network has grown more than ever, and the number of great miniseries that have come our way in that time is a testament to HBO's need to create top-tier content.
Not all their shows are as effective as others, but as a whole it's hard to argue with their success or their consistency. With that in mind, here are all 38 HBO miniseries ranked worst to best.
39. The Casual Vacancy (2015)
Following the success of Harry Potter, J.K Rowling began branching out into more mature, adult novels, one of which was the political drama The Casual Vacancy. The show aired as a three-part miniseries in 2015...and sunk like a lead balloon.
Unfortunately, The Casual Vacancy, with its heavy-handed political themes and underdeveloped characters, commits the worst offence a show can: It's boring. There's never any investment, no hook and no reason to get excited. It's there, it drags, and then it mercifully ends, having said nothing of importance about the themes it brings up.
38. The Far Pavilions (1984)
The Far Pavilions was the first miniseries released by HBO, and it shows just how unrefined the network was in those early days. The story of a soldier who has fallen in love with an Indian princess (the very non-Indian Amy Irving), The Far Pavilions works as an ill-advised lesson on how not to pace a story and not much else.
Long, meandering and weirdly undeveloped in terms of character and setting, the miniseries is a sloppy attempt at romantic drama that only ranks higher than The Casual Vacancy because it has brief splashes of semi-decent cinematography.
37. Tsunami: The Aftermath (2006)
Not only did Tsunami: The Aftermath come out far too soon following the Indian Ocean tsunami in 2004, but it doesn't really have the decency to show the true "aftermath" the title so proudly speaks about.
Some of the devastation is there, and the messy plot is well-disguised in places by the solid ensemble cast (Chiwetel Ejiofor, Tim Roth, Toni Collette), but the film's need to see the disaster through the eyes of western vacationers and not on the locals affected by the tragedy makes it feel like some kind of wannabe Hollywood blockbuster. Plus, seriously - far too soon, HBO. Far too soon.
36. Catherine The Great (2019)
Catherine the Great is set in 18th century Russia and stars Dame Helen Mirren as the titular Empress. She is joined by Jason Clarke and is assisted by a plot revolving around the entirety of Catherine II's reign.
And yet, somehow, Catherine the Great is all surface and no meaning. The wardrobe is impressive, the acting stellar, but the story deviates jarringly between plot-points and never takes the time to settle on a thread. What you're left with is a factually ambiguous visual treat that is forgotten as soon as the last episode closes things up, and given the potential, that really is a shame.
35. The Young Pope (2016)
The Young Pope had all the makings of a HBO great, but manages, much like Catherine the Great, to squander its basic influences. Jude Law is the best thing in the series, playing Pope Pius XIII as he takes on the Vatican's customs and threatens to derail the entire establishment. Other than Law, little of the show's mechanics seem to work.
Aside from the supporting cast (Diane Keaton, James Cromwell) and the visual delights of the scenery, The Young Pope is a narrative shambles, unable to settle. There's dark humour and daring religious themes, but no real reason to focus on either of them.
34. Empire Falls (2005)
Based on Richard Russo's acclaimed novel of the same name, Empire Falls comes complete with a intriguing set-up and impressive cast, including Ed Harris, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Paul Newman, but struggles to find its footing.
It's a shame, too, because the story has all the hooks needed for an epic and compelling multi-narrative drama, but it's well-claimed that good books don't make good adaptations. Despite a striking lead performance from Harris and some brief stabs at themes such as memory and family, Empire Falls falls frustratingly short of the mark, and really deserved better.
33. Parade's End (2012)
Produced in partnership with the BBC, HBO's attempt to adapt the novels of Ford Maddox Ford is actually quite effective, primarily thanks to Benedict Cumberbatch's powerful and complex lead performance. Set after the First World War, the miniseries follows Cumberbatch's married conservative Christopher Tietjens as he falls in love with another woman.
With tragic character development and a moving overarching story, Parade's End is kept afloat by its performances, even if some of the narrative urgency feels slightly lost over its five-episode run.
32. The New Pope (2020)
The New Pope does a lot of things more effectively than The Young Pope. First off, there's the introduction of John Malkovich as John Paul III, who acts as a striking contrast to his controversial predecessor, Pope Pius.
It also deserves props for its risky religious themes, which, despite being historically questionable, does allow for some added intensity. Unfortunately, though, The New Pope still has all the issues of the original, in that the narrative feels awkwardly clunky and inconsistent, with the story losing its momentum over its nine episodes.
31. House Of Saddam (2008)
Biopics about infamous historical figures are nothing new, but with House of Saddam HBO at least tried to mix up the formula by telling the rise and fall of Saddam Hussein as if he wasn't just a genocidal dictator, but a gangster and criminal mastermind. It's a clever spin, anchored by Yigal Naor's remarkable central performance.
There is, however, a sense of underdevelopment that taints many biopics, in that House of Saddam doesn't look deeply enough at its subject or really dig into the true extent of his complex image and personality.
30. Gunpowder (2017)
Nearing the end of his stint as Game of Thrones' resident hero, Kit Harington found himself playing his own ancestor Robert Catesby, the mastermind behind the 1605 Gunpowder Plot. Gunpowder features much of what made Game of Thrones such a hit, from its complex characters to its unflinching look at historically accurate and grisly violence.
Gunpowder, despite Harington's uncharismatic performance and the fact at only three episodes it still feel slightly overlong, is still a tense and informative drama, and its quality is held up by a genuinely affecting finale.