Game Of Thrones: 10 Worst Changes From The Books

Want to know the truth behind the Red Wedding?

Euron game of thrones
HBO

Book to film adaptations very rarely work. Even when they do, you're always going to find certain members of a respective fandom moaning about something.

Adapting George R.R. Martin's epic political drama, set in a fantasy world, was never going to be easy. There is just too many characters and subplots to do the thing justice. A word by word retelling would mean the show runners would still be churning out episodes long after we're all living in a Mad Max style, apocalyptic-wasteland.

For all the difficulties, Game of Thrones did a great job with Martin's work, at least early on. The show captured the complex political structures, while conjuring up a world of mystery, magic and intrigue. But somewhere along the line the wheels started falling off. The truth of the matter was, the writers were working off source material that had no resolution.

Getting ahead of the books doomed the show. It soon became clear that characters and plot lines, established early on, were not as integral to the story as first thought. This resulted in a baffling amount of false starts for new characters, and anti-climactic endings for old ones.

Without proper foresight and planning, these changes ended up harming Game of Thrones, in unforgivable ways.

10. Killing Off Stannis

Stannis Baratheon Game Of Thrones
HBO

Stannis really didn't have a lot going for him. He was hot-headed, stubborn, and lacked a sense of humour; combined with having a penchant for religious fanaticism, it was a recipe for disaster. The last we saw of him, he was surrounded by dead men after Ramsay wiped the floor with his army.

When Stannis was defeated by Ramsay, ending his bid for the Iron Throne, it solidified Ramsay as one of the key antagonists in the show. This completely changed the trajectory of Martin's story. For one, Jon was forced to spend an entire season trying to rally enough men to defeat him.

In the books, Stannis is still camped in the woods, not far from Winterfell. His army is in pretty bad shape, but they've laid a cunning trap to lure in the Boltons. Everything indicates that Stannis will likely defeat the Boltons, (or at the very least Ramsay), meaning the Battle of the Bastards won't take place.

Although that scene made for some great TV, it resulted in huge amounts of screen time being taken away from the Walkers - characters we never got any solid answers about.

Jon will likely warg into Ghost before being resurrecting, and gain some insight about the Walker threat. There's even some theories that believe the White Walkers will use Jon's body for some dark sorcery.


9. Toning Down Daario Naharis

daario naharis
HBO

While the Daario in the show was a fun character, he was a painfully dull version of his book counterpart.

In the show he offers Dany's trio of male devotees (Grey Worm, Jorah, and Ser Barristan) a nice bit of healthy competition for her affection. At first, non of them really trust the arrogant, good looking rogue - seeing him as a mercenary cashing in on an easy paycheque. But he eventually wins everybody over, becoming an integral part of the team. After several seasons as Dany's love interest he conveniently gets left in Essos to avoid any awkward confrontations with Jon Snow.

Things are very different in the books. Daario is a bloodthirsty cutthroat. He has next to no moral compass, and constantly has confrontations with Dany's other advisers. No one trusts him, not even Dany - she only keep him about because of his skill as a swordsmen, if you take my meaning...

Daario in the books undoubtedly has affection for Dany, but after her marriage to Hizdahr zo Loraq, he becomes increasingly unpredictable. He's also far more extravagant; think Captain Jack Sparrow with a blue beard and even less honour.

If he makes it to Westeros, his jealous nature will no doubt bring him into conflict with any hopeful Dany love interests. There's no way this guy isn't fighting Jon Snow.


8. Jon Snow Isn't Aegon Targaryen

Jon Snow
HBO

The big reveal during season seven confirmed that Jon Snow was in fact the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark, and his true name was Aegon. Wrong again, show! As it stands, Jon is still dead at the Wall after being betrayed by the Night's Watch. Everything indicates that Jon is likely the son of Rhaegar and Lyanna, but he is most definitely not called Aegon.

This is the name of another character the show sadly cut-out, and simply folded into the Jon character. In the books it's revealed that Lord Varys was able to save Rhaegar's baby - who was supposably killed by the Mountain - and hide him in Essos under the alias 'Young Griff'.

With the help of a character named Jon Connington - the exiled former Hand of the King - Young Griff manages to rally the Golden Company to his cause. They invade lower Westeros and plan to form an alliance with the Dornish against the Lannisters.

This means that Dany will have to contend not only with Jon as a rightful king of Westeros, but her other nephew, Young Griff, aka Aegon Targaryen. As the legitimate son of Rhaegar and Elia Martell of Dorne, this character has the best claim to the Iron Throne.


7. Changing Talisa Stark's (Jeyne Westerling) Back Story

Gameof Thrones Red Wedding
HBO

The show made a huge error altering the back story of this character. In the books, Robb does marry another women, pissing-off the Freys and dooming his cause. But she was not a healer from the Free Cities, she was a noble women from Westeros whose family were Lannister bannermen.

This was how the Red Wedding was orchestrated. Jeyne's (Talisa) family feign loyalty to Robb while secretly helping Lord Tywin plan the massacre. Although Jeyne doesn't have anything to do with the betrayal, it's clear her family used her to get close to the Starks. The entire Robb-marriage-plot-line is all the more tragic knowing it was manipulated from the start. Jeyne does not attend the wedding in the books, which also has huge implications for the future plot.

In the books, the Blackfish (Robb's uncle) is still alive and flopping. It's believed he's rallied many Stark forces who escaped the wedding, and is leading a guerrilla war against the Lannister. Jeyne is also believed to be pregnant. Currently she's under Lannister captivity, but Martin has hinted that the Blackfish will rescue her. Robb's unborn child will then be the symbol for the North to rally around. If this happens, it's far less likely the North will be willing to submit to Dany, even with Jon Snow's support.


6. Tanking The Dornish Plot

Game Of Thrones Prince Doran
HBO

The massive scope of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire means it would be next to impossible to include every detail, character and subplot. Even with axing a huge amount of material, the show runners struggled to resolve their remaining plots succinctly and in a satisfying manor.

But they still made the mistake of entering into plot lines they had no intention of finishing. The introduction of Oberyn Martell, and his death at the hands of the Mountain, kicks off a whole series of events in the books.

The Dornish scheming is some of the most complex in the story: They send a Prince on a secret mission to marry Dany and claim her dragons; they attempt to put Myrcella on the Iron Throne after Joffrey dies. They're also in talks to team up with the long lost son of Rhaegar Targaryen, who is in fact half Dornish. This house basically has a contingency plan for any outcome, and will more than likely play a huge part in tipping the scales one way or the other.

Sadly non of this was explored in the show. Introducing a brilliant character like Oberyn soon became redundant when the remaining Dornish characters drifted into obscurity.


5. The Absence Of Lady Stoneheart

Catelyn Stark
HBO

After the Stark cause died in a storm of Frey knives and crossbow bolts, book fans were eagerly awaiting the arrival of Lady Stoneheart. But with each new season it became ever more likely that Stoneheart would not make an appearance.

For those who have not read the books, Lady Stoneheart is the reanimated corpse of Catelyn Stark.

After the Red Wedding, her body is thrown into the river and after several days she's found by the Brotherhood Without Banners, who resurrect her. But due to her being dead for so long, little is left of the women she was, only a burning hatred for her enemies. She eventually becomes the leader of the Brotherhood and essentially turns them into a terrorist organisation.

She spends her time hanging people left right and centre, including Brienne and Podrick Payne. They're spared at the last minute, however, when Brienne agrees to lure Jaime Lannister into a trap. This would have been a brilliant moment in the show.

Stoneheart also foreshadows what will happen to Jon. Martin has expressed that Stoneheart was a plot device to indicate what can happen when people are brought back after being dead for too long. Whatever happens with Jon, when he returns he won't be the same guy we saw in the show.


4. The 'Actual' Death Of Mance Rayder

Mance Game Of Thrones
HBO

Mance raider was the charismatic former Night's Watchmen who led the biggest army the Wildlings had ever assembled. Sadly, not much came of the endeavour. The Wildlings were defeated and Mance got the ol' fiery death treatment.

All this happens in the book, but the show missed out one key detail: Mance was not the man they burned. In the book it's all an elaborate ruse. Melisandre uses her magic to make Mance and the Lord of Bones appear as one another. The Lord of Bones is killed and Mance is spared.

Mance then agrees to infiltrate Winterfell where Jon believes Ramsay is holding his sister captive (in the books the Boltons are claiming to have Arya Stark, but they actually have Jeyne Pool disguised as Arya). The former King-Beyond-the-Wall takes six spearwives, and together they help Theon and Jeyne Pool escape.

When Jon receives a letter from Ramsay demanding his bride back, it states that Mance was captured and has been left hanging in a cage with only the skins of his spearwives to keep him warm.


3. Making Ramsay The Main Antagonist

Game Of Thrones Ramsay Bolton
HBO

During his tenure on Game of Thrones, Ramsay Bolton became the most hated character in TV history. What with all the raping, flaying, and infanticide, he didn't have many redeeming features. But he wasn't just cruel, he was calculated.

Ramsay had a plan to rule the North, he used his prominent father to gain legitimacy and then did away with him when he wasn't needed. Although he had the backing of the Lannisters, one certainly felt he could get on quite happily without them.

This isn't really the way it works in the books. If anything, Ramsay is far more depraved, but he's also a bit clueless. He thinks he's surrounded by a group of loyal men known as the 'Bastard's Boys', in actual fact these men are loyal to his father Roose, and report to him about his son's actions.

Roose is still alive in the books, and is most definitely calling the shots. It's a far more interesting dynamic as we see Roose use his son - much like Tywin used the Mountain - as the wildcard on the battlefield.

Choosing to focus on Ramsay resulted in attention being taken away from Euron, who is in actual fact the true threat in Westeros, and may even trigger the coming of the White Walkers through dark sorcery.


2. Barristan Selmy's Early Demise

Barristan Selmy Game of Thrones
HBO

Even Ian McElhinney was shocked to find out his character, Ser Barristan Selmy, would be killed off in season five. Cut down by the Sons of the Harpy, Barristan's end was heroic but it came far too soon for viewers liking.

And for good reason. Barristan had a much larger role to play in the story. Although the show skimmed over the Battle of Meereen, it's a far larger affair in the books, and is far from over. As it stands, Dany is still lost in the Dothraki Sea. Meereen is under the rule of Selmy and a number of non-show characters, who are desperately trying to hold the city together.

A vast slaver army has laid siege to the city, leaving Barristan no choice but to lead a desperate counter-attack. In the teased chapters released from the upcoming book, The Winds of Winter, Barristan leads a force outside the walls to do battle. As the fight intensifies a fleet of Iron Born appear, and to everyones surprise lend a hand in fighting off the Slavers.

It's unlikely Dany will return in time to save the day, and Selmy will likely be the one to claim victory. He will then have the task of treating with the Iron Born - who happen to have a magic horn that can control dragons...


1. Turning Euron Into A Joke

Euron greyjoy game of thrones
HBO

This guy really should have become the most terrifying villain ever to plague our screens. Instead we got a man with silly mutton chops delivering the most ridiculous lines of dialogue in the show.

Book Euron is a character who threatens to undo everything the Lannisters have worked so hard for. He's raiding the coasts of Westeros, amassing plunder and ships, and generally causing terror. His Iron Men are roaming around unchecked, pillaging and burning their way up and down the country.

Euron has also sent his (not-in-the-show) younger brother, Victarion, with another fleet to capture Dany. Euron has 'gifted' his brother a Dragon Horn, which when blown, will potentially bind Dany's dragons to Euron's will.

He's also gathering huge amounts of holy men and women for some kind of mass-ritualistic-blood-sacrifice, which will likely summon a fleet of krakens.

This guy might become such a threat to Westeros that the Starks, Boltons, Lannisters and whoever else is left alive, will have to team up in the hopes of stopping him... , well maybe that's a stretch. But the point is this guy is going to cause some serious issues for everyone who's not on team squid.


Contributor

Before engrossing myself in the written word, I spent several years in the TV and film industry. During this time I became proficient at picking things up, moving things and putting things down again.