Gotham: 10 Easy Ways To Make It Amazing

Because it's not right now and it should be.

When the pilot for Gotham first aired on September 22, its reception was an awkward mix of muted disappointment and undeterred optimism. "Okay, so maybe it wasn't exactly a great episode," many of us thought to ourselves, "but it definitely has potential. Maybe we just need to give it a few weeks to find its legs. Maybe by then it will be the show that we'd hoped for." That was four months ago. And in that time, Gotham has not only displayed a persistent denial to recognize its own obvious flaws, but worse, it's upped the ante: the humor is as flat as it's ever been, there's close to zero tension, the dialogue is positively sour, and even the one consistently strong element that Gotham has going for it - its production design and visuals - has become less than dazzling in recent weeks. If Gotham was just a complete and utter disaster, it would be relatively easy to simply write off; but the truth is that while it's a show with a ton of problems, it's also a show that regularly displays glimpses of being something better...and that makes it tougher to ignore. There is an amazing, sweeping comic book epic inside of Gotham that's but a few key fixes away from becoming a reality. Listed here are ten such fixes that Gotham has to make if it truly wants to be a show worth watching.

10. Ditch The Caricatures, Give Us Some Characters

Commissioner Jim Gordon, Lieutenant Harvey Bullock, Alfred Pennyworth, Oswald Cobblepot, Edward Nygma, Selina Kyle, Bruce freakin€™ Wayne. Comic book characters don€™t get much more well known than this lot; one would think, all things considered, that a television show focused squarely on their early days, well before the Caped Crusader entered into the picture, would more or less write itself, right? Alas, apparently not. Despite having access to thousands of terrific stories from across all manner of comic, film, television, novel, and even video game from which to draw inspiration, Heller and company have thus far chosen to ignore any outside material, favoring instead to craft their own original stories, with their own takes on these classic characters. Which would be fine, if their €œtakes€ were actually, you know, interesting or distinctive or even the least bit three-dimensional. The characters€™ lack of depth is doubly frustrating for Batman fans, who over the course of the last decade or two have been witness across mediums to some truly seminal depictions. We know that it€™s possible for these characters to be done right; sadly, all that Gotham has thus far shown is that it€™s just as possible for them to be done wrong, as well.

9. Bring On The Rogues Gallery

Since it first premiered back in late September, Gotham has more or less played by the prototypical television procedural rulebook, with each €œcase of the week€ mirroring the very same tropes that we€™ve seen played out on countless CBS shows for years now, albeit here tinged ever so slightly with just enough comic book idiosyncrasies to justify the series€™ reputable title. Unfortunately, this adherence to procedural methodology is also mirrored in the way that the show handles its villains. Balloonman. The Electrocutioner. The Spirit of the Goat€ these aren€™t exactly the baddies that we're itching to watch Gordon and Bullock take down. Let€™s be honest: we want the baddies, those deviant evildoers who we most associate with the Bat-brand. Joker, Two-Face, The Riddler (the actual ruffian, not the irritating knockoff-version who we€™ve gotten so far), Bane, Ra€™s al Ghul, even someone slightly more fantastical like Killer Croc or Manbat. Now those are real villains. Jada Pinkett Smith€™s Fish Mooney is amusingly vivacious from time to time, and to the show€™s credit, it has given us a formidable-enough rendering of serial killer Victor Zsasz. But if Gotham€™s going to continue to hold a weekly space on our DVRs, it€™s first going to have to get us interested in what it€™s doing€and what better way to do just that than having one of Batman€™s most iconic baddies drop by for a visit?

8. Ease Up On The Overacting

First off, let€™s just clarify one thing real fast: there is nothing inherently wrong with scenery-chewing €“ as a form of acting, it definitely has its place. However, a key component in delivering a great scenery-chewing performance is being aware of how one€™s turn is being received in relation the rest of the film or show that it€™s a part of. Unfortunately, if there€™s one thing that Gotham is almost 100% lacking in, it€™s self-perspective. Where to start? From start to end, nearly every moment of every scene of every episode of Gotham is stuffed to the gills with the sort of over-the-top emoting and excessive mugging that would make even William Shatner blush. Taken individually, Ben McKenzie€™s unceasingly short fused performance as Gordon, Donal Logue€™s blustery turn as Bullock, Cory Michael Smith€™s extravagantly unamusing rendition of Nygma, and Robin Lord Taylor€™s scummy take on Cobblepot would be eye rolling enough€but taken together, they become something close to unbearable. Look, guys, we get it: Gotham is a terrible place to live, and it takes a certain type of demagogue to settle down there. Point made. Now, please, give it a rest already.

7. Decide What Show To Be And Then Stick With It

One reason why so many fans held out hope that Gotham would turn out decent, maybe even amazing, was because of the man that Fox had appointed as its head showrunner: Bruno Heller. Creator of Rome and The Mentalist, Gotham appeared as if it might be the perfect amalgamation of styles for Heller, one part epic and bombastic drama, the other part calculating and subtle procedural. In theory, it should have worked splendidly; in reality, however, the results were decidedly unexceptional. Regardless of the why behind the show€™s failure to cohere the way that it should €“ too many writers? Excessive studio input? Heller simply not €œgetting€ the appeal of a comic book-based program as this? €“ the end product remains as is: a weird, haphazardly fused amalgamation of three or four wildly different shows that, when viewed as a single work, is simultaneously both despondently fascinating and maddeningly inconsistent. Moment to moment, you never really know what you€™re going to get with Gotham: is it going to be a gritty crime drama in the vein of Nolan€™s Batman movies, or is it going to hew closer to the dark whimsy of Tim Burton€™s films? Is it going to aim for some of that Batman: The Animated Series-esque bombast, or is it instead going to go for something tamer and more colorful, ala the 1960s Batman series starring Adam West and Burt Ward? It doesn€™t really matter which one Gotham decides to be; just that it picks one and then sticks with it.

6. Is It Too Late To Make This A Silent Show?

There€™s only so much poorly written dialogue that someone can be reasonably expected to endure, and with pearls like €œYou€™re a slovenly, lackadaisical cynic!€ or €œIf my hair gets frizzy, you gonna be!€ or €œIf I want riddles, I€™ll read the funny pages€€well, let€™s just say that Gotham isn€™t exactly doing itself any favors when it comes to convincing viewers that it knows how to spin a good turn of phrase. Even more mind boggling? These choice dialogue samples are all just from the pilot alone. That€™s right, folks: courtesy of Heller and Co., we€™ve got 12 of these suckers (and counting) to savor€because dialogue as amazing as this can€™t be contained to just one episode, right? Only in these episodes will you get to see talented performers like Jada-Pinkett Smith cough up lines like €œSome day soon, I am going to kill that old man with my bare hands€and my teeth!€ Or let€™s not forget Donal Logue, who delivers with the utmost conviction and verve such choice turns of phrase as €œScum-sucking toads!€ and €œYou sit there with a panel of chimpanzees and a bucket of crack and come up with that?€ Practically Shakespearean, isn€™t it?

5. A Bit More Variety, Please

The average episode of Gotham clocks in at around 44 to 49 minutes. Of those minutes, a solid chunk of them €“ 2/3, maybe more €“ are going to be scenes that you€™ve already seen in previous episodes. Okay, not exactly like you€™ve seen them before, but darn close. Whether it€™s Jim Gordon spouting off yet another cliché-riddled diatribe on how corrupt the city is, Fish Mooney cooing to her right hand man Butch about how she€™ll soon take down old man Falcone and seize control of Gotham€™s mob families, Oswald Cobblepot flitting from character to character as he schemes and schemes and schemes, Harvey Bullock lamenting about€uh, just about everything, or Bruce and Alfred having the same exact conversation about how Alfred is now Bruce€™s caretaker, but Bruce is still technically in charge, even though Alfred argues that according to his parents€™ will€ €ugh. Enough. For some reason, Heller and crew seem reluctant€“even reticent€“to let their show stretch its legs, to actually try and be the fun, comic book crime epic that it so obviously has the potential to be, were it not so afraid to step outside of its shell and try out new things. If and when that day comes, Gotham could be something really special; until then, it will have to settle for being merely pedestrian.

4. Cool It With The Overplotting

Attention, Gotham storywriters, producers and all around head honchos: contrary to what you might have been led to believe by the impressive box office successes of such comic book blockbusters as Spider-Man 3, X-Men: The Last Stand, or Iron Man 2, we your humble viewing audience do not - we repeat, do not - require every episode of your wonderful program to feature everysinglecharacter that€™s on your considerable roster. We€™re perfectly fine if Nygma needs to hunker down for a while and hammer out his plan of attack with Ms. Kringle, or if cute little Selina wants to take the night off from her usual alley slinking and rooftop hopping, or if Barbara just isn€™t feeling up for yet another evening of leaden pillow talk with her on again/off again lover. If you€™d rather take a week or two off from these riveting character portraits, then please, by all means, do so. Your best episode thus far, Penguin€™s Umbrella, focused entirely on a single story €“ the escalating mob war €“ and to wit, centered only on the characters that were actually direct players in the action, like Gordon, Mooney, Cobblepot, Carmine Falcone, and Sal Maroni. That episode proved that all of you are more than capable of coming together to turn out a finely tuned, well paced hour of television that doesn€™t feel totally schizoid. We are confident that it€™s a trick that you can pull off again.

3. Stop Winking At The Camera And Start Having Confidence In Your Own Material

This is one of those weirdly subjective and kind of personal flaws where, if you€™re at all a fan of Batman or even just mildly acquainted with his general mythology, the show€™s tendency to belabor certain verbal or visual points to act as €œEaster Eggs€ most likely falls somewhere between lame and annoyingly precious. Alternatively, for those of you who aren€™t quite as Bat-saavy, these heavy-handed allusions are probably less annoying as they are simply puzzling and distracting: what€™s up with that scientist guy constantly talking about riddles? And why is that little girl always covered in dirt and yammering on about plants? There€™s no reason that a show called Gotham that€™s set in the world of the Dark Knight can€™t have its share of throwaway references or nods to the fans€“just look at how well a balance Marvel€™s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. has managed to strike between drawing from the broader MCU for much of its larger narrative direction, while at the same time taking extreme pains to make sure that, episode to episode, it€™s the show€™s characters and their interpersonal drama that are serving as its main dramatic fuel, as opposed to the series merely existing as just a 42-minute infomercial for Marvel Studios each week. Whereas S.H.I.E.L.D. approaches its Easter Eggs as one might, say, supplemental material, Gotham treats its own allusions with considerably more emphasis, yet decidedly less intent. One of these shows works; the other doesn€™t. Care to guess which one is which?

2. More Violence, More Darkness

The critical acclaim and insane amount of fan fervor received by NBC€™s Hannibal has proven two different, but equally noteworthy things about the state of modern broadcast television: firstly, that if a show is well written, well shot, and well acted enough to garner huge buzz, then it doesn€™t matter how violent or disturbing or controversial the material is: just so long as the trophies, Top 10 lists, and feature articles keep on rolling in, the network will continue to air it. And secondly, it€™s also proven that even if the ratings for such a disputable show aren€™t exceptional €“ heck, even if they€™re sort of terrible €“ that a strong, vocal contingent of passionate viewers can possess the power to keep that series on the air, at least for a tad bit longer. If Heller and his team are truly are interested in making Gotham into a series that's more than just safe, ratings-guaranteed filler for Monday nights, but instead something that€™s as bold and daring and unapologetically gutsy (no pun intended) as NBC€™s prize program, then easing up on Nygma€™s kooky office antics and Selina Kyle's "cute" visits with Bruce Wayne while emphasizing the series€™ quotient of pitch-black-storytelling and horror movie-esque imagery is the best way to start accomplishing that. Sure, the show might lose some younger viewers (who, let€™s be honest, probably shouldn€™t even be watching Gotham as it is now), and no, the amount of violence or lack thereof doesn€™t necessarily make or break a show€™s quality€ but at the very least, it would represent a significant step in the right direction for the series, as well as serving as a nice repudiation of the milquetoast methodology it's abided by thus far in favor of something substantially more interesting.

1. Kill Bruce Wayne. Yes, Seriously

You know that old adage about killing two birds with one stone? Well, killing off poor Bruce would be the television-equivalent of killing off a hundred birds with an entire mountain. The entire notion of a show €œkilling off characters€ often comes with its fair share of baggage, much of it emotional, some of it unavoidably cynical. However, the importance of shows retaining at least the mere possibility of killing off its key characters is a crucially important card to hold on to. Ensuring the possibility of death ensures stakes, and ensuring stakes ensures tension. Without either of those, you€™ve got€well, Gotham. Heller and his crew are in a tough spot: by setting their show in the years prior to the Dark Knight€™s arrival on the scene, they have the chance to play with some truly iconic Batman €œtoys,€ i.e. familiar characters, locales, etc. It€™s obviously a huge opportunity, one that most creative types would jump at the chance to have. But there€™s a catch. While the Gotham team is allowed to muck about all they like in the Batman universe, at the end of the day they are still required to put the toys €œback in the box€: everything that they touch that€™s even remotely seminal, they have to be sure to put back exactly as they found it. That means that there€™s absolutely zero threat of death befalling Gordon, Bullock, Oswald, Nygma, Selina, Bruce, Alfred, or any of the mainstays€and that€™s a big problem. That€™s why killing Bruce Wayne off early on in Gotham€™s run would be such an effective move: not only would the show once again have its stakes and tension back, but by taking even the mere potential of Batman ever coming to Gotham off the table right from the start, Gotham instantly goes from being a show where nothing is allowed to happen to a show where literally anything can happen. What would you rather watch: a show that is forever tied to a pre-prescribed story€or a show that takes the trappings of the Batman mythology that we are all familiar with, twists them on their head, and makes from them its very own thing? Gotham can be saved: at only 12 episodes in, it€™s by no means a show that is beyond the point of redemption. All that's needed now is for those behind the scenes to step up and make it the amazing series that we know it can be.

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Watcher of films. Reader of comics. Player of videogames. Writer of articles. Lover of cats. Hero of men.