Game Of Thrones: 10 Actors Who Were Almost Cast

1 Logo The last few years have been something of a Renaissance for genre TV. There's geek culture comedy The Big Bang Theory on CBS, apocalyptic horror series The Walking Dead on AMC, and, of course, HBO's Game of Thrones, which has done more to bring fantasy than any book/show/film since Lord of The Rings. With what's got to be close to the the largest ensemble cast on TV, it makes sense that the show would have had the occasional bit of casting fall through, the occasional slip-up. As such, the following list should provide an interesting look at what might have been had Game of Thrones gone a slightly different route. SPOILERS

10. Dominic West

dominicwest

Case and point: McNulty himself. The British actor best known as the dogged, alcoholic cop on The Wire was apparently first choice for the role of Mance Rayder, leader of the Wildling forces and self-styled King Beyond the Wall, for Season Three. West apparently turned the role down due to family commitments - shooting would have required relocating to Iceland - though it's hard to believe that three-episode bit part would have kept him away from home for too long. Even so, Ciaran Hinds was able to step in, bringing with him a crustier, less civil version of the authority he displayed as Caesar in HBO's Rome. Given the important role that Mance presumably has left to play in the affairs of Westeros, it's intriguing to consider what a younger, slightly more virile take on the character might have been like.

9. Liam Burke

Liam Burke

The first of the actors on the list whom you're unlikely to have heard of - Liam Burke appeared as Mr. Boaz back in 2008's City of Ember. However, he was also set to appear as the Mad King, Aerys Targaryn II, back in Season One of Game of Thrones. Apparently scenes were filmed of Robert Baratheon's Rebellion, which took place more than twenty years before the events of the series and in which we would have witnessed the death of Ned Stark's brother and father in the court of the Mad King. The decision was made, for the sake of time and simplicity to remove these flashback sequences - the plot of Game of Thrones is sprawling enough without resorting to non-linear storytelling. Still, it would have been fascinating to witness the acts of a tyrant that served to make Robert king, Ned Stark his subject, and Jaime Lannister into the infamous Kingslayer.

8. Perdita Weeks

Perdita Weeks 2277588b

Having played Mary Boleyn, sister to Henry VIII, on Showtime's The Tudors, Perdita Weeks certainly has experience of the period drama. While her background may also tend towards the Victorian side of history - such as Lost in Austen or the BBC 2011 Great Expectations miniseries - it seems a little unusual that she'd turn down a part in a show as big as Game of Thrones. The role she's rumored to have been offered - that of Edmure Tully's bride, Roslin Frey - is hardly the most glamorous part but better-known actors have taken smaller for the sake of appearing on the show (see further down the list). After the project that won out over Game of Thrones fell through for her, Weeks seems to have been at a loose end - she admits to having rung the show's producers to "beg for back", but having appeared on Downton Abbey creator Julian Fellows' high-profile Titanic early last year (as a lady heiress no less) she seems to be doing pretty well nonetheless.

7. Simon Fisher-Becker

Simon Fisher Baker

Another relatively minor role, the High Septon, though head of the Faith of the Seven, the only accepted religion in the Seven Kingdoms, was played by an extra in his first appearance, appearing in the background of the grisly events that play out on the steps of the Great Sept of Baelor during Season One. When the character appeared in Season Two - just in time to bless the middle Baratheon child before being torn apart by an angry mob - he was played by David Verry, who you may recognize as one of Slitheen from Series 1 of Doctor Who. In any case, he took over the part from Simon Fisher-Becker, similarly recognizable from new Who as plump, blue merchant Dorium Maldovar. Not much of a story behind this one, just apparently one of those things. The primary difference, we imagine, is it would have been, in theory, a different arm that peasant was waving around. http://youtu.be/_N9M4R47nRU?t=1m8s

6. Tamzin Merchant

Tamzin Merchant One of those changes that would have made a major different to the world of the show, the role of Danaerys Targaryen AKA Danaerys Stormborn AKA Khaleesi was originally intended for Tamzin Merchant, one of the stars of 2005's Pride and Prejudice. After the unaired pilot, however, Merchant left the show - of her own free will or otherwise - and Emilia Clarke was cast in her stead. Merchant went on to do the BBC's Mystery of Edwin Drood while Clarke became something of an unusual feminist role model. Still, it's unlikely that Merchant can hold it against her too much: Clarke was more or less an unknown when she took on the role, as Merchant was when she made her debut in Joe Wright's Pride and Prejudice back in 2005.

5. Izzy Meikle-Small

Izzy Izzy Meikle-Small has an interesting niche in the world of acting, namely in playing younger incarnations of the main characters. She played the childhood version of Carrie Mulligan's character, Kathy H., in Never Let Me Go, as well as Young Estella in Great Expectations - the same production Perdita Weeks appeared in - the Young Ravenna (Charlize Theron's witchy queen) in Snow White and The Huntsman and, most recently, as Young Molly in the film adaptation of Michael Morgupo's Private Peaceful. It seems, however, that she made also made it down to the final two to play Sansa Stark in Game of Thrones. Meilke-Small has since expressed relief at not getting the role based on the amount of flesh it would require her to show. With no offense to Sophie Turner, Sansa has proven so insipid over the last three seasons its difficult to imagine it'd make much difference who was playing her.

4. Ian McNeice

Ianmcneice

Referring back to my previous comment on great actors taking small roles, veteran of stage and screen Ian McNeice was initially set to appear in Game of Thrones as Illyrio Mopatis, the wealthy merchant who seeks to help restore Visery Targaryn to the Iron Throne. Another graduate of HBO's Rome, McNeice's two-episode arc in the role was taken over by Roger Allam when he proved unavailable to reshoot the pilot - too busy appearing as Winston Churchill in Doctor Who Series Five. Roger Allam, if anything more illustrious than his predecessor, premiered the role of Javert in the musical Les Miserables, winning four Olivier Awards in his thirty-something years on the London stage, though somewhat less in-keeping with the description of the rotund Illyrio. It's a shame that most of the meaty roles seem to be resigned to the youth...

3. Jennifer Ehle

Jennifer Ehle Another actor who was, in fact, Jennifer Ehle appeared as Catelyn Stark in the Game of Thrones pilot, but when the time came round to shoot the full episode order she was nowhere to be seen. Michelle Fairley took over and Ehle - who still claims to be a fan of the show - went onto appear in Steven Soderbergh's Contagion and co-star in CBS' A Gifted Man (cancelled after its first season). On a peculiar side note, Ehle has also appeared in a notable production of Pride and Prejudice - not the Joe Wright one, but the 1995 BBC version alongside Colin Firth - for which she won a BAFTA. Though having a young kid may have prevented Ehle from committing to a 13 episode shoot in the likes of Iceland and Ireland, she did get to act alongside Firth again in The King's Speech as the wife of his character's speech therapist. Ehle doesn't seem to have borne any bitterness: as she says in the interview linked above, "clearly the show is what it was meant to be". It's nice to see someone respond to losing a major role with such class.

2. Derek Halligan

Derek Halligan Casting your mind back to the first season of Game of Thrones, you may recall the character of the Night's Watch Master-of-Arms, Alliser Thorne. Pudgy and whey-faced with curly blonde hair, it was he who gave Samwell Tarly the nickname "Lord Piggy" and generally behaved like an unlikeable arsehole in training the recruits, going so far as to mock Jon Snow after his adopted father, Ned, was arrested for treason. Though Owen Teale certainly bought the character to suitably loathsome life, its notable that Derek Halligan was originally set for the role. Halligan, scrawnier and more verminous-looking than Teale, left the project for "unspecified reasons" (apologies to both men for my unflattering physical descriptions - they are, of course, both great character actors). After two seasons off-screen, Teale will be returning in the role for Season Four. Finally, after so long with just Joffrey and Walder Frey, someone else that fans can really hate!

1. Richard Ridings/Jamie Campbell Bower

Combine Images There've been plenty of recastings in Game of Thrones three year history, but no scene in the show has shown the effects quite so much as the very opening one. The three members of the Night's Watch we see venturing beyond The Wall only to be shortly slaughtered by White Walkers. The role of Ser Waymar Royce, the noble who leads the expedition, was originally to be played by Jaime Campbell Bower, whom you might recognize as Anthony from Tim Burton's Sweeney Todd, as Caius from The Twilight Saga, or as Jace Wayland in the upcoming Mortal Instruments: City of Bone. Rob Ostelere played the short-lived Royce in the series proper while Dermot Keaney took over as Gared, the ranger who quite literally loses his head, from Richard Ridings. Oh, well: actors come actors go, but the stories remain the same. These are just 10 of the actors (unisex term) that have come closest to appearing in Game of Thrones as we know it. Are there any of them you think you would have preferred in the roles, any characters you wish had been recast altogether? Sound off below.

Contributor
Contributor

Robert Wallis hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.