Family Guy: 5 Reasons It Was A Huge Mistake To Kill Brian Griffin
I'll be honest: I haven't watched Family Guy religiously for a long time. The show took a noticeable dive in quality a few years ago when the originality seemed to drain out from within, almost as if the writers - and creator Seth MacFarlane - had given up caring. There wasn't a particular thing about the show that put me off, but it became increasingly mean-spirited, the jokes more obscure and less funny, and the popular culture "references" were bizarrely hollow - Peter on a skateboard whilst the Back to the Future theme plays. That's not a joke. That's just... something. So even though I wouldn't say I'm a huge fan, I've spent enough time with Family Guy to say I'm probably more familiar with it than your average schmo. I don't keep up with it anymore, but I'll check it out if it's on and I haven't got better things to do, like cut off one of my fingers, or jump from a fatal height. Family Guy has taken a few narrative leaps already, of course, some funny (Stewie is gay!), some painfully unfunny (The Cleveland Show), but last night something happened that I'm barely able to comprehend. In fact, to be honest, I'm rather appalled. Family Guy killed off Brian Griffin. The family dog, and Peter's best friend. They killed him. They killed him off in a generic, banal and ridiculously dull fashion. Forget that Brian is by far one of the most likeable characters on the show, or that the only "good" episodes of Family Guy in this era usually consists of Brian and Stewie getting into some kind of misadventure... what the writers (and MacFarlane) don't seem to realise is that Brian is arguably the most important character on the show. Here are 5 reasons why killing him off was a huge, incalculable mistake...
5. Brian Was An Audience Surrogate
Despite his many flaws and his tendency to get into as much trouble as the rest of the Griffin family, Brian's most important quality is that he's the most normal. We need a Brian character in this vein because it gives us somebody to associate ourselves with - despite the fact that he's a dog, he was ultimately the most rational member of the cast. He was... the most human, if you will. The fact that there was somebody like that around made it all more enjoyable to watch. When Peter gets into a crazy scheme, it's Brian who says what we - the audience - are thinking. I suppose it started off as something of a running joke that Brian was the most "sensible" member of the family, despite the fact that he was a dog. Great - that's funny. But how could MacFarlane and his team have missed the fact that Brian is an essential element inherent to what makes Family Guy funny? The fact that he was essentially more human than the human characters was what brought us round to him. Whether you realised it or not, or thought Brian was fundamentally a "boring" character, he was necessary to the equation: our kindred spirit and straight man.
4. Killing Brian Takes Everything Away From The Show, But Adds Nothing
Think about it: killing Brian off will generate a few weeks of arguably interesting episodes - how do our characters deal with the death of such an important cast member? Okay, fine. But after that, then what? What have we gained from killing off a character who was in no way asking to be killed off? Had the writers killed off Meg or something, I could understand: what has Meg offered Family Guy for the sum of the last 10 years except for jokes made at her own expense (funny, sure, but Family Guy could go on without them, right?). What's more irritating about this, though, is that the whole ordeal seems to contrived to bring ratings and attention back to a show that is clearly flagging. Whether or not MacFarlane and friends thought that it would help to mix things up now that the show's on its twelve season doesn't really come into play - Family Guy is ultimately a comedy sitcom, one that has no respect for continuity, its - rather annoyingly - own set-up... what business does it have bringing in a purely sentimental storyline at this stage? Now it suddenly wants us to take it seriously?
3. Stewie Is Automatically Rendered Less Funny
When the writers first put Brian and Stewie in a room together, they obviously realised they had a magical combination (even if it is just Seth MacFarlane talking to himself in a room - weird when you think about it like that). In recent years, though, Brian and Griffin's adventures became one of the few things that could get older fans excited about the show. There's something special about the way these two both respect and despise one another, and the resulting banter was rarely ever disappointing. But now Brian is gone, what happens to Stewie? Stewie is probably still the world's favourite Family Guy character, of course, and I'm not suggesting that Stewie can't be funny without Brian. But Brian was the only character in the show who could hear Stewie talk. Sure, they had great chemistry together anyway, but there was another fundamentally and largely logical reason why the writers had these two teaming up in the first-place. And no matter how the writers contrive a way to have Stewie being funny without his old friend, there's no denying that their friendship became the true heart of the show.
2. Brian Was Able To Fit Any Situation Or Personality
The more and more I write about Brian Griffin, the more I realise how important and therefore underappreciated he probably was as a character. Aside from being our surrogate and straight man, then, and one of the characters who made all the other characters funnier as a result, Brian was also able to believably fall into pretty much any personality and it still felt true to him. Sure, he's set up as the straight man and as an failed intellectual most of the time, but it was also possible for Brian to be mean-spirited, jealous, scheming, drunk, and just a terrible person. Whereas the other members of the Griffin family seem to switch personality traits on a whim to suit any story or plot point, though, Brian's transformations always seemed more realistic. Why? Because, simply put, he's the show's most developed character. You could find more words to describe his personality than with anybody else on the show. The amazing thing, however, is that although some of those words clash with one another at first glance, they still make sense - Brian can be both "selfish" and "caring," because he was like us: human.
1. He Was Actually The Best Character
Whether you find yourself identifying with Brian the most (God forbid you'd identify with any of the other Family Guy characters), or you find him plainly irritating (most failed writers are, right?), it has to be said: Brian Griffin was the show's best character, whether we realised it at the time or not. I don't think I really did until I woke up this morning and found out the writers had squashed him under a car. The loss of this character might not seem like such a big deal, but - for me, at least - it just lacks any kind of respect the show has for itself or its fans. "Killing off a character" is only necessary when it's... well, necessary. What late stage game does Family Guy think it's playing? Bringing in a replacement dog, too, seems like a last ditch effort to bring something "new" to the show for the sake of it - but couldn't the writers have done that without erasing such an integral part of Family Guy's format? Many will claim that people are overacting with all this "How dare they kill Brian?" stuff, but it's not just about that: Brian was a friend, and he had been for a long time. Ultimately, I'm just sad to see him go. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.