Game Of Thrones: 12 Ups And 5 Downs From Season 7

"A long and bloody tale. To be honest, I was drunk for most of it."

Game Of Thrones Season 7
HBO

The last flaming embers of Game of Thrones Season 7 have died out, the Wall has come crashing down, the joy has turned to ashes in our mouths, and it really was all c*cks in the end. Well, maybe.

Season 7 was a year unlike any other on Game of Thrones, and not just because it started in summer and only ran for seven episodes.

While there were fewer instalments this year it was, in some ways, a much bigger season than ever before. Whereas previously the effects and extras-heavy set-pieces would come but once a year, here they seemed to arrive every other episode.

On the flip side, it was also one of the more divisive and criticised runs of the show so far, with bad ideas, incomprehensible rules of travel, and some storylines that didn't quite work. We're no longer in the Great Game but the endgame, and this season mostly served to set that up.

It was at times beautiful, on occasion baffling, but above all brilliantly entertaining, and while not the series' strongest year, it still had a lot to love.


Ups...

12. Dragons

Game of Thrones Drogon
HBO

Ian McShane dismissed the series as just being about "t*ts and dragons", a common reference point for the show.

That's always been far too reductive, and there is much more to the series than either of those things, but at the same time it was glorious to see them unleashed in such incredible fashion.

T*ts didn't have much of a role to play (save for Davos checking out people's 'good hearts'), but dragons came to the fore in a way unlike any other, and it was spectacular to witness.

It's easy to see where the budget went this year, because the CGI of the dragons was as phenomenal as it was thrilling to see them in action, especially in the barnburner that was Field of Fire 2.0. There have been criticisms of them as a deux ex machina, but given the show has been building towards unleashing these beasts since the very beginning, there's more than enough to justify the way they've been used this year.

Whether living or (un)dead, burning enemies or sharing a much quieter moment with Jon Snow, it was the best year yet for the dragons.


11. The Humour

The Hound Game Of Thrones Season 7
HBO

Game of Thrones has always had its quotable quips, most often delivered from the mouth of Peter Dinklage, but this year definitely felt like one of the funniest so far.

From Euron asking about Jaime and Cersei's sex life, to Tormund's continued flirting with Brienne, and pretty much every line spoken by the Hound and Bronn, there were a lot of laughs to be had among the carnage of Season 7.

The show has plenty of dark, bleak moments, and those of heart-racing tension, so it's important to balance those out with scenes and lines that add levity to the drama, and also serves to further humanise its characters.

Death may be the enemy coming for everyone, but at least we can still laugh at Thoros' top-knot and enjoy three characters who all excel at dropping the C-bomb. Handily, all the season's funniest moments have been packaged into one video too, which is certainly worth a watch:


10. The Action

Game of Thrones Wight Bear
HBO

It almost goes without saying at this stage, but once again the action on Game of Thrones continues to be on another level entirely. We've already discussed the dragons, but even outside of the fire-breathing creatures there were some stunning action sequences this year, and more than usual too.

Again, there's more to Thrones than this, but in a season when the storytelling took a dip the spectacle and scale of the show really shone through. It's enough to remind you that we should be thankful this show even gets made at all.

The battle at sea kicked things off, giving us a different, darker perspective on the typical battle. It was fast, frenetic, and, while a little difficult to make out at times, exciting to see Euron Greyjoy in full mad pirate mode.

Beyond-The-Wall, again, gave us some gorgeous set-pieces, thanks to the icy backdrop and heart-in-mouth tension of the episode. The wight bear was a wonderful monster movie-esque scene, and the battle with the dead - and subsequent arrival of Daenerys - some of the best zombie action you'll find on television.

Then there's The Spoils of War. The episode wasn't perfect, but watching the 'Loot Train Attack' unfold was a sight to behold. Dragon aside, it was great to finally see what the Dothraki are capable of in an open field, while following Bronn through the battle - a la Jon during the Battle of the Bastards - was an indelible bit of camera work, and gave one of the show's best characters his big moment. If anything this season had too much focus on its action and dragons but, in terms of watching those things play out, it was pretty marvellous.


9. The Behind-The-Scenes Crew Had An Amazing Year

Ramin Djawadi
Gage Skidmore [CC BY-SA 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Game of Thrones is, in so many ways, the biggest show on TV, and the sheer amount of work that goes into making a season is astonishing. There are far too many people to highlight in terms of the behind-the-scenes work, but Season 7 did include a few real standouts.

Ramin Djawadi has been one of the show's hidden strengths since the very beginning, and he did some superlative work yet again this year. His score can, by turns, add drama, suspense, pace, weight, or romance, perfectly meshing with what we see on-screen to help carry it along. This year didn't give us anything quite as insanely good as Light of the Seven, but with so many characters meeting it was great to see how he utilised old scores in different ways, and guided us through the story without even realising it.

Michele Clapton is the other crew member who had a ridiculously good year. Game of Thrones' costume designer (who was missing from Season 6), she was on-point more than ever before this season, from the black outfit of Cersei to that stunning white winter wear of Daenerys when she goes beyond the Wall. Again, there were clues and symbolism within the costumes, such as Arya and Cersei both invoking memories of their fathers, and by the end it seemed almost everyone had taken the black.

The series was once again beautifully shot, thanks to Robert MacLachlan and co, and Deborah Riley's production design was again incredible, especially in reintroducing us to Dragonstone. The editing team didn't have quite as great a year, with the season at times feeling a bit like The Force Awakens in the way it rollicked from one beat to the next, but that's forgivable when they also gave us perhaps the most disgustingly brilliant cut in TV history.


8. Reunions And First Meetings

Game of Thrones Jaime Tyrion
HBO

One of the most notable aspects of the show, now that it's nearing the end, is the way characters are colliding like never before. The vast lands of Westeros and Essos have served to keep major players apart for most of the run, but Season 7 saw almost all the big players having either a long-awaited reunion or first meeting.

There was a real thrill as these characters came together, be it for the first time in years or the first time ever. These are moments we've been waiting aeons for, some of which were dangled in front of us (the close calls between Sansa and Arya), others with a great build-up of anticipation.

There is an element of fan-service to this, but it comes after years of waiting and wondering, which means we're really owed a bit of it. The Starks coming back together didn't lead to a great story in the end, but the initial reunions - especially between the sisters - provided real emotion. Likewise, Tyrion reuniting with first Jaime, then Cersei, gave us two incredible scenes, while it was fun to watch him catch up with Pod and Bronn too.

Gendry and Davos, the Hound and the Mountain, all of the Eastwatch Seven, Jon and Theon, Brienne and Arya, Jon and Tyrion, and of course Jon and Dany - all these meetings had years - in some cases decades - of weight behind them, and it was satisfying to see it all finally happening.


7. The Greyjoys Were Interesting Again

Game Of Thrones Trailer Theon
HBO

The Greyjoys have had a bit of a mixed time on the show. Theon has had a great arc - albeit one that involved him being graphically tortured - but the rest of the family hasn't fared so well. They did come back into play a little in Season 6, but it was quite brief. Season 7, for the most part, did a great job in building them back up.

There's a fair argument to be made that Euron Greyjoy was the most improved player of Season 7. Not only did he get a fancy makeover, complete with haircut and eyeliner, but he was also more fully realised as a villain. He got a little lost in the shuffle towards the middle, but for the first three episodes he was one of the strongest characters, with some of the best lines, a great action sequence, and a tangible threat to him.

Theon, meanwhile, made huge strides in his redemption arc. Alfie Allen has long been one of the show's best performers, and he was utterly heartbreaking this year when he fled Euron at sea, and when his shattered self was reunited with Jon (especially their second scene). Yara was the least served of the family, but even she had some strong moments in the early stages, especially her off-the-cuff scene with Ellaria and the brilliant sea battle that followed.


6. The Rogues

Game of Thrones Bronn
HBO

Outside of its truly main characters - basically anyone with the surname Stark, Lannister, Targaryen, or Snow - the show has a ridiculous wealth of supporting players to try and balance. And while that's a difficult job it doesn't always succeed in, Season 7 did well by a number of the wise-cracking, badass rogues we've grown to love over the years.

Bronn has felt a little underused since teaming up with Jaime, and that seemed to be the case again after the first three episodes. But then The Spoils of War was, in part, focused around him, and following him through the battlefield was one of the season's most stunning moments. He got to be a hero, shoot a dragon, save Jaime's life, reunite with Tyrion and Pod, and deliver some ridiculously good lines.

Likewise, Tormund serves as something of his Northern equivalent, and while he disappeared to Eastwatch for a spell, he again had some huge moments this season (two of which he probably should've died in), and was a joy to watch. Davos was once again the best of the advisors, serving by Jon's side and offering up plenty of sage advice; Jorah was cured of greyscale in rather gross out fashion, was reunited with his khaleesi, and then got to go off to capture a wight (a dumb plan, but his part was still noble); the Hound, after coming back in Season 6, really reminded us why he's one of the show's greatest, most well-developed characters as he saw into the flames and overcame - and then was haunted by again - his fears; Beric got to wield his flaming sword once more.

These characters may not be outright heroes, but they're among the show's most fascinating and, on a more basic level, enjoyable to watch, and that was definitely the case this year.


5. The War Of The Two Queens

Game Of Thrones Trailer Daenerys Dragonstone Throne
HBO

Last season ended with Cersei taking the Iron Throne while Daenerys sailed for Westeros, so naturally a big part of this season was the War of the Two Queens.

Having Daenerys in Westeros added some much-needed agency to her storyline, and her arriving on Dragonstone was a genuinely touching moment (while the castle itself looked lush). Cersei, meanwhile, was afforded the opportunity to revel in her Mad Queen role, which Lena Headey grabbed with both hands.

It was in this storyline that we found some of the old Thrones, with conversations taking place in dimly lit rooms and political manoeuvering becoming important once again, as Cersei/Jaime and Daenerys/Tyrion plotted away around their respective impressive maps.

The rivalry gave us a couple of great action sequences, brought Tyrion back into the fold more (even if his plans were terrible), made Euron a bigger and better player, gave Dany and especially Cersei lots to work with, and led to the death of Olenna Tyrell, one of the best scenes of the season. It's still unresolved, pushed to one side due to the White Walkers, but while it was ongoing there was riveting drama and incredible spectacle to be found in the War of the Two Queens.


4. Jaime Advances His Redemption Arc

Game of Thrones Jaime Snow
HBO

Jaime Lannister is one of the most fascinating characters in A Song of Ice and Fire, something that the show hasn't conveyed quite as successfully. Jaime is still great - with some help from Nikolaj Coster-Waldau's performance - but we needed to see more of his inner-conflict, and ultimately a turn away from Cersei.

Building on some of the groundwork from previous years - his relationship with Brienne, conversation with Edmure Tully etc - we get to see Jaime clearly uncomfortable with the actions of his sister, and how far he's come since the days of "the things we do for love." There he was happy pushing a child out of a window, now he wants to give an old woman (and enemy) a peaceful death.

There's a certain tragedy in the way Jaime knows he's being outsmarted by his sister, and is unable to prevent it, which is compounded with the pregnancy reveal. But we also get to see the brave warrior of legend too, as he leads the troops in the Loot Train Attack, risking his own life to try and take out Daenerys.

Finally, he wants to fight for the good of the realm, choosing the side of the living, which brings him into much more conflict with Cersei than ever before, and he ultimately decides to leave. It built up throughout the season, and was a wonderful payoff for such a rich character, setting his full redemption arc in motion.


3. Lena Headey (And The Rest Of The Cast)

Game Of Thrones Cersei Eastwatch
HBO

Even when Game of Thrones isn't on top form in other areas, you can generally rely on the cast to produce some stellar work, and so it was in Season 7.

Indeed, some actors gave better work than perhaps ever before: pairing Kit Harington and Emilia Clarke together brought out the best in them both - especially the latter, as Harington has really upped his game overall since coming back from the dead - while Maisie Williams and Sophie Turner were obviously having a great time getting to act opposite each other for the first time in years.

Alfie Allen, as previously mentioned, continues to do incredible work with Theon, adding so many layers to make the once-reviled character now someone we actively root for; Peter Dinklage was back in Westeros, and back on top form (not that he ever really dipped, but it was great to see him more involved); Liam Cunningham gets better every year; Jim Broadbent was an addition so fitting it made you wonder how he hadn't been there all along.

Top plaudits, though, must go to Lena Headey. While she's always been good on the show, the last couple of seasons have seen her performance become something really special, and Season 7 must put her in strong contention for that elusive Emmy. There's seemingly no emotion she cannot convey with her face, and her mouth acting alone deserves to win awards. Cersei's rule may be under threat, but Headey reigns supreme.


2. A Song Of Ice And Fire

Game of Thrones Jon Snow Daenerys
HBO

Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen have long been the two central protagonists of this story, and yet had been kept worlds apart. That was always likely to change in Season 7, with Dany coming to Westeros, but the how and when was unknown. A meeting six years (or over 20, for long-time book readers), there was a huge amount of pressure on the biggest coming together of two characters in the series' history.

Mercifully, they nailed it.

Their first meeting on Dragonstone was a tense, slightly awkward affair, punctuated by the input of their respective right-hand men, before things eased into an increasingly strong chemistry between them.

It all happened rather quickly, but there was a tinge of rivalry, a hint of attraction, and a lot of weight in the representations of ice and fire being, and then working together, eventually building to the romantic climax in The Dragon and the Wolf.

Quite where it goes from there is unclear, since Jon may be uncomfortable with incest, Dany will still want to rule, and there's a strong suggestion of them having a child together. But for Season 7 to pivot around these two more than ever before, with them now joined together, was a wise move, and a major success given how much was riding on it.

Yay, incest!


1. The Great War Is Here

Game of Thrones Night King Viserion
HBO

The marketing campaign for Season 7 leaned heavily on the arrival of the Great War, usually with Jon and Davos giving an ominous warning about the coming dead.

That was slightly misleading because, being the penultimate season, this year was really just setup for the Great War. But as far as setup goes, it did in epic fashion.

One of the opening scenes of the season was a vision of the White Walkers and the army of the dead, now featuring giants, and even unseen their presence weighed heavily on the season. The show has been ramping up the threat they pose ever since Hardhome, but this year - and especially the final two episodes - took us into the Great War like never before.

Beyond The Wall had its issues as an episode, but the sight of the Night King killing a dragon, and then resurrecting it, was a huge moment, and that blue eye opening up won't be forgotten anytime soon.

Likewise, the closing stages of the season were spectacular, with the Wall coming down after around 8,000 years. If the Night King killing a dragon was impressive, then him riding one as it produced blue fire to bring the great structure down was doubly so, and the army of the dead flooded into Westeros at last.

Thankfully the show still has Cersei around too, so it can (hopefully) maintain its political intrigue as well, but the Battle of Ice and Fire - thanks to the closing episodes of this season - is shaping up to be a stunner.


Downs...

5. Characters Pushed To The Side

Game Of Thrones Ghost
HBO

I've already spoken about how the show handled some of its big supporting characters, and did so extremely well. There is a flip side of that, though, and for every favourite done right, there were those underserved by the plot this year.

Varys, for so long one of the game's biggest and most brilliant players, was no longer spinning his webs or listening to little birds (who are now in the service of Qyburn). Instead he was mostly sitting around at Dragonstone, being directly threatened by Daenerys and having his death foreshadowed by Melisandre. He had a couple of good scenes, sure, but his role and importance dwindled massively, a real sign of how the game is changing (see also: Littlefinger dying).

Brienne, too, was mostly just left kicking her heels and sharpening her sword. She had one excellent scene with Arya, but aside from that and brief (but fun) exchanges with the Hound and Jaime, did pretty much nothing in the entire season. The same could be said for Pod too, although that's more typically been his role anyway.

The most egregious, though, has to be Ghost. The show has rarely handled direwolves particularly well anyway - in part because of the financial cost to end quality ratio - but Ghost was completely MIA this year. It's strange that Jon, who is supposed to be so close to his wolf, wouldn't take him to Dragonstone, and even stranger he wouldn't take him beyond the Wall. Maybe he left him at Winterfell as protection, but since we didn't see that (we just hear a passing mention of him), it really just feels like Ghost was forgotten about, and not included because of the budget. That's a real shame, because Ghost is an essential part of who Jon is, and one of the last remaining emblems of the North.

It is, of course, an almost impossible task to fit all of these characters into a season, especially a shortened one when we're so close to the endgame, and storylines are coalescing. Nonetheless, it's still frustrating to have some great characters pushed so far to the sidelines.


4. A Lot Of The Winterfell Plot

Game Thrones Beyond Wall Arya Sansa
HBO

Winterfell wasn't necessarily the worst part of the season, but it was the strangest. Arya returning home was well-handled at first, with a reunion in the crypts and then that awesome sparring with Brienne, but it all went downhill after that.

The show forced a lot of tension between Arya and Sansa, which reached its nadir in the odd showdown in Beyond The Wall. The sisters never really got on, but it was really weird to see death threats being made, and viewers left wondering if it was a game or not.

In the end Littlefinger got the knife, and his death scene was brilliantly executed, with the scene between the Stark sisters after perhaps even better - an example of what it should have been all along.

Petyr Baelish's death was always the end goal, but the journey to reach that destination was badly handled, feeling more like a cheap attempt to trick viewers and keep the plot at Winterfell ticking over so they could have Littlefinger's death in the finale.

Bran gets dragged into that as well, and even with the deleted scene between him and Sansa it wouldn't be much improved. His abilities were too ill-defined for the most part, the character feeling too bizarre (and a little creepy). Littlefinger's plot was more an act of desperation than a calculated scheme from the master manipulator, and most of the Winterfell storyline did a disservice to its characters, not least Arya Stark.


3. Sam's Storyline

Game Of Thrones Sam Gilly Citadel
HBO

Since leaving the Wall in Season 5, Samwell Tarly's storyline has taken a big nosedive. Someone who was a fairly important - or at least consistent - character for five seasons hardly appeared in Season 6, and this year was a continuation of that.

He was in most of the episodes, but his time at the Citadel - where we expected him to make a major discovery - was spent cleaning out bedpans, serving Jorah's story, discovering information we already knew and ignoring that which we didn't.

The whole subplot of Sam going to Oldtown is messy and poorly written, so it's probably good that we can now move on from there, but it still feels like a bit of a waste. Heartsbane, the sword he stole from his father in a defining moment, doesn't come into it, he apparently doesn't learn about his father and brother dying, and him revealing to Bran about Rhaegar's annulment seems like an attempt to shoe-horn him back into the plot, even though Bran could feasibly have just seen that on his own.

All that's without even mentioning Gilly, whose one important scene involves just being ignored, and is probably too good for this cruel world anyway.


2. The Logic Gaps

Game Of Thrones Captured Wight
HBO

There is, of course, always a suspension of disbelief in a story about magic, dragons, and ice zombies. But Game of Thrones has always been incredibly tight with its own internal logic that it all worked cohesively.

Season 7, more than ever before, really pushed the limits of logic and took some major leaps with it. The most offending example was Beyond The Wall, where Gendry (the fastest runner, who can also see the colour of a bear's eyes in a storm from some distance) manages to navigate his way back to Eastwatch, the non-existent Maester sends a raven which flies to Dragonstone in record time, and then Dany comes and saves the day. Now, people on the internet have put a lot of time and effort into figuring out if this works or not, but Thrones should be tighter than that, and at least show the passage of time more effectively.

Even then, they could've asked Dany in the first place, and if they'd just stayed put then the White Walkers wouldn't have been able to bring the Wall down (and maybe it was all a plan by the Night King, but that still leaves gaps, such as it being Tyrion's idea).

Indeed, the teleporting around Westeros is something that's drawn a lot of criticism (it had some in Season 6 too, in fairness), and at first this was easy to ignore. They had to get on with the story, after all, but the more it happened the worse it became.

Character decisions didn't make much sense either. No one ever asked Bran anything (apart from in a deleted scene) even though he could've cleared a lot up; he conveniently hadn't seen a key scene with Rhaegar and Lyanna (which, sure, his abilities mean he has to look for something, but he was very focused on Jon's parentage); they, in turn, named a son Aegon, ignoring that there was another Aegon Targaryen alive (again, there are possible explanations out there, but nothing watertight); and capturing a wight was possibly the dumbest idea Tyrion's ever had, and somehow everyone went along with it and didn't ask any questions.

I don't think any of this makes the show bad, and especially in the heat of the moment it's heart-racing, thrilling stuff, but it has been and should still be better than that.


1. Not Enough Episodes

Jon Snow Ser Davos
HBO

A lot of these problems do, ultimately, come down to one overarching issue: there just weren't enough episodes in Season 7.

David Benioff and Dan Weiss have said of their decision to have shorter seasons that it's how much story is left (other reports have since suggested it's to do with production/budget, but HBO would surely give them what they need), and watching Season 7 it's clear there's enough story for a regular 10-episode run.

It's easy to understand them wanting to pick up the pace, but the slow build has always been one of the joys of Game of Thrones. And even Season 6, which went at a faster clip than normal, had 10 instalments and found time for that gradual rise.

Benioff and Weiss know how this story ends, but just as important (if not more so) is the journey to that point. Unfortunately, a lot of Season 7 felt like them rushing past that; they knew where characters had to be for the endgame, and got them there as quickly as possible. It led to some of the storytelling feeling rather rushed (for example, Jon just going to/being at Dragonstone could've taken up a lot of a regular season), rather than a meticulously-plotted masterpiece.

What did you think of Season 7? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.