Game Of Thrones: 10 Craziest Fan Theories

Sometimes the maddest theories are the closest to the truth.

Game Of Thrones is crazily hot right now, especially after the long awaited Mountain versus Viper fight, and inevitably, fans perpetually second guess what is coming next: even those who have already reads the books, since HBO have consciously sought to add surprises even for those fans. And as well as looking ahead, fans are encouraged heartily to look back at what has already happened, speculating on the meaning of the show's manifold unresolved questions and plot lines, and seeking to solve the biggest mysteries in Westeros - as well as inventing some of their own for entertainment purposes. Naturally in this world of speculation, every character has an amazing destiny and a shady past and there are secrets everywhere - even the most innocuous of characters - though somewhat inevitably the most enduring theories concentrate on the most popular characters as no one really cares about the truth behind the background of Grand Maester Pycelle. While there are hundreds of Game of Thrones theories spread across the internet, we're celebrating the best and more importantly the most ludircous of those dedicated to the characters and locations already seen in the television series, which should change the way you view the show. For better or worse. But be warned that spoilers follow for events that haven€™t yet appeared on the show.

10. Is Jon Snow€ A Targaryan?

There are theories that pretty much everyone in Westeros is a Targaryan, but the most enduring is that the primary heir to that throne is Jon Snow. The idea itself isn€™t particularly unlikely - George R.R. Martin famously asked David Benioff and D.B. Weiss €œWho is Jon Snow€™s mother?€ in order to judge their worthiness to produce the show. He never said whether their guess was correct but Weiss said that €œhis smile was his tell€. So who is the most unlikely person to be the mother of Ned Stark€™s bastard son? Naturally the answer (if you€™re not a Lannister) is his sister, Lyanna. This is because he isn€™t Ned€™s son at all €“ he€™s the son of Rhagar Targaryen and was taken by Ned from his dying sister at the Tower of Joy. This is an element not covered in any great detail in the series but the books show Ned travelling to that location in Dorne at the end of Robert€™s Rebellion. There he finds three Kingsguard defending the Tower (remember this was after the sacking of King€™s Landing) and he and his companions fight their way inside where he finds his sister in a pool of blood. Speculation is that this was Jon€™s birth gone wrong and Lyanna made Ned promise before her death that he would protect the boy. As Robert would have killed any potential Targaryan heirs in Westeros, Ned had to hide Jon as his own bastard. Why would the overly honourable Ned Stark ever cheat on his wife? The story of a Stark/Targaryan child would be suitable to be called €œA Song Of Ice And Fire€.

9. Who Is Hodor?

Hodor is far larger than everyone else in the series, barring the Mountain himself, and it was even suggested by Osha that he could be descended from giants. As for his ancestry, fans have suggested a possibility €“ that he is a descendent of Ser Duncan the Tall, who has featured in a series of short stories by George R.R. Martin, who had also said that a descendent of his would be revealed in A Feast for Crows. However this was almost certainly a reference to Brienne after she mentioned a shield with his crest on it in the armouries of Tarth. The other and far more likely suggestion is that he is actually a member of House Frey, as Nan revealed that Hodor isn€™t his name €“ it€™s actually Walder, and the only other character in the series to hold that name is Walder Frey. It is also said that many Freys name their sons Walder in order to curry favour with their liege and with the Brotherhood Without Banners hunting the Frey family in revenge for the Red Wedding, it could be that Hodor could end up being the last surviving male heir. Lord Hodor perhaps? The final Hodor related theory is based on the idea that George R.R. Martin uses Norse mythology throughout A Song of Ice and Fire and so the character is actually related to Höðr (also spelt as Hodur or Hoder). This may be the name of the god of the White Walkers, one that Melisandre has said must not be named. With Hodor now north of the wall and potentially heading deep into their territory, perhaps he is destined to resolve something related to their god.

8. The End Of Cersei

When Cersei was young, she visits a fortune teller named Maggy the Frog €“ these scenes look set to be shown during season five, according to the casting call that went out. At that meeting she is told she would marry the king (and that he would father far more children than she would bare) and that her little brother would kill her. This set in motion her path and her belief that Tyrion would eventually kill her €“ meaning that she took steps to ensure that this wouldn€™t happen. The fan theories are that this was totally incorrect because Cersei has two little brothers, as there is also Jaime to consider. There is a scene coming up towards the end of season four where Tyrion will kill Shae by strangling her to death with a chain of golden hands, which fans have interpreted to be a reference to Cersei€™s eventual end by being strangled by Jaime€™s golden hand. There are other fans who decree this to be entirely too obvious by the standard of Game of Thrones theories. They suggest that it may in fact be a double bluff and that Tyrion will be the one to kill his sister after all, while those who support the Jaime idea instead argue that Tyrion€™s reaction to his double murder (coming up during season four) will prevent him from ever considering killing his sister. Who knows really? The one thing that they agree on is that Cersei is going to come to an untimely end at some point.

7. Who, Where Or What Is Benjen Stark?

One of the most popular theories to be discussed on the web is what happened to Benjen Stark after he disappeared while on a ranging north of the wall only three episodes into the TV series. While his horse made its way back to Castle Black and his companions were found dead, there was no sign of Benjen. There are three obvious possibilities €“ he€™s dead (but his body wasn€™t found), he€™s alive (which begs the question as to why he didn€™t return to the wall as he was only a mile from it), or he€™s become a wight. For a while there was e a theory that somehow, Daario Naharis was actually Benjen in disguise, but this was debunked by the television show as they were certainly not played by the same actor. The other major theory is that he is actually a character called Coldhands who is yet to appear on TV €“ he is a wight that was formerly a member of the Night€™s Watch and rides a giant Elk. In the books he saves Samwell Tarly and Gilly after fleeing Craster€™s Keep and later guides Bran and his company. But the Coldhands theory is probably disproved as he was referred to as being killed €œa long time ago€ by a character over two hundred years old €“ which wouldn€™t have been said if it actually was Benjen, as he would have only have been killed a matter of years prior. But with Bran, Hodor and co still heading north, if Benjen is still about it seems inevitable that they might come across him no matter who or what he now is.

6. Syrio Forel Lives!

Back at the end of season one when Meryn Trant and his men came for Arya Stark, her €œdancing master€ Syrio Forel delayed them while only armed with a wooden sword, giving her enough time to escape. During the fight he declared himself to have been the First Sword of Braavos €“ and certainly from the description in the book and what was seen on screen, he did enough damage with just that wooden training sword. The thing is, he isn€™t described as actually being killed on the page or on screen. In A Clash of Kings, Cersei says, €œI sent Meryn Trant to take her in hand when Robert died, but her wretched dancing master interfered and the girl fled.€ This can be taken to mean that Trant survived, and never told her about the whole first sword business. Cersei is unlikely to want to inspect the body of a dancing teacher, and so it is entirely possible that Trant lied, while in fact the Lannister stooge got smacked silly with a wooden sword and made to submit before Syrio fled the capital. It has even been suggested that not only did Syrio escape, but he is actually Jaqen H€™ghar in disguise. This would mean that the Faceless Men were interested in Arya right from the beginning. It might be her natural ability in her training sessions with Syrio that actually makes them spot her. This Jaqen link may yet be explained as he€™s due to come back in the TV show, as he has reappeared in the books under the new face that Arya saw him change into.

5. Daenerys Was Raised In Dorne

According to Daenerys, she spent her childhood in Braavos at a house with a red door and a lemon tree outside. It is that particular tree which is the important clue here, as when Arya later travels there she makes a very specific remark to state that there are no trees in Braavos. So is it likely that in the time since Daenerys spent her childhood there that all the trees have vanished, or was Daenerys told that she was in Braavos when she was actually somewhere else? In Storm of Swords it is repeatedly said that lemon trees grow in Dorne €“ does this mean it€™s possible that Daenerys was actually brought up in Westeros? Additionally there's the fact that the secret marriage pact between Viserys Targaryen and Arianne Martell (which he wasn€™t even aware of himself) was signed by Oberyn Martell. The contradictory point is that the pact was witnessed by someone pertaining to be the Sealord of Braavos €“ but instead of being signed there, maybe this simply shows that it was being financed by the Iron Bank? The purpose of this pact? House Martell wanted to overthrow King Robert and oust his Lannister backing and the Dornishmen continue to support the Targaryen cause with Oberyn€™s eldest brother, Quentyn, travelling to Meereen in an effort to bring Daenerys to Westeros. So with all of these connections it seems that Dorne has always been the power behind the Targaryen resurgence.

4. King€™s Landing Will Be Destroyed

The destruction of King€™s Landing has already been referred to once in the series, with Jaime Lannister killing King Aerys II Targaryen to prevent him from ordering the detonation of wildfire caches spread throughout the city. While it is often considered that these were used to defend the city against Stannis Baratheon€™s fleet, that was actually new wildfire created on the orders of first Joffrey and then Tyrion. This means that there are stockpiles of wildfire still hidden throughout King€™s Landing. It is certainly likely that the reader/viewer would not have been alerted to their presence if there was no intention by George R.R. Martin to use them at some point in the future. All it would take is for some massive heat source with a large area of effect to hit the city€ say for instance the flames of a rather large dragon€ to detonate those caches and destroy the city utterly. Given that any assault by Daenerys and her dragons would eventually result in a last line of defence around the city, it is entirely probable that they will unintentionally destroy the city and the majority of the army defending it. Or it could be that Cersei, in her eventual madness, finds out about these caches and is plotting to destroy the city in revenge during Daenerys€™ inevitable attack, resulting in Jaime killing her to save the city once again.

3. The Truth Behind Robert€™s Rebellion

There are fans who believe that Robert€™s Rebellion wasn€™t simply started by the abduction of Lyanna Stark by Crown Prince Rhaegar Targaryen €“ instead there was an element of empire building instigated by the likes of Rickard Stark (Ned€™s father) along with the Tullys and the Arryns. The Mad King has often been called paranoid for believing that there was a faction out there to get him and in fact he was right. Robert Baratheon€™s father died young and so the young Lord was sent to foster with Jon Arryn alongside Ned Stark. They hadn€™t planned for the events that would ultimately result in the rebellion after Lyanna was taken as when her oldest brother arrived at King€™s Landing and demanded combat with Rhaegar, the King threw him and his men into prison. Then when their fathers arrived to demand their release, he had them all killed. Rickard demanded trial by combat and as his champion, Aerys II chose fire €“ setting Lord Stark alight while encased in a full suit of armour. But the theory states that it wasn€™t simply the Lords of the great houses that were the power behind the play that ultimately resulted in the Rebellion €“ it was actually the Maesters working together. This couldn€™t have gone undetected by the Grand Maester, so in order for this theory to be correct then Pycelle must have been behind the whole thing.

2. Missandei Is A Faceless Man

This is an interesting theory, which may be utterly destroyed by the recent events in the television show that showed that Missandei and Grey Worm may be entering into a romantic liaison. Until now it was suggested that she might in fact be a Faceless Man as she seems wise far beyond her years. In the books she€™s meant to be only around eleven years old (as specifically stated in A Dance of Dragons). There are several clues to her unusual nature, which includes her ability to sneak up on Ser Barristan and her ability to hear noises from half a mile away. She was meant to have a brother who was killed in Astapor, but that simply could have been another Faceless Man as who is to say that all of them are as technically proficient as Jaqen H€™ghar. Missandei also seems to fall into a nasty habit of referring to herself as €œthis one€, but not on a constant basis, and she is often found reading old scrolls from the Meereen library. While this might be a red herring, it could be that the Faceless Men are searching for information on something and they have been secretly guiding Daenerys into taking Meereen to gain unhindered access to their libraries.

1. The Resurrection Of Eddard Stark

Until the end of the first season there was a rumour that the person executed wasn€™t Eddard Stark at all because of the description of him in the book. However it was made clear that it was Sean Bean at the time and the likelihood that a Faceless Man would impersonate him (and be killed) would seem extremely low. So it is certain that he was killed €“ but with Caitlyn Stark resurrected as Lady Stoneheart there remains the chance that the same magic could be used on Ned. Sean Bean even said after season one that €œIt would be nice to come back, if it's relevant to the book, and do a few days, it would be nice to get to see everybody.€ But really, how would this actually work? In A Clash of Kings, Caitlyn states that the bones received are far too small for Eddard €“ so whose were actually sent? Could his corpse somehow find its way into the hands of the Brotherhood Without Banners (a faction he indirectly founded) and be resurrected by the magic of the Lord of Light? Or the alternative is that the person killed at the end of season one wasn€™t Ned at all €“ instead Varys disguised someone to appear the same and smuggled him out of the city to support the interests of The Spider. Would Stark support this though, as he€™s always come across as an entirely honourable man? It isn€™t something that has been covered by the books as yet and it seems distinctly unlikely. Perhaps the best that fans can hope for is a return for Sean Bean if a flashback is shown at the Tower of Joy to show Jon Snow€™s birth. One thing is for sure, until the rest of the books come out these theories can only grow in number. But what did you think? Do these seem likely, or do you have other ideas of your own? Let us know below!

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a pop culture addict. Television, cinema, comics, games - you name it, and I've done it. Or at least read the plot synopsis on Wikipedia.