Game Of Thrones Season 4: 10 Book Deviations We'd Love To See

Sacrilege? Possibly. Needed? Definitely.

Now that the stupid Winter Olympics are out of the way, it's time to get back to the only game that matters. Don't be coy. You're the one who clicked on the article. You know damn well what game we're talking about. With season four well within spitting distance, it's time to break out the direwolf memorabilia and reconsider that Hodor tattoo because "Game of Thrones" is back for ten episodes of soul-shattering awesomeness. One of the best parts of watching a movie or TV show based on a series of books is listening to all the hardcore literature fetishists bemoan how "the book was better" and "they left out my favorite scene." But oftentimes, change is for the best. Ever heard of Tom Bombadil? Exactly. When you're trying to adapt a ten thousand page nerd bible into mainstream entertainment, sometimes it's best to make a few alterations here and there. Here, we're gonna throw out some suggestions that Weiss and Benioff could use to make the already awesome source material even more awesome. And if you haven't read the books, then no. Just no. There are so many twists and turns in store for the upcoming season that it'd be almost impossible to dance (with dragons) around all of them. Let us be clear: this article contains every spoiler ever.

10. Stoneheart Speaks

Seriously, guys. If you haven't read "A Storm of Swords", you're about to run into the biggest spoiler since Robb Stark traded in his wedding ring for a wolf head. Odds are non-book readers could never guess what's going to happen next €“ Lady Catelyn Stark, back from the dead to wreak havoc on Westeros in full-on zombie mode. "A Storm of Swords" ends with one of the series' most shocking and outlandish twists; and keep in mind when we say "outlandish," we're talking about the same series that beheaded its lead protagonist and made us watch a woman give birth to a cloud of smoke. While the twist itself is game-changing, Stoneheart has made only fleeting appearances. And because the Walders gave her a red smile below the chin, the not-so-late Lady Catelyn is forced to communicate mostly with guttural sounds and the occasional mumble. While this might achieve the appropriate chills in the novels, it certainly doesn't give actress Michelle Fairley much to work with. Our advice? Give Stoneheart some dialogue and trust the actress to bring the creepy factor. One of the greatest benefits that the TV series has over the books is the excellent casting. Actors are creative people too, and it's almost a given that the showrunners took the Stoneheart twist into consideration when they cast Fairley.

9. Give Us Victarion

Be honest with yourself. Literally nobody read "A Clash of Kings" and though, "Wow, that Balon Greyjoy guy is going places." If by "places," you mean "a watery grave," then you would be right on the money. When Balon takes a tumble off a rope bridge and makes an unexpected visit to the watery halls of the Drowned God, the Lord Reaper leaves a considerable power vacuum in his wake. Cue the typical Westorosi tradition of backstabbing, power-grabbing, and general unpleasantness. "A Feast for Crows" introduces us to Balon's three brothers, all of whom harbour different ambitions for the future of the Iron Islands. In the books, our point of entry for this storyline is Asha (known in the TV series as Yara), who cuts her reaving campaign short and returns to the Iron Islands to attend the inevitable kingsmoot. But since the TV series has set Asha (dammit, Yara) on course to rescue Theon from the clutches of the Boltons, it seems unlikely that she'll divert course to attend the Iron Islanders' admittedly archaic election. Since the show is already introducing Tycho Nestoris and Hizdahr zo Loraq well ahead of the books' timeline, it wouldn't be too big a stretch to toss Victarion into the mix as well. It only makes sense that Yara (or Asha, whatever) would recruit the Iron Captain to help her rescue Theon, and it makes even more sense for her to send him as her representative to the kingsmoot back on Pyke. It would bump up Victarion's debut and avoid just randomly cutting to character's we've never met like they did with Davos and Stannis in season two.

8. The Bronn And Jaime Power Hour

If you weren't paying attention last season, Westeros' most renowned king-slayer/child-murderer/incest-advocate, Jaime Lannister, somehow managed to wiggle his way up to the title of "Everyone's Favorite Character Bar Tyrion". And all he had to do was lose a hand and challenge a bear to a pit fight. Now that he's returned to King's Landing and rejoined the Kingsguard, Jaime's going to need some training with his new sword hand, which up until now has been regulated mostly to "imaginary girlfriend" duty. In the books, Jaime selects the headsman Ser Ilyn Payne as his sparring partner. But since actor Wilko Johnson will no longer be able to appear on the show due to pretty tragic circumstances, the writers decided to substitute his character with fan-favourite Bronn. Now, maybe we're just being overly-optimistic, but this could very well lead to the best spin-off in television history. Or, at the very least, some memes and a YouTube compilation. Don't get us wrong here. As much as we'd like to see the show go completely off-track and follow Jaime and Bronn on a buddy cop rampage across the Seven Kingdoms, there's actually a lot of potential here. As we all know, Tyrion isn't long for King's Landing, leaving Bronn to hole up in a castle and just sort of linger. But having Bronn accompany Jaime to Riverrun would be a nice diversion, and substituting Bronn in Payne's role could solve the problem of keeping everyone's favourite sellsword on the show and making sure Jerome Flynn doesn't return to his music career when his contract expires.

7. A New Death For Shae

Something needs to be made clear right off the bat. We are not George R.R. Martin. We have no delusions of being George R.R. Martin. There will never be a point in our lives that we will hold a candle to the awesomeness that is George R.R. Martin. However, since there's a pretty sizeable divide between Book Shae and Show Shae, granting them the same fate would seem a little out of whack, and it may require a pretty serious deviation from from the source material. Don't get us wrong here. For the sake of the story, Shae needs to take a one-way trip to the great big Wolfswood in the sky. In the book, Tyrion strangles her with the Hand's golden chain of office after she betrays him and beds Lord Tywin, who €“ as irony would have it €“ really did love dem hoes all along. Within the context of the novels, Tyrion's actions make sense €“ Book Shae is a childish gold-digger who's only out for herself. Show Shae, on the other hand, actually shows love and even devotion to Tyrion, so it's hard to imagine her meeting the same fate as her literary counterpart. In the context of the show and the way the characters have been constructed, Tyrion strangling Shae would come off as incredibly dark, even for "Game of Thrones." While we concede that, yes, Shae has to bite the dust before the curtains close on season four, maybe a crossbow bolt or a throat slit would be more merciful. And yes, we just referred to being murdered by a crossbow-toting dwarf as "merciful." Welcome to Westeros.

6. The Tower Of Joy

One of the greatest mysteries presented by the series is the enigmatic identity of Jon Snow's mother. If anyone here is unfamiliar with the famous "R + L = J" theory, then maybe skip past this one if you want to remain completely unspoiled. Still with us? Good. Then you know exactly what we're talking about when we say that it's about time the series started delving into the Lyanna Stark subplot/backstory that Martin has deemed so important. The show has generally shied away from flashbacks, and for good reason; the material is dense enough as it is, so there's no reason to to start ripping out pages from "Lost." However, since the Lyanna theory is almost certainly true €“ seriously, guys, we're more sure about this than we are about our own parentage €“ it'd be nice if the show-runners started throwing a bone to the television crowd. And if flashbacks are to remain a strict no-no, how about some expository dialogue in the form of a story? On a surface level, Ned's quest to rescue Lyanna from the Tower of Joy reflects the classic "damsel in the tower" archetype, only that it ends with her death. Having Littlefinger relate the story to Sansa would put yet another knife in Ginger Stark's fairy-tale reality. Sansa may be a princess locked in a (metaphorical) tower, but there is no Prince Dashing riding to save her. And drawing a parallel between Sansa and Lyanna would highlight Sansa's eventual evolution into Alayne Stone and foreshadow the idea that maybe €“ just maybe €“ Sansa Stark might break out of the role of perpetual pawn and become a legitimate player in the game of thrones.

5. Joffrey Dies More

Disclaimer: This article is titled "10 Book Deviations We'd Love to See," not "10 Book Deviations That Have Any Chance of Happening." With that being said, let's dive into the change we really, really want to see happen. Scene: the royal wedding. Joffrey is being a smug piece of incest fruit like always. He taunts Tyrion. He brags about beheading Ned Stark and using whores for crossbow practice. He takes a sip of wine and a handful of pie. Those who have read the books feel a smug grin play at the corner of their lips. They know what's coming. They know that King Do-As-He-Likes is about to get his just desserts. And when Joffrey's eyeballs start bulging out of his head, a collective cheer rises across the world. But this is TV, and Joffrey is too much of a royal fartbag to get off that easy. As His Grace chokes, a member of the Kingsguard leaps forward. He tries to clear the King's throat €“ with his fist. Cue Joffrey getting punched in the throat. While choking. But that's not enough. In all the confusion, someone knocks a lantern over and it lands, you guessed it, on King Suck. Now Joffrey's on fire. And choking. And the knight is still punching him in the throat. This goes on for approximately twenty-six minutes. And then, as "I'm Telling Mother" is about to breathe his last, a raven flies overhead and looses its bowels all over his face. Ahem. Now that that's out of our system...

4. Penny Or Bust

One, let's get the obvious out of the way: there is a dwarf jousting scene in "A Storm of Swords," which may or may not make it into the actual show. Two, said dwarf jousting scene contains a character who may or may not end up being important in the long run. Since the writers are apparently privy to most of the important plot points that will ultimately drive the series home, odds are they know whether or not Penny will ultimately amount to anything significant. But reading about dwarf jousting and actually watching it happen are two totally different things. The scene could stir up a mess of controversy, and we're not even sure that series star Peter Dinklage would be willing to go along with it. But assuming that everything goes well and the producers decide to throw the scene in, why stop there? Since we'll probably see material from "A Dance with Dragons" by next season at the latest, why not have Penny make a post-wedding appearance at Tyrion's trial?

3. Strong Belwas Cameo

If there's any character that fans of the book are pining for, it's Strong Belwas. What Dany's eunuch bodyguard lacks in brains, he makes up for in gal and downright awesomeness. But since it appears that HBO has no interest in adding yet another member to Daenerys' admittedly crowded entourage, maybe twist the mythology a bit and include him in a totally different way. About midway through "A Storm of Swords," Dany parks her army outside of Meereen on the eve of the city's inevitable dragon-sacking. At this point, the masters of Meereen demand that the Breaker of Chains send forth a champion for some one-on-one combat. In the books, this role is played by Belwas. But since it looks like Daario will win the role of the Dany's champion in the adaptation, why not have everyone's favorite eunuch colossus show up for a moment in the sun as the champion of Meereen? Imagine the look on everyone's face when Daario unhorses the mysterious rider, only for him to shed his mask and reveal himself as Strong Belwas. Who then gets brutally cut down by Daario. A fan favorite brought in only to be killed in his first scene? It's approaching "Iron Man 3" territory, which is what makes such a twist so exciting. For those unfamiliar with the books, it'll be a cool one-off character and a badass moment for Daario. For those of us who have read the books, it would be a fun, almost meta moment to keep us on our toes for whatever changes might come next.

2. Brienne In King's Landing

If there's any meeting we want to see more than Ramsay Snow and Joffrey, it's the two most important women in Jaime Lannister's life. In one corner of Cat Fight 2014, we have Cersei, Westeros' Mother of the Year (sponsored by the Cersei Lannister Foundation) thirteen years running. And in the other corner, there's the Maid of Tarth, the woman everyone keeps insisting is hideous but c'mon, you know you would.

But seriously, we can't think of a single person who would feel less at home in King's Landing than Brienne. Like honorable Ned Stark before her, Brienne is naive to a fault and wouldn't last a moment in the gaping jaws of the Westerosi capitol. In the books, her time in King's Landing is glossed over, but maybe the TV series could be a bit more liberal and show us some wacky shenanigans before Jaime sets her on her way. Maybe have the ever-jealous Cersei invite her brother's new favorite sidekick to a three-person dinner. Awkwardness (and by awkwardness, we mean hilarity) ensues. But chuckles isn't the ultimate goal here. Brienne and Cersei represent two conflicting aspects of Jaime's personality: on one hand, he was once an idealistic young knight trying to find his place in the world, like Brienne, but on the other (slightly more golden) hand, his service to the Mad King and years of ridicule as the Kingslayer has seen him adopt Cersei's narcissism, ambition, and flippant disregard for honour. Seeing these two ideals clash onscreen would be an interesting way to examine Jaime's character in the same way that Martin does in the novels. And if all else fails, at least we'll get the "Game of Thrones" version of this below.

1. Let Coldhands Change The Game

Allow us to set the scene: Bran Stark and his company of misfits have migrated beyond the Wall to search for the three-eyed crow. Or raven. Whatever. Anyway, they manage to make it about ten feet before being assaulted by a band of wights. Things look grim. The small party is surrounded. Hodor has soiled himself, as is his way. And just as they're about to become zombie dinner, a cloaked figure leaps out of the shadows and slays all the wights. The figure lowers his hood, revealing the icy, zombified face of Benjen Stark. "Uncle Benjen?" Bran cries out in disbelief. "Benjen Stark is dead," the once-crow replies. "Only Coldhands remains. Err, remain. Only Coldhands remain." Awkward silence. "I am Coldhands." Cue dramatic music. And if you're about to scroll down to the comments and inform us how wrong we are, give us a moment to explain before you Falcon Punch us through your keyboard. Here's a piece of depressing reality for us all: "The Winds of Winter" isn't exactly galloping towards us on the horizon, and the television series is catching up faster than the fans would care to admit. But here's where it gets sticky: even if Martin manages to crank out book six in time for HBO to produce another couple of seasons, what are the odds that he'll finish "A Dream of Spring" in time for season whatever? Those odds, constant reader, are quite slim. Which means if the game is to continue, then the game must change. And since Weiss and Benioff have access to the outlines for books six and seven, there's nothing (legally) stopping them from charging ahead without Martin. Ever since season one, viewers who partake in the show but ignore the books have had to wear iron earmuffs 24/7 to avoid spoilers. Since the books have been out for years and the Internet is a real place that exists, "Game of Thrones" fans have had to tread carefully to avoid being spoiled by fans who have read the books. But, sooner or later, this dichotomy is going to flip. And rather than dancing around plot developments and dragging their feet, maybe the show-runners should just fire off a spoiler-filled warning shot that says, "We now declare ourselves Punctual R.R. Martin. If you're waiting on the books, don't watch the show and avoid Twitter on Sunday nights. Valar Morghulis, nerds!" Because, seriously, we all know who Coldhands is, which makes him good ammo for this metaphorical warning shot. And while all this may sound extreme, the split is going to be inevitable. The sooner that band-aid is pulled, the sooner we can quit worrying about it and leave poor Martin in peace.

Contributor
Contributor

I am not creative enough to make up a fake biography.