Gotham: 10 Dream Choices To Play The Joker

What came before the Clown Prince Of Crime, and who should play him?

The immediate appeal of Fox's upcoming Gotham show is easy to quantify. Not only does it promise Batfans another taste of their favourite comic book locale, it also boasts established characters like Jim Gordon, Bruce Wayne, The Penguin and Two-Face, if the teases are all to be believed. And even more attractively, the show promises new takes on all of those characters, looking at the Bat family and the rogues' gallery before Bruce Wayne put the cape and cowl on. With new origin stories and young actors portraying other iconic figures like Poison Ivy, Alfred and Catwoman, it's hard not to wonder whether we will get to explore origin stories for all of Batman's most famous characters. Could we see The Riddler turn from conman to master criminal intellect? Might Clayface already be stalking the streets of Gotham in disguise? And what of that most iconic of Batman villains? We already know that the Joker will not appear as the Joker: it stands to reason - not only because the typical and accepted origin for the villain ties him to the Batman, but also because the presence of the Joker without the Batman - his counter-point - would be inconceivable, and we already know that the show is likely to end with Wayne becoming the Bat. But a pre-cursor of the character will turn up in the show, which has been presented as a spawning ground for iconic villains, and that begs the irresistible question of how would they go about casting him? There are of course several directions they could go with the Joker origin: they could go for a joker similar to the flashbacks in Alan Moore's The Killing Joke where it was alleged the Joker was an unnamed stand up comic who was down on his luck before turning to crime to support his pregnant wife, which of course would also bring the opportunity to introduce the Red Hood. Or the writers could take liberties and come up with a whole new Joker, say perhaps a rival classmate of Bruce Wayne (David Mazouz) who could be smarter than him but less athletic, harbouring envious hatred for the young heir thanks to his perceived greater life.... But then we probably wouldn't want to see Gotham Babies, and it's pretty clear that Austin Powers already went in that exact direction. Either way, with the show underway for a Fall 2014 airdate possibilities of the Joker being in the series is still up in the air. There is certainly time to cast a young Joker fore-runner, but it is clear that he would need to be the right age (younger than Gordon, but possibly older than Bruce Wayne) and that the way he carries himself in past roles would fit the character.

10. Jordan David

Jordan David might not be the most notable name on this list, but he is probably the most likely to be cast, given his slighter profile and the fact that he wouldn't stick out like a sore thumb as an important character. And he has shown in a brief flash that he would make a wonderful choice for the role, thanks to his appearance in American Horror Story: Murder House. The striking looking actor played Kevin Gedman during the series tribute to the columbine shootings, and his performance was tangibly creepy, successfully burrowing under the skin of the audience in a way that would translate impeccable across to a young version of the Joker. He also fits the profile established in the comics - he is tall without being towering, and his frame is slight, rather than hulking. Plus he's 23, which would fit nicely into the timeline of the new TV show, especially if the show draws on the origin story where he is an aspiring stand-up comic who turns to crime for the sake of his livelihood. Given his relatively low profile, David would no doubt be something of a gamble, but that also comes with benefits. If the show introduces the character early, without overtly hinting that he will become the Joker later, that would require the kind of lower profile actor who wouldn't attract undue, spoilerific attention by his very presence.

9. Liam Aiken

Having broke out all of ten years ago, in Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events and before that in Road To Perdition, Aiken is a recognisable face in Hollywood, even if his canon of work hasn't exactly been too notable since, other than the seemingly catastrophic revelation that he was rejected as Harry Potter for being American. But after a handful of TV appearances, Aiken reappeared with Michael Winterbottom's The Killer Inside Me, playing a supporting but crucial role that he then followed up with the critically lauded Electrick Children. So far, his career has taken in mostly gentler performances, but there is a grain of oddness in his characteristation of Klaus in A Series Of Unfortunate Events that could translate well to a portrayal of a young, slightly off-kilter loner who takes pleasure in his criminal activities, with a more perverse note added by the fact that he has a certain youthful look that would be jarring in that context. Perhaps the biggest key to not spoiling the deception of who the Joker is in Gotham would be to be unexpected, and Aiken would balance that perfectly with a nagging suspicion that he is slightly other-worldly, and when the revelation finally came, it wouldn't feel like a cynical switcheroo by the writers for impact.

8. Lucas Till

The X-Men: Days Of Future Past star has enjoyed something of an inconsistent career so far, matching high-profile stinkers like Battle: Los Angeles and All Superheroes Must Die (released ironically immediately after he appeared in the first X-Men reboot) with the brilliance of X-Men: First Class, and less heralded roles in the likes of the hugely creepy Stoker and Dark Hearts, but he has proved himself to be a dependable young talent. Many of his more notable performances have been marked by the kind of emotional intensity that made him a good candidate for the screen version of Havok, and there is something very appealing in the idea of a pre-Joker character who is far more petulant and less in touch with his control mechanisms than he would become when he's more obviously the monster. Burton's version of the Joker was a caricature of the existing character - his injuries, both physical and mental merely amplified things that already existed in him - and Till as a young, sadistic enforcer would fit with that image.

7. Nicholas Hoult

Some might accept Hoult's suggestion on the strength of his eye-brows alone, but he is far more than a physical gimmick. Yes, he clearly shares some genetical similarities in the brow department as both Jack Nicholson and Christian Slater, and that might represent a slight, pleasant similarity to past versions of the character (and success by proximity in the eyes of the fans) but he has proven himself a hugely capable actor. Since breaking out with the movie version of About A Boy, Hoult has taken a turn to the darker side of characters in the notoriously Skins, before Hollywood came calling with some seriously high-profile roles, including as Hank McCoy in the new X-Men franchise, and as Jennifer Lawrence's other half in actual real life. Again, he fits the profile of the character, even if he might be a little too buff at the minute in the wake of his X-Men preparation, with that intangible otherworldliness that has a lot to do with his piercing eyes and impressive bone structure. Clearly, the fact that Hoult is currently starring in a Marvel property for Fox somewhat stands in the way of him working on a DC property, but it didn't exactly hurt Chris Evans to play two different comic book characters, and James Marsden has played two important characters on either side of the DC/Marvel divide in his film work. And besides, fantasy casting allows for such impediments, particularly when the actor has such a good look for the role.

6. Daniel Radcliffe

He might not immediately scream creepy sidekick right now, but that might just change when Paul McGuigan's Frankenstein is released late next year, and there is certainly something non-conventional about the former Harry Potter's appeal. He has grown up on screen, from sweet innocence in the first Harry Potter to a slightly gawky adulthood that is likely to see him star in less conventionally star-lead projects like The Woman In Black, Kill Your Darlings and A Young Doctor's Notebook. And there's no doubt he would bring some appropriate energy to a young, slightly unrestrained Joker, perhaps leading to the kind of career swing that Elijah Wood enjoyed with Sin City and Maniac. If he was to look for inspiration for his performance, he shouldn't look too far beyond his Harry Potter co-star David Tennant, whose unsettling, tweaked performance as Barty Crouch Junior in The Goblet Of Fire. Part meth-laced fever, part wild-man thanks to his tongue-flicking idiosyncracy that brought a serpentine feel to the character that perfectly fit his villainy. If Radcliffe could bring some of that energy to what he has already done on screen, we could see the makings of a very memorable supporting character, though of course his profile might negate the impact of the revelation that his character is the Joker in the end.

5. Logan Lerman

Lerman might be better known for lighter fair like the Percy Jackson franchise, but he is definitely a gifted actor, as his performance in The Perks Of Being A Wallflower proved. Those roles might be more heroically and sympathetically aligned, but that might actually work well as conscious misdirection. The apparently nice guy without a history of violence is always the least likely to have committed the crime, and as Ed Norton proved way back in Primal Fear, and that archetype could offer the model for an actor of Lerman's make-up to succeed. There is nothing to suggest that the Joker wasn't a sympathetic character before his transformation, or before the necessity for crime awoke something in him that fundamentally changed him from nice to deliciously naughty. Gotham is unlikely to stick too closely to the source material of the comics, with a broader look at some of the important events in Bruce Wayne's early life, and it would probably serve the show well not to be too close to the movies that already exist, for fear of comparison by proximity. The idea of casting someone who seems to be the polar opposite of everything that the Joker represents isn't a bad one at all, as long as the twist revelation, when it eventually comes feels like it's been executed well. In fact it's a quite logical route to go with much like Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde, which could eventually tie up loose ends in who the Joker really and truly is at his core. So imagine Lerman playing a good boy who eventually loses his way to crime out of an act of desperation.

4. Michael Cera

Perhaps the biggest and most unlikely actor on the list, given his Hollywood association, but as a fantasy pick there's a lot to like about Cera for a young version of the Joker. He proved with Youth In Revolt that he was more than just the slightly odd side-kick character in quirky comedies, and followed up that stereotype-bending performance with one in Magic Magic as Brink that completely broke expectations. Cera has the same exoticness that marks the majority of the actors on this list out, and his would arguably be the most likely to shock, and even infuriate fans of Batman. But ignoring some of his past film appearances, and the general consensus on the kind of performances he will always stick to, Cera has the kind of interesting look that suits grotesque characters - there is even something of the Penguin in his face - and which could be the foundation for a strong, intriguing performance. He is charismatic enough, and certainly interesting enough to pull off the manifesto to be memorable enough not to fade into Gotham's background, and the most engaging of TV shows tend to have an eye-catching, expectation-defying performance at the centre, which is precisely what Cera would offer.

3. Robert Sheehan

Misfits star Robert Sheehan is one of the more intriguing suggestions. Though he is Irish, he wouldn't be the first of his countrymen to make it big playing an American character, and there were clownish elements to his characterisation as Nathan in Misfits that would lend well to a young pre-transformation version of the Joker. It's unlikely that the show is going to play up the comedic elements of the character, unless just as slight link to what he will become down the line, but comic timing helps with villainous characterisation, particularly of even remotely grotesque characters. That is why Jack Nicholson's Joker worked, why Jim Carrey's Riddler worked (and yes, it did) and why Robin Williams is a far more engaging, creepy villain than anyone could ever have suspected from his more bloated comic performances. All three also trade heavily on charisma, and that is something that Sheehan has proved himself amply laden with: he is a genuinely likeable screen presence, which would lead to the irresistible possibility of a character who we fall in love with who turns out to be Batman's greatest ever villain. That is the sort of dynamic that audiences remember long after shows disappear.

2. Rhys Wakefield

Thanks to an all-too-brief, and startlingly creepy performance in The Purge, Australian former soap star Rhys Wakefield has seen his face become the instantly recognisable motif of that movie. And while that movie wasn't universally loved, its strong points - the concept and the villain - were excellent, and made the less well executed moments easier to accept. In The Purge, Wakefield was psychosis personified, the kind of well-mannered, smiling psychopath who is probably distantly related to Hannibal Lecter and Patrick Bateman. He was a glorious grotesque, a caricature whose face and presentation were almost enough to cement the immediate mythology of the character before he even spoke or committed any act of villainy. That is precisely the kind of impact that a lesser character would need, and the image of Wakefield calmly stalking around Gotham in the same manner as his measured, brutally sadistic walk around Ethan Hawke's house in The Purge would be immediately iconic. Though Gotham could go for misdirection and cast someone who isn't obviously going to turn into the Joker, there is certainly something to be said about the idea of him already being a psychopath before his transformation, which leads nicely to the top fantasy pick...

1. Ezra Miller

Though Wakefield's performance in The Purge was a strong claim to this top spot, Ezra Miller gets the final nod thanks to an even more startlingly creepy performance. In We Need To Talk About Kevin, Miller was incredibly difficult to watch, at the same time as being utterly irresistible. He seemed the walking embodiment of evil, a perverse realisation of every mother's worst fears and his cold detachment and despicable sadistic nature made that performance immediately brilliant. And even better, he was oddly charismatic, in the way that all great villains are: even in his most heinous of actions, the audience were left to marvel that he could be so extreme, and so calm about the likely repercussions. Miller fits the bill as the unhinged enforcer type that we're likely to see the Joker re-imagined as, he is just about nondescript enough the blend into the pack, and his evil would come as a shock, and he is practically bursting with the creepy factor that will be the casting team's highest priority for bringing the right hints of the Joker to screen. Who would you like to see playing Gotham's young version of the joker? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.