Every Philip K. Dick TV Adaptation Ranked Worst To Best

Everyone knows the films adapted from Philip K. Dick's work, but what about the TV shows?

The Man in the High Castle
Amazon

If you're a film fan then it's very likely that, even if you haven't read any of his many novels or short stories, you'll know the name Philip K. Dick.

Since his death in 1982, silver screen adaptations of the prolific author's work have been plentiful, resulting in a varied collection of feature films ranging from the bewildering (Radio Free Albemuth) to the sublime (Blade Runner).

Given that Dick's fiction features mind-bending themes covering perception, human nature and the intricacies of reality, the difficulty of creating a film that's actually watchable is perhaps an inevitable side effect of attempting to adapt some of these stories.

But what about television, a medium that can sometimes allow for more scope in style and format? There have been a few experiments over the years: some good, some bad and some simply lost to the annals of history.

So, does Philip K. Dick's material benefit more from the extended world and character building that episodic TV allows for? Are his stories better suited to an anthology format where each episode is its own self-enclosed story? And how does each adaptation compare?

Let's find out.

5. Impostore (1982)

Dick's short story Impostor, first published in 1953, has been adapted on a few different occasions and is notably the only work adapted for the screen prior to the author's death in 1982. It concerns a man attempting to clear his name following accusations from colleagues that he's an android infiltrator.

The story was first adapted for television in 1962 as part of the well-received British science fiction anthology show Out of This World. Unfortunately, this version is lost to history, deleted immediately after broadcast as was common practice at the time.

Nearly 20 years later, Impostor, was again adapted for the small screen, this time as Impostore, an episode of the second season of Italian sci-fi anthology show Il Fascino Dell'insolito (The Charm of the Unusual). The entire episode is available on YouTube but with no English subtitles available, you'll need to brush up on your Italian.

Impostore suffers from poor direction, and a lack of dynamism, focus and urgency are apparent from the outset. The crumbling industrial backdrops, somewhat reminiscent of Andrei Tarkovsky's Stalker (the comparisons end there), are quite effective but overall it's not particularly memorable.

In 2001, a feature film adaptation starring Gary Sinise also struggled to tell the story in a compelling way, in part due to a run-time that the source material just can't support.

There's clearly an interesting story to be told here, albeit a familiar one, and perhaps a slickly produced television adaptation with a suitably short running time could be good. Impostore, unfortunately, is definitely not it.


4. Minority Report (2015)

Minority Report TV series
Fox

In 2002, Stephen Spielberg successfully adapted Philip K. Dick's 1956 short story The Minority Report for the big screen. Minority Report is a bombastic, special effects extravaganza set in a near-future society where law enforcement officers are informed of serious crimes in advance by a team of psychics or 'pre-cogs'.

Over a decade after the release of Minority Report, a TV show of the same name was developed by Amblin, Paramount and 20th Century Fox, as a direct sequel to Spielberg's film, first airing in late 2015.

Set after the collapse of the pre-crime division, the story follows the fortunes of former 'pre-cog' Dash as he continues to work with law enforcement, to prevent crimes, whilst attempting to keep his abilities hidden from those who would seek to exploit them.

It sounds promising but with a lacklustre plot and limited chemistry between the primary cast, Minority Report is a huge disappointment right from the start. Poor viewing figures and less than favourable reviews led to a three-episode reduction in the show's initial run and it would not be renewed for a second season.

The film's success proves that Dick's work can be adapted well but it seems that there's limited capacity to expand on that initial idea. If Dick were still alive, perhaps input from the visionary author himself could have resulted in a more unique and engaging show.


3. Total Recall 2070 (1999)

With a name like Total Recall 2070, you might expect this 1999 television show to be heavily influenced by Philip K. Dick's short story We Can Remember It For You Wholesale or, at the very least, Paul Verhoeven's ultraviolent action adaptation from 1990. But in reality, there are only a few nods that confirm this show exists in that same universe.

Instead, with its neo-noir setting and paranoid psychological thriller-esque storylines, involving self-aware androids, Total Recall 2070, takes far more inspiration from Ridley Scott's 1982 genre classic Blade Runner, itself based on another of Dick's stories, Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep?.

Generally, the show works as a police procedural where the characters tackle a new case each episode but with an overarching plotline slowly uncovering the despicable motives and ethics of the world's evil megacorporations. Despite being a touch dated, it's generally a decent watch.

The stories are engaging, the characters are interesting, the world is suitably dark and grungy and there are decent performances across the board from the main cast. Unfortunately, only a single season of 22 episodes was made and as a result, significant plot points were left unresolved.

Total Recall 2070 is not officially available on streaming services (although it can be found on YouTube) and with only limited DVD releases worldwide it's very difficult to get a hold of the full series. However, the two-part pilot episode is readily available on DVD as Total Recall 2070: Machine Dreams, which is definitely worth checking out.


2. Electric Dreams (2017)

Philip K Dick's Electric Dreams
Channel 4

Electric Dreams is an anthology series released by Amazon Prime in the US, and Channel 4 in the UK, which adapts ten of Philip K. Dick's short stories into self-contained 50-minute episodes and, on paper at least, it would appear to be an ideal way to present these short, high concept tales.

The series is slickly produced, and with a consistently high production value throughout, each episode looks and sounds fantastic and the acting is top-notch, which is unsurprising given there are some really big names involved: Bryan Cranston, Timothy Spall, Anna Paquin and Steve Buscemi, for example.

Unfortunately, the series is a bit of a mixed bag. There are a few universally acclaimed episodes including Kill All Others and Real Life (based on The Hanging Stranger and Exhibit Piece respectively) but the jury's out on many of the other episodes which range from the distinctly average to the entirely forgettable.

The series sometimes suffers from predictability and overfamiliarity; The Father Thing, for example, feels like a retread of Invasion Of The Body Snatchers, which is perhaps an inevitable symptom of adapting these stories, many of which are over half a century old.

However, Electric Dreams is still easy to recommend. It's a nice collection of interesting science fiction concepts and stories, well produced and well acted, and if they can look past some of the more familiar cliches and tropes, most viewers will have a good time.


1. The Man In The High Castle (2015)

A Nazi-occupied New York City- Man In The High Castle
Amazon Prime

The Man In The High Castle is by far the best known and most successful television adaptation of the work of Philip K. Dick to date. It takes Dick's classic 1962 Hugo Award winning novel and brings its terrifying alternative history concept to life with the benefit of modern special effects and production techniques.

The series explores what could have happened if the Axis powers of Nazi Germany and The Empire of Japan had won World War II and describes a former United States Of America divided into distinct areas controlled by the two factions.

The Man In The High Castle's world is brought to life brilliantly and it's a joy discovering how this unfamiliar world looks, feels and operates on a daily basis. It's both fascinating and horrifying.

The look and feel of the show is one of its biggest assets perfectly blending a fondly familiar 1960s retro aesthetic with harsh World War II era fascist iconography and values. It starkly contrasts our modern life and past history which is equally engaging and uncomfortable to watch.

Over the course of its four seasons so far, the show has had to expand beyond the confines of Dick's original story and the showrunners have achieved this reasonably well, maintaining a standard consistent enough to keeps viewers engaged and winning several accolades in the process. The Man In The High Castle is not to be missed.


Contributor
Contributor

Christopher is a freelance pop culture writer, podcaster and self-confessed nerd from Scotland. He's also the owner, founder and editor at "The Head Scratcher" and a host of "The Scratch Cast" podcast. Visit www.theheadscratcher.com to find out more.