Every The CW Superhero Show Ranked Worst To Best

The home of DC superheroes since its debut, which of The CW's live-action heroes will stand tall?

Arrowverse Characters
The CW

Comic book-inspired programming has been around for decades, allowing us to enjoy the escapades of costumed superheroes from the comfort of our own homes, but never has a TV network become so synonymous with superheroes in the way that The CW has.

A joint venture between Warner Bros. and CBS, it was, for the longest time, primarily a teen network, housing beloved shows like One Tree Hill, The Vampire Diaries and The Secret Circle (and it was once even the home WWE's Friday Night SmackDown). And yet, in the past decade, it has undergone something of a rebrand.

Sure, it still houses a number of teen shows and ultimately influences some of its non-teen programs to give into its more, well, angsty tendencies (when they shouldn't), but that doesn't change the fact that it is now primarily considered the home of DC Comics programming.

That reputation is down to the popularity of the Arrowverse - a shared universe of superhero shows spun off from 2012's Arrow, all of which focus on some of DC's most iconic superheroes. With comparisons to Marvel's big-screen cinematic universe, The CW's line-up is ever-changing, with some shows leaving our screens just as new ones join the fray. But its line-up hasn't just consisted of Arrowverse superheroes.

With all that in mind (and two more potential superhero shows on the way), let's take a look at The CW's heroic programming and, while we're at it, rank them.

7. Batwoman

Batwoman Season 1
The CW

The latest addition to the Arrowverse, Batwoman's arrival sparked a little bit of controversy among fans before it was even released because of its diabolically poor trailer. The on-the-nose dialogue and thin character motivations painted the show in such a poor light before it even debuted that all the show had to do was just be better than it was presented. Needless to say, it was... and then some.

Debuting with a decent - albeit slightly flat - pilot episode, Batwoman showed potential and the writers quickly put their hearts and souls into the show in the hopes that they could make it live up to that potential. It took them a little while, but man oh man, did they get there in the end.

The show stopped playing around and kicked into gear just prior to the annual Arrowverse crossover - which on this occasion was only bloody Crisis On Infinite Earths - and after said crossover was finished, it started firing on all cylinders.

One of the best comebacks in recent TV memory, the Ruby Rose-starring series managed to become this season's strongest Arrowverse offering, so it's a real shame that the season was cut short before it could end the way that the creative team wanted it to. But if it continues to dominate the way that it did in the back half of Season 1, it could certainly find itself moving up this list. Let's hope that it's capable of doing that now that Rose has left the show.


6. Black Lightning

Black Lightning
The CW

What sets Black Lightning apart from the majority of the other shows on this list is that it doesn't even remotely feel like it belongs on The CW. It's nothing like the other offerings in the Arrowverse but it doesn't feel like any earlier non-Arrowverse offerings either.

With its own distinct tone, the show focuses on high school principal Jefferson Pierce who, after years of retirement from superheroics, is forced to return to the streets of Freeland after The 100 gang's hostile takeover puts lives in jeopardy.

A hard-hitting, realistic drama that doesn't shy away from social commentary or tackling important issues head-on, the show thrives because of its strong writing, familial nature and authentic character journeys - and it's capped off by an incredible leading performance from Cress Williams.

The show spent three years unattached to the Arrowverse before Crisis On Infinite Earths had its wicked way with the continuity and retroactively set it on Earth-Prime, but the truth is that Black Lightning's greatest strength lies in the fact that it's only an Arrowverse show in name.

And even though some of the follow-up seasons haven't lived up to its glorious debut, it's still one of the most engaging - and important - shows on network television.


5. DC's Legends Of Tomorrow

Legends of Tomorrow
The CW

When DC's Legends of Tomorrow made it debut on The CW, it instantly fell to the bottom of the Arrowverse heap. Though it had promise, its overserious tone resulted in this vehicle for some of the most beloved supporting characters from The Flash and Arrow having ignition problems right from the beginning. A year later, it completely turned things around.

Weaving its rich dramatic characters into a plot that was ridiculous in its approach and unfathomable on paper, Legends found a way to time-travel its way into our hearts, making us forget about the fantasy-driven past and focus on the humour-driven future. And it was all the better for it.

A show that thrives on the lunacy of its own storylines, its a refreshing and enjoyable take on the superhero genre that dares to be different because the creative team is fully aware that no other show on television would be brave enough to try some of the things that it can get away with.

It's true that the two most recent seasons have taken it too far off the rails with its heavy emphasis on mindless comedy, but when it's on those rails, it's the best superhero show on TV.


4. Supergirl

Supergirl Season 5 Kara Danvers Melissa Benoist
The CW

One of the two shows on this list that didn't get its start on The CW, Supergirl debuted on CBS back in 2015 to a whopping 13 million viewers. Though it was a larger than life show, there was uncertainty as to whether it would return to the network and, lo and behold, it was indeed moved to The CW for its second season.

Originally more of a distant cousin of the Arrowverse, Supergirl is now an official part of the gang and the show that follows the adventures of Kara Zor-El of Krypton has crossed paths with all of the CW stalwarts since it arrived four years ago.

Though less traditionally heroic than it was at the beginning, Supergirl's strength lies in its ability to tell heartfelt and meaningful storylines, tackling important issues in the process.

Most of the time it handles them very well, but it would be nice if it managed to find a way to return to its more fun and triumphant roots at the same time. There is a way to balance both elements, and when Supergirl pulls it off, the sky isn't even the limit for our beloved Girl of Steel.


3. Arrow

Arrow Season 8 Oliver Queen John Diggle Laurel Lance Black Canary
The CW

That takes us to this one: The show that started the very superhero renaissance we've spent most of this article talking about. We are, of course, referring to Arrow.

Fresh off Smallville's uber-successful run, Arrow had to find a way of distancing itself from Justin Hartley's excellent comic-accurate rendition of the Emerald Archer in that show, so the creative team decided to take Christopher Nolan's approach in his revered Dark Knight trilogy and apply it to the small screen instead. The result was nothing short of genius.

It's hard to imagine where the world of superhero TV would be without the barriers that Arrow broke down. A clear example that modern day comic book programming could fit the mold of serialized storytelling and still pull off the fun capers of the week that its golden age predecessors did, the show's dark retelling of Oliver Queen's origins felt like they belonged on the big screen. And it was nothing short of incredible seeing this deeply troubled vigilante taking on the likes of Dark Archer and Deathstroke.

It's hard to sum up all that Arrow accomplished both as a show and for its genre, and it would be fully deserving of the top spot on this list for that alone. Unfortunately, it's impossible to overlook the poor creative direction that hampered multiple seasons midway through, brought on by far too many deviations from the source material, the death of a beloved character and one of the most problematic couplings in recent TV history.

That said, it had one heck of a run and will forever be remembered as the founding father of both the Arrowverse and the modern-day superhero resurgence.


2. Smallville

Smallville Superman
The CW

The unsung hero of the superhero revival, Smallville was the glimmer of hope that remained when superheroes' days of dominating television was little more than a memory of years-gone-by.

An evolution of the genre that successfully adopted many of the teenage conventions of YA TV at the time, the show focused on a young Clark Kent as he attempted to reconcile his struggles over the fact that he was alien from Krypton with the everyday pressures of high school. And this subversion of the norm proved to be a highly popular one, as the show ran for an incredible 10 seasons.

Had all of Smallville's seasons run on The CW, we may be handing it the victory on this list because it did wave the flag for the genre when there weren't any others to. However, as it was a pre-CW show, it arrived on the new network long after its glory days, resulting in it debuting with some of its more problematic seasons.

That said, once the sixth and seventh seasons were out of the way, it improved a great deal, dropping the angst and going full-superhero show in the process - resulting in one heck of a comeback.

Many superhero shows will come, and many superhero shows will go... but we'll always hold onto Smallville.


1. The Flash

The Flash Season 4
The CW

The first of the Arrowverse spin-offs, few of us could ever have predicted the titan that The Flash would ultimately become. Centering on DC Comics' Scarlet Speedster, the show single-handedly broke ratings records for the network in its first year and took the shared universe to greater heights than it could have imagined.

Led by an endearing performance from Grant Gustin, The Flash is the opposite of its parent show in that its greatest strength is its undeniable optimism. It takes its cues from the fun superhero shows of old while also employing a number of the storytelling methods that made Arrow the success that it was.

Like Arrow, The Flash has also had a number of highs and lows throughout its run. The difference, however, is that its highs were higher and its lows were nowhere near as low (thanks in no small part to the fact that it never disrespected the source material). And although it did hit something of a lull midway through its run, it's hard to overlook the fact that its first season was perhaps the greatest season of the whole genre.

Back on track with a stellar sixth season - and its seventh on the horizon - The Flash clearly shows no signs of slowing down in the near future, and it's safe to say that we're all thankful for that.

-

Which CW superhero show is your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.